News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by pedalpete on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:01PM (#32795588)
Why does the author think they should be able to get USD out of an ATM in a non-US country? Does this happen in any country?

I can't think of any country I've been to other than the US which let me withdrawal USD from an ATM.

When telling friends about some of the benefits of Crypto, I often use Argentina as an example, but this one comment regarding ATM -> USD I think is hurting the credibility of this author.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by fragmede on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:59PM (#32795913)
> I can't think of any country I've been to other than the US which let me withdrawal USD from an ATM.

Have you been to Argentina or even anywhere in Latin America? You can't just visit a country like, say, Sweden and use Swedish Kronas or Korea and use Korean Wons and from there extrapolate that in $country you just use $local_country_currency and it's as simple as that.

In countries where the local currency is unstable, transacting in USD in some manner is just a fact of life. Eg People in Costa Rica who work for US corporations may just get paid partially in USD, as well as in Colóns.

More to the point is that the reason the expectation is there, is that Argentinians used to be able to visit the ATM and pull out USD until currency controls were enacted, and that the surprise is that even US citizens can't pull out USD.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by EdwardDiego on Sunday September 11, 2022 @08:10AM (#32798952)
> that even US citizens can't pull out USD

Did I miss some weird constitutional amendment that American citizens have super-duper special status at overseas ATMs?

The fact of US citizenship is entirely irrelevant to what notes come out of an ATM.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by fragmede on Monday September 12, 2022 @12:53AM (#32806223)
Are ATMs mysterious black boxes that dispenses random amounts of paper to random people, at random times? Of course not! The person standing in front of the ATM is entirely relevant to what comes out of the ATM. First check is that there's enough money in their bank account, but other bits of information, like their citizenship status are relevant to the transaction. American citizens typically have US bank accounts with US dollars in them, and the super-duper special status that they have; the privilege that US citizens enjoy, is that the US government has no currency trading control. As a US citizen you're allowed to trade away all of your USD for whatever other currency you want.

If you had the luck to be born in a country with a strong currency, like Sweden, you're also blessed with this privilege, but if you're from a different country, like say, Argentina, then you're only allowed to trade a certain amount before you're cut off, which the bank, and by extension the ATM will check. It's less about US citizens having some super-duper special status, but that they have rights that people that only have Argentinian citizenship don't have.

Of course, being a US citizen isn't going to magically turn the bills inside the ATM into USD, but prior to the currency controls, Argentinian ATMs had USD to dispense, to both Argentina and US citizens, as well as citizens of other countries.

The stated goals of Argentina's currency controls was to stop the out flow of Pesos to USD. An American tourist visiting Argentina is going to spend their money in Argentina while they are there, which, no matter how you denominate it, which would be an inflow of money to Argentina.

When the controls were announced, the banks went overboard implementing their blocking, which also prevented this inflow of money into the country. Which is why it's remarkable.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by EdwardDiego on Monday September 12, 2022 @02:42AM (#32806808)
> but other bits of information, like their citizenship status are relevant to the transaction.

No, it's not. Your card issuer and the ATM owner participating in compatible interbank networks is what's relevant.

Seriously, "even a US citizen couldn't get USD out of an Argentine ATM" is a massive distraction to the point you're trying to make.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by fragmede on Monday September 12, 2022 @01:31PM (#32813730)
Your card issuer cares a lot about who you are. Your US citizenship status was asked about when you created an account with them. Some smaller banks won't even give non-citizens accounts because they can't handle that.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by santimt on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:16PM (#32795672)
In Uruguay, neighbor of Argentina, you can extract up to 500 USD daily from ATMs.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by cesarb on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:39PM (#32795811)
Here in Brazil, I've seen a couple of ATMs from a major bank which allow you to directly get USD out of them. I searched just now and found a list of these ATMs: https://www.bb.com.br/pbb/pagina-inicial/voce/produtos-e-ser... (other banks might have them too, but the ones I've personally seen are on this list).
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by odiroot on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:22AM (#32798426)
Most airports in Europe have ATMs that let you cash out EUR,GBP,USD.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by gspetr on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:21AM (#32796799)
You could trivially cash out thousands of dollars in ATMs of many banks, both foreign and domestic, in a certain "world's enemy No.1" country before Feb 24.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by trashtester on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:04AM (#32800193)
I think you're talking about "world enemy No.2".

#1 has 10x the GDP compared to #2.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by ulfw on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:05PM (#32795948)
You need to travel more often then.

You can get USD out of Citibank ATMs in Hong Kong (and many many others too, I just happen to use Citi last week).

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by refurb on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:56AM (#32798871)
Not sure about ATMs, but in Singapore the banks are happy to transact in USD, including withdrawals in USD from SGD accounts (with a pretty decent conversion rate).
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by Scoundreller on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:09PM (#32795637)
Some Canadian banks have ATMs on Canadian soil in airports and border towns that will dispense USD.

I’d guess “dollarized” non-US countries definitely do too.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by Mountain_Skies on Saturday September 10, 2022 @08:19PM (#32795691)
Yes, in Ecuador that happens, which is nice if you're a tourist from the US. When I was there, the local bank didn't even add a fee for using their ATM, though my US bank added their own charge. Still better than in the US where both banks would add a fee.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by trashtester on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:06AM (#32800212)
I don't think those ATM's carry the dollars for use within Canada, though. Rather, they're there so that travellers can bring some dollars to countries with a non-functioning financial system (for instance with currency controls).
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by neither_color on Sunday September 11, 2022 @12:29AM (#32796831)
Off the top of my head ATMs in Cambodia, El Salvador, Ecuador, Panama all give out USD.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by sdfhbdf on Sunday September 11, 2022 @10:17AM (#32799805)
Ecuador is not surprising since it’s official currency is USD
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by el-salvador on Sunday September 11, 2022 @11:50AM (#32800654)
El Salvador and Panamá too.

Even though for accounting reasons Panama calls it Balboa, its actually USD banknotes and Balboa coins at a 1=1 exchange rate.

Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by kilroy123 on Sunday September 11, 2022 @06:20AM (#32798416)
Yes lots of countries have this around the world.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by kingofpandora on Sunday September 11, 2022 @07:49AM (#32798832)
Pretty common, not even counting countries like Lebanon where USD used interchangeably with the local currency.
Re:Argentina's currency exchange black markets by danielfoster on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:40PM (#32796112)
This is normal.