News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by garyclarke27 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:29AM (#32850750)
It’s a shame that the competition authorities don’t seem to have any interest in these type of acquisitions which destroys competition and harms consumers. Same thing happened with Architecture software eg when Autocad bought Revit - end result is extortionately priced software that many architects cannot afford because they are paid so poorly. Same will happen for graphic designers.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by vouaobrasil on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:35AM (#32850848)
I actually think we need new antitrust laws that are a bit more proactive when it comes to super-massive companies like Adobe. Such companies have learned to be much more cunning when it comes to get around existing laws, and plus they have much more money than ever.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by javajosh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:48AM (#32851017)
>we need new antitrust laws that are a bit more proactive

Bingo! Adobe has a de facto monopoly on vector and bitmap editing software tools, and it would make total sense for this acquisition to be stopped by the government on that basis. "The government" in this case would be the DoJ's antitrust division headed by Jonathan Kanter [1]. Looks like the process is to send a letter requesting a "Business Review" [2]. It's probably a "fill out this simple 30 page form, wait 2.5 years (max!) and then have your review request politely declined" situation, but I suppose it's foolish to complain before trying.

1 - https://www.justice.gov/atr

2 - https://www.justice.gov/atr/business-reviews

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by legitster on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:28AM (#32852586)
>a de facto monopoly

This isn't a terribly meaningful distinction. There are a dozen+ editing tools out there, most of them are pretty good and free. If Photoshop/Illustrator have 90% of the market because they are superior products, I'm not sure how much the government could/should do.

Apple controls something like 90% of all mobile phone profits across the entire industry. I'm not sure how breaking them would actually provide any consumer benefit.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by itsoktocry on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:41AM (#32852768)
>Apple controls something like 90% of all mobile phone profits across the entire industry.

Profits don't have anything to do with it though. Apple has sub-50% market share. Competition in the mobile space is so competitive there are few profits to be had.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by legitster on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:56AM (#32852961)
If profits have nothing to do with it, then there's even less case to call it a monopoly. They nowhere near match the install base of all the free editing softwares (GIMP, Inkscape, Paint.net, etc).
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mrcartmeneses on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:03AM (#32853085)
I used to like Freehand.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by dylan604 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:50AM (#32851929)
>wait 2.5 years (max!) and then have your review request politely declined" situation >2 - https://www.justice.gov/atr/business-reviews

"3. The Division may, in its discretion, refuse to consider a request. "

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by CamelCaseName on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:17AM (#32853337)
But why? What is stopping competitors from coming out and beating them?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by ratg13 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:31AM (#32853591)
A 10 year development cycle and the exact same monopolistic practices we are discussing here.

This isn't the first time Adobe has done this and won't be the last.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by snarf21 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:26AM (#32851582)
No, we just need to fund the SEC and FTC and let them do their job. We also need to enforce consumer protection not simply maximize shareholder value.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by capableweb on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:30AM (#32851632)
Doesn't current laws require harm to competition to have already been made in order for them to enforce anything?

So Adobe acquiring Figma isn't unlawful, until it is proven to have a bad effect on consumers.

I think what parent is saying, is that we should adjust laws to be more pro-active, that if there is a possibility/high-risk of the acquisition to have a bad effect on consumers, it should maybe be considered a bit more than usual.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by lvzw on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:57AM (#32852043)
Current antitrust laws do not require harm to have already occurred to challenge a merger. Once an intent to merge has been filed, the FTC/DOJ has a certain amount of time to issue a 'second request'. [1] If the FTC/DOJ finds during their review of the materials turned over from the second request that the merger is likely to be anticompetitive, they will sue to block the merger. This merger in particular would likely be mostly scrutinized according to the horizontal merger guidelines, given the parties' overlap in a specific product/market. [2]

[1]: https://www.ftc.gov/advice-guidance/competition-guidance/gui... [2]: https://www.justice.gov/atr/horizontal-merger-guidelines-081...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:56AM (#32851151)
What do you think happens to VC investments when it’s harder for companies to be acquired?

If you were a founder and wanted to sell your company, would you want the government telling you that you can’t sell it for the best price?

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by vouaobrasil on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:10AM (#32851347)
Of course not, I would be selfish and want the billion dollars. But maybe a culture of creating small companies out of VC capital only to be acquired by megacorps is not the best way forward for society. I also don't like paying taxes, but that doesn't mean there shouldn't be any.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:08AM (#32852249)
What would the alternative be? There will always come a day when founders and investors want to move on. Retirement age comes faster than you might think. Even if you deny an exit strategy, the principals are still going to stop eventually, and the product will still come to an end at that time. Allowing a sale at least provides an opportunity for the product to live on, even if there can be no guarantees about how the next guy decides to treat it.

