News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by houstonn on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:41AM (#32940490)
Satoshi's largest error was not making Bitcoin private by default and it strikes me as out of character given his/her level of commitment to being anonymous.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by SkyMarshal on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:50AM (#32940654)
I don’t recall why that decision was made, but there could be a couple reasons.

First, it isn’t easy technically. Especially back when you’re designing the very first decentralized cryptocurrency and have no prior experience informing your design. ZCash, Monero, MimbleWimble and others came later after learning from Bitcoin, and there’s zero chance they could have come first.

Second, shielded transactions risk undetected inflation bugs, which actually happened to ZCash some years ago.

Third, Bitcoin was designed shortly after the Liberty Dollar founder was arrested and jailed, and everyone in Bitcoin was concerned about that too, including Satoshi. He may have decided just not to push his luck.

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by cowtools on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:59AM (#32940793)
Let's not speculate:

https://satoshi.nakamotoinstitute.org/quotes/privacy/

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=770

It seems like satoshi thought pseudo-anonyminity was sufficient. The integration of zero-knowlege proofs into cryptocurrencies was not really well understood at the time.

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by rorrim on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:00PM (#32942443)
Quit it with this revisionist history nonsense, your second link contains where Satoshi specifically mentioned that a ZK-based version of bitcoin would be better, he just didn't know how to do it: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=770.msg8637#msg8637
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by SkyMarshal on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:19PM (#32942669)
I wouldn't call it revisionist, he's referencing the source.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by SkyMarshal on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:19PM (#32942679)
Thanks, I knew there were discussions of it back then on bitcointalk and probably bitcoin wizards irc, just not where to find them. The bitcointalk thread seems to confirm #1 - it was just technically difficult to do back then.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by beauHD on Thursday September 22, 2022 @01:17PM (#32941867)
So is it safe to say Monero is a sort of Bitcoin 2.0? I mean if Bitcoin had 'versions' that would be great. Then we wouldn't have to invent entirely new cryptocurrencies, we could just iterate on existing ones, and have our userbase intact without having to 'gain traction' for an entirely new alt-coin.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by cowtools on Thursday September 22, 2022 @01:58PM (#32942412)
I suppose the monero userbase has similar attitudes as the early bitcoin userbase, but monero/cryptonote is not a bitcoin fork in the same sense that zcash/zerocoin is.

>we could just iterate on existing ones, and have our userbase intact without having to 'gain traction' for an entirely new alt-coin.

I think there are some fundamental limits to the throughput of a single cryptocurrency due to network latency and bandwidth. Perhaps the solution to scalability is simply to have multiple cryptocurrencies and to facilitate atomic swaps between them. So in this sense, the creation of new cryptocurrencies with minor feature changes (litecoin, bitcoin cash, wownero, cheapeth, etc.) is actually good for network diversity.

That being said, the owners of existing "big" cryptocurrencies will usually want to make changes that increase its usability to compete with these "trivial forks"

Bitcoiners have been soured by the idea of a hard fork since the XT dispute, while the monero userbase has commited itself to regular hard forks every 6 months to upgrade the network.

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by tromp on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:23PM (#32942717)
No; Monero is not an improved Bitcoin; it just makes different tradeoffs [1].

[1] https://phyro.github.io/grinvestigation/why_grin.html

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by grappler on Thursday September 22, 2022 @04:53PM (#32944498)
many cryptocurrencies do have 'versions' of a sort. See ethereum's recent one known as "the merge" which moved that currency to a completely different consensus algorithm!
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by wickoff on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:51AM (#32940661)
He wanted to, but blockspace-efficient privacy cryptography wasn't discovered back then.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by TrapLord_Rhodo on Thursday September 22, 2022 @12:27PM (#32941194)
its not an error or oversight but a feature.

Being anonymous to the 'Real world' but carry an identity in the "BTC world". Wallets, mining, interactions are all public within the network and significantly contributed to it's 'Community', 'make btc wallet size go up', and increase account nonce with use.

Early in the community, these metrics where your 'leaderboards'.

BTC never was anonymous, but rather a 'seperate idenitity'.

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by earnesti on Thursday September 22, 2022 @03:52PM (#32943813)
Dude, he was the inventor of cryptocurrency, did you except him to get everything right at once.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by olalonde on Thursday September 22, 2022 @04:15PM (#32944059)
"Alexander Graham Bell's largest error was to not build end-to-end encryption by default in the telephone."
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by imdsm on Thursday September 22, 2022 @01:03PM (#32941677)
Bitcoin may not be private but it's pseudonymous, multiple public keys per private key. I think if it had have been private though, it never would have taken off. The transparency and exploitability of blockchains is key to their success. Without Bitcoin & other prominent open source blockchain-based crypto-currencies and crypto-assets, private crypto-currencies and crypto-assets wouldn't stand up.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by cowtools on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:03PM (#32942485)
I couldn't disagree more. Without the silk road, bitcoin would have never taken off. monero has seemingly displaced bitcoin here.

The transparency of the ledger is key to the censorship, control, and abuse of the network.

>open source

Are you implying that the cryptonote/zerocoin projects like monero aren't open source?

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by WHATDOESIT on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:45AM (#32940556)
Perhaps it was a tradeoff they knowingly made to not have it become illegal immediately.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by rorrim on Thursday September 22, 2022 @02:01PM (#32942455)
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by cowtools on Thursday September 22, 2022 @12:05PM (#32940892)
No, it wasn't.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by TrapLord_Rhodo on Thursday September 22, 2022 @12:32PM (#32941258)
The BTC core team was highly concerned with the legality of the network due to previous failed currency's (eCash, B-money, Bit Gold, and Hashcash) that ended up driving certain decisions in architecture.

The original btc had a networked pokergame along with the wallet, but was taken out for a couple of reasons, including regulatory issues.

I'm not saying parent is right, or wrong but to dismiss it and to speak for the core team out of hand is folly.

Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by WHATDOESIT on Thursday September 22, 2022 @12:54PM (#32941542)
Please share your reasoning - as the sibling comment mentions, there was a series of high profile online cash cases at the time, KYC being the biggest problem. It'd be weird if they didn't think hard about avoiding the same fate and perhaps this was they way they've chosen.
Re:Chainalysis: A startup that helps governments trace crypto by wyre on Thursday September 22, 2022 @11:47AM (#32940586)
>Privacy for me, but not for thee