News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by huevosabio on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:44PM (#32841472)
If you think, as I do, that this is absurd join other like-minded people in San Francisco's 2022 YIMBY Prom Party: https://yimbyaction.org/2021/events/yimby-prom-gala-bay-area...

There will be drinks and appetizers, as well as the bulk of the Yimby and Yimby-adjacent people in the Bay Area.

The funds raised go exactly to fight the type of cronyism and insanity that makes SF so ossified and housing impossible to build.

(if you do buy tickets, write huevosabio as referral and DM me to meet there :))

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by braingenious on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:28PM (#32842094)
> The funds raised go exactly to fight the type of cronyism and insanity that makes SF so ossified and housing impossible to build.

Is there a detailed breakdown of how these funds are allocated exactly? I see that the mayor is the star VIP guest, is this function for her re-election?

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by klyrs on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:12PM (#32841879)
> (if you do buy tickets, write huevosabio as referral and DM me to meet there :))

it is so weird when people do this on HN with no contact info in their profiles ;)

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by pooper on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:23PM (#32842031)
> it is so weird when people do this on HN with no contact info in their profiles ;)

I googled their username, clicked through to github, clicked through to repositories, clicked through to personal page (first repository on list), clicked through to cv folder, clicked through to cv pdf, and there they have a phone number and email address.

All of this is publicly available but takes at least four clicks but most importantly, I am not sure whether it is the same person!

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by huevosabio on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:46PM (#32842378)
Lol!

Reach out to me at [email protected]

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by actionfromafar on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:24PM (#32842042)
You are clearly not in their backyard. :-)
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by huevosabio on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:47PM (#32842385)
Good point!

email: [email protected]

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by offsign_p on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:40PM (#32842289)
Does YimbyAction.org support the 'inclusionary housing' permitting requirement cited in above article? (Based on the site, certainly seems so.)

The article describes these mechanisms as the "800-pound gorilla" in what makes development in SF unaffordable (and therefore economically unviable), so having trouble aligning this advocacy with the root cause of the housing shortage.

What am I missing?

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by huevosabio on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:02PM (#32844034)
YA is against the inclusionary housing requirement _as implemented by SF_. It is often used as a type of extortion to outright dissuade new construction.

More broadly, in my experience, Yimbys have mixed-to-negative opinion on inclusionary zoning since it is essentially a tax on new construction, though there are a non-trivial amount of Yimbys who think its a good way to produce subsidized housing.

I personally think we should not be taxing new projects implicitly or explicitly at all, and instead we should use property taxes (especially land value taxes) to subsidize housing either via vouchers or via publicly built housing.

The reality of the CA political system makes all of this very hard to achieve and we often find ourselves settling on taking small but achievable steps.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by fmajid on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:23PM (#32842844)
It's not one 800lb gorilla but a whole troupe of them mentioned in the article:

- a capricious and arbitrary permitting process

- multiple opportunities for groups to cause mischief, with some like Calle 24 barely disguising that they are shakedown rackets

- excessively restrictive zoning

It essentially boils down to this: there are haves (people who own their own homes like many SF supervisors and like to see them appreciate, and Boomers benefitting from rent control and paying a pittance) who have political power and new entrants who have none. The solution will not come from within, but from the State preempting local control, like Scott Wiener's heroic efforts in Sacramento like SB35. If a housing project is 50% affordable, it can skip most of the rigmarole, as occurred in Potrero Hill:

https://www.sfchronicle.com/sf/article/How-one-S-F-housing-p...

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by ed25519FUUU on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:47PM (#32841514)
Do the YIMBY groups support dropping environmental impact studies for new buildings?
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by huevosabio on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:52PM (#32841569)
For the most part, archaic and ad-hoc requirements yes. For example, you'll often see us complain about CEQA.

In an ideal YIMBY world, the government would just give a clear checklist of what can be built (based on safety and environmental requirements) and as long as your project follows that, no one should be able to delay or oppose your building.

