News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:14PM (#32639951)
Humans learn to produce good art largely by learning from existing art. Copying, mimicking, or just generally taking inspiration. We're going to need to get over this hang up. Status quo bias is dumb. Especially among people who are otherwise fond of piracy or anti-ip legislation.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:19PM (#32640014)
Sounds to me like you've decided that AI veganism is not for you!

I've thought about this comparison to human artists taking inspiration from each other a bit. The problem becomes the scale. A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour.

Consider facial recognition technology. At an individual level, empowering people to quickly see all of the photos they have taken of their spouse through running facial recognition against their photos is useful and harmless. Allowing governments to run the exact same technology against every photo uploaded to Facebook is a massively harmful expansion of the surveillance state.

I don't think training models against 5bn unlicensed images is in the same scale of harm as running facial recognition against an entire country's worth of people. But this example does show that things that are fine on a small scale can be harmful at a big scale.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:24PM (#32640074)
> Sounds to me like you've decided that AI veganism is not for you!

I feel it is insulting to veganism to try and coin this term. The moral arguments are not similar, and this one is frankly much weaker.

> I've thought about this comparison to human artists taking inspiration from each other a bit. The problem becomes the scale. A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour.

A human can mimic something with a single reference. It might not be good, but that can hardly matter for a discussion of ethics. The morality cannot depend on whether or not humans can do something poorly or not.

> Consider facial recognition technology. At an individual level, empowering people to quickly see all of the photos they have taken of their spouse through running facial recognition against their photos is useful and harmless. Allowing governments to run the exact same technology against every photo uploaded to Facebook is a massively harmful expansion of the surveillance state.

Entirely different issue that happens to utilize a similar tech.

> But this example does show that things that are fine on a small scale can be harmful at a big scale.

It does not.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:32PM (#32640173)
I agree that this analogy is (mildly) insulting to veganism.

This is another example of an ethical choice that I made!

Is the harm here that is caused by being offensive to veganism outweighed by the value of sparking useful conversations about personal approaches to AI ethics?

I think that it is.

It's similar to the ethics of attaching a click-bait headline to a valuable piece of journalism. Is it OK to do that? That depends, both on the specific case and on the opinions of individuals who observe that decision.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by chrispine on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:37PM (#32640262)
Seems like a disproportionate number of these comments are about using the vegan analogy. So setting aside offense or ethics, do you think it was a good idea to go with this analogy, or is it detracting from "the value of sparking useful conversations about personal approaches to AI ethics"? (emphasis mine)
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:39PM (#32640294)
I've been trying unsuccessfully to have good conversations about AI ethics for quite a while. This thread has 59 comments, and more than half of them aren't about veganism - so yeah, I think it worked.

And to be honest, if it hadn't worked I would have thought "well, it was worth a shot". The analogy genuinely works well for me.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by bowsamic on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:30PM (#32640151)
> I feel it is insulting to veganism to try and coin this term. The moral arguments are not similar, and this one is frankly much weaker.

I agree. This would more accurately be called "AI Luddism", opposing a new technology because of fears related to its immense productivity over humans. It has nothing to do with veganism

EDIT: that said, vegan is used in the sense of the article as "a really obvious and strong stance that people do not follow even though all the information about how it is bad is readily available"

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by ZeroGravitas on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:22PM (#32640870)
That's not really what Luddites were about though. They were poor people in a reactionary and anti-democratic country, that was fighting (and winning) wars to stop democracy spreading while people at home starved:

https://theguardian.com/commentisfree/2015/jun/17/napoleon-d...

> In one conversation on St Helena, Napoleon was asked by his doctor what he would have done if he had managed to invade southern England in 1805. Napoleon’s reply was an absolute cracker: “I would have hastened over my flotilla with two hundred thousand men, landed as near Chatham as possible and proceeded direct to London, where I calculated to arrive in four days from the time of my landing. I would have proclaimed a republic and the abolition of the nobility and the House of Peers, the distribution of the property of such of the latter as opposed me amongst my partisans, liberty, equality and the sovereignty of the people.”