Traditionally, when a product doesn't want to be lost, the customers will pool their resources together and offer a buyout. That seemingly didn't happen, so Adobe probably is the next best thing. Adobe is a public company, so the public still has the ability to shape its future.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:08AM (#32853182)
There are always options besides selling the whole company to a giant competitor, the difference is just that you won’t get as high of a return if there are fewer bidders in the marketplace.

A company like figma could have always just gone public if the founders/investors just wanted to get out.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:16AM (#32853302)
> A company like figma could have always just gone public if the founders/investors just wanted to get out.

The company has gone public (or will shortly) and is now at the mercy of the public shareholder. Which is specifically the concern here. The worry is that the public shareholders, who aren't necessarily users and are only shareholders out of interest in profit, will see more value in squashing the product than carrying on.

The users pooling resources would have been the logical buyer, to keep out of the general public with competing interest's hands, but seemingly they didn't want the company, so...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:21AM (#32853425)
I suppose I just don’t understand you original point then?

> What would the alternative be? There will always come a day when founders and investors want to move on.

Going public means you can move on and sell your shares at any time on the open market, they never needed Adobe to buy them out except to get a higher valuation.

Your original comment implied that if companies like Adobe weren’t able to buy out smaller competitors, the products would just die, which, obviously isn’t even the case here.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:28AM (#32853544)
I guess I don't understand yours. There is no functional difference between offering shares to the public directly or offering shares to the public by proxy through Adobe. Either way the public controls the company and gets to decide the fate of the product. If they see value in continuing it, they'll do so. If there is more value in letting it die, they'll do that instead.

The problem with shareholders made up of the general public is that they aren't interested in the product itself. It it goes by the wayside, oh well. They never used it in the first place. This doesn't serve to protect the offering in the manner the customer expects. It might work out, but often it doesn't. Adobe's products themselves are a prime example of what happens when the general public has more say than the users. No user-controlled company would play those shenanigans, but the general public doesn't use Adobe products, so they don't feel the pain. They only see the profit pleasure.

This is why, traditionally, customers who want to ensure that a product remains aligned with their expectations pool their resources and enact a buyout before it reaches the hands of outsiders with other ideas. This allows them to put priority on the product itself, not competing concerns like profitability. But there is no evidence that happened here, so they decided it was okay to let it go to the whims of the rest of the world.

It's a tradeoff. Such is life.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:38AM (#32853678)
I’m making my comments in the context of the thread:

>we need new antitrust laws that are a bit more proactive when it comes to super-massive companies like Adobe

> What do you think happens to VC investments when it’s harder for companies to be acquired?

> maybe a culture of creating small companies out of VC capital only to be acquired by megacorps is not the best way forward for society

> What would the alternative be? There will always come a day when founders and investors want to move on

> A company like figma could have always just gone public if the founders/investors just wanted to get out

The whole point was that anti trust should be stepping in more, and then people were making over the top claims about there being no alternative.

The whole point is that it is not up to the public shareholders to sell to whoever they want if the government will block the sale.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:46AM (#32853811)
> then people were making over the top claims about there being no alternative.

Nobody said such a thing. I did ask what the alternative is. Going public isn't an alternative. That's what is happening. Figma is being transferred into a public trust. And that is the worry expressed with respect to its future, because the general public has no reason to care about the product and will not act in the interest of the product.

Anti-trust could, in theory, do more to prevent the general public from not caring about the product they control. The problem is that laws (where Figma and Adobe are located) are prescribed by the very same general public, so you have to convince them its a good idea. And if you've done that, the law becomes largely superfluous because at that point they're already on board and will act as such on their own accord.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:56AM (#32853955)
> What would the alternative be? There will always come a day when founders and investors want to move on. Retirement age comes faster than you might think. Even if you deny an exit strategy, the principals are still going to stop eventually, and the product will still come to an end at that time. Allowing a sale at least provides an opportunity for the product to live on, even if there can be no guarantees about how the next guy decides to treat it.

This is what you wrote in response to the idea that anti trust should be used to block these kinds of buy outs.

> The problem is that laws are prescribed by the very same general public, so you have to convince them its a good idea. And if you've done that, the law becomes largely superfluous because at that point they're already on board and will act as such on their own accord.

That is frankly an absurd oversimplification. Shareholders are a miniscule subset of the general public.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:04PM (#32854090)
> Shareholders are a miniscule subset of the general public.