What we have instead is arbitrary impact studies that anyone can throw to a developer and snooze the project indefinitely.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by robocat on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:08PM (#32841826)
The NZ government (bipartisan decision) has recently made all city councils allow densification by default. “The so-called Medium Density Residential Standard will require the country’s most populous cities to permit up to three stories and three dwellings on all existing residential parcels of land. The policy would allow a parcel with a detached single-family dwelling to be redeveloped into row houses or a small apartment block.”[3].

> as long as your project follows [the planning and building codes], no one should be able to delay or oppose your building.

That is how the regulations are designed in Christchurch, New Zealand: automatic consent if you stick within the codes. You require consent if you need to do something outside of the default rules, and NIMBYs can affect that consent process, so the default rules really really matter.

Housing prices were fairly insane levels[1] but are now reducing[2] (although interest rates are also affecting that).

[1] March 22: Auckland is eighth least affordable city for housing in new rankings https://www.stuff.co.nz/life-style/homed/real-estate/1280272...

[2] Sept 22: NZ tumbles down international house price growth ranks https://www.stuff.co.nz/life-style/homed/real-estate/1298444...

[3] New Zealand’s bipartisan housing reforms offer a model to other countries https://www.brookings.edu/blog/the-avenue/2022/01/24/new-zea...

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by wwweston on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:58PM (#32841666)
I'd imagine the tradeoff here is that impact studies allow for more variation, while generally clear checklists might need to include overgenerally strict items in order to prevent problems that might only be applicable in a few situations.

I suppose the middle ground would be automatic green light for developers who can tick off every box on the overgeneral checklist + impact studies for people who want exceptions.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by jjoonathan on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:07PM (#32841807)
How is that a middle ground? How does it address the "snooze forever" exploit?
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by wwweston on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:21PM (#32844835)
The overall endpoints for this discussion are "no oversight, laissez faire all the development!" and "no development, snooze forever."

The endpoints suggested by the comment I responded to were "impact study" (with risks of indefinite timeline) and "greenlight checklist."

I responded with this suggestion: greenlight checklist, with the option for impact study to justify exceptions to that checklist. Would-be builders get a choice between the two.

The reasoning is that any greenlight checklist that's sufficient to do the job of custom impact studies will probably need to impose requirements that may not be practically necessary for every project. So, let people choose to check all the boxes (even some that might not be strictly necessary in order to avoid negative impacts) OR have a custom impact study done in order to receive specific exceptions.

How is that not middle ground in between either set of endpoints?

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by chongli on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:14PM (#32841908)
clear checklist of what can be built (based on safety and environmental requirements)

Such a thing doesn’t and cannot exist. One of the (many) purposes of environmental impact studies is to stop (for example) a new golf course from destroying a bunch of wetlands habitat for endangered species. If the species can only be found in one small area then there’s no rubber-stamp process that will protect it. These projects need to be studied in detail, on a case by case basis, to determine what impact they’ll have on the environment. There are whole fields of engineering that deal with this subject.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by thebradbain on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:24PM (#32842043)
Ok, but that's not what OP is advocating for. At the very least there should be streamlined CEQA processes applicable for certain developments in certain areas. IE -- it is not at all crazy for a 4/8/10-plex townhome-style development to be built on a piece of land in San Francisco that currently contains a single family home, or an undeveloped paved parking lot.

Individual parcels of land that are especially exceptional within such areas can be marked as such (think historical landmark designations, though that process is a whole separate can of worms).

Yet currently San Francisco has some of the kafka-esque building requirements for the most common types of buildings AND 4 private golf courses on what would most certainly be classified as protected wetlands today. So clearly today's CEQA isn't even working by your own scenario.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by ROTMetro on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:28PM (#32842099)
The problem is that this consideration has been weaponized to the point of abuse so bad that some people cynically no longer see deferring to these considerations as something legitimate.