They smashed machines because that hurt the people oppressing them, not because they hated the machines.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by jhbadger on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @09:18AM (#32650026)
Britain at the time wasn't as democratic as it is today certainly, but it was far more democratic than Napoleon's Empire that it was fighting against. Napoleon liked to pretend that he defended the French Revolution's ideals of liberty, equality and fraternity, but in fact he went around creating new kingdoms and making his relatives monarchs.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by ZeroGravitas on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:23PM (#32652838)
I wasn't really trying to make the case that Napolean was a great guy, but he rose to power by winning battles in a war between the French Republic and a bunch of Monarchies, so there was a fairly clear democratic side.

Admittedly, the UK was warring againt the French Monach as well before, so it's not a clear cut thing, but things like Luddites and the 'Peterloo' show that Britain was not speeding towards greater democracy. They very slowly gave ground over centuries of struggle.

> The Tory Prime Minister in 1830, Arthur Wellesley, First Duke of Wellington, was resolutely opposed to parliamentary reform. However, there was growing support for limited change within his party, primarily because partially extending the franchise would allow the wealth and influence of Britain's growing middle class to be exploited.

That's 20 years later, a small extra step of democracy.

I was just trying to point out that smashing some stuff was a fairly reasonable thing to do when you don't have a vote and you're hungry, by providing some political context on the era.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:33PM (#32640190)
I think calling it "AI Luddism" would offend people who are opposed to generative AI a lot more than calling it "AI veganism" offends vegans.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by bowsamic on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:35PM (#32640216)
Why? The argument is very similar to the one that Luddites used: that the increased efficiency is harmful to artists
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by forgotusername6 on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:59PM (#32640568)
The argument is slightly different. This isn't about taking away a person's job. This is about eroding something that we as humans had previously thought was uniquely ours, intellectual creativity. The point of art was to express something by humans for other humans. The point was not to make a pretty picture, or a pleasant sounding song. When an AI does this it is and likely always will be a mere imitation of what art is supposed to be. The sad thing is that this imitation will be good enough and cheap enough that it will flood our daily lives. AI image and song generation will do what mobile did to computer games. Endless piles of low effort useless output and concepts distilled to the smallest possible set of features necessary for us to be suckered into purchasing them.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by Karrot_Kream on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:02PM (#32641368)
As more labor was automated, these exact arguments were made. It was thought that no machine could capture the beauty and skill of human craftsmen as creation was a fundamentally human task. It was thought to be "sad" that low-effort, mass-produced, standardized goods would be "good enough" to satisfy human needs, that there was some inextricable timeless beauty to human output that elevates over machine output. Time has shown us that machine output has become even more precise and skillful than human labor. These arguments feel almost 1:1.

At times this whole thing feels hypocritical. Generations of laborers grew up with the reality that their work was essentially a commodity. Now that it's our turn, we raise the age old arguments again.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by trention on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:53PM (#32642013)
Those "generations of laborers" had the option to earn more for less (and less dangerous) work most of the time. It doesn't seem this will be the case now.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by Karrot_Kream on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:26PM (#32642405)
Not at all. The changes were sudden and extreme. Look at the original Luddite rebellion for its oldest incarnation, but just look at the mechanizing of factories in the 60s with the introduction of CNCs or protests against automation at ports.

Automation of labor has been an ongoing force for decades and a reality laborers have had to live with for years.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by trention on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:32PM (#32643179)
This is of course not true (for ports in particular the writing had been on the wall for more than a decade) but even if it were, there eventually were other jobs. There won't be this time around.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by bowsamic on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:00PM (#32640591)
Is the argument of Luddism not also the erosion of transforming material things with your hands, something we also thought was uniquely human?
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:50PM (#32640433)
Try even hinting at calling them Luddites and see how they react!
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by bowsamic on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:52PM (#32640457)
So basically, they want to be called vegans, because that's a historically virtuous label, but not Luddites, because that's a historically maligned one? Even though they are literally not vegans, and literally are much closer to Luddites?
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by kixiQu on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:32PM (#32640178)
> I feel it is insulting to veganism to try and coin this term. The moral arguments are not similar, and this one is frankly much weaker.

There are many, many, many people out there who believe it's fine to eat meat but not fine to e.g. feign attribution on intellectual work. Asserting that objections to this kind of tech are much weaker than various vegan arguments without explanation is odd.

> A human can mimic something with a single reference. It might not be good, but that can hardly matter for a discussion of ethics. The morality cannot depend on whether or not humans can do something poorly or not.

