News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by Bostonian on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:15PM (#32841019)
In some cases the young women involved are exploiting guys who are messed up. It's legal, but I don't think it's moral.

"But David worked the night shift at a car manufacturing plant, and he was always broke. He could only pay the girls on Fridays when he got his paycheck. Despite this, he consistently spent quite a bit of money for Lainey to send feet pics (only the bottom of the feet!), and — crucially — to tell him he was a loser, his dick was small, and “send me money.” The mismatch between his income and his spending worried the girls enough that they considered intervening, but ultimately decided there was not much they could do to help."

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by smoldesu on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:58PM (#32840801)
> But both sides, the girls and the men paying them, benefit from the objectification of the other, at least on the surface — the girls, by profiting from the man’s isolation and dire circumstances, and the men, by sexualizing the girls. One perhaps is not worse than the other, but neither is worth celebrating.

It's great when you read an article so obviously ill-founded that the author has to admit they're wrong at the end. This is a cycle that has existed for hundreds of years, it's asinine to me that people are still trying to make some kind of 'moral play' here. It's a free country; these free people are creating enterprise based on their likeness. I'm sure that riles up HN users who spend their lives building thankless, exploitative SaaS products that get cursed by their users under their breath, the same as this site seems to hate 'influencer culture' and social media as a whole. At the end of the day, though, they're living a life they're happy with. They can advocate for themselves and aren't being pimped out by someone who doesn't care about their wellbeing. Other jobs and careers are completely attainable still, if not completely possible to have alongside whatever OnlyFans account you run.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:09PM (#32841834)
You are equating the happiness of the individuals involved as the basis for determining whether or not the action is moral. Its inherently a hedonistic perspective. Of course you can't make a moral claim that prostitution is wrong if you consider the "happiness" of the pimp, prostitute, and john as the highest good involved. Frankly, I'm not sure how you could make many moral claims considered reasonable based on that kind of criteria. Using the same measure you could justify all sorts of abusive situations so long as the exploited is "happy" with their circumstances.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by smoldesu on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:36PM (#32842224)
I make no moral claim because I don't see a moral axis here. It's equivalent to arguing about the morality of cigarette companies or breweries; our societal precedent for freedom overrides whatever personal harm it might cause. Same goes for selling knives, guns, porno films or sex toys. We can obviously regulate the obscene and dangerous conduct surrounding these things (and we do), but the right to having them is what drives our free market. It's no more exploitative than Apple teasing you with an iPhone 14 event, getting you tech-horny enough to open your wallet come October.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:24PM (#32843568)
You are making many moral claims. Your standard for what is moral are all over the place but you just made one:

> "...our societal precedent for freedom overrides whatever personal harm it might cause"

You've just appealed to a relativistic moral standard. Essentially, because we have a precedent for "freedom" in regards to possession of certain substances or items we as a society are justified in ignoring the detrimental effects of the mentioned items.

By that same train of logic, societal reform of any kind is actually a bad thing because you are overturning the existing precedent 0f that society. Its absurd.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by rngname22 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:16PM (#32841940)
Sorry, but you can acknowledge that something is ethical and moral while also acknowledging that the incentives of a system result in some local maximum in the happiness of the players involved where a different set of incentives might yield a global maximum that yields a great satisfaction for all parties involved.

The best good-faith criticisms of this arrangement of dating have nothing to do with puritanism, misogyny, envy, or selfishness but instead are criticisms that the dating market involved is dissatisfying to most or all involved compared to what it could be.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by smoldesu on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:49PM (#32842435)
> but instead are criticisms that the dating market involved is dissatisfying to most or all involved compared to what it could be.