You mean shareholders of Adobe? Sure. But the rest of the population see how it applies to their own shareholdings. According to Gallop polling earlier this year, 58% of Americans own stock. I speculate you'll find even more owning stock indirectly (pensions, etc.).

Or do you mean in other countries? America certainly ranks much higher than many other countries with regards to what portion of the general public are interested in such matters. Which is no doubt why it is more relaxed about such things. This probably wouldn't fly in many other countries, but those countries are not where this is taking place.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:21PM (#32854318)
Setting aside the fact that your own measure means that 42% of Americans own zero shares, meaning that it is already not representative. The fact that 58% of Americans own a share does not imply that they are shareholders of every single one of the ~6,000 companies listed on the public markets in the US. Further, 10% of Americans hold 89% of the stocks in the US, and therefore as many voting shares.

So yes, I do mean the US. I’ll reiterate: it is absurd to imply that “the public” in reference to shareholders is somehow synonymous with “the public” in reference to voters in America.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:46PM (#32854733)
> 42% of Americans own zero shares, meaning that it is already not representative.

You don't need it to be representative, just to form majority. 51% is more than sufficient. 58% provides a healthy margin.

> The fact that 58% of Americans own a share does not imply that they are shareholders of every single one of the ~6,000 companies listed on the public markets in the US.

Should it imply it? I don't see the relevance.

> Further, 10% of Americans hold 89% of the stocks in the US, and therefore as many voting shares.

Fun fact, I guess. I don't see the relevance here either.

Unless you're suggesting that 10% of the population is more likely to speak to representatives on the regular, not hide behind a computer on HN all day while assuming their representative is a mind reader, thus being disproportionally represented? I could definitely see that being true based on my anecdotal observations, although I lack the data to confirm.

> it is absurd to imply that “the public” in reference to shareholders is somehow synonymous with “the public” in reference to voters in America.

If you make the false assumption that the public requires 100% support to do anything. Back in the real world...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:20PM (#32857207)
Ah yes, so according to you, in the “real world”, shareholders interests and the interests represented by the government are functionally equivalent. This must be why we have no minimum wage laws, worker protections, nor does the FTC ever block any mergers.

> If you make the false assumption that the public requires 100% support to do anything.

You’re sitting here complaining about not being perfectly understood over and over and yet here you claim I said 100% support is required. I said one group isn’t representative of the other, ie it’s interests are not reflective of the pother groups interests.

> You don't need it to be representative, just to form majority. 51% is more than sufficient. 58% provides a healthy margin.

Assuming 88% of that 58% are in actually in agreement.

> Should it imply it? I don't see the relevance.

You made the argument that the shareholders of one public company are somehow functionally equivalent to the public at large:

> Anti-trust could, in theory, do more to prevent the general public from not caring about the product they control. The problem is that laws (where Figma and Adobe are located) are prescribed by the very same general public, so you have to convince them its a good idea. And if you've done that, the law becomes largely superfluous because at that point they're already on board and will act as such on their own accord.

Your position is basically: we already live in an anarchy capitalist society with extra cruft.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:38PM (#32857436)
> This must be why we have no minimum wage laws, worker protections, nor does the FTC ever block any mergers.

Uh huh. The public that directs the government have jobs and have to live in society, so they are quite concerned about these things. The public might also be concerned about the future of Figma, but other comments suggest that they won't be. And I tend to agree as it is a fairly niche product. If something like Microsoft/Windows, which almost everyone uses, was being sold to Adobe it might draw more questions from the public.

> Assuming 88% of that 58% are in actually in agreement.

For sure. They often don't agree. Just as we are only speculating that Figma is destined to disappear here. The public that holds control might decide it's the greatest thing since slice bread and make it Adobe's flagship product. The future is uncertain. I'm surprised you didn't already know that.

> You made the argument that the shareholders of one public company are somehow functionally equivalent to the public at large

You must be replying to the wrong person. Careful which button you press.

> Your position is basically: we already live in an anarchy capitalist society with extra cruft.

Quite the opposite. The public very much coordinates centrally. We just got finished talking about 51% being significant because of that centralization... Replying to the wrong thread confirmed. I hope you find your way back to where you wanted to be.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:08PM (#32855148)
Until a billionaire or a Bain capital comes along and tries to do a hostile takeover.

If anyone can buy stock in a company, that means any entity can come along with deep enough pockets and buy a controlling interest unless the founder has enough clout to keep a majority of voting shares.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:41AM (#32853728)
Going public also leaves you to the short sightedness of the public market. There is a reason that public companies are taken private when they need to make long term changes.