Asserting this without argument suggests you have a particular unstated idea of how ethical determinations are supposed to be made that you are projecting out onto the discussion. This would be important to lay out.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by andreilys on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:44PM (#32640355)
Murdering (or being complicit in the factory farming model), and then consuming another living conscious being is on a very different moral plane than remixing intellectual work.

It's hard to imagine the mental gymnastics required to think the two are in the same league.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by trention on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:33PM (#32641000)
>It's hard to imagine the mental gymnastics required to think the two are in the same league.

It's really not hard. You just have to care more for the harm to the well-being of human artists than for the harm for the well-being of farmed animals. It may surprise some people but speciesism is the default position for the vast majority of the population.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by jerojero on Monday August 29, 2022 @07:02PM (#32644658)
Wait. When you say well being you're aware that killing them is close to the ultimate harm we can inflict on them.

What you're saying is that you think intellectual property is more valuable, to you, than the life of other conscious non human beings.

I think for most people, this is a stretch.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by trention on Monday August 29, 2022 @07:10PM (#32644707)
It really isn't. Most people don't consider farming murder and do not care about the well-being of non-cute, non-immediately present animals at all.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by kixiQu on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:22PM (#32640865)
Deciding that "living conscious being" is the category that merits moral status is one framework of justification for veganism – the Western originated-in-the-1970s-one. https://www.bbc.co.uk/ethics/animals/rights/moralstatus_1.sh... I'm not saying that it's wrong, but to act like it should be taken as the default prior without requiring laying out its context is a very narrow view.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by vagrantJin on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:16PM (#32642281)
Eating animals is kind of what our species has been doing for millenia.

The mental gymnastics are required to rationalize the act of eating meat and murder being the same thing.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by biztos on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:11PM (#32642231)
Redefining words like “murder” to include killing animals for food requires some pretty impressive mental gymnastics too.

But I don’t find either one hard to imagine.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:08PM (#32640691)
> There are many, many, many people out there who believe it's fine to eat meat but not fine to e.g. feign attribution on intellectual work. Asserting that objections to this kind of tech are much weaker than various vegan arguments without explanation is odd.

The vegan argument is that factory farms are literal lifetime torture pins. This isn't much up to debate. You can shrug and choose to eat meat anyway, but co-opting their name for your argument on ip seems incredibly shallow. Even if you believe that ip violations are worse than animal cruelty. I'm not a vegetarian at all fwiw. Not too dissimilar from trying to frame this as the holocaust of artists or any other strongly held event / movement by many others.

> Asserting this without argument suggests you have a particular unstated idea of how ethical determinations are supposed to be made that you are projecting out onto the discussion. This would be important to lay out.

If your ethical framework suggests ip violations are immoral, unless you think the execution was bad that's just silly.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by harrylove on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:35PM (#32640227)
> The problem becomes the scale. A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour.

Can you say more about the scale argument? It reads as if you're saying that an entity that has an advantage shouldn't use that advantage.

If you reduce the comparison to human scale, do you still have a problem with the competition? I.e., if one artist has a working memory of 5 inspirational artworks (unlicensed) and another artist has a working memory of 3, is that wrong if they both compete to produce new artwork based on what they know of existing art?

If the answer to that question is no, then I don't see how the scale question is applicable.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:55PM (#32640501)
I'm saying that one artist walking around an art gallery and being inspired by the art they see there (or even visiting hundreds of galleries over a lifetime) is operating at such a minuscule scale compared to an AI that trains itself on 5bn images that the similarities between the two do not necessary mean that if one is OK then the other is OK as well.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by Karrot_Kream on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:46PM (#32641187)
Computers have scale benefits that no human has. An industrial controller can control all the machines in a factory all at once, and make them move faster than a human can react. A script can send out communications to hundreds of thousands, maybe millions, of humans at once. A machine controlling door locks in a building can lock every door at once. No human can compete. It's unclear to me why art generation is unique in this regard unless there's a human status-quo bias at play. I'm increasingly inclined to think that it's ennui over the fact that creative work isn't unique anymore and can be automated, a reality that many laborers have already dealt with and accepted.

One of the computer's "super powers" is its ability to run at scale.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by candiodari on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:34PM (#32645713)
I think more and more humans are seeing this as a serious disadvantage that creates an ever greater asymmetry between companies and humans. The most egregious example is spam, but these days almost every large company communication essentially uses this "scale advantage".

Very few people are happy with that.