In addition, in the crazy red state I now live, people are slowly filling anything that could be considered wetlands on their property to proactively protect their property rights. So this consideration is now RESPONSIBLE for active wetland destruction and a hostile attitude by many towards wetlands on their property.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by kevin_thibedeau on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:21PM (#32841999)
SF isn't pristine nature. It's entirely a man made construct.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by Aunche on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:31PM (#32842149)
I doubt you're going to find any meaningful insights from a environmental impact study of a standardized 5-over-1 built in a suburb.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by purpleblue on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:32PM (#32842164)
We should ban new golf courses, and reclaim 90% of all golf courses completely. It's a game that uses a ridiculous amount of resources that benefits very little. I'd rather see housing built on existing golf courses.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by samatman on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:41PM (#32842308)
Fortunately, we don't employ eminent domain because some guy on the internet is sure that something better should be done with the land.

Golf courses generally underpay property tax and services, so you could try and tax them out of existence, the ones which aren't municipal at least. Progressive water bills is an option for the dryer parts of the country.

This would be a quick education in the role which golf actually plays in society, I expect.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by bombcar on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:04PM (#32843334)
Just combine the golf courses and cemeteries! Problem solved.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by idontpost on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:41PM (#32842302)
This conversation is about housing, not golf courses. In particular, it's about housing in areas where housing is already built.

> If the species can only be found in one small area then there’s no rubber-stamp process that will protect it.

So don't zone that area for housing. Problem solved.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by enragedcacti on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:55PM (#32841620)
> Policies in this category include “by right” or “as of right” permitting, permit streamlining, California’s SB 35, and reform of environmental review processes.

https://yimbyaction.org/2021/solutions/

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by agalunar on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:36PM (#32842237)
I read some time ago an interview with a member of the San Francisco Board of Supervisors and an article about the YIMBY movement:

• https://www.currentaffairs.org/2021/11/san-francisco-sociali...

• https://www.currentaffairs.org/2021/01/the-only-thing-worse-...

I'd be very interested if anyone knows anything further about the topic or knows of any replies to the criticisms levied.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by myspy on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:02PM (#32842602)
I see it similarly in Germany. More social housing build by the government is needed to enable people with lower income living there.

We did that less and less in Germany and now we pay the price. Higher rents and less room to live in.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by agalunar on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @08:42PM (#32845521)
Thank you so much, @ZoomerCretin and @huevosabio!

I think this has left me with only more questions, and I might ask a few of them later when I have a moment, but I wanted to say I appreciate you taking the time to reply.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by ZoomerCretin on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:55PM (#32843949)
Robinson: "It’s a gentrifying city..."

"""Gentrification""" being used unironically should be the only thing you need to know about how far Robinson's mental model of the housing market is from reality.

Preston: "…is that they’re market fundamentalists. And they believe that simply creating more housing for rich people will ultimately trickle down to people who aren’t rich—maybe in a decade, maybe 50 years."

YIMBYs are not libertarian market fundamentalists. We believe that the principal cause of the housing crisis is that there is a shortage of housing. Simply removing zoning restrictions would not fix the situation for poor people, but that's not what YIMBYs argue. They want a mix of zoning reform, expanded housing vouchers, and yes, public housing.

Let's suppose that we only expand housing vouchers. We have rules forbidding increasing the supply of housing, and a policy that subsidizes demand. What happens to price? It goes up. How many more people do we house? No one, because you can't subsidize your way out of a shortage, and you can't redistribute your way out of a shortage.

Let's suppose that we only build public housing. We still have rules forbidding increasing density. Unless "build public housing" means building public single family home lot sprawl, nothing will get built. _The same zoning restrictions that prevent new private housing also prevent new public housing._

Let's suppose that we only reform zoning. Now it's legal to build more housing, and people will spend money building taller buildings with far more units for more people to live in. Since apartment units are built for far less money per-unit than detached homes, this lowers the price floor that housing can be offered at, allowing housing to become cheaper if we build enough housing to put serious dents in the vacancy rate. We're still leaving out the poor, since housing does take time to filter.

