News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by avalys on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:24PM (#32629604)
The obvious solution here is to have a tiered pricing system for water, where the price per gallon increases with consumption.

Increase the price of the higher tiers and/or rate of increase until consumption drops to level you need.

And then you don’t need to pay government employees to drive around and inspect celebrity lawns all day.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by RosanaAnaDana on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:09PM (#32629990)
I've done worked with or developed outdoor water use models for almost all water districts in the state of California.

The issues cited in the article are a direct consequence of tiered rates. Districts become disinsentivised to reduce the water use for their highest using customers because thats where they make the most revenue. They need to show water use savings in gallons, but they make far more from high using customers. Its much more cost effective (gallons of water saved/reduction in revenue) for them to target users who only irrigate in the lowest use tier because thats where they receive the least revenue per unit volume water delivered.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by lostdog on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:55PM (#32630940)
I don't understand. Isn't the point of tiered rates so that the customer reduces their water usage?
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by RosanaAnaDana on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:27PM (#32631257)
Is it? One might assume on fce value and with a bit of charity that's the point. But districts are in a contradictory position. They are being mandated by state of California to reduce water usage. If they did so by mandating caps, this could work. However, their revenues would drop linearly with use in a flat rate scenario. If, rather, a district goes without caps and uses a tiered price structure, they can up the price enough on the bottom teir that the 'commoners' do cut back on water usage enough to meet their goals. However, there is a subset of users for whom price of water is not an issue. They want a putting green or driving range in the back yard. They want to feel like they are in Kauai or Maui when they sit in their backyard garden in Malibu. They already spend hundreds of thousands building a water slide in their back yard, what's a couple grand a month for the kids to enjoy it? You might think of these as extreme examples, but I've seen each of these. These people do not care about the price of water.

With tiered based rates a district can maintain revenues and can make overall reductions. These rate increases happen at the bottom tier to create reductions in use and at the highest teirs to maintain revenues.

The result is that all of the lower and middle income regions stop watering completely, and the wealthy just ignore any water use limitations. Some of these water users use 10-1000x as much water as a typical SFR, 5000 SQ foot lot.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by manholio on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:51PM (#32631460)
> These people do not care about the price of water.

They will if the top tire price is $10000/gal. It might be politically unpalatable to push such prices, but it would surely solve the consumption problem without compromising revenue.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by Thorrez on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:58AM (#32634935)
Are the water authorities really earning much from these massive users? This[1] says they fined Kim Kardashian $2,325 for overuse. That's nothing to her. They have plenty of room to increase those prices and earn more money. They have 2 goals: earn money and reduce usage. The solution to both is to raise prices. Why aren't they doing it? As long as the lowest tier is wide enough for all reasonable household indoor use and has a low price, I don't see why it would have a big negative impact on regular people. Sure their lawns will turn brown. But it sounds to me like that's inevitable; there's simply not enough water to keep everyone's lawns green.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2022/08/24/1119112184/kim-kardashian-kev...

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by bcrosby95 on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:40AM (#32635103)
A water slide wouldn't use anywhere near a couple grand worth of water per month.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by avalys on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:12PM (#32631639)
Is part of the problem here that there just aren't that many rich people?

If there are a few people in a district of 100,000 who are using 1000x as much water as a normal household, and those people cut their usage 100%, that's still much less overall savings than convincing the remaining 99,990 people to cut their usage by 20%.

Yes, it looks bad that rich people can consume whatever they want and the masses of poor people are the ones that have to conserve, but if this is the reality of the situation then focusing on the rich seems rather petty and spiteful.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by zbrozek on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:37PM (#32631340)
Suppose you're a billionaire. Quite a few of them live in my town. Do you actually care at all? Do you even know what you spend on water? I'd wager not.

Someone down the street from me is not a billionaire, but the property tax savings of operating a "farm" (a vineyard) pays for a huge amount of water. And it's totally worth it for him.

