News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by senectus1 on Saturday August 27, 2022 @09:46PM (#32624988)
It’s the logo of the United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals. And Japan is all in.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by planetsprite on Saturday August 27, 2022 @09:52PM (#32625022)
Those goals being: No poverty, zero hunger, good health and well-being, quality education, gender equality, clean water and sanitation, affordable and clean energy, decent work and economic growth, industry, innovation and infrastructure, Reduced Inequality, Sustainable Cities and Communities, Responsible Consumption and Production, Climate Action, Life Below Water, Life On Land, Peace, Justice, and Strong Institutions, Partnerships for the Goals.

All agreeable prospects, but all too vague and hard to define. They're more a wish-list than goals.

For example, what defines poverty? Wages vs the median, or quality of life factors? What makes work "decent"? What does inequality mean in this context, economic, judicial, racial?

Vague aspirational goals sound nice but are rarely met without considering the real decisions that have to be made to meet them. These things are things everyone wants, but what are we willing to sacrifice to meet them?

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by resoluteteeth on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:08PM (#32625103)
> All agreeable prospects, but all too vague and hard to define. They're more a wish-list than goals.

> For example, what defines poverty? Wages vs the median, or quality of life factors? What makes work "decent"? What does inequality mean in this context, economic, judicial, racial?

They're actually defined in far more detail: https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/content/documents/2125...

(The details of the goals start around half way through)

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by franciscop on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:06PM (#32625092)
Japan consistently ranks the last of the developed countries on gender equality[1], and they kill hundreds of dolphins a year in a frowned-upon manner[2], so are there any specific measures Japan is taking or is it all posturing?

[1] https://www.asahi.com/ajw/articles/14668828

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taiji_dolphin_drive_hunt

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by yongjik on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:35PM (#32625527)
Japan emits 8.5t CO2 per capita (2019), much less than the US (14.7t), though it's still worse than the UK (5.2t) or France (4.5t).
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by oefrha on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:46PM (#32625575)
And they’ve been hovering around that and on a trajectory of slow decrease long before this SDG thing is “suddenly everywhere”, so I doubt SDG has anything to do with it. This vacuous SDG thing sounds like bureaucrats and corporatists finding something to do to justify their jobs. It’s like trying to refactor working code into using abstract class factory factories.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by yongjik on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:55PM (#32625617)
You're probably right about that, but I'm just saying that "They kill dolphins!" is a low-effort remark, when America is doing much more damage to the ocean via CO2 emission.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by franciscop on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:09AM (#32625683)
There are many axis of taking care of the environment, and CO2 emissions is fairly (but not completely) independent from killing dolphins in a cruel way. This unfortunately makes it so that comparing how environmentally friendly one country is from another is very tricky.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by joecool1029 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:24AM (#32626469)
To be fair it's a resource poor (having only modest coal deposits) nation for electricity generation that idled most of their nuclear reactors after Fukushima. That greatly increases their carbon output.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by franciscop on Sunday August 28, 2022 @07:06PM (#32633008)
It's actually renewable-heavy, I don't know the details (which might be important here) but Japan is very rich in wind and water resources, so solar, eolic and hydro could be major players. If only there weren't usual typhoons and floods and earthquakes that could make those nonviable (that's why details might be important).
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by soperj on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:34PM (#32625250)
They're also one of 3 nations still hunting whales. Iceland and Norway are the others.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by pvaldes on Sunday August 28, 2022 @06:46AM (#32627308)
UK also.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by soperj on Sunday August 28, 2022 @01:38PM (#32630253)
is this a wales/whales joke? Everything I can see has the UK abandoning whaling in the 60s.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by pvaldes on Sunday August 28, 2022 @02:48PM (#32630885)
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by grapeskin on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:12AM (#32625694)
Why the random mention of dolphins? The ones being hunted aren’t at risk of extinction.

It’s not as bad as cattle farming, which is straight up destroying the environment in several ways, from clear cutting rainforests to feed them to filling the air with methane.

And dolphin tastes pretty good, too.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by pvaldes on Sunday August 28, 2022 @06:14AM (#32627165)
Eating dolphinidae has proven to cause brain impairment in human children and babies, so will affect the public health, one of the objectives of this thing. Because cetaceans will typically bioaccumulate heavy metals and toxic products in its fat.

> The ones being hunted aren’t at risk of extinction.

Cetaceans travel huge distances so... how much are "too much" dolphins? 1000 dolphins in a bay can seem a lot but, what if is 1000 for the entire Mediterranean?

If a machine comes with 30 screws, you just don't remove 20 screws randomly and expect the machine work as well as before. Is clearly a bad idea. Top predators provide environmental services for free, that are extremely expensive or impossible to replace. When we broke it, is broken for a long, long time, at least the rest of our lives.