Zoning is not the end-all be-all of policy tools for fixing the housing crisis. YIMBYs agree. But it is the first step, and the single biggest tool in our policy toolbox. Everything starts with supply, and the biggest constraint on supply is zoning. After that, you can clean up the remaining market failures (i.e. homelessness, rent-burdened low-income people) with housing vouchers and much smaller public housing projects than you would need without zoning reform.

Preston: "For all the talk in this city, even a city that’s more progressive on some issues, for all the talk when it comes down to who our economy caters to—not just in housing, but especially in housing—it caters to the wealthy."

Preston literally blocked a 400+ unit housing development _on a valet parking lot_. _He is_ the wealthy person being catered to by the establishment.

Preston: "I thought we could control the rents a bit and have some protections in place. Maybe this can work if we just make developers do a handful of affordable units when they build, and maybe we’ll get there somehow."

Developers don't build out of the kindness of their hearts, they do it for money. If they're forced to subsidize too many "affordable units" with market rate units, the development won't be profitable, so they don't build. If the rent they can collect is capped early, they don't build. Remember, in California, because of Proposition 13, there are enough property owners paying 40-year old property tax valuations that renting is frequently 5-8x cheaper than buying. Literally some properties that rent for $4k/month (@ $600/month property tax) sell at prices of $15k/month mortgage + $3.5k/month property tax. In order for new build rental housing to be competitive with old rental housing, you need to build a shit ton of it to get the per-unit costs down since you're already paying far higher property taxes than landlords who have owned the same property for 30-50 years. San Francisco simply is not zoned for the density of housing that would make a lot more construction financially feasible. Add on rent control and making 30-50% of units "affordable", and you make it even harder for new housing to be built.

Preston: "Well, I think the city and government has to be in the business of actually creating housing for people that is not for profit, right?"

Public housing is good. However, the city and government will be building housing at per-unit prices that would be financially infeasible for private developers and renting them below cost. Even at-cost, these units would be far more expensive than they need to be. You still haven't fixed the underlying cause that you've put so many artificial constraints in front of building housing that you've made it far more expensive than it needs to be. Making the government pay $900k to build a unit and renting it for $800/month and just throwing the entire state budget into doing this _could_ solve the problem, yes, but I think we're better off making new units cost less than $900k to build than we are throwing money that could be better spent on this.

Preston: "I think that’s certainly a factor here. We commissioned a report—and we’re expecting to announce it fairly soon—from the budget, legislative analysts looking at vacancies in San Francisco. And there are a ton of vacancies. A lot of newly constructed places like these luxury condos that sit particularly in the South of Market neighborhood in San Francisco just sit empty, and it’s exactly as you’re describing. You can see at night what’s lit up and what isn’t."

People don't have their lights on at night, therefore their units are empty/vacant? Does he leave all of his indoor lights on when he goes out at night? I certainly don't.

Preston's Board of Supervisors actually passed a vacancy tax on units. It excluded luxury properties (Single family homes) like his. Take that for what you will.

Robinson: "If you have an apartment building with 50 units occupied by working-class tenants, and it’s demolished, and they build something that has 100 units, but it’s 100 people from Palo Alto who come and move in, you have the aggregate number of total units increased—you say we’ve got more housing—but you’ve actually managed to displace more working-class people from the city in the process."

If they're rent-controlled, they can't force the tenants out. If it's not, those working-class tenants were forced out by rent increases or general cost of living costs long ago. More units are better, because the root of the housing crisis is the shortage.

Preston: "Right. It’s always the loopholes around rent control that are used to attack rent control. There’s just such a disconnect between working-class folks and the pundits on rent control, right? You go to all these economics departments, and you can find lots of professors who are going to tell you how rent controls are bad and distort the market. A few of them will give you some support. But generally, you go and talk to people who are living in rent-controlled apartments, or live in San Francisco, where there would be virtually no working-class left in San Francisco, were it not for rent control."