Therefore, if there was some way to eliminate this sort of advantage, especially for very large organisations like the government, that would be excellent.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by MattGrommes on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:04PM (#32640637)
Why though? Scale in and of itself isn't a bad thing just because we can't do it with our puny human minds. I'm open to the argument but I don't see it.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by bowsamic on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:27PM (#32640111)
> I've thought about this comparison to human artists taking inspiration from each other a bit. The problem becomes the scale. A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour.

To me this seems to similar to old fashioned luddites. The machines back then that improved the productivity of labourers mostly displaced the societal role of skilled craftsmen. Of course using the machine is different to doing it by hand, but we did have some benefits from improving our productivity using machines, as well as some downsides. The interesting thing is that in this case we are moving from using machines to improve productivity of material objects, into sociocultural objects (art), and it's not clear what that will "do" exactly.

> But this example does show that things that are fine on a small scale can be harmful at a big scale.

Right but of course, the words "can be" are there. I don't think anyone is claiming that scaling a given thing up is always harmless, but generally with these kinds of technological developments you really need a super strong, clear, and concrete (for this specific case) argument to stop them. I haven't seen any such arguments, except the traditional luddite one I posted above.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by EGreg on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:42PM (#32640338)
Simonw, we are about to have much worse problems from bot swarms. Sleeper bots trained on “get more upvotes” will amass karma points and then be unlesshed as implacable crowds of “people” pushing public opinion around. They will amass capital and social capital to the point where regular humans represent a vashingly small sliver of online capital.

This idea of CAPTCHAs and “human only, no bots” networks is only for a decade or two, until bots just become more desirable members of every community, to humans and other bots.

What people don’t get is that their individual decisions in their own self interest doom the group. Dad works 10 hours a day to provide for family. Then mom does too. Now they both neglected their kids and each other.

Similarly, you choose a bot for its wittier comebacks and impeccably romantic style of talking. Your husband chooses a bot for its better sexual techniques and never complaining. Ultimately, neither of you needs the other and you’re one step away drom NO ONE IN SOCIETY needing you.

You would become the Borg. Except why have the drone bodies at all?

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by enlyth on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:37PM (#32640255)
> A human artist can't look at 5bn images and use them to be able to instantly mimic the style of another artist, hundreds of times an hour.

It's just another step on the path towards AI being better than humans at certain activities. We've already gone through this with things like math, chess, imitating voices, translating languages, and lately visual art seems to be coming close to a point where the AI will have an edge over humans. We will have to learn to cope, one way or another, because eventually, AI will be better at everything, as we are limited by our biological bodies.

Humanity will create its own synthetic god, and the consequences will be interesting.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by tshaddox on Monday August 29, 2022 @07:04PM (#32644675)
The argument about differences in scale constituting differences in kind is compelling, and yet I'm not sure how to evaluate any particular instance of this type of argument without just deferring to my existing opinion on the topic at hand.

For example, it's easy to construct hypothetical scenarios where a difference in scale seem to clearly constitute a difference in kind and where suppression of a new technology seems clearly reasonable. An easy hypothetical (but not implausible) example is some new kind of extremely deadly weapon that would be much easier to build than existing weapons if the "recipe" was made public.

But it's also easy to make the same argument for things like, say, the printing press. And indeed there has always been intense opposition from many to the printing press and subsequent technologies that make distributing written language much easier, with opponents often presenting arguments in this same form. Yet it feels wrong to me to apply the argument this way.

Is that just because I have existing opinions that generally oppose restrictions in the ability to distribute ideas, but I don't generally oppose restrictions on very deadly weapons? Or is there some other way to distinguish between valid and invalid instances of this form of argument, perhaps by attempting to estimate the overall risk versus reward?

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by tshaddox on Monday August 29, 2022 @06:50PM (#32644562)
These problems of scale aren't unique to recent leaps in technology, or even to automation or technology at all. Government intelligent agencies can, given certain goals and management, do a great deal of harmful and disturbing things without using any secret or advanced technology. A team of 1,000 people with, say, basic PC office equipment from the early 2000s, could do a great deal if they were competently trained and managed and told to, say, investigate and attempt to undermine some group that the agency doesn't like for whatever reason. In my opinion the technology has little to do with the problem, even though the potential for harm is unique to the scale of resources dedicated to it, and even though they would be a lot less effectively if they didn't have that technology (i.e. imagine if they no longer had access to personal computers at the office).
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spyder on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:49PM (#32641214)
But author of the article says he would be fine with AI trained on licensed images, which could be also on bigger scale than a single human is capable of. Looks like some people doesn't like it because the data it was trained on but others are worried about the technology and its capabilities over humans.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by chrispine on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:33PM (#32640194)
"vegan / not-vegan" is a false and harmful dichotomy