Scientists say this since ages. Nobody listen.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by Bakary on Sunday August 28, 2022 @10:30AM (#32628656)
On the contrary, the fact that SDGs became buzzwords is likely tied to the fact that Japan does well or can market itself as doing well in most of these indicators. Obviously gender equality is a glaring problem, but you'll notice they rebranded whaling (and possibly dolphin hunting if we dig into it) as controlling the fish population as per the article. Their systemic issues such as a greying population are not in the SDGs because Japan is essentially a snapshot of what awaits developed economies in the future rather than anything to do with the struggles of development.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by creakingstairs on Saturday August 27, 2022 @11:51PM (#32625598)
I don’t know. The train I take sometimes have SDG wrapping, the ads on TV always mention SDG and the Starbucks have been asking me whether I want my coffee without lid (futa nashi), so they must really care about it /s
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by 0xy on Sunday August 28, 2022 @06:55AM (#32627354)
Worth noting this is "ranked" by the "you will own nothing", "lockdowns are quietly improving cities" World Economic Forum.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by dflock on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:07PM (#32625096)
Those are just the names of the high level goals!

If you go here: https://sdgs.un.org/goals#goals then click on each goal, its expanded in more detail, including implementation targets, of which there are over 150.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by colechristensen on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:09PM (#32625109)
> For example, what defines poverty?

Many, especially governments, have definitions of poverty which are statistical, either percentile or a proportion of median income which makes it either actually impossible (there will always be a bottom n percent) or practically impossible (nobody earning less than half median wages).

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by narrator on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:11PM (#32625115)
They assume all these goals are mutually compatible. I see clean energy and climate action vs. everything else. Look at Sri Lanka for example.

https://foreignpolicy.com/2022/03/05/sri-lanka-organic-farmi...

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by JKCalhoun on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:17AM (#32628168)
> For example, what defines poverty?

I think we can all agree that homelessness is a problem we should address. If we could somehow tackle that one our country would be in a better place.

No need to kill the idea because we can't precisely describe what the definition is.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by immibis on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:23AM (#32628212)
We can't even seem to agree on that. Many people - perhaps the majority - believe that homelessness is a deserved punishment for laziness etc.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by lioeters on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:43AM (#32628334)
I won't be surprised if those in the upper/ruling class considers maintaining a certain level of homelessness and unemployment as appropriate motivation to keep the working class in line.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by immibis on Sunday August 28, 2022 @05:20PM (#32632169)
Not sure about "the ruling class", but it's necessary for our economic system to work, yes.

Look at the central bank inflation/unemployment dilemma.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by JKCalhoun on Sunday August 28, 2022 @10:15AM (#32628545)
That would seem ill advised. Having the whole cake should make you worry a bit about a growing population of people with nothing to lose.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by JKCalhoun on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:28AM (#32628233)
Wow.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by fezfight on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:03PM (#32625080)
Aim for best possible outcomes in each category, and be satisfied failing but pushing the overton window up.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by drewcoo on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:31PM (#32625232)
> All agreeable prospects

Complete gender equality but otherwise only reduced inequality? I find that disagreeable.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by deepsun on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:33PM (#32625243)
And also whales. They eat them. And these goals say to eat more, to save the fish.

PS: I'm not even sure whales eat fish that much. Either plankton or squid.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by zzzeek on Saturday August 27, 2022 @10:21PM (#32625172)
for evidence that this is mostly bullshit, look no further than bizarre things like this:

> Whales, the argument goes, consume a ruinous quantity of fish, and controlling their population is critical for preserving the oceans’ diversity. An online video from an industry association recommends eating the mammals “to protect the balance of the marine ecosystem and contribute to marine S.D.G.s!”

It is fascinating that whales have found a way to be both an endangered species, and an overpopulated ocean scourge (as an apex predator, no less) at the same time!

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by freetime2 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @12:23AM (#32625752)
While I agree that is a fairly comical quote, I also think it’s an oversimplification to say that whales are “an endangered species”. There are many different species of whale, some of which are endangered and some are not. The humpback whale, for example, is no longer listed as endangered as of 2022.
Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by pvaldes on Sunday August 28, 2022 @06:44AM (#32627291)
Less than 500 North Pacific right whales remain in the planet, only 30 of them visit Alaska, and the rest live mostly around the Japanese sea.

Spreading the idea that endangered animals eat "too much" is evil. Rotten to the core.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by freetime2 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @07:17AM (#32627447)
I don’t think that’s relevant to the discussion here, because Japan does not hunt Right whales. Japan’s fishing ministry only allows hunting of Minke, Bryde’s, and Sei whales [1] - and in limited numbers which would not endanger the overall population of those species.