According to who? You? I know this site's demographics and prejudices, the middle-class heterosexual white male perspective on dating should be worse than it was 50 years ago! Especially here in the US, the notion of the man courting multiple women has been flipped on it's head. Women are getting more cautious, thinking long-term instead of throwing their hopes and dreams into Joe Shmoe with his Bachelors degree and $50,000 of college debt. I'll listen to people whine about morals until the cows come home, but I think Occam's razor would suggest that men simply have less authority in the dating scene now, leading to greater dissatisfaction and mounting resentment towards sex work. It's a childish thing to complain about.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by rngname22 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:04PM (#32842617)
I find your notion that dating 'should be worse' implies dating as a zero-sum game where conditions for one demographic improving necessitates the loss of another group. I disagree with that premise, and none of the 'dissatisfying' parts of dating that I'd say men uniquely experience are necessarily at the benefit of women or some other demographic. And finally I'd not say that the growth of sugar baby style relationships or OnlyFans is primarily at the detriment of men, I'd say it's less than ideal for any gender or group involved. But not really interested in further discussion as it seems like you're more interested in identity politics or looking at things through demographics.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by Joewashere on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:45PM (#32843826)
For pete's sake. Sexting and sending pictures to customers is NOT being a sugar baby. Please stop misusing the terms.

A sugar baby is a mistress, which is a girlfriend that is financially supported. A sugar daddy is a rich boyfriend, usually married. The relationship is real. The sex is real. The friendship is real. The laughs are real. The squabbles are real. For most of these couples, they know the relationship will come to an end when it starts, but for that time in their lives, it can be perfect.

A young woman who is busy with school or starting her career, doesn't want the drama and endless obligations of a "normal" boyfriend, would like regular intimacy with a regular partner anyway, and could use financial or career help can find having a sugar daddy as a boyfriend can be fantastic.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by samsin on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:00PM (#32844628)
It's not a 'real friendship' if you have to pay the other person to stop them ending the relationship. Sounds more like a contract.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by kelseyfrog on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:15PM (#32841924)
Voluntary transactional free association between consenting adults and the author ends with a "yes, but not like that!"

> Only this complete upheaval of traditional gender dynamics could allow high-achieving women to “sugar baby” for working class men, and without any tangible consequence to the women.

The author advocates a social-regulatory framework to preserve market relations. I can't see how increasing regulation can do anything but distort the market, but I'm willing to be proven wrong. The whole piece comes across as a "I'm more interested in a return to regulatory capture than I am interested in competing in an evolving and dynamic environment." Sorry, but in any market there's winners and losers. What are we going to do, start getting rid of free markets?

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by aaplok on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:53PM (#32843927)
> What are we going to do, start getting rid of free markets?

This is a standard response to markets societies wants to apply boundaries to, yes. Obviously for illegal ones (slaves, child porn, hard drugs) and also regulated ones (medical advice, nuclear weapons).

> in any market there's winners and losers.

Most examples I gave above all have one thing in common: there is a moral objection to the free market due to the vulnerability of one of the parties.

This is an issue that needs to be addressed, and particularly so by proponents of free markets, in a more convincing way than "tough luck". Otherwise the "losers" have no reason to accept that free markets are desirable.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by kelseyfrog on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:02PM (#32844647)
Market losers are typically guided into individual responsibility. This is no different.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by avmich on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:20PM (#32843509)
> I can't see how increasing regulation can do anything but distort the market

You're saying it like distorting the market is always wrong.

> What are we going to do, start getting rid of free markets?

Free market is an abstraction, which doesn't exist in reality.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:45PM (#32843829)
I would like to add that "free market" is a bad description of the state of markets with the United States in general. The government has directly affected the price and legality of many goods including cheese, magnets, corn, houses, education, and more. That's all before we can even start to discuss the systematic effects of fiat money. The idea that we are collectively operating in a free market is a fairly tale.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by kelseyfrog on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:46PM (#32843840)
What are the regulations distorting the dating market?
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:52PM (#32843919)
Calling it a market is a bit odd, but I'll play ball.

Marriage. Unequal rules for participants based on financial success would be another. Arbitrary age limits.