There's so many perverse incentives baked into California life that it's hard to express to people outside without sounding like anything but a paranoid raving lunatic.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by sidewndr46 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:37PM (#32631839)
When water is a tiny percentage of your monthly costs, you could care less. For example, my dad pays for actual water used. Not sewer, he provides that himself. As a result a 35000 gallon a month bill costs him something like $25. They obviously don't use that much each month, but he isn't concerned by the sometimes high bill that comes in.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by richk449 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:20PM (#32631203)
Thanks for explaining this. Once you point out the misaligned incentives for the water boards, the disfunction makes so much more sense.

If water boards charged a fixed rate, and the state taxes use by tier, would that better align incentives?

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by Dylan16807 on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:54AM (#32635155)
> Districts become disinsentivised to reduce the water use for their highest using customers because thats where they make the most revenue

Good! Now build a desalination plant and turn that into guilt-free income!

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by z3c0 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:36PM (#32629707)
As the saying goes, "when the punishment is money, it's only a punishment for the poor."

There are plenty of mega-wealthy people in California who would pay the premium to maintain their image of wealth, no matter how large. It may raise more money, but I can't imagine that it would deter consumption much, as it's already the rich using the most water.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by gruez on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:56PM (#32629895)
>There are plenty of mega-wealthy people in California who would pay the premium to maintain their image of wealth, no matter how large.

Good. The money they're paying for water can now fund projects to get more water for everyone else (eg. desalination plants, water diversion, or buying water rights from current farmers).

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by z3c0 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:04PM (#32629954)
So... let them use up the water so that it's affordable to stop them from using up the water?
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by gruez on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:19PM (#32630064)
The goal isn't to "stop them from using up the water", it's to charge them the true price of providing that water, and charging a bit extra so we can subsidize the price of water for the poor.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by z3c0 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:36PM (#32630236)
I think this premise is sufficient in any scenario where there are disparities in the distribution of a plentiful resource, as is the case in countries with privatized water.

However, when the resource is no longer plentiful, it is unwise to try the "let the market fix it" route (always a popular one on HN), because the resource in question can be consumed much faster than the systems you are describing can combat it (or can even be gotten off the ground.)

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by gruez on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:58PM (#32630436)
>However, when the resource is no longer plentiful

My previous comment mentioned acquisition methods up to and including desalination, which would make the resource virtually unlimited. If the rich want to water their huge mansion grounds and are willing to pay for a desalination plant to do it, why stop them? If they're willing to do that, and we can take a portion of that money to subsidize water supply for the poor, all the better.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by Judgmentality on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:10PM (#32631111)
I'm genuinely curious - what are the economics like for desalination plants? I feel like we'd see a lot more of them if they were viable, but maybe we're just horrible at planning and fixing things.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by gruez on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:40PM (#32631357)
Here's an article I turned up while researching for another reply:

https://www.advisian.com/en/global-perspectives/the-cost-of-...

tl;dr: all in cost is around $1.75/m³

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by VBprogrammer on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:15PM (#32631663)
There are plenty of environmental issues associated with desalination, it's not a get out of jail free card. Obviously energy use (and even if that energy comes from solar it's not completely free of consequences) but also the brine from desalination can cause significant local salinity issues which damages aquatic life.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by gruez on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:28PM (#32631758)
All of those issues can be addressed with money, which is presumably not an issue because the original premise of this thread is that the rich will gladly pay the steep costs.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by josephcsible on Sunday August 28, 2022 @05:07PM (#32632071)
No. The idea is to charge them enough for their water that you can afford sources that are expensive but won't run out (e.g., desalination) to provide it.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by refurb on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:49PM (#32633993)
I mean, they're using as much water as they want now. The difference is that they'd actually pay a high price for it.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by sillystuff on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:18PM (#32630060)
> when the punishment is money, it's only a punishment for the poor.

