Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan?
by chrispine on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:37PM
(#32640262)
Seems like a disproportionate number of these comments are about using the vegan analogy. So setting aside offense or ethics, do you think it was a good idea to go with this analogy, or is it detracting from "the value of sparking useful conversations about personal approaches to AI ethics"? (emphasis mine)
Re:Image generation ethics: Will you be an AI vegan?
by simonw on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:39PM
(#32640294)
I've been trying unsuccessfully to have good conversations about AI ethics for quite a while. This thread has 59 comments, and more than half of them aren't about veganism - so yeah, I think it worked.
And to be honest, if it hadn't worked I would have thought "well, it was worth a shot". The analogy genuinely works well for me.
This is another example of an ethical choice that I made!
Is the harm here that is caused by being offensive to veganism outweighed by the value of sparking useful conversations about personal approaches to AI ethics?
I think that it is.
It's similar to the ethics of attaching a click-bait headline to a valuable piece of journalism. Is it OK to do that? That depends, both on the specific case and on the opinions of individuals who observe that decision.