Rent control reduces supply and doesn't help newcomers. It is great for current tenants, though.

Imagine you're a woman who's in an abusive relationship, but you share a rent-controlled unit with your abuser. If leaving means your share of rent goes from $800/month to $2,500/month, how likely are you to leave your abusive husband/boyfriend?

Rent control does not help people who have only recently started renting. A rich software engineer who lives in a rent-controlled unit for 30 years is paying less than a student who just moved to the bay for school and has to fork over $2-3k/month for a room. Is that fair? Older, well-established dual income married couples in rent-controlled units who are in the later and highest-earning stage of their career pay far less than the 26 year old transplants who just want enough space for themselves and a kid. Is that fair?

We are all better off when the market rate is lower for everyone. Rent control reduces supply and forces landlords to raise rents in other units, forcing poorer, younger, possibly abused newcomers to subsidize the older, richer, and more well-established residents of an area. That is not a solution to the housing crisis. Just build more fucking units.

Preston: "Even the studies from the economics professors who attack rent control always have to acknowledge, in all those studies, how effective rent control is in stabilizing housing for seniors, disabled folks, and the most vulnerable folks, even as they attack it on theoretical grounds. They still acknowledge that it works to do what it’s supposed to do, which is to stabilize people in their homes."

Rent control is America First, but for local cities. This is the principal flaw of democracy; politicians have no incentive to represent people outside their district. This "America First"-style politicking, more specifically, is politicians putting their constituents' interests before the interests of non-constituents _to the detriment of everyone_. Rent control may be great for the few is benefits, but it makes the problem worse for everyone else.

Don't get me wrong; rent control is a great policy when enacted with some limitations. Rent should not be allowed to be hiked more than 10% per year; but it cannot be enacted without other measures to increase the supply of housing, else you create a two-tiered housing market: one for the rent-controlled, who are stuck in place but get fabulous rents, and one for newcomers who are stuck with the bill for all of your overly-generous rent control.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by ZoomerCretin on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:56PM (#32843962)
I'm realizing now that it would take far too long to refute each and every point in one article, let alone both. I'll just leave you with some tweets and sources that support the YIMBY point of view of the housing crisis and let you peruse them at your own rate:

Current Affairs is run by Nathan Robinson, a "socialist" union-buster who fired every Current Affairs staff member that attempted to unionize. That should tell you what kind of socialist he is; a rich trust fund baby that is more concerned with the aesthetic of being a socialist than the real and actual material conditions that socialism is intended to improve.

Dean Preston is a millionaire homeowner "socialist" who blocked a Nordstrom valet parking lot from becoming 400+ homes (many of which would have been reserved for people with below the area's median income) because "it wasn't affordable enough", AKA not perfect. The status quo of zero new housing supply suits Dean's class interests just fine, as his property will appreciate far faster without it.

Now that I've finished with the ad hominem, onto the articles, tweets, and sources:

Removing zoning restrictions is effective in increasing housing construction: https://twitter.com/mnolangray/status/1559610823353307136?s=...

Building more housing, even market-rate housing, reduces aggregate rents and displacement: https://twitter.com/IDoTheThinking/status/155136150802978406...

Real world example: Auckland, New Zealand: https://twitter.com/UrbFuturistDem/status/154986439702730342...

Vacancies are directly correlated with rent prices.

See New York City: https://twitter.com/NYCComptroller/status/154686782637968589...

Vacancies rose during the pandemic as people left the city. Rent fell. Then people came back, reducing housing vacancies. Rent went back up, climbing to new record highs. Vacancy rates determine the price of rent. Building more housing increases the supply of housing, which increases vacancy rates, which in turn slows rent price growth or reduces rents entirely.

This is not a fringe political ideology, but one tacitly endorsed by President Barack Obama: https://twitter.com/cafedujord/status/1541601275212619777?s=...

