Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by ugjka on Thursday September 22, 2022 @01:27PM
(#32941990)
Whatever the pirates adopt will be the de facto codec
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by 0x457 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @07:35PM
(#32946031)
Ehh, that's not the case anymore. It used to play some roles because source material used some ancient inefficient codecs. WebRips are well, ripped as is. BDRip generally ripped as is as well.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by account42 on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:14AM
(#32950313)
Ripping Blu-Rays as is makes little sense except for preservation as most of them have hardcoded black bars in the video stream instead of letting playback devices letterbox/pillarbox as needed. Apparently the standard only supports a few resolutions, not even including 24:10 and other common cinema aspect ratios.
Also still plenty of Blu-Rays around using VC-1 which is garbage compared to current codecs. Perhaps all new ones have migrated to H.264 - at least all UHD ones I have seen have.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by IshKebab on Thursday September 22, 2022 @05:48PM
(#32945043)
Nah, piracy is much less popular than it used to be. And there are plenty of formats that have been quite popular with pirates but had zero use commercially. Matroska for example.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by account42 on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:22AM
(#32950367)
webm is matroska (with limits on what you can use) so it actually has seen quite a bit of commercial use.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by IshKebab on Friday September 23, 2022 @07:58AM
(#32950702)
It's based on Matroska. But it's a different thing. Matroska itself still isn't used commercially.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by account42 on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:46AM
(#32951160)
It isn't just "based on" matroska, it literally is matroska. Call it a subset if you want to be pedantic.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by anjbe on Friday September 23, 2022 @08:09PM
(#32958557)
An incredibly limited subset for sure. WebM with VP8/VP9/AV1 is a far cry from how Matroska is typically used, with supported codecs like h.264/h.265 and chapters, subtitles, multiple audio tracks, and linked external files.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by TacticalCoder on Thursday September 22, 2022 @04:20PM
(#32944115)
Honest question: what would currently be the most commonly audio format supported by pirates for pirated movies? I've got a home cinema projector but never paid much attention to the audio (just using my stereo: it's a good stereo but it's not 5.1 or anything).
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by izacus on Thursday September 22, 2022 @04:39PM
(#32944329)
You get all of them, since they tend to be ripped as-is from the source media. I commonly see Dolby Digital+ (because Netflix/Prime/etc. use them), Dolby TrueHD (because BluRays use that) and nowadays there's more and more Atmos.
Ocassionaly you can see an odd DTS/DTS-MA now and then, but not a lot.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by 0x457 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @07:31PM
(#32946005)
Well, pirates don't care about licensing of audio or video formats, but most do care about fidelity. For audio, generally, whatever source was is used: Dolby Digital+, Dolby TrueHD, Dolby Atmos, AAC or AAC+ if source is wack.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by pixelatedindex on Thursday September 22, 2022 @04:43PM
(#32944390)
Personally I see a lot of AAC/AAC+ and some Dolby Digital.
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by kyriakos on Thursday September 22, 2022 @03:32PM
(#32943602)
And porn
Re:Google wants to take on Dolby with new open media formats
by dopa42365 on Thursday September 22, 2022 @07:53PM
(#32946168)
Porn uses old and free formats for maximum compatibility. h264 and aac, works on every budget device from the last decade (and older). Even the highest quality 4k porn is just 20 mbit/s h264. These companies aren't youtube, they don't encode every video in 10 different formats for every use case. If pornhub statistics are to be believed, like 85% of visitors are mobile users. There's no point in optimizing anything for expensive big screen great audio home theater experience when your target audience is 5" low res screen 1% volume ashamed at night phone fappers.
The very opposite of cutting edge technology (with the exception of tiny niches like VR).