I am generally a supporter of these concepts and this kind of meddling.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by tinglymintyfrsh on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:56PM (#32843236)
I ran into the Stanford law school exotic dancer on CL personals when those existed. She took some startup guy for half his net worth in a divorce. I asked her how he was doing but didn't receive a response back.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by kurupt213 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @09:02PM (#32845682)
The only thing new about this is the label and the digital marketing
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by nh23423fefe on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:06PM (#32841784)
author thinks the election was stolen

https://stanfordreview.org/stanford-future-gop/

> Then the president began a legal fight for the election. Countless numbers of his supporters have rallied around him, with 70% of Republicans suspecting fraud. But many who claimed to support the President were more than happy to roll over and hand the presidency to Biden without a fight. Since election night, many prominent Republicans have hesitated to support the president. Senator Mitt Romney and former President George W. Bush have even called on Trump to concede the election. Many more, in their silence, have failed to give the President their support in his hour of greatest need.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:10PM (#32841855)
What has that got to do with this thread?
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by metadat on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:15PM (#32841920)
It brings into question the author's credibility.

At this juncture, claims of 2020 election theft are akin to being a Flat Earther. Do you, dear reader, desire to get advice, a hot take on sugar babies, or have anything to do with such a person?

It's at least nice to be aware and have the information.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @05:16PM (#32843457)
Its absurd to take someone's opinion on an a completely unrelated issue and then apply it as a blanket denunciation of all their opinions or speech. Having an unorthodox opinion, even being a flat earther, says next to nothing about your expertise or knowledge in other areas. Bobby Fischer held many opinions that many would denounce: but if he was recorded speaking about the best chess openers then there is no reason to factor in his opinions on Semitic people groups. The two topics simply aren't related and it's unlikely that one is affected by the other. Likewise it's unlikely that this opinion piece on "sugar babies" is affected by the author's opinions regarding the legitimacy of the 2020 US presidential election. You cannot simply hop from one conclusion to another with no explanation and expect others to agree that you are making a cogent argument.

Further, claiming there may have been issues with or that you personally take issue with the logistics of the last United States presidential election is hardly akin to being a flat earther. The former represents a broad range of perspectives some of which are contrary to the facts and some of which are of a more philosophical or pragmatic nature and are worthy of discussion. The latter is a school of thought which hasn't held any real ground for hundreds or perhaps thousands of years. This kind of tattletale rhetoric is contrary to the spirit of serious discussion and debate which HN is known for. If it had not become so common, I would simply write it off as trolling or perhaps your confusion as to the purpose of this site. At this point, however, I think I speak for many when I say that you ought to save that kind of foolishness for either Reddit or Twitter where it will be applauded.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by metadat on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:12PM (#32844727)
Are you intending to convey that the author somehow deserves to be considered an expert in sugar babies? ..wow.. I'm truly speechless.

Unsolicited feedback for you, sir, madame, or they @powerslacker: Characterizing things as "absurd" is detrimental to discussion quality in every case across the board. The label is arbitrary and uncurious, making it a poor choice of starting place if your goal is to inform and persuade.

Best wishes, MD.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @09:56PM (#32846079)
I'm not calling the author an expert on sugar babies. I was providing an example to show that it is illogical to dismiss everything a person says, even if they have said something outrageous in the past.

Absurd: wildly unreasonable, illogical, or inappropriate.

It's not detrimental to discussion to point out an absurd statement. I'm not saying absurd in order to be rude, but pointing out that it's a logical error. It's not a poor starting place if my goal is to inform others that the addressed statement is in fact absurd. Since that is exactly what I was attempting to do I'd call it a very reasonable starting place.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by nh23423fefe on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:50AM (#32852880)
No you are just pretending to be reasonable. It's fake. You are ignoring information and calling it generosity of mind.

I don't care what you assert is "logical." Because you can't even modus ponens correctly.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by metadat on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @10:00PM (#32846105)
Let's please just agree to ignore each other from now on. We'll both have a better life this way. Cheers.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by _aavaa_ on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:19PM (#32841971)
They would at worse be arguing in bad faith. But their argument is right or wrong because of its bases and assumptions, not based on who's saying the words
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by smoldesu on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:32PM (#32842159)
Their argument is based on opinions of morality and soft-truths, but they're casting it like an objective problem (which it is not). The author even feels the need to admit as much at the end, simply acknowledging that the cycle of sexualization will always continue, regardless of our opinion on it.