Current zoning restrictions weren't set in stone from the founding of cities, but enacted in the 70s to prevent population growth after the Fair Housing Act was passed. It had the intent and effect of keeping out poorer residents, a good-enough proxy for people of color. https://twitter.com/mateosfo/status/1540060815490813952

Los Angeles used to be zoned for 10,000,000. New York City used to be zoned for 55,000,000. We can simply remove this outdated restrictions in every city and allow builders to create the housing we need. Imagine a New York City or Los Angeles where rents were $1,500/month, and far lower in the rest of the country. This is the future that the YIMBY movement is fighting for. All it takes is pre-empting local zoning restrictions, which the states of California, Oregon, and Minnesota have already begun to do. [This is how Tokyo's housing prices have grown no more than 10% since the year 2000](https://twitter.com/aaronAcarr/status/1539606088819085312?s=...): they set zoning laws at the federal level, and build far more housing than we do.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by huevosabio on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @06:34PM (#32844353)
I think ZoomerCretin took the effort of going over the two articles in a more thorough fashion. I simply skimmed through, but am roughly familiar with the type of arguments Dean Preston and the prog side of the city would make.

I will try to go over the main type of accusations and refute them as best I can. I previously created a deck for an internal presentation at my company that you can peruse for a broad overview of how I see the whole thing [0]. You can find charts and some sources there backing what follows.

Note that the movement is actually quite diverse and the exact opinions vary, but I will try to summarize in good faith what we stand for.

--- Accusation: A common argument would be that we are "market fundamentalist" and that we believe in "trickle down economics".

This accusation seems to be made so that the audience lumps us with Tea Party conservatives and George W Bush. I find it laughable. Yimby Action members are on average left-of-center. I would probably fall on the right-most side of the spectrum and still would be far from the Tea Parties and GWBs of the world.

In reality, we tend to look at the data and draw conclusions based on economic principles. The truth is that we have been under producing housing for decades now. It's a widespread issue in the West, but it is particularly acute in the Coastal US and other anglophone countries.

We know it is a supply issue because reliably rents are go up as rental vacancies go down and viceversa. Same holds for prices (though I think rents are a better metric, given that housing prices bolt in a layer of speculation). We know that supply is constrained because of ridiculous laws because you can see it in data as the one shown in this article, and because you see alternatives such as Tokyo where building is relatively unhampered, has been growing over the last decades and yet has kept stable housing costs.

--- Accusation: That we are astroturfing for developers and only care about developer's giveaway.

This is just an attempt to create a boogeyman and then connecting everything to it. They chose to make developers the boogeyman instead of landlords, unsurprisingly because most of those making the accusations are landlords themselves.

Every building that has ever existed had a developer (in the general sense) behind it, and profited in one way or another. That's why they built, because it made sense for them. We engage in transactions where one party makes a profit in exchange for generating something valuable for the other party. This is good. We don't want to give away money to developers, we want them to be able to perform their productive function in society.

Landlords are not necessarily bad either. Owning is not necessarily for everyone, so there must be a rental stock. Landlords manage that rental stock and there is value in that.

What is actually bad is having a fixed housing stock that continuously appreciates and extracts increasingly higher rents. We think this is our current situation, and the only way out of it is to make it easy to add more to the housing stock.

--- Accusation: We are against government all intervention in the housing market.

This accusation again is used to try to scare those that are currently hurt the most by the housing situation from joining our side. But it is far, far from truth.

We think that shelter being a basic necessity should be regulated to an extent. We believe there should be a proper system for how and under what conditions a landlord can evict a tenant.

We aren't against government investment in housing, be it via vouchers or by developing public housing. In fact, most of us would readily admit that even in the ideal world you will need some government effort to keep the poorest among us from falling into homelessness.

---

I hope this helps.

[0] https://docs.google.com/presentation/d/1O1_oW0Ci2SJEIIhXzuzV...