Also, Adobe can invest money in a product without going to the public markets for more money or taking out loans.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by wbsss4412 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:46AM (#32853817)
You can argue whichever is better for society, more anti trust, more big corp acquisitions. My point is only that the idea that without big corp acquisitions, founders would have no options besides walking away and letting their product die is preposterous.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:10PM (#32854176)
So preposterous, in fact, that not a single person even tried to say such a thing. What purpose does this straw man serve?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:36AM (#32853656)
LinkedIn didn’t “need” to be acquired as a public company. But they did
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by joshmanders on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:56AM (#32852963)
> What would the alternative be?

Donate it to the Earth. https://www.patagonia.com/ownership/

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by anders_p on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:22AM (#32853433)
> What would the alternative be?

Your imagination can't be this limited?

Are you really not able to come up with any other scenario than "bought up by your biggest competitor"?

Like...they could go public, or sell to a new owner that isn't already the biggest in the field, etc.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by randomdata on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:14PM (#32854225)
> Like...they could go public

That's the option that has been chosen. That is not an alternative. The product will soon be in the hands of the public. That's also the worry as the public doesn't care about the product and thus won't put the product's interest in mind.

> or sell to a new owner that isn't already the biggest in the field

That's not really an alternative either with respect to the discussion about the new owners potentially letting the product languish or die. It is different, but still reaches the same outcome, potentially. You are still risking that the owner doesn't care about the product.

As discussed, selling to the customers would mitigate this, as they have reason to care about the product, but we already established that they didn't express interest. We would never want to force someone into owning it.

> Your imagination can't be this limited?

It is. Hopefully someone with an imagination will come along at some point. I'm quite interested to hear about alternatives.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:52AM (#32853891)
The “public” doesn’t give a rats ass about how good the product is and are very short term focused. The minute the company goes public, you are then at the mercy of “activist investors” not interested in the core product.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by robbiemitchell on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:24AM (#32851550)
Figma turned ~$330M in investments into a $20B outcome and gave countless companies a better way to do their work. How is this a bad path for society?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by m3at on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:33AM (#32851668)
I think you misread, the parent agree with you that Figma created value, the issue is the acquisition by Adobe that might stop or slow this.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by supportlocal4h on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:03AM (#32852165)
Perhaps you misunderstand that Figma was motivated to create value. A large part of the motivation for many startups is an exit plan wherein they get bought out by established competitors.

If you prevent such purchases, you eliminate a major factor in creating the value to begin with.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by ryanisnan on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:38AM (#32852736)
The point of the stock market is to trade and build wealth. Yet we have agreed insider trading should be illegal, because it ruins the game for everyone.

Anti-trust laws are similar.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by anders_p on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:34AM (#32853634)
> Perhaps you misunderstand that Figma was motivated to create value. A large part of the motivation for many startups is an exit plan wherein they get bought out by established competitors.

> If you prevent such purchases, you eliminate a major factor in creating the value to begin with.

You're basically saying that they wouldn't have made Figma if they'd only been able to sell it for 15 billion.

Same tired argument as the "unless you lower taxes on the wealthiest even more, they'll stop creating jobs!" (Even though the taxes haven't been lower in history than they are right now).

People do stuff even though there are anti-trust laws limiting how many tens of billions they get out of it.

As long as there's insane profits to be made, there'll still be an incentive.

Selling out to the market leader, creating a virtual monopoly that harms the consumers in the long run, isn't the only way to make money on a start-up. Far from it.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by supportlocal4h on Saturday September 17, 2022 @12:58AM (#32874872)
If Figma had sold to, say... Autodesk for $15B would that be an anti-trust issue for you? What if they sold to Google?

I'm pretty wary of monopoly abuse. But I'm also very wary of entitled people (including myself sometimes) demanding that somebody else has the responsibility to create great stuff for free to make their life better. It's beyond my ability to create an amazing electric vehicle so somebody else should be required to do it and give it to me for free or else it is an anti-trust violation. Somebody else should make something as good or better than SolidWorks or Fusion or XD for free or else AutoDesk/Adobe/MS/Alphabet/... are harmful monopolists.

I don't like Adobe or AutoDesk or MS or Meta or many others companies. I disagree with many of their behaviors for various reasons. I think some of what they do is or should be illegal. But I think misguided consumption is more often the root problem. And it is a mistake to punish those who take advantage of misguided consumption in a way that encourages more misguided consumption and entitlement.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by bmitc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:27AM (#32852571)
What are you are are describing are bad motivations. It’s like wanting a salary when volunteering. One doesn’t actually care about value if the only motivation to create said value is to get obscene amounts of money.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:39AM (#32852740)
They weren’t creating a company for the “good of mankind”.

