News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by hammock on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @11:33AM (#3270545)
We use the label's songs till we get a 100m uniques, by which time we can tell the labels who is listening to their music where, and then turn around and charge them for the very data we got from them, ensuring that what we pay them in total for streaming is less than what they pay us for data mining.

This part doesn't quite make sense to me. Besides being news to me that this is their business model, how could it possibly be that UMG is willing to pay more for the data about a song play than they charge for that play?

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by adrianwaj on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @11:44AM (#3270581)
I think the data helps determine terrestrial radio playlists - it's what made last.fm an attractive acquisition. It may also help with targeting certain demographics and geographics with music in advertising, tv and film.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by sliverstorm on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @04:18PM (#3271771)
I hope you aren't upset about this revelation.The quality of their service is pretty high, I don't recall ads, nor do I recall having to pay a subscription fee.

If you are discomfited by it, take comfort knowing that the only reason they get money for it is they are selling the amalgamation of what thousands (millions?) of listeners chose; from the sound of it, you are going to be completely invisible among the masses.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by overcyn on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @07:09PM (#3272397)
That was from an internal email. I can't find any sources saying that grooveshark is actually making money from the labels.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by thebooktocome on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @05:48PM (#3272135)
There are plenty of ads, unless you're a paid account. Look at the sidebar to the right.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by john2x on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:25AM (#3270283)
"$271,350,000" Wow. And all they had to do was read a comment on a blog post. If I didn't know any better (I'm not sure I do), I'd say piracy is big business for the entertainment industry.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:53PM (#3270885)
I wonder if there's any money to be made in posting comments that companies can use to file frivolous lawsuits.

For $5, I'll claim that I watched the CEO of Grooveshark waterboard an orphan while listening to a song he didn't own.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by bookwormAT on Saturday November 26, 2011 @08:12AM (#3279714)
See also: "Battling the Internet Water Army: Detection of Hidden Paid Posters"

http://arxiv.org/PS_cache/arxiv/pdf/1111/1111.4297v1.pdf

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by adammacleod on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:38PM (#3272928)
News at 5! Grooveshark co-conspirator pavel_lishin releases shock claims that CEO waterboarded helpless orphan child whilst stealing money from legitimate artists! More to follow.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by j_baker on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @07:15PM (#3272412)
Am I the only one who noticed that Custer claimed he wouldn't fight Universal in the press... in a statement released to the press including his arguments as to why Universal is wrong?

I'm willing to support just about anyone who is taking on the record labels, but don't claim you won't fight Universal in the press right after doing so and scolding your opponents for doing so as well. That's just hypocritical.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by yuhong on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @03:24PM (#3271573)
I still remember the WordPress/Thesis fiasco that involved Twitter, blog comments and Mixergy interviews.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by siddhant on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @03:47PM (#3271644)
Do you have a link? Thanks!
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by harryf on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @01:44PM (#3271136)
A trial of this nature could end as a fantastic promotion for Grooveshark, assuming they can survive it.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by paul9290 on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @05:51PM (#3272149)
Sure similar to the lawsuits and trials of Napster, Kazaa, Limewire, Muxtape and all the others that were sued out of existence.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by cq on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:26AM (#3270087)
I still think Grooveshark is the best cloud music service there is. I can't stand spotify or google music.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by sjs on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @02:54PM (#3271454)
Here in Canada I can't use Spotify, Pandora, Google Music, or Amazon's thing without jumping through hoops and proxies, and I'm just too old and lazy for such shenanigans now.

Grooveshark has me as a customer for life whether the labels want want to play nice with them or not. The only alternatives we have are Rdio, Slacker, and maybe a couple of others. None of them are nearly as good as Grooveshark. Grooveshark's biggest drawback is having to jailbreak to get their iOS app, and that's not something they have control over. Major points to them for developing it anyway for a smaller jailbreak audience.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by paul9290 on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:56AM (#3270180)
Are you willing to pay $10 a month for GrooveShark once they are forced to change their business model?

Pardon the pessimism, but I don't recall any online music service that didn't negotiate with the labels first surviving these lawsuits. Though maybe I am forgetting one that is still around and going strong?

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by OriginalSyn on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:09AM (#3270222)
If Universal shuts down Grooveshark they set a precedent that can get Youtube shutdown, because they are run on the same model. Users upload content, Grooveshark removes content and users when they get DMCA complaints.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by paul9290 on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:28AM (#3270295)
I don't think the YouTube analogy works here, because YouTube's main focus was never to be an online music service. That is Grooveshark's sole purpose and is marketed as. There are many music services that allowed that same thing and are no longer around like muxtape for example.

Also the wild west that YouTube was is no longer, as they pay they labels. Maybe Grooveshark won't go the way of all the other unlicensed music services & they'll negotiate the proper licenses to remain in business?

If that happens their model will be like Spotify and the others(pay monthly fee for mobile access). Though will it's users stick around or jump ship to what service I'm not sure? I don't know of any other Grooveshark like services as the press only covers Spotify, MOG and Rdio these days.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by samtp on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @11:13AM (#3270461)
You can make your own music, just like you can make your own videos. I think the analogy works pretty well
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by paul9290 on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @11:45AM (#3270585)
Sure, but the masses are not listening to the unknown bands. They are listening to the best talent in the world which the labels find, cultivate, market and create icons out of - ones that the MASSES follow, love and adore.

Further the majority (Grooveshark's users/visitors) are there to listen to the label's music not the unknowns. Now if the unknowns are really good then they'll get a record deal because they want to be heard by as many as possible (become famous).

Just like us entrepreneurs wisely seek out investment to grow our businesses artist do the same with the labels. Some artists could say "I hate the labels they will never sign me!" Though once that artist gets a following and a taste for money/fame they'll change their mind! They'd be foolish not to!