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by socalledyimby on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:12PM (#32842715)
> The funds raised go exactly to fight the type of cronyism and insanity that makes SF so ossified and housing impossible to build.

I am a San Francisco resident and living near the Mission laundromat in the article.

I am skeptical your cringe thing will achieve much against problems from this article.

The people on your website have been in power for a few years. They haven't dealt with some problems that take an afternoon to solve, that don't seem to exist everywhere. A poll is cheap, and I'm sure they've conducted some to determine a popular and re-electable course of action.

Clearly the status quo is popular enough to win them office, so why the fuck should I give them money? That will achieve the opposite of what I want. It's completely bonkers dumb.

An intellectually honest approach would find an opposition candidate to run.

The real problem is votes. The right to do whatever the fuck you want with a piece of shit laundromat is, essentially, protecting the minority from a dumbfuck majority.

It's crazy because it's the same energy that mobilizes San Franciscans on many issues, like the minority rights to an abortion, gay marriage, minority religions, etc. For some reason minority rights are organized by how strongly the emotions are felt, instead of like, an objective criteria.

There are issues with strong emotions people can mobilize for. Let me give you a taste of what would motivate me:

> Likewise, the board cited CEQA in denying Tillman’s project in 2018, saying it could cast shadows over a nearby playground.

Alioto Park, which is not obscured by this site but is another playground of many in the Mission, is inhabited by literal heroin addicts, alcoholics and other bottle guys all day. Unusable by children. Dolores Park has people also drinking alcohol and doing drugs. And yet, the playground is eminently usable, clean and well maintained. What gives?

Some people just fucking suck dude. Bottle guys really suck way harder than hipsters. It's so fucking ridiculous that some pieces of shit care about this abstract shadow problem, and in the same breath tolerate their shitty bottle guys in Alioto.

They shit their obese chihuahuas on every street and don't pick up. Listen, some people just don't fucking ever litter. I don't ever litter.

They do a shit job maintaining their million dollar, crumbling homes. Their schools suck. They voted for a repeal of the law that would let them send their kids to better schools, because they're dumb. They pile kids and old relatives into apartments to maximize buyout costs. They pay property taxes stuck in the 80s. They park in the middle of Valencia street for church, and put up a sign that says "Church Parking Only." On a public street dude. They block people's driveways, renters' driveways.

The action I want is, "Everyone deserves a community, not the same community." Identify a politician brave enough to say these people suck, the people who tolerate them suck and should leave or let economic forces drive them out, and I'll come to your cringe thing. Until then, you'll keep shoveling over money to losers, putting pussyhats into dumpsters.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by twixfel on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:26PM (#32843610)
Not a very convincing argument on any level. All you're telling us is that you don't want people living near you, OK, but we already knew that.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by nopenopenopeno on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:41PM (#32842301)
FYI: When someone uses the term “YIMBY” all I hear is “LANDLORD” and I don’t think I am alone.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by TulliusCicero on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:44PM (#32842344)
That makes no sense. Landlords tend to be opposed to YIMBY's, because allowing for more housing makes for a more competitive housing market, rather than one in which landowners dominate.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by nopenopenopeno on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:55PM (#32842512)
Why would landlords in the market with the highest demand prioritize fending off competition? The answer is they wouldn’t. You’re full of it.

Landlords want to maximize profit from their property and when demand is soaring above supply, adding units is the way to do that so they are organizing to overturn laws that prevent them from doing so.

There is a reason the tickets to this event cost $100+. This isn’t a working class movement lol.

You are either stupid yourself or you’ve got a lot of nerve to act like others are, which is to say you certainly act like a landlord.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by prottog on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:29PM (#32842925)
> Landlords want to maximize profit from their property and when demand is soaring above supply, adding units is the way to do that

You're saying that as supply catches up to the soaring demand, profits will go up instead of down?

