News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by mort96 on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:18AM (#32775899)
One thing I never understood about this passkeys thing is: how will the passkeys database be kept in sync between your iPhone, your Windows desktop, your Linux laptop and your Android tablet? I've tried to research the topic a bit but everything I've been able to find has been about exporting and importing between ecosystems, but most people don't use only a single company's products.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by izacus on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:41AM (#32776465)
In words of Tim Cook on the last event: "Just buy an iPhone (or a Mac and an iPad)".

Making your experience bad on non-Apple devices is part of the design, not accident.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by hnbad on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:08AM (#32790783)
As a person who isn't in the Apple ecosystem, this has always been what kept me off iOS.

If I have an Android device, I can use Linux or Windows (or macOS for that matter) on my laptop/desktop. If I have an iOS device, not using macOS just doesn't make sense and the only way to get a macOS legally is buying Apple hardware.

When the Apple watch came out, I was interested to see what Apple brings to the space but my interest was killed when I realized it will for all intents and purposes be an iOS companion device, not a true standalone product. So buying an Apple watch would have meant replacing my phone with an iPhone, which would have meant replacing my laptop with a macbook and my Android tablet with an iPad.

On paper there's nothing stopping anyone from using iOS devices and keeping their desktop/laptop on Windows or Linux. But the path of least resistance is buying into the entire Apple ecosystem (including iCloud, iTunes, etc) and getting any non-Apple alternative to occupy any of the slots Apple provides its own options for is an uphill battle (e.g. even when Apple provided a Windows version of iTunes it was notoriously bad, slow and lagging behind).

This irks me not only because it means you'll want to replace every digital device and every app Apple provides a stock solution for, you'll also find it nearly impossible to leave because there's no clear migration path if you have come to rely on iCloud, Keynote, Facetime, iMessage, your Apple wallet, your Apple credit card, or even Apple maps. If you want to add any "foreign" device, it will instantly be a worse experience than if you had picked the Apple alternative. Instead you'd have to either go cold turkey or wean yourself off by using alternative cross-platform apps when available (and willingly accepting the worse experience).

I think there are plenty of disingenuous criticisms of Apple (especially about their devices being "overpriced" when they're really just "too expensive" compared to equivalent consumer products available with more affordable specs) but I think it's extremely fair to describe their practices as an extreme example of vendor lock-in.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by threeseed on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:46AM (#32776489)
I worked at Apple and no one is deliberately making the experience bad on non-Apple devices.

They just have a million things they want to do, limited resources and so they simply don't prioritise it.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by sofixa on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:07AM (#32776635)
Using "limited resources" while talking about Apple is surely a joke, right?
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by threeseed on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:22AM (#32776727)
You should read the Mythical Man-Month.

You can't just add unlimited developers to a project and expect it to be productive or sustainable.

No different at Meta, Spotify, Netflix etc.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by harperlee on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:15AM (#32777132)
I don’t see how an extra program built for windows or linux can in any way stall whatever project limits Apple faces for macos. They’re effectively independent projects.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by massysett on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:18AM (#32777487)
There are only so many competent software developers and managers out there. Managers have limited bandwidth as well. For everything any organization says “yes” to, it’s saying “no” to something else. That’s true even if the organization has a huge cash pile.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by pwinnski on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:24PM (#32785095)
> They’re effectively independent projects.

Unless you care about interoperability, which for a product like this is essential.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by harperlee on Saturday September 10, 2022 @09:51AM (#32790630)
Nah not really - there is already a proprietary API in iCloud that they use to synch keys between devices, that will be internally documented.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by saagarjha on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:20AM (#32777499)
Apple historically runs skeleton teams for everything. The company is all about getting more from less.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by soco on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:53AM (#32776539)
Potato, potahto. So they deliberately don't prioritise it.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by amelius on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:59AM (#32776582)
This is still quite bad, just like omitting the truth is a form of lying.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by manigandham on Friday September 09, 2022 @07:37AM (#32777945)
The multi-trillion dollar megacorporation does not have "limited resources" when it comes to interoperability of such a core security feature.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by saagarjha on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:21AM (#32777510)
Apple product direction is set by execs who buy their entire extended family iPhones and switch between their three HomeKit-enabled houses and driving to work in their CarPlay cars. This biases how they determine value in things, beyond the obvious reasons.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by izacus on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:25AM (#32776754)
The CEO of Apple just publicly said something that contradicts your working experience. I'll trust him to clearly explain the strategy over your experience.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by emptyfile on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:05AM (#32776628)
> limited resources

haha, oh really?