Most non profits have plenty of paid staff.

In fact, there is a Ted Talk about non profits and why their employees should get paid well.

https://www.ted.com/talks/dan_pallotta_the_way_we_think_abou...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by bmitc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:23AM (#32853456)
> They weren’t creating a company for the “good of mankind”.

I feel most VC blurbs disagree with that, although of course that’s not their actual motivation.

I don’t see how non-profits are relevant other than as examples of companies/organizations that do actually provide value in lieu of massive gains and profit.

And I think you missed my point as I was responding to:

> If you prevent such purchases, you eliminate a major factor in creating the value to begin with.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:37AM (#32853668)
And you believe what the VCs say?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by afavour on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:55AM (#32852012)
Because now that it's owned by Adobe they no longer have competition for their XD product. They will likely merge both, resulting in an inferior product. They'll then jack up the price, hurting countless companies that have gotten used to a better way to do their work.

But I'm very glad they generated income for their shareholders.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by krferriter on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:58AM (#32852057)
I would prefer the investors just get paid back plus ROI using the value and revenue the company generates, instead of the standard being just merging the company into a larger one.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:18AM (#32852422)
Well, if you would like that, you are free to start your own company, find the talent and the like minded investors and take the prerequisite risks to create a company that meets your ideals. But Figma is a private company and the founders get to choose who they sell to.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by geodel on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:42AM (#32852789)
Yeah, exactly right. People here are saying "I pay 20 dollar a month for something, now whole universe must stay same forever lest that 20 dollar thing disappear"
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mschuster91 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:02AM (#32852158)
I think the problem with VC that GP means is more a systemic one - it's not specific or even applicable to Figma, but for other large VC projects.

It's fine if a company like Figma takes VC to build a good product that fills a niche that hasn't been explored before and uses the VC to grow and eventually exit to the general public market so that the investors get their return.

It's not fine if larger companies like Adobe can simply swoop in and pay billions to get rid of a competitor, although that one should be dealt with by anti-trust agencies anyway.

It's not fine if a company like Uber uses cheap VC money to price-dump against essential services - and yes, taxis are essential for those without a car, and the anti-discrimination frameworks make sure that access to them is fairly available to everyone, no matter why they would need a taxi for. Uber, in contrast, routinely got associated with everything from wage dumping over racism [1] to extorting people with excessive surge charges [2].

It's not fine if a company like AirBnB uses cheap VC money to wreak havoc on local rental markets [3][4] or to run effectively hotel-like operations in residential zones, while conveniently ignoring things such as fire codes [5], neighbors' quality of life [6], taxes [7] or that people (both guests and hosts) were and are randomly banned for "background checks" [8][9], a return of ages-old banned housing discrimination.

Society definitely needs a hard regulation on anything where VC is involved.

[1] https://venturebeat.com/ai/researchers-find-racial-discrimin...

[2] https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/business/india-business/...

[3] https://www.tagesspiegel.de/berlin/ferienwohnungen-stehen-le...

[4] https://travelnoire.com/the-airbnb-effect-on-an-already-high...

[5] https://www.nfpa.org/News-and-Research/Publications-and-medi...

[6] https://www.wired.co.uk/article/living-next-to-airbnb-sharin...

[7] https://news.bloombergtax.com/daily-tax-report-state/airbnb-...

[8] https://eu.usatoday.com/story/opinion/policing/spotlight/201...

[9] https://www.airbnbhell.com/banned-from-airbnb-over-backgroun...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:32AM (#32852655)
Those taxi companies that are their “for the poor” routinely wouldn’t go into “poor” neighborhoods or pick minorities up.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/posteverything/wp/2015/07/23/...

If a company could bootstrap their company and grow organically, they wouldn’t need VC funding. By definition any company that is using VC funding is pricing their product less than it takes to make it - ie “price dumping”.

There are already laws about zoning that should keep AirBnB in check. I’m doing the digital nomad thing starting next year. I am specifically avoiding AirBnbs and staying in hotels - mostly mid range extended stays.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mschuster91 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:51AM (#32852890)
> Those taxi companies that are their “for the poor” routinely wouldn’t go into “poor” neighborhoods or pick minorities up.

There's no reason to replace an already poor service with one that's even worse and requires a smartphone and a bank account, which adds a further layer of discrimination as about 5% of US households don't even have a bank account, much less a credit card, and 24-13% of poorer classes don't have a smartphone [2].