There's a lot of name-calling in your post and not a lot of sense.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by deathanatos on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:27PM (#32843620)
> You're saying that as supply catches up to the soaring demand, profits will go up instead of down?

I don't think you're wrong on the larger point that landlords are more likely to be on the side of NIMBYism / NIMBYs are going to be land owners.

But, to an extent this is possible; the price would drop for the additional supply, but the total of (now_higher_supply * now_lower_price) can still be greater than (original_lower_supply * original_higher_price). Depends on how the market demand responds to the additional supply, and how much additional supply there is. (It can happen the other way, too, where the drop in price outweighs the new profit from the new supply, and total profit drops.)

… so it kinda requires an idea of how the additional supply would cause the price to change, beyond what I suspect most landlords have. And a foresight/long-termism that I also don't think exists. And if you're a small time landlord not planning on building additional properties, then your supply is always 1, and if the price does down, obviously then too the product does. And I think in SF, the additional supply that is needed, from a more moral standpoint of "people need to live, commuting is bad for the environment and people's health", is crap tons of additional housing. The price to rent could halve and still be too high.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by nopenopenopeno on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @10:03PM (#32846136)
Right. It doesn’t matter if landlords collectively profit because their behaviors are guided by their individual interests, not all the landlords of SF as one.

In other words, different landlords with different plans, assets, and resources will act differently. Even if the collective landlords of SF did somehow lose profit from NIMBYism’s rise, some of them will stand to gain a lot and I’d bet on landlords at this NIMBY Prom event standing to gain a lot.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by bombcar on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:08PM (#32843378)
NIMBY in the streets and YIMBY in the sheets I guess.

If I owned a block of single family houses in Frisco I’d want to be able to turn my block to a giant apartment complex at the same time I’d want to prevent anyone else doing a similar thing.

Then my profit goes up and isn’t endangered.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by nopenopenopeno on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @10:05PM (#32846141)
Precisely.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by dannyobrien on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:49PM (#32842425)
I think you're in a relatively small demographic that has even heard of YIMBY, and mainly heard of it through a small contingent of leftist critiques (and also has a negative view of landlords).

Even in SF, that's not really the group whose mind the movement is intending to change. That's the group whose dominant historical grip on the left they're determined to dislodge, because of its harmful effect on San Francisco's progressive program.

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by nopenopenopeno on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:00PM (#32842568)
So who are these people? The politicians are absolutely landlord-adjacent (i.e. NIMBY adjacent) if not landlords themselves, but who are the others? Just some desperate wage earners eager to dispose of their latest $100+ of income on this cheesy fundraiser? Give me a break!
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by dannyobrien on Friday September 16, 2022 @04:05PM (#32871351)
I'm a bit confused by you using NIMBY and YIMBY interchangeably here, but most of the YIMBY activists I know come from people who got into housing policy because they couldn't afford to live in SF. They're all renters, and most come from a lefty political background.

Fundraising events are pretty common in this kind of environment: if it was landlord driven, i'd imagine the tickets would be more in the thousands, as that's common for traditional for party political fundraisers in US cities, where you are paying for access. I'd compare it to, say, the Harvey Milk Club Gayla, whose prices you can see here: https://www.milkclub.org/gayla

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by justinc-md on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:47PM (#32842386)
Why would landlords want to drive down the price of housing?
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by nopenopenopeno on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:48PM (#32842412)
Landlords care about profit, not price.
Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by api on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:17PM (#32842775)
If supply isn't increased but demand is increased, the price goes up. San Francisco is a popular city with a strong job market (demand) and won't build housing, so the price goes up.

What part of that is hard for people to understand?

Re:How San Francisco makes it insanely hard to build housing by prottog on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:33PM (#32842985)
The part that's hard for people to understand is not the basic supply and demand issue, but rather why well-intentioned, good-sounding policies like environmental review processes, rent control, or mandatory affordable housing quotas don't accomplish what they say they would; to understand the latter requires an understanding of the higher-order repercussions of those policies.