This is true, but only because the amount of fines are typically identical regardless of income/wealth. Fines should be based on a percentage of income/wealth. A poor person being fined $1000 may end up homeless as a result. For a rich person, $1000 would, at most, be annoying and depending on how rich, might not be noticed even as much as that same poor person accidentally dropping a penny and being unable to retrieve it. Fine the rich person a more equivalent $100K, $1M or $100M, and their compliance level would increase dramatically.

Fixed monetary fines brings to mind this quote:

“In its majestic equality, the law forbids rich and poor alike to sleep under bridges, beg in the streets and steal loaves of bread.” — Anatole France

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by manholio on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:55PM (#32631499)
> "when the punishment is money, it's only a punishment for the poor."

And there is nothing wrong with that: if you are poor and waste 10000 gal watering your lawn during draught, you should be punished because your are just as anti-social as the millionaire next door.

I'm ok with that as long as there exists a free/low cost tire that covers the basic necessities of a regular family, so that even the poor are guaranteed a certain level of service.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by lalaland1125 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:42PM (#32629765)
> it's already the rich using the most water

That's not true. The main water use is agriculture, which is a pretty small portion of our GDP and would cut down usage if we raised prices.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by z3c0 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:45PM (#32629791)
Given the context of the article, I thought it was fairly obvious that I was referring to domestic use, but if it was not, I was.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by throwaway09223 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:03PM (#32629944)
Sure, but your complaint is that it's punishing the poor.

The reason we need to properly price water isn't to increase costs for municipal use. Those rates can stay the same, or even be reduced.

The problem is that the agricultural sector is paying a fraction of the prices that municipalities pay -- or in some cases they are paying nothing at all.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by z3c0 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:13PM (#32630015)
My complaint isn't that it punishes the poor, it's that it doesn't deter the rich, who are - in the context of the article - the primary issue. I just invoked an old saying to draw attention to the disparity. A tiered pricing model would likely not change anything for the poor.

Agriculture and overuse of water is a different discussion that this restrictor does not presume to address.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by throwaway09223 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:26PM (#32631742)
The rich aren't the primary issue, though. The total water used by wealthy people in their own homes is utterly negligible.

The article cites celebs like Kevin Hart, who has used (gasp) 150% of what LA would prefer him to use. This is simply a non-issue. It does not need to be addressed, at all.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by avalys on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:14PM (#32631655)
What is the distribution of total consumption by income range?

Yes, the rich use more water per capita, but there aren't all that many rich people compared to the rest of the population. Does the top 1% of the income distribution use more water (in total) than the bottom 99%?

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by jeffbee on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:57PM (#32629898)
Most California utility districts do have tiered prices, but the first tier is usually pretty large, the marginal prices are really low, and the national press has a tendency to characterize even this mild scheme as "rationing" so people hate it.

As an example, LADWP charges a maximum marginal rate of 17¢/gallon. You can use as much as 650 gallons per day without hitting this rate. The basic rate is 3¢/gallon.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by sillystuff on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:13PM (#32630018)
My water district (in California), sent out mailers a few years ago explaining their new rate structure. They said people were "conserving too much" that the fees were not covering infrastructure maintenance costs. So, they lowered the price of water and set a base fee (charged whether you use any water or not) to $54/mo.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by jeffbee on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:30PM (#32630167)
Well, how do you expect them to fund scale-free costs? I pay $60 water service charge and another $40 wastewater service charge, every other month.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by sillystuff on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:18PM (#32630615)
My original comment didn't make a value judgement on the rate restructuring, but it is true that I think the rate restructure was short-sighted. By lowering the per unit cost of water, they are discouraging conservation. And, the base fee is quite high for even our median wage earning households.

