Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University
by powerslacker on Wednesday September 14, 2022 @09:56PM
(#32846079)
I'm not calling the author an expert on sugar babies. I was providing an example to show that it is illogical to dismiss everything a person says, even if they have said something outrageous in the past.
Absurd: wildly unreasonable, illogical, or inappropriate.
It's not detrimental to discussion to point out an absurd statement. I'm not saying absurd in order to be rude, but pointing out that it's a logical error. It's not a poor starting place if my goal is to inform others that the addressed statement is in fact absurd. Since that is exactly what I was attempting to do I'd call it a very reasonable starting place.
Re:The Sugar Babies of Stanford University
by nh23423fefe on Thursday September 15, 2022 @10:50AM
(#32852880)
No you are just pretending to be reasonable. It's fake. You are ignoring information and calling it generosity of mind.
I don't care what you assert is "logical." Because you can't even modus ponens correctly.
Unsolicited feedback for you, sir, madame, or they @powerslacker: Characterizing things as "absurd" is detrimental to discussion quality in every case across the board. The label is arbitrary and uncurious, making it a poor choice of starting place if your goal is to inform and persuade.
Best wishes, MD.