"meat-based" vs "plant-based" is a spectrum we are all on; no reason to make it all-or-nothing

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by hot_gril on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:50PM (#32640431)
If the AI is looking at 5bn images, that means it's drawing inspiration from individual ones even less than a human would.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by peteradio on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:16PM (#32640783)
What if the AI was trained entirely on a corpus of artwork in a style you've uniquely developed over decades? The AI did not do any of the legwork or market testing but it would theoretically be making your art form at scale better than you could. Knowing AI would be deployed to rip-off your efforts will you pursue art?
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by hot_gril on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:54PM (#32641266)
People can already do that, and copyright law doesn't really protect it. It's hard to copyright a style. Whoever first painted that multi-colored landscape of a couple walking through a park, it's been copied a million times. Even parodies, which often use a lot of the source material, are explicitly legal. And then there's the Hyundai Genesis.

To the last question: No, but I wouldn't pursue art either way.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by atemerev on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:23PM (#32640053)
> Allowing governments to run the exact same technology against every photo uploaded to Facebook

We should allow _everybody_ to run the exact same technology. Governments are not special. Power to the people.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by fragmede on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:25PM (#32640094)
I don’t own my own supercomputer to run the same analysis the NSA can, though.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by dahart on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:25PM (#32640903)
This blindly steam rolls over some important distinctions. Humans aren’t allowed to sell direct copies of other people’s art (not in the US and many other countries anyway). This isn’t a hang-up, and it’s not status quo bias, it’s well covered law and economic philosophy that is already blending new digital rights ideas into hard fought legal precedents. We have explicitly decided to have the social goal to protect the rights of artistic creative people & businesses without having their work instantly ripped off.

Humans also are good at taking inspiration from ideas, where today’s AI is borrowing pixels. The AI is copying in a way that humans don’t, it’s not mimicking and taking inspiration - that is anthropomorphising the software that is trained and programmed to make automated mashups of images.

So in part it depends on what we do with AI images. There may be nothing wrong with training on copyrighted material if the resulting inferences are never distributed publicly nor used for commercial purposes. Of course that seems extremely unlikely, which is why it needs to be discussed carefully and debated in good faith, right?

Maybe in part it also depends on whether the AI software is guaranteed to produce something very different from any individual training image. If the outputs are guaranteed to be always a mashup, and never indistinguishable from any single input, that seems like it would be an easier pill to swallow. (There appears to be legal precedent along these lines for music sampling.)

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by karmasimida on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:33PM (#32641008)
> Humans aren’t allowed to sell direct copies of other people’s art

Direct copying yes, but stealing ideas? No. Actually it is a well-known practice in the art industry to use several existing works as references, and creating new artwork that is bit of mixture of all of them.

That is exactly what DALL-E/StableDiffusion are trying to do.

AI isn't borrowing pixels, either. If you read the idea of diffusion models, quite the opposite, what it directly learns is how to destroy an image from what it is into gaussian noise. The trick here is we can reverse this process 'creating' arts from noises.

There is no copying pixels, not even in the most simplistic version of how this model works.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by remram on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:14PM (#32642268)
More importantly, humans are inspectable. You can ask a human why they did something one way. You can put them on a stand and ask them whether they had knowledge of X, why they didn't do alternative Y, how they arrived at formulation Z.

All this goes out the window with AI, we have to judge the entire model as a whole, and even though we see DALL-E etc spit out watermarks we can't call it a liar or a thief. "This part overfits but the whole model is transformative, we think" say the authors.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by IanCal on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:31PM (#32640984)
> Humans also are good at taking inspiration from ideas, where today’s AI is borrowing pixels.

I disagree with this, we don't just hear about ideas we actually see the art. Both are shown pictures.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by thomasahle on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:05PM (#32640643)
1) Humans learn from existing art, but they mainly draw on their experience and perception of the physical world when creating new art. AI doesn't have access to the real world, so it's art is 100% based on existing work, not just inspired by it.