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by randomdata on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:02PM (#3270680)
The same could be said for YouTube. It was primarily the Lazy Sunday video from SNL, along with some other major production videos, that made YouTube popular. It was only after the service saw success that the user-generated videos became interesting to the masses. They came for the major label productions, but stayed for the home movies.

But that is, of course, the fear of Grooveshark. The masses come to hear Lady Gaga's latest single, but they just might stumble upon an independent that they enjoy while they are there. That discovery leads to wanting to find more, and eventually the major labels, like in video today, become even less relevant. Grooveshark has already started promoting bands I have never heard of, and I'll usually give them a chance when I am there.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by bri3d on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @04:31PM (#3271834)
There's a timing game being played here that YouTube already won, and which I think GrooveShark are about to lose.

Both YouTube and GrooveShark bet that they'd be able to (quasi-illegally) host major production content without the owners' consent until some derivative (in YouTube's case, raw audience combined with ad revenue and in GrooveShark's case apparently metrics) gave them enough value and/or capital to strike deals with legitimate content owners.

YouTube won; they were able to push enough traffic to entice labels into partnering with them for a revenue-generating service (VEVO), and were subsequently able to begin enforcing the DMCA aggressively via automated tooling combined with an easy takedown process for labels.

I think GrooveShark are about to lose. So far, labels seem less interested in making deals with them than in destroying them, and I highly doubt they have enough legitimate content to survive. They didn't make it past the "host infringing content for long enough to generate value" inflection point quickly enough.

It's also worth noting that it's possible to host a much wider variety of independent / user-generated content which is actually interesting on a "video site" than a "music site." "Video" encompasses an incredible range of content (including music!), while "music" is a single content type with a much narrower range of producers. Many more people have cute kids, athletic talent, cool cars, funny pets, and so on than have musical talent.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by Kylekramer on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:49PM (#3270870)
It is a nice ideal, but I highly doubt that is the fear of Grooveshark. If that was the fear, they would have sued Myspace out of existence back in its heyday (which they probably could have, tons of pirated content was there). But they embraced it. A quick perusal of http://grooveshark.com/#/explore/popular shows that Universal Music Group artists are by far the most played, and UMG doesn't see a cent of that. I think that is the fear, a well justified one even it is trying to hold onto a dying business. Occam's Razor and all.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by Karunamon on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @10:07AM (#3270220)
Eh, there's a first time for anything. Maybe it'll finally take a company with more guts than brai^H^H^H^Hbusiness acumen to finally stand up to these bullies.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by earbitscom on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:47PM (#3270861)
You did read all of the letters from King Crimson and the Eagles who try every day to get their music taken down from Grooveshark and cannot, right?

Now who's the bully?

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by invisible on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @04:54PM (#3271918)
A competitor's co-founder spouting off half-truths is legit. What you read on DMN should be taken with a grain of salt.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by earbitscom on Thursday November 24, 2011 @03:18PM (#3275318)
My personal bias does not make what everybody knows about Grooveshark less true.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by Karunamon on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @03:45PM (#3271632)
I haven't heard of that one yet.. got a link?
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by modoc on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @04:28PM (#3271826)
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by dhughes on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @05:59PM (#3272176)
Not after their recent redesign, hate it!
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by sukuriant on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:56PM (#3270901)
I already pay 9$ a month for GrooveShark, so ... yes.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by chrischen on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:14PM (#3272716)
It doesn't sound like you've even tried Spotify or Google music, as google music does not do the same thing as Grooveshark or Spotify.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by PagingCraig on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @11:57AM (#3270661)
What's wrong with Spotify?
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by docgnome on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:51PM (#3270878)
Irrelevant, irritating, LOUD ads played in between movements of a single piece that are tied together. It's really irritating to be listening to something and have Spotify suddenly SCREAM at me the lyrics to some country song about taking my clothes off that I would NEVER be interested in, which Spotify would know if they could be bothered to look at my listening history, or even my last.fm account, both of which they can see. That said, I still use it to listen to music I haven't yet purchased.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by revorad on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @07:41PM (#3272478)
I'm amazed how stupid spotify's (and all other free music services') ads are. Haven't they heard of contextual advertising? I'm listening to Kings of Leon, sell me KoL t-shirts, have them talk about their gold plated vinyl record, sell me wristbands with their lyrics on them. Nooooooooo, here's Rihanna's latest single. Enjoy!

It's like no one told them you don't have to exactly copy the old school radio advertising model.

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by eCa on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @03:45PM (#3271635)
You either pay with your money or your time. I chose to pay with my money.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by docgnome on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @09:27PM (#3272744)
I have no problem paying with my time. I just wish they would have me pay with my time by listening to stuff I don't despise with a passion normally reserved for Hell and all Montagues.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by pavel_lishin on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:54PM (#3270894)
My breaking point is that their library doesn't have the music I want to listen to. I own a lot of Rammstein albums, and if I can't have those on my mobile playlist, I'm not going to bother.

(Yes, I can have it pull music from iTunes, but then I'm having to manage two separate libraries, one of which could disappear overnight as a result of a court ruling. The odds of that happening are greater than all of my backups suddenly vanishing.)

Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by gcp on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:21PM (#3270769)
Facebook.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by sukuriant on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:58PM (#3270905)
This. This is exactly why I do not ever use Spotify. Ever. I downloaded it, installed it, then noticed I needed a Facebook account and never looked back.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by rmc on Wednesday November 23, 2011 @12:43PM (#3270847)
Doesn't work in some countries.
Re:Grooveshark Bites Back: We’ll Fight Universal in Court, N... by aswanson on Thursday November 24, 2011 @05:42PM (#3275612)
Wow. Had no clue there was such a thing as "Google music ".