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by cm2187 on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:12AM (#32776668)
The developers of iTunes for windows certainly do. I wrote developers because I assume there is more than one, but I guess that number may be 1 or 0.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by iggldiggl on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:35AM (#32776829)
I find not having to contend with the break-up of iTunes into a gazillion of separate apps (so far, fingers crossed) to actually be an advantage of using it on Windows these days.

That's because I prefer to manage my collection of radio comedy episodes as podcasts [1], and with unified iTunes that's simply a matter of changing the media type of those files to "Podcast" and voila, it just works. On a modern Mac on the other hand, from what I've gathered this is no longer possible, and the separate Podcasts app that has replaced iTunes in that regards only supports subscribing to "real" podcasts, and doesn't allow manually adding additional episodes. (I suppose I'd have to resort to either hacking the local podcast database, or set up a local HTTP server with a fake podcast feed in order to add those files, or just give up on that prospect entirely…)

[1] So they don't clutter up my actual music library, to get the listened/unlistened visual indicator, and due to way I'm syncing iTunes with my Android phone, to also get my phone to remember the playback position, too (in iTunes you can enable remembering the playback position for any file, including music tracks, but my Android media player nevertheless only supports this for files synced over as "podcasts").

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by zxcvgm on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:03AM (#32776177)
The passkeys are only synced across Apple devices, via iCloud keychain. Trying to sign in on another device (e.g. Windows laptop, Android phone) will require scanning a QR code. The devices then establish a secure channel using FIDO caBLE v2 (introduced by Google/Chrome, I believe) to perform the authentication. This ensures the passkeys never leave your Apple device, but can still be used on other devices.

You can see the sign-in user experience here, when they use a non-Apple device: https://developer.apple.com/videos/play/wwdc2022/10092/

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by mort96 on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:23AM (#32776320)
Aha, so you get a significantly worse experience if you're not 100% in the Apple ecosystem, and you can't sign in at all if you don't have your Apple device on you.

I'll keep using passwords, thanks.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by threeseed on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:44AM (#32776482)
If you are using passwords that you can remember without your phone then I assume it's pretty basic and insecure.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by elashri on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:59AM (#32776580)
You can use password manager that is cross platform. You can even use something like KeePassXC and sync the database between devices. All encrypted and secure without even having a phone if you want. You don't need to remember passwords without or with your phone.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by mort96 on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:14AM (#32776690)
Presenting this as a choice between using Apple's closed solution or using easy-to-remember passwords is disingenuous. Please don't participate in the discussion if you're going to be this bad faith.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by sbuk on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:32AM (#32776809)
> Please don't participate in the discussion if you're going to be this bad faith.

That works both ways. You've asked a question, to which the information is easily accessible online[https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT213305]. It very clear from both the article and other online sources that this is based on WebAuthN[https://webauthn.guide]. You have been equally as disingenuous and based on your responses, acted in bad faith from the beginning in a bid to start a flamewar. How what you are doing is anything but basic bullying is beyond me.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by mort96 on Friday September 09, 2022 @06:16AM (#32777483)
Wow, why so angry?

My question was genuine. I have been trying to look into this before and not found anything on how keys are supposed to be synced across ecosystems. And your links don't explain that either; the Apple link explains how it syncs _within_ the iCloud ecosystem, not how it syncs between the different ecosystems. I didn't find your WebAuthN link before, but quickly skimming through it, I don't see anything about how keys are supposed to be synced between ecosystems. And when I have looked into this before, all I've been able to find is solutions to migrate between ecosystems, not syncing between them, which are wildly different use-cases.

If you have nothing productive to contribute, please don't.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by hnbad on Saturday September 10, 2022 @10:12AM (#32790817)
It's especially ironic given that what Apple has implemented is literally an existing web standard. Luckily web apps supporting WebAuthn should also be able to support alternative means of authentication so they don't break when you don't have your device with you.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by pwinnski on Friday September 09, 2022 @05:26PM (#32785127)
You literally said you would keep using passwords. The dichotomy was established by you.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by fdztbgrstnhrt on Friday September 09, 2022 @11:39PM (#32787565)
> I'll keep using passwords, thanks.

