First, it isn’t easy technically. Especially back when you’re designing the very first decentralized cryptocurrency and have no prior experience informing your design. ZCash, Monero, MimbleWimble and others came later after learning from Bitcoin, and there’s zero chance they could have come first.
Second, shielded transactions risk undetected inflation bugs, which actually happened to ZCash some years ago.
Third, Bitcoin was designed shortly after the Liberty Dollar founder was arrested and jailed, and everyone in Bitcoin was concerned about that too, including Satoshi. He may have decided just not to push his luck.
https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/quotes/privacy/
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=770
It seems like satoshi thought pseudo-anonyminity was sufficient. The integration of zero-knowlege proofs into cryptocurrencies was not really well understood at the time.
>we could just iterate on existing ones, and have our userbase intact without having to 'gain traction' for an entirely new alt-coin.
I think there are some fundamental limits to the throughput of a single cryptocurrency due to network latency and bandwidth. Perhaps the solution to scalability is simply to have multiple cryptocurrencies and to facilitate atomic swaps between them. So in this sense, the creation of new cryptocurrencies with minor feature changes (litecoin, bitcoin cash, wownero, cheapeth, etc.) is actually good for network diversity.
That being said, the owners of existing "big" cryptocurrencies will usually want to make changes that increase its usability to compete with these "trivial forks"
Bitcoiners have been soured by the idea of a hard fork since the XT dispute, while the monero userbase has commited itself to regular hard forks every 6 months to upgrade the network.
Being anonymous to the 'Real world' but carry an identity in the "BTC world". Wallets, mining, interactions are all public within the network and significantly contributed to it's 'Community', 'make btc wallet size go up', and increase account nonce with use.
Early in the community, these metrics where your 'leaderboards'.
BTC never was anonymous, but rather a 'seperate idenitity'.
The transparency of the ledger is key to the censorship, control, and abuse of the network.
>open source
Are you implying that the cryptonote/zerocoin projects like monero aren't open source?
The original btc had a networked pokergame along with the wallet, but was taken out for a couple of reasons, including regulatory issues.
I'm not saying parent is right, or wrong but to dismiss it and to speak for the core team out of hand is folly.
Reference: https://github.com/lightning/bolts/blob/master/04-onion-rout...
ZK based privacy was possible and working fine for many users through TC before the sanctions. Now it is risky as you may end up with locked funds or in jail for seeking privacy.
Edit: Should also mention Aztec and Aleo. These are working currently but in the same position that TC was before its sanctions. Hard to know what regulators will do as these tools allow for absolute privacy which is antithetical to the US government’s goals.
This is simply not going to happen in the current anti-money-laundering environment. The US made Switzerland give up hiding money, they're not going to let some random geeks make trillions of dollars vanish.
i've heard this sentiment conveyed in the crypto space since 2011... still waiting on this prophecy to come true.
Due to incompetence, profit motive or traitors to their country, who can tell the difference? (Paraphrasing Robespierre here)
Want to purchase an ENS name without corporations and the US government having clear knowledge of it? Too bad, the US government will not allow that. The privacy that we enjoy wish cash purchases will erode as we continue down the path of stripping away privacy in digital transactional systems.
AFAIK ring signatures hold. It's like a mixer on every transaction so trying to track more than a few transactions back, the complexity explodes.
TL;DR Ring signatures, like all sender-obfuscation methods, have a limited anonymity set: it limits you to a pool of possible senders. If Alice frequently sends funds to Bob, who frequently sends funds to Carl, who frequently sends to Alice, she can see that Alice->Bob->Carl->Alice is one possible outcome. She does this because she can trace the coin she associates with Bob to a coin she associates with Carl. There is a ton of plausible deniability at first, but the relationship between Bob and Carl becomes more obvious the more Alice->Bob->Carl->Alice continues to happen.
Alice can be multiple exchanges collaborating using KYC.
How to resist poisoning: limit your risk, churn, bigger ring-size/anonymity set, do atomic swaps (this severs chain of ownership, but is not generally sybil-proof), do multi-output transactions if you are sending to multiple people at once who can co-ordinate (this reduces the number of coins they can co-ordinate).
1. e.g. what happens if a large exchange's records leak / are subpoenaed, a criminal group being compromised by law enforcement, etc. means that a fair fraction of a mixer's transaction volume at a particular time can be identified, making it easier to focus on the remainder?
Bitcoin transactions that use CoinJoin (e.g. Wasabi Wallet). https://en.bitcoinwiki.org/wiki/CoinJoin
> is a very effective decentralised Bitcoin mixer with many privacy-focused options
> provides possibly the most convenient and secure way to mix Bitcoins
[0] https://www.tbstat.com/wp/uploads/2020/06/Europol-Wasabi-Wal...
It seems an obvious target to be a Trojan horse in the midst of criminals and tax-evaders.
I suspect that most monero black markets are taken down by sting operations. The black markets all have a limited shelf life and these days they tend to intentionally retire before getting "silk-roaded"
Similar tech to this could become standard on Ethereum L2s in the future after more optimisations.
I'm pretty sure withdraws from Ren darknodes are private as they come from the network itself and aren't correlates to your node.
* Bitcoin lightning transactions when the lightning nodes involved are trusted to not keep logs
* Transactions through mixers with a lot of users
* Monero transactions
* Zcash private transactions
And everything is de-facto traceable except:
* Tornado cash users who use standard-size amounts (or users of another equivalently large smart-contract-based mixer)
* Monero users who are careful about their entry/exit
Zcash privacy doesn't have enough users for anonymity, most mixers are too small, and lightning users generally use nodes from exchanges which do log a lot of information that isn't kept on chain.
Am I missing anything? This seems kind of bad for cryptocurrencies in general if everything is basically traceable.