In contrast, a taxi can (at least by law) be used by anyone with cash, and the data about your travel is not available for police or anyone else to abuse [3].

> By definition any company that is using VC funding is pricing their product less than it takes to make it - ie “price dumping”.

IMO, there's a difference between using VC money to provide funds for growth (aka, a high-risk loan) and using VC money to intentionally provide a service at below-cost - five euros for half a hour taxi ride is not sustainable, it won't even pay for the working time of the driver.

> There are already laws about zoning that should keep AirBnB in check.

Yes, now after years and years of issues and complaints. AirBnB could only grow as large as it did by following the "better ask for forgiveness than permission" lifestyle and blatantly breaking all kinds of laws.

[1] https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/index.html

[2] https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2021/06/22/digital-div...

[3] https://www.vice.com/en/article/mbqq7y/is-uber-doing-enough-...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:58AM (#32853002)
Cell phone penetration in the US is above 85%. Cell phone penetration has been higher in developing countries for years.

At least I as a minority don’t have to worry about a taxi cab bypassing me when I take an Uber.

Taxi companies have been breaking laws for decades against discrimination and don’t get me started about the government monopoly in regards to the medallion system in major cities.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mschuster91 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:06AM (#32853130)
> Cell phone penetration in the US is above 85%. Cell phone penetration has been higher in developing countries for years.

Taxis should be available for everyone, not just the 85% that own a smartphone and don't end up banned by the app out of random [1].

That existing taxi companies don't follow up to the regulations is a different problem (and one where the government definitely has to step up), but Uber and friends aren't even required to follow the same rules, that is the whole point of why these kind of services are so dangerous for society!

[1] https://www.johnnyjet.com/got-banned-uber-fix-problem/

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:38AM (#32853696)
Taxis aren’t available “to everyone” they don’t go into “dangerous neighborhoods” or pick up minorities
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mschuster91 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:47AM (#32853836)
To repeat myself in a bit more detail: by law and regulations they are available to everyone. Non-discrimination is a criteria in almost all medallion / license contracts, not to mention certain laws (e.g. the ADA [1]).

These laws and regulations are, I admit that, often sparsely enforced and most people don't complain anyway, which makes the problem worse as it isn't quantified and shows up on the statistics that politicians and activist groups use either. A lack of data is the single biggest issue in fighting discrimination!

The solution however is not to promote apps like Uber, to which taxicab regulations do not apply at all (or severely restricted) and which just a few weeks ago entered a multi-million dollar settlement for over 65.000 cases of discrimination because they violated the one law that actually is enforced [2].

[1] search for "taxi" on https://www.ada.gov/enforce_current.htm

[2] https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/uber-commits-changes-and-pays...

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @01:10PM (#32855192)
Well, we have an existence proof. The government that you wanted to depend on didn’t in fact do it’s job, a private company did. But you believe that the government will get it right next time?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mschuster91 on Friday September 16, 2022 @04:13AM (#32863497)
> a private company did.

They did not. Uber also got caught discriminating against people.

> But you believe that the government will get it right next time?

I have more faith in government than in private companies which have a massive financial interest in saving the money that compliance with anti-discrimination regulation costs.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by AlexandrB on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:21AM (#32851506)
What's the point of VC investment if the innovative products that are funded are snuffed out by large companies? Might as well not bother and save everyone some time.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:45AM (#32851846)
The point of VC investments by the VCs is to invest in companies and make a healthy return when the company exits.

You didn’t think they were doing it for the good of society?

Once any founder accepts VC funding, all of the talk about “vision” and “impact on society is also null and void”

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by krferriter on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:01AM (#32852129)
They can make a healthy return even if the company isn't sold off and gutted in an acquisition.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:34AM (#32853637)
Who are you to tell the company how much they “should” make? The company was valuable to Adobe because of “synergies”.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by merubin75 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:31AM (#32852640)
I thought it was “to make the world a better place.” ;)

https://youtu.be/B8C5sjjhsso

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by gretch on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:41AM (#32852775)
They did make the world a slightly place. Ppl use their tools and are happy.

What’s the better alternative? That it never existed?

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by bmitc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:24AM (#32852524)
It’s a problem that the MO of venture capitalism is just pump and dump. The only thing VC investments optimize for are exit strategies and not creating actual value. So I wouldn’t see it as a bad thing that such investments are diminished.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:42AM (#32853754)
So who are you going to get to take their place?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by littlestymaar on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:38AM (#32852734)
That's exactly what stock exchanges are for!

