News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by JacobThreeThree on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:04AM (#32662994)
Ironically, Europe is now becoming dependent on Chinese LNG imports, much of which comes from Russia. The sanctions are not working.

>The more desperate Europe becomes about its energy supplies, the more China’s policy decisions will have the power to affect the bloc. As Europe attempts to wrestle out of its dependence on Russia for energy, the irony is that it is becoming more dependent on China.

https://www.ft.com/content/1e20467a-5b53-42b7-ad89-49808f7e1... https://archive.ph/APcGS

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by Brometheus on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:13AM (#32663151)
For the moment. There's a strong urge in Germany to switch over to heatpumps and more renewables now.

The gas is not coming back. The ministry of economy instructed city energy utilities to "stop investing" into their gas infrastructure...

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by scottLobster on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:29AM (#32663443)
Germany is neither sunny nor windy, and is maintaining an anti-nuclear stance for the moment. I'm sure it will try a renewable play, waste tons of money for marginal results, and end up burning its local coal deposits instead. That or concede to Russian demands.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by Brometheus on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:39AM (#32663640)
40% of our electricity comes from renewables already. And it would be much higher, if the Energiewende ("energy turn (to renewables)") hadn't been sabotaged by the same parties that wanted to use coal and gas (namely CDU and SPD).
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by scottLobster on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:42PM (#32664807)
German power consumption is around 500 TWh https://www.enerdata.net/estore/energy-market/germany/

If 40% of that was renewable, that puts renewables' portion at around 200 TWh

It's hard to find consolidated recent figures for German electricity storage capacity, but everything I can find lists it in double digit GWh at most, including battery and pumped storage capacity. https://www.hydropower.org/country-profiles/germany https://www.energy-storage.news/germany-growth-in-home-and-i... https://www.energy-storage.news/residential-segement-continu...

So there's clearly some creative accounting going on behind that 40% figure. Maybe it's 40% of raw power produced that then gets exported and pays for other sources or something, or maybe that 40% is strictly during the day and can't be replicated at night. But it's clear the storage necessary for a completely renewable grid is lacking by multiple orders of magnitude.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by r00fus on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @06:47PM (#32669340)
You don't need equivalent storage to energy production. I'm not sure what the ratio should be but if you're offsetting 40% of production (ie, during the day) that's pretty good.

Of course, you need baseload power generation for non-peak power, and DE really should have stayed with nuclear for that instead of pushing coal/gas.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by hef19898 on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:41AM (#32663683)
Local coal deposits are not economical anymore, haven't been for decades. We get our coal from places like Asia and Australia.

Last time I checked Germany was among the leaders in Europe for installed PV capacity, ahead of Spain, Italy, Portugal and France. And the northern part is quite windy, ever heard of the north sea?

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by mdavis6890 on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:32AM (#32663500)
Instead of what? Making the switch will require tremendous effort that must come from something else, which Germany will necessarily lose (not produce). Likely this would be distributed through the economy so that there will be a bit less of everything else - shoes, haircuts, food, etc.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by Brometheus on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:40AM (#32663664)
We will produce the solar cells ourselves again and we have two of the biggest producers of wind power plants, so there's that.

https://www.enercon.de/ https://www.siemens.com/

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by vorpalhex on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:29AM (#32663444)
The most efficient appliance still needs electricity 24/7 to run. Even when it's dark and the wind isn't blowing.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by Brometheus on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:41AM (#32663685)
We will implement storage in hydrogen for the winter. It's already on it's way (again).
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by spywaregorilla on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:14AM (#32663176)
If China buys from Russia at discounted prices because the demand for russian oil has fallen, and then resells at a higher price to Europe, it's not quite true that the sanctions are not working. Russia's bleeding out as well.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by fomine3 on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @08:42PM (#32670295)
But also market gas price is increased by sanctions.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by jelliclesfarm on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:17AM (#32663216)
so is this like cutting the nose to spite the face?
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by spywaregorilla on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:22AM (#32663305)
I guess, though to me that idiom inappropriately suggests that the actions are not understood. This is direct economic warfare and it sucks but it's got clear strategic objectives.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by jelliclesfarm on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:33AM (#32663514)
right. but how is this a 'win'?
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by spywaregorilla on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:38AM (#32663626)
The gradual decline of Russia is a strategic objective. You're allowed to disagree on whether that it's a net positive for western Europe.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by syzar on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:15AM (#32663194)
Russia’s economy is contracting so in what sense are sanctions not working? They aren’t 100% effective but they do appear to be having an effect and long term the effects, if sanctions remain, will force Russia into a pseudo vassal client of China.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by landemva on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:34PM (#32664680)
Most economies worldwide have been contracting this year, along with price inflation on commodities including food.