> If you are using passwords THAT YOU CAN REMEMBER WITHOUT YOUR PHONE then I assume it's pretty basic and insecure.

> Presenting this as a choice between using Apple's closed solution or using EASY-TO-REMEMBER passwords is disingenuous.

All caps to indicate how sbuk changed the meaning of what mort96 said.

The dichotomy was between using using Apple's solution and using passwords. Deciding the latter must mean using easy to remember passwords and not acknowledging the existence of password managers and complex password generators is at best ignorance or forgetfulness and at worst dishonesty.

Unlike mort96, I didn't automatically assume dishonesty, but sbuk posted this in response to mort96's accusation:

> You have been equally as disingenuous and based on your responses, acted in bad faith from the beginning in a bid to start a flamewar. How what you are doing is anything but basic bullying is beyond me.

This implies that they were aware of what they were doing and, rather than call mort96 out on what they believed to be an attempt at a flamewar, decided to contribute to it by deliberately altering the meaning of mort96's message.

I believe mort96 and sbuk were both accusatory and rude, but what sbuk appears to have done would be worse in my view. Rather than just assume the worst of who I'm communicating with, I'd rather give them the benefit of the doubt by inquiring for more information, attempting to inform, or possibly explaining how I interpreted a passage.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by blooalien on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:28AM (#32776781)
Obligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/936/
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by cm2187 on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:14AM (#32776686)
Is there a way to export the private key? What if I want to switch to Android? I lose all my accounts?
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by Y-bar on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:25AM (#32775937)
Passwords are synced to Windows via iCloud, i suppose these keys would be synced like that as well: https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/icloud-windows/icwd3c1...
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by mort96 on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:39AM (#32776042)
Right, but all software which uses passwords would need to support it too, right? I'm not confident that all of the Windows ecosystem will adopt iCloud for passkeys, nor am I confident that Apple will tightly integrate into whatever system thing Microsoft puts in Windows to manage FIDO keys... This isn't like a password manager after all, where getting the key in your clipboard is a universal way to use it anywhere you want.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by WorldMaker on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:51PM (#32783355)
Apple says they are working with Microsoft and Google to meet all FIDO standards on this. It's still early days, but FIDO as a standards body does seem to be working towards standards for working with heterogenous keychains. Given how many users use Chrome on Windows and have an iOS device, I think heterogenous keychains are going to be critical to mass adoption and everyone says they are working towards that. A lot of this may be on FIDO to truly coordinate.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by huijzer on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:25AM (#32775934)
Apple has a long history of working best together with Apple. For example, the iPod music players only worked with iTunes. I think that Apple hopes that such features cause people to switch more of their electronics to Apple
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by mort96 on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:31AM (#32775984)
Sure, but this is trying to replace passwords. As much as Apple would want it different, there's a whole lot of people who use one Apple device but has other devices from other manufacturers, and surely an industry effort like FIDO to replace passwords would take that into account?
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by izacus on Friday September 09, 2022 @03:43AM (#32776473)
Apple made talking to family, friends and other people a moat to keep people in their walled garden. Taking control of your passwords is extension of that strategy, not something they feel bad about.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by JumpCrisscross on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:41AM (#32776048)
> there's a whole lot of people who use one Apple device but has other devices from other manufacturers, and surely an industry effort like FIDO to replace passwords would take that into account?

They're not the beachhead. Once the product is tuned for core users, it can be expanded to more complex use cases. This is basic product development, and something Apple gets right.

Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by hsbauauvhabzb on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:28AM (#32775961)
And the educated consumer hopes one of these players will push to face and trigger anticompetitive legislation.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by hammyhavoc on Friday September 09, 2022 @02:07PM (#32782818)
Uh, iPods could be used with plenty of third-party software, including WinAmp, foobar2000, MediaMonkey. I could go on for another several minutes rattling off names.
Re:Apple’s Killing the Password. Here’s Everything You Need ... by cm2187 on Friday September 09, 2022 @04:15AM (#32776697)
What does the passkey database contain? Only the master private key? Or does a private key or token gets generated for every new account I sign up to?