2) We still don't know exactly how much the models memorise. I'm sure you'll agree that something like Google image search retrieval doesn't qualify as original art, and copyright is still an issue. If you photoshop two images together, you probably also still have to give credit to the original images. We have to draw the line somewhere on the scale from "100% derivative to 100% original". It's not yet clear where AI image generation falls on this.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:30PM (#32640974)
> Humans learn from existing art, but they mainly draw on their experience and perception of the physical world when creating new art. AI doesn't have access to the real world, so it's art is 100% based on existing work, not just inspired by it.

Ok so let's just feed the ai some dashcam footage and this argument is null.

> I'm sure you'll agree that something like Google image search retrieval doesn't qualify as original art,

Yes

> and copyright is still an issue

No

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by tomatotomato37 on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:20PM (#32642332)
If the AI researchers actually go through the effort of strapping a bunch of go-pros to people for a year as they experience life and used that as the majority of training data than I'm fine with calling anything it generates original art.

But for now when the training set is 100% others work and you can see the AI literally trying to inject a jumbled artist name/trademark into "original" art I can't see it as anything more than extreme photobashing

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:05PM (#32645522)
Seems like an impressive amount of mental gymnastics to me
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by thomasahle on Monday August 29, 2022 @09:52PM (#32645798)
>> I'm sure you'll agree that something like Google image search retrieval doesn't qualify as original art,

> Yes

>> and copyright is still an issue

> No

You don't think I'll get trouble with copyright infringement if I start using images I find on Google commercially? "But officer, I came up with the keyword for this image all by myself!!" Or do you just mean you don't think copyright should exist in the first place?

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by mbreese on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:34PM (#32640201)
> Humans learn to produce good art largely by learning from existing art

I think you’re wrong on this. Humans learn (anything) from teachers. Yes, you can learn much on your own, but the idea of a solo artist learning from books is exceedingly rare.

So in this case, you learn art by doing, critiquing your work and the works of others. You put forth effort.

While I am amazed at the generated images and think they truly are amazing, I can’t help but think they all feel a little cheap. Like someone took a shortcut that was never meant to be found.

I do think there are real ethical issues behind the training data for both image and code generation. Nothing that can’t be solved, but random images scraped from the web are not meant for training. First - it’s not necessarily a fair-use issue. And second, garbage in, garbage out. I don’t want my auto generated images to come with a Getty watermark.

Where I do think there is hope is for the use of these as tools for artists. Where there can still be a human behind the choices and curation, but using the algorithms as a means rather than an end.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:14PM (#32640756)
> I think you’re wrong on this. Humans learn (anything) from teachers. Yes, you can learn much on your own, but the idea of a solo artist learning from books is exceedingly rare.

If you take an art class where a teacher instructs you and tells you to replicate 12 paintings by Van Gogh, I would argue you've learned more from Van Gogh than the teacher, even if he's showing you some physical techniques.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by mbreese on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:36PM (#32641803)
You could masterfully copy the Van Gogh stroke for stroke, but without the understanding behind the composition, intent, and meaning behind the work, I’d argue you learned nothing. Except for how to copy.

The student/teacher interaction is where you learn. Even if you want to only paint in Van Gogh’s style, the back and forth with the teacher is where you actually learn how to apply that style to new works. To explore the meaning behind the stars, etc.

(You could get there solo, but you’d still need to go through the criticism/questioning phase somehow, which is probably best done with an IRL teacher).

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by throwaways85989 on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:25PM (#32641654)
But that is just art. Not great art. Great art comes from stepping away from your peer group after you mastered it, being able to incooperate "unrelated" or "impossible" other concepts into the art. Its a subconscious process, of recombination and filtering.

And only some can boldly go, to were no person has gone before.

Which makes this the ultimate training goal for AI. Not AGI, but a synthesis AI, capable to produce "breakthrough" candidates for the field it is trained upon, by allowing noise and filtering for the criteria of great break throughs- explanation power, beauty, higher consistency, that puzzle piece fitting all gaps moment. If there is ever a creature out there, doing that, silicon or otherwise, humanity will own its continued existence to its existence.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by bluehorseray on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:53PM (#32640477)
To a certain extent I agree, but another argument would be that at the end of the day, computers are deterministic (even on the incredibly large scale of these image generators, given parameters x, it will produce y).