[1] https://us.whales.org/our-4-goals/stop-whaling/whaling-in-ja...

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by zzzeek on Sunday August 28, 2022 @11:05AM (#32628943)
> The humpback whale, for example, is no longer listed as endangered as of 2022.

I see, so , humpback whale population has just crossed the line of no longer being an endangered species, *this year*. So did they overnight become an environmental pest that is decimating the fish population? I am going to guess you would say no. So I don't think your comment is relevant to the actual point being made. If OTOH you are just applying some factual editing so that my amazing comment can be printed in a newspaper, let's clean up that language sure!

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by freetime2 on Sunday August 28, 2022 @03:45PM (#32631408)
I was just pointing out what I think is a major flaw in your logic. I think it’s entirely possible to have some stocks of whale which are endangered, and other stocks of whale that are not endangered and are eating large amounts of fish and krill.

Do I think that whales are decimating fish populations? Probably not, but I would need to see some data to say with any degree of certainty. And again, this is something you would need to look at in terms of local whale stocks and fisheries vs. just looking at all whales as a whole.

> So I don't think your comment is relevant to the actual point being made. If OTOH you are just applying some factual editing so that my amazing comment can be printed in a newspaper, let's clean up that language sure!

I think it is relevant to point out flawed logic or overly simplistic thinking in pretty much any discussion - regardless of whether or not it will be printed in a newspaper.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by zzzeek on Sunday August 28, 2022 @11:33PM (#32634536)
> I was just pointing out what I think is a major flaw in your logic. I think it’s entirely possible to have some stocks of whale which are endangered, and other stocks of whale that are not endangered and are eating large amounts of fish and krill.

OK see this is where you are wasting everyone's time. Japanese whaling fleets are targeting those exact whale populations that *are* endangered. Most of the international community opposes their practices and there are many international protections on various whale species that the Japanese whalers simply ignore. pointing out "flaws" in what random people are saying about some random NYT article that mentions it is irrelevant to understanding what is actually going in the world, things that are true and actually happening that you can confirm (or whatever you feel like) on your own, see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whaling_in_Japan.

> Do I think that whales are decimating fish populations? Probably not, but I would need to see some data to say with any degree of certainty. And again, this is something you would need to look at in terms of local whale stocks and fisheries vs. just looking at all whales as a whole.

your time then would be better spent *researching that* instead of wasting it nitpicking people. If I make a comment here, my audience are those people interested in making good faith interpretations. Sitting back and saying "hmmm, what if whales DO actually eat too much fish, and maybe the Japanese are only hunting whales that are not endangered? Here's one that's stopped being endangered for 8 months! ah HA! a flaw!" that's what we call a "bad faith" interpretation. it's non-constructive and reveals you aren't really very curious about the actual issue. I am not very interested in word games myself.

> I think it is relevant to point out flawed logic or overly simplistic thinking in pretty much any discussion - regardless of whether or not it will be printed in a newspaper.

The argument made by Japanese whalers in that quote is clearly idiotic, which you can confirm through a little bit of googling, where you would then know more about the subject. Correcting people who are failing to convince you of something due to small inaccuracies in their language OTOH fails to teach you anything new at all.

Put another way. an actual rebuttal to my comment would be, "I'm a marine biologist, and here are whale species X, Y and Z that are not endangered at all, to which the ecosystem is now being improved thanks to the Japanese whaling industry wiping out a third of them, and here's why the vast majority of the international oceanic community is wrong on this issue in their opposition to Japan's killing fleets". That would be some argument for sure, since it doesnt exist, but if one did, would at least be an informed comment that's valuable to the discussion.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by freetime2 on Monday August 29, 2022 @12:05AM (#32634701)
You say:

> Japanese whaling fleets are targeting those exact whale populations that are endangered.

But the wikipedia article you linked basically says the exact opposite - that Antarctic Minke whales are not designated as threatened:

> Their objective is to hunt 3,000 Antarctic minke whales over 10 years, starting with 330 whales during the 2015–16 season.[citation needed] Antarctic minke whales have experienced an apparent decline in population, though the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) indicates that it lacks sufficient data to confer a threatened designation on the species of minke whale.

It also says:

> The 1985 IWC estimate put the Southern Hemisphere minke whale population at 761,000 (510,000–1,140,000 in the 95% confidence estimate).[179] A paper submitted to the IWC on population estimates in Antarctic waters using CNB gives a population of 665,074 based on Southern Ocean Whale and Ecosystem Research Programme (SOWER) data.[180]

So Japan is planning to kill about 300 Minke whales a year out of a population of 500,000 or so (using the lowest estimates from the wikipedia page). That’s about 0.06% of the population per year, which definitely does not seem like enough threaten the survival of the species.