If the intent of Russian sanctions was to increase prices of food and fuel in USA to harm the working poor in USA, then Russian sanctions are going great.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by syzar on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:50PM (#32664925)
Russia’s economy, from what I’ve read, is contracting much more with sanctions than without them. I think it’s clear and obvious that the EU did not impose sanctions on Russia for the purpose of increasing prices of food and fuel for poor people in the U.S. The EU and the U.S. have announced the reason for sanctions. There are secondary effects of the sanctions and I believe that food price increases are more a result of global supply chain issues and Russia preventing Ukraine from fully exporting its products.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by spaceman_2020 on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @05:33PM (#32668644)
The problem is that a contracting economy doesn’t faze ordinary Russians outside of Moscow and St Petersburg all that much.

They were already poor. They’ll get a little poorer. But they’ll have enough to eat and enough to heat their homes. And they’ll still believe that Russian pride is intact, and that’s all that matters.

The entire sanctions approach fails so spectacularly because the capitalist Western ideology sees everything in terms of money and wealth. Outside of the west, most people will happily suffer if they believe that their pride and identity is being protected. This is something Americans just don’t understand at all.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by origin_path on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:25AM (#32663379)
The European gas sanctions specifically aren't working:

1. The gas is just being arbitraged via China. It's a commodity, it makes no sense to stop buying from source A and start buying from source B if B is willing to buy from A.

2. Gazprom is now making record-breaking profits.

Europe is now facing an unprecedented and mostly self inflicted crisis of the type that didn't occur even during the cold war. The Russians claim they are willing to fill up to half of Nord Stream 2 the moment Germany decides to accept it. If that's a lie then the energy crisis is real. If it's not a lie then European leaders are manipulating the public - sanctioning Russia so they feel good and virtuous whilst simultaneously claiming the sanctions are the other way around and there's nothing they can do to get more gas.

Sanctions on non-commodities like chips, specialist tools, infrastructure access? That can work and is probably having an impact. Sanctions on a commodity that can be moved around as a liquid? That can only work in theory if everyone does it despite the huge incentives to defect.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by afiori on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:39AM (#32663643)
This economic war is being fought differently from the two sides: Russia is trying to squeeze as much money as possible out of Europe for gas and oil, Europe is trying to starve Russia of every thing else.

Of course Gazprom is making record profit it is currently an unregulated adversarial monopoly. The sanction effect are thing like how the other week Russia was unable to operate some of its warship for lack of replacement parts.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by landemva on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @07:15PM (#32669576)
> This economic war is being fought differently

Economic war? This is a new cold war with countries* being compelled to choose sides and split banking channels. The war material manufacturers are creating career paths for their grand children.

* Turkey is attempting to make money from everyone, while remaining in NATO.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by origin_path on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:17PM (#32664382)
Gazprom does not have a monopoly on supplying gas, and the point of sanctions is not to make the sanctioned entity rich.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by syzar on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:32PM (#32664645)
Which other Russian companies supply Russian gas to Europe in significant quantities? I thought Gazprom was pretty much the only company doing this but I have only a cursory knowledge of this matter.

The point of sanctions is a combination of two things. One is to punish a country and the other is to make a moral stance. If in the course of punishing the country a particular company makes more money that does not necessarily negate the efficacy of the sanctions or necessarily negate the morality of the sanctions.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by origin_path on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @12:51PM (#32664952)
Europe doesn't only use Russian gas, large parts of it hardly rely on Russian gas at all. For example the UK only gets ~5% of gas from Russia. Europe is dotted with LNG import terminals that can import gas via ship from anywhere.

The reason there's a price spike across Europe is that Germany is suddenly trying to buy the supplies it needs from elsewhere, and gas is a (mostly) fungible commodity. So there's effectively less supply now in Europe, but with same or greater demand (to fill storage), which means the global LNG price goes up for everyone.

"The point of sanctions is a combination of two things. One is to punish a country and the other is to make a moral stance."