We're still not sure whether humans are deterministic or not. So you can't really equate the human process of art creation to a computers. Humans may still be pulling from some external inspiration that will never be within the reach of computers (I like to think that's the case).

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by Verdex on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:45PM (#32641174)
I'm not sure determinism is where you want to draw the line. Just have the computer get a webcam pointed at a lava lamp. It's non-deterministic now.

Or maybe you want to still argue that that's ultimately deterministic.

Okay, well, just have a person show up to the art computer, look deep within their soul, then type in a completely random, soulful, non-deterministic seed value into the art computer. Bam! Now the computer can create real art.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by akira2501 on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:48PM (#32641207)
Yes.. but a human can understand what I want and anticipate various outcomes from much shorter conversations that don't involve all this ridiculous prompting. Asking this system for a simple picture like "a dog smoking a cigarette" reveals just how limited this system is.

Thinking that this system, with such a small set or data and no natural language processing, is going to replace artists anytime soon, is, I think, incredibly eager to the point of foolishness.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by Buttons840 on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:51PM (#32640439)
That's fine, until an AI regurgitates a unique page of code I wrote without modification. That's just copying. Although, if the courts want to clarify that straight-up copying a page or two of code is okay, I would be happy.

My fear is copilot will be allowed to copy code, but I won't be.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by spywaregorilla on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:17PM (#32640800)
But that's just stupid. You find some code on stack overflow that solves your problem. Are you going to do the refactoring dance until it looks different enough or are you just going to use the code? You find the same code on a non open source github repo. Well what now? You've got a mental model of how to solve the problem. Can't use that knowledge? That knowledge has been locked away as illegal?

This is not a reasonable model.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by hot_gril on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:55PM (#32640502)
Just copy the code and claim the AI did it.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by ZeroGravitas on Monday August 29, 2022 @02:33PM (#32641756)
I wonder what would happen if an artist got their stuff legally removed from the sources, and then you asked the AI to produce something in the style of their main influences.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by t0bia_s on Monday August 29, 2022 @03:37PM (#32642540)
I don't understand why AI generated images are called as art.

Art is not about form. It's about content. Meaning that can be generated and understand only by humans.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:04PM (#32642870)
Artists are using AI models to generate art right now, with an enormous amount of interaction along the way. Watch this video for an example of how involved the process can be: https://www.reddit.com/r/StableDiffusion/comments/x0b0rq/img...

Would you say that artist did not produce something that could be called art, just because they used an AI model as part of their process?

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by t0bia_s on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:20PM (#32643025)
It's an digital image. Not very interesting to be honest.

Art is more deep. Has meaning. It doesn't matter how is it done. I mean... You wouldn't find something like that in art gallery on wall.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @04:45PM (#32643341)
That sounds like your personal taste.

What if the image that person had drawn really impressed you on its artistic merits before you learned how they had made it?

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by t0bia_s on Monday August 29, 2022 @05:02PM (#32643508)
Impression is one thing, that is for me now, not that important as meaning, story, message... Especially nowadays, when generating beautiful impressive images is easy and overdone (waving on Instagram).
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by sp332 on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:53PM (#32640471)
Sure but the output from the AI does not give credit. So I don't know what the inspiration is or where it came from or how to find more of the same kind.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by rasz on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:13PM (#32640745)
Humans learn, the "AI" (in this case fancy content aware fill) takes a stencil copy of the original copyrighted work, and stores it in its memory.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:48PM (#32641202)
I don't think calling it a stencil copy is the right mental model.

These models take 5bn+ images and use them to influence the weights on a giant array of floating point numbers. Each input image has a truly tiny effect on the finished product.

The final model is on the order of 4.5GB - the compression ratio is unreal. Nothing of the original images remains.

So "stencil copy" doesn't work for me.

Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by rasz on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @01:13PM (#32652730)
and yet its able to generate Getty images watermark
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by simonw on Tuesday August 30, 2022 @03:55PM (#32654325)
Right - because it's seen thousands of those watermarks, so it's very easy for it to output its own rendition of one.
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan? by leeoniya on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:40PM (#32640312)
is this in the same vein as professional Go and Chess players having and existential crisis over AlphaGo/AlphaZero/MuZero attaining superhuman playing ability with zero supervised learning in something like < 72 hours on non-supercomputer hardware.

i suppose we'd all feel uneasy when AI eventually becomes better than humans at creative tasks which pay our bills or differentiate us within a profession.