News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by logicchains on Friday September 02, 2022 @02:54PM (#32694496)
>As an outsider, it seems pretty clear that the rejection to the industry is more about the cultural mismatch than it is to the actual work needing to be executed.

Look at Intel. It's a western company, but it famously fell behind its competitors due to offering comparatively shit pay and conditions to its staff, so the best people left. The problem is hardware company culture, not Asian company culture.

Apple's M1 is an example of what a company that compensates its staff fairly can achieve in hardware. Hardware companies need to get the idea out of their head that they can pay people shit (even when they've got huge monopoly profits like Intel had) and still expect to remain competitive.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by joe_the_user on Friday September 02, 2022 @03:54PM (#32695076)
Look at Intel. It's a western company, but it famously fell behind its competitors due to offering comparatively shit pay and conditions to its staff, so the best people left.

As far as I know, working in a non-chip part of Intel in the 90s, the place was always an abusive sweatshop except maybe for some top people. And Intel isn't some failed from the start enterprise - they're currently third or so in a long, long competition among fabs, chip-makers and etc. They had a long, long successful run while being awful.

Essentially, model the of gaslighting, abusing and discarding people works great as long as a company can keep their employee's illusions alive and/or trapping them so they have no choices regardless.

As far as I know, Apple pays well compared to the US median for a job but poorly relative to other FANG companies. Plenty of tales of abuse and secrecy exist in Apple but plenty of people assert the virtues of working there and show great loyalty.

Which is to say these practices are very common in globally competitive markets. A company that pays well and inspires great loyalty and hard work from it's employees can always be undercut by a company that pays shit and still inspires great loyalty and hard work from it's employees. And if the model falls-apart, it can be rebuilt elsewhere (this is the problem/challenge of markets that are truly global).

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by BeetleB on Friday September 02, 2022 @03:17PM (#32694719)
Apple's M1 is an irrelevant comparison. Apple doesn't run a fab. Yes, Intel lost a lot of chip designers, etc, but the submission is about fab related work, which Apple is not involved in.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by elteto on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:06PM (#32697154)
Seeing how Intel hemorrhaged talent that went straight to their competitors, like Apple, I’d say your distinction is not very relevant.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by klyrs on Friday September 02, 2022 @03:28PM (#32694837)
Hot take, apparently: VHDL/Verilog developers should make 5x what JavaScript developers make, and not the other way around.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by structural on Friday September 02, 2022 @07:10PM (#32696775)
RTL development is a very interesting beast. On one hand, development is challenging, and there's a massive amount of global $$$ in integrated circuits. These guys should be the top paid, cream of the crop, right?

However, the tools suck more than the English language has good words to describe, so it's hard for an engineer to be productive. And the products are complex, so you need a lot of engineers. And you're manufacturing physical products, so most of that huge dollar amount in the industry is trapped in manufacturing, not design. So even if you were the cream of the crop engineer, it's hard to extract much of that value for yourself.

On the other hand, webdev has extremely low capital overhead, and improvements in tools can go directly into developer productivity, which can immediately be realized as value (which gives you resources to improve even more).

So even if Verilog developers made the same money as JS developers today, in ten years, I'd expect the JS developers to make more.

One lesson here is that if you want your designs to improve rapidly, decouple them from the manufacturing business as much as you can. And you'll probably be able to pay better and attract better talent in the proces, which is a not insignificant benefit. Perhaps the rise of fabless semiconductor companies is understood even better in this light?

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by tester756 on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:21PM (#32695846)
Hmm

In my country there are probably 2? 3? serious semico companies

And shitton of JS-using companies

Maybe this explains why embedded/hardware/firmware devs are underpaid?

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by dougabug on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:39PM (#32696018)
If it weren’t for pesky things like supply and demand.

If the pay is so low, it’s kind of curious that the supply doesn’t drop.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by AlphaSite on Saturday September 03, 2022 @02:17AM (#32699253)
Prestige can confound this in the short or medium term.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by dougabug on Saturday September 03, 2022 @09:06PM (#32708549)
Prestige can be a kind of non-monetary compensation, but one which is generally difficult to measure, especially for rank-and-file employees.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by pts_ on Saturday September 03, 2022 @12:57AM (#32698881)
But...ad revenues, microtransactions etc. Solution - hardware full of ads and rentals eek!
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by y0ungarmanii on Saturday September 03, 2022 @03:45PM (#32705387)
They do if they get into high frequency trading :(
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by eru on Friday September 02, 2022 @10:08PM (#32697910)
What sense of 'should' are you using here?
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by nightski on Friday September 02, 2022 @02:56PM (#32694517)
Isn't M1 manufactured by TSMC? Are you saying TSMC has good pay and treats it's workers great? (it might I honestly don't know).
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by KerrAvon on Friday September 02, 2022 @03:12PM (#32694674)
I'm not taking a position either way, butI believe the poster is talking about the design/integration phase.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by JimmieMcnulty on Friday September 02, 2022 @04:34PM (#32695427)
Just to be clear, I make no value judgement about Asian cultural norms w/r/t chip manufacturing, my comment is merely meant to suggest the employment experience probably will be adjusted to fit American cultural mores, so the concern that few Americans would want these jobs isn’t entirely fair.

I am entirely unqualified to judge cultural advantages/disadvantages in the manufacturing industry.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by Aunche on Friday September 02, 2022 @08:14PM (#32697223)
Is the M1's design really that technically impressive? The product itself is revolutionary, but my impression was that its main technical advantages is that ARM is more efficient and they had a monopoly on TSMC's 5 nm process.

I think general mismanagement explains Intel's decline more than money or working conditions. TSMC pays embarrassing low, which is why a lot of engineers end up being poached by China.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by astrange on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:32PM (#32698392)
> ARM is more efficient

This is backwards; M1 is not merely an implementation of an efficient ISA, Apple sponsored the design of the ISA in order to create M1 with it. That's why ARMv8 is significantly different from v7.

ISA doesn't matter that much though and it is well designed besides that.

Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by mensetmanusman on Friday September 02, 2022 @05:38PM (#32696011)
Intel lost because of their business model. TSMC was making an order of magnitude more chips at far lower margin and all those manufacturing runs/experiments let them advance that much faster.
Re:Will young Americans want to work in semiconductor manufa... by astrange on Friday September 02, 2022 @11:15PM (#32698297)
I don't get the impression that Apple SEG pays very well, though it does pay slightly more than competitors.