For as long as any country is willing to arbitrage gas it simply punishes the buyer, not the seller. From this whole thread it seems the basic economics of this seem to have got lost somewhere so let's do a worked example:

1. Russia sells $1000 worth of gas per day to Europe and $500 worth to China (or India, or wherever).

2. Europe says to Russia we don't want to buy your gas anymore. Russia is now $1000/day poorer, but has lots of spare gas. Now Europe needs to buy $1000 worth from somewhere else like China.

3. China looks at its natural reserves and thinks, well, we don't really have much more to sell from local production. But hey, we have pipelines and LNG terminals and gas is the same no matter where it comes from. Russia, would you be willing to sell us all your spare gas?

4. Russia says sure, that'll be $1000/day. China says OK, we'll take it.

5. Now China turns around to Europe and says sure, we can sell you gas. That'll be $1200/day. Europe is desperate for gas and so says yes; they don't have many other options because most sellers can't meet such a huge block of demand.

Result: Russia makes the same money as before and doesn't care, China takes a profit off the top, Europe ends up shooting itself in the foot. But at least its politicians can feel virtuous.

What's happening isn't as pure cut as that example. Obviously, Europe is trying to get gas from lots of alternative locations, only some is being arbitraged via third party countries. And in reality the arbitrageurs would pay less because there's greater supply, pushing down the price. But in any situation where you're trying to buy something that is a fungible commodity sanctions like that only make sense if there are no groups that break them. The moment someone does they make huge profits. So it doesn't make sense in an international market, it'd be like trying to sanction oil or grain. Someone will just buy it at the new lower price, relabel it and sell it back to you.

As for the moral stance argument, German politicians have no moral authority to bankrupt the poor throughout Europe or break down the electricity grid. They were not elected to do that, and it is deeply immoral to do that even if it worked which it does not. The working classes of Europe are not cannon fodder to freeze to death so Scholz can take a "moral stance".

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by syzar on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:08PM (#32665219)
So Gazprom is a monopoly within Russia. Germany is not solely the reason for the EU sanctions. Other countries were involved in the sanctions decision. The Baltics and Poland, etc. have been far more vocal about wanting sanctions.

The fact is Russia hasn’t been stably non expansionist for centuries and it is they who have been aggressors in Moldova, Ukraine, Belarus, and Georgia. At some point it’s a reasonable response by those threatened by Russia (the Baltics) to respond by demanding action by their allies. Russia alone is at fault and it alone deserves ire.

The moral imperative clearly lies with those desiring sanctions. Europe is going through the painful process to divest itself now of Russian resources. This will pay dividends in the future.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by afiori on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:33PM (#32665613)
I don't believe that china pays as much as Europe for Russian Gas
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by origin_path on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @03:47PM (#32667364)
Probably not, the numbers chosen were arbitrary.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by afiori on Thursday September 01, 2022 @04:29AM (#32673596)
But it would change the equation a lot. Russia in very reliant on its fossil fuel exports both to finance its imports and its internal economy; the EU would like sanctions to affect both of those fields, but one is better than zero.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by origin_path on Saturday September 03, 2022 @10:07AM (#32701996)
If China pays less it just means the above situation works out to China's advantage even more than with my toy numbers, and even less to Europe's. Regardless of what numbers you use, Europe loses more than Russia. Sanctions only "work" (by the very low standards of workingness they're held to) if the sanctioned party needs to sell a lot more than the sanctioner needs to buy. With Europe that's clearly not the case - Russia can easily sell to others but Europe faces more or less immediate collapse. The advantage here is Russia's and the inability of the EU to recognize that they miscalculated threatens its population with dire levels of deprivation of economic destruction.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by zajio1am on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @01:08PM (#32665222)
There are no gas sanctions. It is the Russian side that restricts supply of gas.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by pcrh on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:21AM (#32663294)
More accurately, Europe is diversifying its energy sources at a very rapid pace. It imports a lot of LNG from the US for example.

FTA: >Through these emergency measures, Europe looks to weather the coming winter, even if pipeline flows are 80 per cent lower than at normal times.

Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by jelly on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:28AM (#32663430)
"The sanctions" in this context being Russia's refusal to supply gas to Europe. The EU has not sanctioned Russian energy because they are dependent.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by morsch on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @11:23AM (#32663333)
There are no sanctions on gas imports.
Re:How Bad Europe’s Energy Crisis Is by rich_sasha on Wednesday August 31, 2022 @02:34PM (#32666424)
My understanding is that the gas China is reselling is not from Russia, or at least mostly, rather Middle East. Russian energy exports to China are small and without an obvious immediate way to increase it. It is also had that China has no use for si they are a beneficiary too.