Going public should be the norm, not being bough by a monopolist, otherwise the entire premise of what makes capitalism desirable is broken.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by scarface74 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:40AM (#32852763)
As a point of reference. How many companies has YC invested in? How many have gone public? How many of those are profitable?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by buovjaga on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:42AM (#32852778)
> Same thing happened with Architecture software eg when Autocad bought Revit - end result is extortionately priced software that many architects cannot afford because they are paid so poorly.

Architects rolled up their sleeves and are solving the problem by writing open source software: https://osarch.org/

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by nashashmi on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:48AM (#32852856)
I rolled up my sleeve too. And found it completely impractical. Especially for non technical experts to undertake such a massive project.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by detritus on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:38AM (#32851757)
> Same will happen for graphic designers.

I'm not so sure about that, I know quite a few graphic designers who've either reverted to the pirating ways of their youthful years, many years ago - or have moved over to Affinity's offerings.

The latter's still a bit rough around the edge - I can't work with Designer (I've been using Illustrator for too many decades to), but I've stopped paying for old rope and nixed my once-beloved Photoshop as it's frankly a waste of cash. Affinity Photo's got some quirks and has a wholly different workflow that I struggle with, but it does the trick in the end.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mynameisvlad on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:55AM (#32852011)
As an amateur who didn’t have extensive use of Illustrator/Photoshop/InDesign, Designer/Photos/Publisher have been godsends. Relatively cheap, quality usable software.

Could not praise Serif enough for what they’ve done. I gladly paid the license on Mac and windows.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by zippergz on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:10AM (#32852286)
The point is, if Affinity gets too good or competitive, Adobe will acquire them too.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by jacoblambda on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:14AM (#32853282)
This kinda highlights the real solution. Instead of investing in a product which will eventually get bought up by some monopoly and used to hold the users hostage, people should be donating to FOSS tools and/or paying for support contracts with FOSS companies.

Eventually the FOSS alternative becomes competitive and then outright better. It happened quickly in the SW space given that SWEs could dogfood the tools but it's slowly happening in almost every other industry as well. Blender is probably the best example while Krita (raster drawing), QGIS(GIS), Qflow(HDL synthesis tooling collection), FreeCAD(2D/3D CAD), KiCAD(EDA), Darktable(RAW editor, photography tooling) and Ardour (Audio mixer and nonlinear editor) are all catching up in their various spaces.

And there's a reasonable chance that some industries won't be able to develop their own FOSS tooling for whatever reason. In those cases it may be worthwhile for governments to step in and fund open source tooling (like the EU does) to protect their industries from the whims of a foreign company.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by detritus on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:12AM (#32852319)
But they're a British company! British companies NEVER sell out to forei... oh.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by quest88 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:51AM (#32852892)
Let's reword it: The founders may want a payout and sell to Adobe too.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by pastor_bob on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:32AM (#32851658)
Yeah, i don't get this. Seems like textbook anti-competitive behavior to me. Doesn't Adobe already have their own version of Figma (XD)?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by ryanSrich on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:37AM (#32851728)
They do, but it’s not nearly as popular (or as valuable) as Figma.

In the last couple of years Figma has essentially overtaken Adobe and Sketch in terms of designer mindshare and usage. I don’t know a single designer (I know hundreds), that doesn’t use Figma. Of course, I’m focused 100% on software, so I’m strictly talking about product, UI/UX design. Not print or graphic design.

The way I see it, Adobe had to buy Figma.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by capableweb on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:50AM (#32851932)
> The way I see it, Adobe had to buy Figma.

It's so fucked up though. Just because Adobe has existed for a long time and managed to squeeze their existing customers enough, they been able to stop innovating. And instead of innovating enough to be able to beat their competition (Figma), they'll just buy the competition and continue doing the same thing. Until another competitor appears, rinse-and-repeat.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by ryanSrich on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:52AM (#32852906)
I’m definitely less anti-acquisition than most of HN. I think bigger companies buying new startups and smaller companies is a fine growth strategy.

However, in this case, I have to agree. Adobe buying any product is essentially the death of said product.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by exodust on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:31AM (#32852634)
> had to

Or didn't have to, instead improving what they already have.

I wonder if their aim is to own the designer's pipeline, from raw concepts to sharing finished work, nudging price hikes over time? All within Adobe walls and everyone agreeing to Adobe terms. I'm sure it's all fine and not creepy at all.

A designer recently sent me XD links to review, and for the most part it was a smooth experience to preview those assets and designs. She seemed to like XD.

Other times I get Figma links, and it's gonna be weird if they're both Adobe.