With regards to:

> Correcting people who are failing to convince you of something due to small inaccuracies in their language OTOH fails to teach you anything new at all

In my opinion the inaccuracies in your comments thus far go far beyond mere "language" issues. I don't think any amount of careful rewording would fix them. These are factual and logical misunderstandings that are core to the very point you are trying to make.

I also believe that I am acting in good faith by engaging with the things you have written so far and browsing the article that you have linked. If you have more evidence that you would like to cite to support your views (ideally something a bit more specific than telling me to "research it" on my own - citing the fact and then providing a link to the source is the generally accepted standard), I would be happy to have a look.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by zzzeek on Monday August 29, 2022 @01:44PM (#32641161)
first off there are many examples in that article of currently endangered whale species still being killed by Japanese whalers. I did not say anything about "Minke" whales specifically. Per the article, killing of endangered species continues:

> Japan kept official hunts of endangered species such as North Pacific right whales until 1994,[141] but intentional by-catches of endangered still continue to present in unknown scales.

Secondly, the actual point is that Japanese whalers claim existing whale populations are bad for the environment because such populations are too large, which is ridiculous, given the endangered, recently endangered, or nearly endangered status of most of the whale species they have targeted, not to mention apex predators are not prone to overpopulation since they rely on lower levels of the food chain to survive. It does not matter which species are currently endangered and which are not. It is not my burden to disprove a made up fact.

> So Japan is planning to kill about 300 Minke whales a year out of a population of 500,000 or so (using the lowest estimates from the wikipedia page). That’s about 0.06% of the population per year, which definitely does not seem like enough threaten the survival of the species.

nor would it therefore have any impact on reducing overconsumption of other fish species, which is their actual claim, if in fact their population reduction across all whale species is extremely low.

> In my opinion the inaccuracies in your comments thus far go far beyond mere "language" issues. I don't think any amount of careful rewording would fix them. These are factual and logical misunderstandings that are core to the very point you are trying to make.

you are clearly very skilled at language which makes it all the more clear that your continued intentional misunderstanding of a point I was making is not constructive.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by freetime2 on Monday August 29, 2022 @05:12PM (#32643610)
Previously you said:

> Japanese whaling fleets are targeting those exact whale populations that are endangered

And the evidence you have cited was this line from a wikipedia article:

> Japan kept official hunts of endangered species such as North Pacific right whales until 1994,[141] but intentional by-catches of endangered still continue to present in unknown scales.

There are a number of different issues here:

> Japan kept official hunts of endangered species such as North Pacific right whales until 1994 ,[141]

This ended nearly 30 years ago, so I will ignore as it is not relevant to the discussion of what Japan is currently doing. (That citation from the wikipedia article is also completely bogus - if you visit the link you will find an article written in 1818 (!) that has been translated to Chinese. So definitely not about modern Japanese whaling.)

> intentional by-catches of endangered still continue to present in unknown scales

Issues here are:

* No citation given in the wikipedia article

* Saying it happens in “unknown scales” provides no indication of the size of the problem. Is is 1 per year or 1000?

* “intentional” appears to be a typo here. “By-catch” by definition means the unintentional capture of non-targeted species.

So to recap - you made a claim earlier that Japanese are targeting endangered species. And then as justification you referenced an improperly cited claim about something that ended 30 years ago, and an un-cited claim about by-catches - which is very much not the same thing as targeting endangered species. There is absolutely nothing here to justify your claim.

By the way, I do think that by-catch is a real issue that is estimated to kill 300,000 cetaceans every year [1]. So many orders of magnitude more impactful than Japanese whaling. But it is a global issue inherent to commercial fishing rather than an issue with Japanese fishing in particular.

> It is not my burden to disprove a made up fact.

I’ll remind you that this whole thread started precisely because you did attempt to disprove this claim. If your position is simply that “This seems like an unlikely claim, but I have no evidence to disprove it” - then that’s perfectly reasonable. But based on the arguments and evidence you have put forth so far, any degree of confidence in your opinion beyond that is completely unjustified.

And finally, I would just like to point out one more inaccuracy in your most recent comment for good measure:

> not to mention apex predators are not prone to overpopulation since they rely on lower levels of the food chain to survive

Baleen whales (which are the types that are targeted by Japanese whalers) are not considered apex predators since they feed primarily on krill and smaller fish. So basically they are competing with fish for the same food source.

[1] https://iwc.int/bycatch

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by JKCalhoun on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:14AM (#32628154)
The last time I felt the U.S. as a country had a goal that was outward looking, forward looking was when we were adopting the Metric System back in the early 70's when I was in elementary school.

Good times.

Re:Why is this colorful little wheel suddenly everywhere in ... by selimthegrim on Sunday August 28, 2022 @09:21AM (#32628199)