So, with that being said, I'd say it absolutely compromises their argument here. If the author is gullible enough to fall for garden-variety conspiracy theories, why should I trust their authority on morality? Their rhetorical triangle is broken. They have no credibility, they make no appeals to logic (and contradict themselves) which leaves them only with pathos - the ability to outrage and incense their audience based on emotional appeals.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by nh23423fefe on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:40PM (#32842293)
Sure, you can pretend to have a uniform prior.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by nh23423fefe on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:37PM (#32842253)
I don't like reading liars. I don't pretend the words someone says are uncorrelated over time. Liars lie a lot.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by bergenty on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:35PM (#32842998)
A credibility issue which is quite relevant. Is she making up everything in that article?
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by midislack on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:04PM (#32842616)
Roughly a third of the country knows it was stolen. The rest either approve, but lie, or weren’t paying attention.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by nh23423fefe on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:49PM (#32843157)
It's funny because you're a liar
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by midislack on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @07:51PM (#32845095)
Polling is conclusive in this respect.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by moomoo11 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:39PM (#32840570)
Proof we are heading towards idiocracy. What a bleak future.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by fknorangesite on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:19PM (#32842795)
> we are heading towards idiocracy

This tired kids-these-days complaint was a dead horse before the movie left theatres.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by moomoo11 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:30PM (#32842942)
Hope I'm not proven right with the way everything is going lol
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by nh23423fefe on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:09PM (#32840931)
women have never sold sex until today
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by MandieD on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:51PM (#32841562)
I think it's the amusement with which the young women are carrying out this work that galls... and that they're keeping most of the money. They're free agents.

The very idea of doing anything like this myself makes me shudder, but hey, if they're having fun and not scamming their customers, who cares, except this classmate who has hit upon the surest respectable way for an attractive young woman to get money out of many rich old men: decry, in lurid detail, the whoredom of your fellow young women.

She gets bonus points for insinuating that the gains we've made over the past century might not actually be that great, and that we gave something up when we got the legal system and economy to (mostly*) treat us like rational actors. My best childhood friend and I once mused that it's shame that we didn't had had the chutzpah to fall back on our Southern Baptist upbringing to do this when we were pretty young things; once you're over 40, it really doesn't work anymore. The role of "semi-attractive young mom in a moral panic" in that media ecosystem is well-filled.

* the unfortunate legal event of this summer excepted, which has already led to both horror stories that you can look up yourselves, and thousands of small tragedies that you'll never hear about. I dread the next few months (at best) for my fellow young American women.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by jnwatson on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:14PM (#32841018)
Exactly. A great number of women paid for college by stripping.

This is one of those “…but on the Internet” stories.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by alphabetting on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:20PM (#32841105)
"...but the internet" scenarios can be greatly different from the past given scale. I thought the culture/pipeline on TikTok was one of the more notable things about piece.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by hollerith on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#32840736)
I always thought that female sexual selectivity guards against our becoming an idiocracy (since intelligence is hereditable).

Help me see your point of view.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by moomoo11 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @02:27PM (#32841214)
Have you watched the movie? People surrender themselves to their basic primal desires and that's it. Instead of having relationships, people go for instant gratification trapped to their screens and entertainment.

I'm just comparing the scenario here to what was shown in the movie. Sure, we have all these apps these days that allow you to do whatever, but at the cost of everyone having mental issues and anxiety.

I don't personally care, I've had my own share of problems that I deal with. My goal is to be in the 20% who won't engage in such behavior, and will be totally fine regardless of what other people do. But that's still 80% who will be wasting their money, potential, resources in these short term flukes and need a bail out from society.

Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by im3w1l on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:19PM (#32841974)
Sexual preferences are themselves subject to evolution. If intelligence isn't beneficial, then people will eventually stop selecting intelligent partners.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by kleer001 on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @01:52PM (#32840727)
It's okay, the population will crash in the next three generations and only the smartest will survive. /s
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by angryasian on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @03:23PM (#32842032)
men love to shame women over sexuality. A man does this, no one blinks an eye. A woman.. oh no
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University by midislack on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @04:03PM (#32842606)
These girls are going to be real put out once they hit Tag The Sponsor. That shits forever.