For me I can find one criticism of Figma. It's loose. Gets messy when there's lots of pieces spread out. Sometimes I want an anchoring page, latched, not zoom slippery... just constrained for my viewing control. Figma doesn't want you doing such things, it wants you hovering above a carpark looking down at the free and occupied spaces. That said, I haven't spent a huge amount of time in Figma, I log out quickly.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by lvzw on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:59AM (#32852087)
Announcing an intent to acquire a company is not against any competition law. The merger has not been finalized or even officially announced by the parties it seems. The FTC or DOJ will review this merger and if they deem it anticompetitive, they will challenge it.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by skizm on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:44AM (#32851831)
Meanwhile FTC blocking Meta from buying a VR fitness app and gif keyboard lol.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by bredren on Thursday September 15, 2022 @12:01PM (#32854043)
I think that the fitness app is more strategic than figma by far.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by RunSet on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:43AM (#32851817)
> Same thing happened with Architecture software eg when Autocad bought Revit - end result is extortionately priced software that many architects cannot afford

I only hope Macromedia's story doesn't repeat itself: Adobe buying the superior offering just to take it off the market.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by toxican on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:15AM (#32852375)
I don't know what specific piece of software you're referring to, but I think of Fireworks. It was never a 1:1 replacement for Photoshop, but for my uses (as a web developer, during the era of slicing up designs) it was leaps and bound better.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by pier25 on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:58AM (#32852048)
You mean Freehand, right?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by legitster on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:21AM (#32852464)
Anti-trust laws were written to address certain perceptions of how businesses operated back in the late 1800s. They were not particularly grounded in reality, and as such they are hard to actually implement as written in most situations.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:25AM (#32852539)
> Anti-trust laws were written to address certain perceptions of how businesses operated back in the late 1800s

Source? First I’ve heard of Teddy Roosevelt’s trust busting being a grandiose PR campaign.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by legitster on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:53AM (#32852918)
Trusts in particular (cooperation agreements between competitors) were entirely a fad of businesses in the 1800s, particularly amongst more progressive-leaning Chairman. It is doubtful they would have had long term success even without government intervention.

https://southerncalifornialawreview.com/wp-content/uploads/2...

We also know that things like predatory pricing and trying to undercut businesses to acquire them was somewhat of a myth. If Standard oil sold for less than you, it was because their operation costs were lower because they were bigger.

http://www-personal.umich.edu/~twod/oil/NEW_SCHOOL_COURSE200...

The enforcement of the Anti-trust act mostly relied on companies suing each other for grievances. But most companies never brought grievances about being acquired.

It was a PR campaign! But for protective tariffs: https://timesmachine.nytimes.com/timesmachine/1890/10/01/103... Sherman himself was pretty open that he wanted to blame rising costs on businesses when a new round of tariffs was passed into law.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by JumpCrisscross on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:11AM (#32853235)
Fair enough. If the claim is that antitrust measures were in the long run ineffective, not that they were dishonestly pursued, you have solid ground to stand on.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by bmitc on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:31AM (#32852645)
It sort of was in the sense of Taft, Roosevelt’s successor, being much more aggressive and effective in actually bringing anti-trust lawsuits to fruition.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by myth_drannon on Thursday September 15, 2022 @08:34AM (#32850830)
The company is Autodesk, the product is Autocad.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by mynameisvlad on Thursday September 15, 2022 @09:56AM (#32852026)
Is this level of pedantry needed? Even without the clarification, everyone knew what the parent comment meant.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by cjbgkagh on Thursday September 15, 2022 @11:06AM (#32853140)
VCs have just been given 20B new reasons to fund a new startup in this domain. Could result in a cornucopia of new startups.
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by bearmode on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:54AM (#32852928)
I used to be a graphic designer, have my degree in it etc before I switched to development.

Adobe's pricing is more than fair. At least compared to what it used to be, where you'd have to shell out a couple of grand every 2-3 years to keep up with major releases. For me, it worked out a bit cheaper now than it did back then, but I also got a massive, high-quality font library thrown in as well as a bunch of other newer programs like Dimension.

They already have a functional monopoly in the industry and the prices aren't too bad.

Also Figma was a rival to Adobe XD, which was already actually cheaper than Figma was/is.

Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by s3r3nity on Thursday September 15, 2022 @03:47PM (#32857553)
Fam - we can’t even make climate change laws without oil lobbies paying lawmakers off…what makes you think that yet another corruptible organization in govt is going to help?
Re:Adobe to acquire Figma for $20B by frakkingcylons on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:31AM (#32852649)
The FTC and other regulatory bodies could still move to block this, it’s not final in any way.