I believe it would have been better to have a lower base fee that does not, alone, cover fixed costs and make up the deficit by higher fees on those with high water consumption by maintaining a high per-unit water charge. The problem with this is that by not fully covering the fixed costs with the base fee, there will be seasonal variability in funding, but basic budgeting would mitigate that. And, GGP's point about such policies dishonestly being framed as, "rationing" by opponents.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by sys_64738 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:36PM (#32630234)
If you've more money then sense then this doesn't work. Restrictors sounds like a win/win for everybody.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by colinmhayes on Sunday August 28, 2022 @11:28PM (#32634503)
The point isn't to stop people from using water. Its to get them to pay for the infrastructure required to increase the water supply so there's enough for everyone.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by lostgame on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:48PM (#32629821)
Uh, that helps nothing. Outside of agriculture, it’s entirely only the rich who are wasting the water (look no farther than the recent example of Kim Kardashian from just this week on this issue) - it’s not like the lower / lower middle class has lawns to waste water on, anyway.

And since the idiots like KK wasting all the water are multi-millionaires or billionaires, of which there are a greater conglomeration of in California then there are in the rest of the states - increasing the price of the water based on more usage won’t change a thing.

Restricting the amount of water used by individuals in general is the only way I can see this working here. But the rich always figure out a way around everything. They always do.

Same issue with the private plane bullshit going on. These people are addicted to an unsustainable lifestyle that allows them to throw money at anyone trying to put restrictions their way.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by nathanaldensr on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:50PM (#32629847)
Correct. Increasing the price actually pushes toward guaranteeing that water is only for wealthy people or companies and therefore not for the poor.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by lotsofpulp on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:58PM (#32629909)
Increased prices result in water being allocated to the most optimal needs.

Marginal water prices mean the price for amount of water needed for a family to bathe and cook and clean costs much less than the amount of water for landscaping around an opulent home.

If people are still too poor, then giving them cash (by taking from richer people) is the solution, not pricing water so low that it gets wasted

Lack of sufficient water and excessive income/wealth gap are two separate problems with separate solutions.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by dredmorbius on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:29PM (#32633898)
"Optimal" is doing a tremendous amount of lifting in your assertion, particularly in a world of grossly-unequal purchasing power. Much conveyed from birth and circumcstance rather than ability, effort, or social value.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by colinmhayes on Sunday August 28, 2022 @11:29PM (#32634508)
Welfare != surplus. Maximizing surplus is rarely the optimal thing to do.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by wkyle on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:13PM (#32630014)
The parent comment suggests a progressively priced system that would presumably allow for cheap consumption of water at small quantities. I think the comments here discarding this idea by claiming price sensitivity doesn't exist for wealthy people are unimaginative.

I'm not totally sold on on the idea, but it is very possible to create a tiered pricing system that makes domestic water waste unsustainably expensive. The price required to deter consumption may be absurdly high, but demand elasticity will always exist at high enough prices.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by throwaway09223 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:05PM (#32629962)
Prices for municipal use don't need to be raised. Municipal use isn't significant anyway, no matter if you're rich or poor.

Prices need to be increased (or, in some cases need to exist) for agricultural use.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by lostgame on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:53PM (#32630381)
Not sure how people don’t get this or why my post was downvoted. Maybe it’s just not a comfortable truth for some people.
Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by kortilla on Sunday August 28, 2022 @04:28PM (#32631757)
It got downvoted because it was uninformed and missed the point.

First, the point was that municipal water usage wouldn’t need and change and could actually decrease in rates if agriculture and industrial paid the same market rate.

Second, if we are talking about lawn watering, that’s absolutely a middle class thing in the vast majority of California.

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by visarga on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:05PM (#32629956)
> But the rich always figure out a way around everything. They always do.

Buy water from their neighbours to hop on their quotas?

Re:The fight against drought in California has a new tool: T... by wkyle on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:19PM (#32630068)
If the intention of this idea is to allocate reasonable consumption to each person at low prices and quickly increase prices beyond that, then I don't think this wouldn't be a bad thing.

Tradeable quotas can be an effective way to protect a common resource.