It's a store for hackers; it's not meant to be a consumer shop. I think they even warn you to not buy if you expect returns or customer service.
I do not understand why somebody would do such a thing consciously. We have the situation that somebody wants to distribute the hardware at cost for development. And a big group of people who want exactly this deal. Why is there a need on a personal level to basically sabotage this? Or what am i missing that doesnt make this behavior really dickish?
edit: And again, i am not talking about people who misunderstood what exactly was offered here. That absolutly shouldnt happen. I just dont understand why somebody would do this consciously.
edit: again, not defending their packaging skills here.
Ultimately "YOU CAN'T DO THAT" just doesn't mean you CAN do that as long as the letters are big enough bold enough or red enough. It means YOU CAN'T DO THAT.
You cannot offer goods that don't work on a website where you anticipate people paying with their paycal mastercard visa or amex and expect them not to exercise terms that must exist by law because the alternative to someone doing the easy thing and yoinking their money relatively cheaply back over the wire isn't the incompetent OEM keeping the money its waiting for a very expensive lawsuit wherein the customer takes back not only their $99 but the $5000 it cost them to collect their $99. If enough people do that ultimately they ruin you and people come to take all your tinker toys and auction them to pay your debts.
The actual alternative is to have an actual signed contract with prospective "developers" for access to equipment. There isn't a blurb you can put on a website that will serve.
But these issues only occur at scale. As long as PinePhone is able to keep their zero-guarantees model under the radar, maybe it's fine
That's worth nothing.
> it's not meant to be a consumer shop. I think they even warn you to not buy if you expect returns or customer service.
Reminds me of: https://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2004/03/24/the-adventures...
"Wow! I didn't know you could even do that."
It’s the kind of place you can maybe talk to an actual human.
It’s not the kind of place where you break your Credit Card Merchant’s rules and refuse refunds on items poorly packaged and broken on arrival.
After reading OP’s comment, I will never be ordering from this company, and I was highly considering it.
But in a philosophical and aesthetic sense, if you can't fix the screen yourself, you might not be the target audience for this product.
A decent comparison would be wild, ad-hoc music festivals or raves. Nobody deserves to have painful experiences, and such experiences certainly do not have to be a fundamental part of these events. Nor should people be shamed for complaining after the fact. That said, it's also true that you have to approach these things with a certain mindset that's conducive to making the most of it. The comments I'm seeing here don't reflect that, even if I don't disagree with their arguments regarding commercial responsibility.
These devices are sold close to cost price. Ethically the disclaimer still makes sense even if shipping killed your screen and not manufacturing.
Although I'm surprised it's not possible to get the shipping company to foot the bill.
If you stuck to "didn't you agree with that policy" perspective, you'd never get in a car, on a plane, or buy anything.
What is a lot harder, and needs additional information about the motivation, is why somebody would consciously engage into this interaction and then demand it to be a different format. Because then it becomes a task of filtering out motivated people.
If i personally send you a prototype at cost and you demand it to be treated like a normal customer interaction the result will be that i wont be sending out prototypes at cost to just anyone any longer. Thats quite the bummer for people who wanted one.
So the question is how can we connect group A (manufacturer) and B(eager testers) without group C(Consumers) getting caught in the whole thing?
edit: Not saying what Pine is doing is good or bad, but the core problem isnt specific to Pine and many tinkerers might end up in this situation one day. And charging above cost is extremely counterproductive in some situations because it locks out some developers.
If you genuinely want people to be prototype/beta testers, give them the phone for free and then ask for it back at the end of the beta period. But the transaction occurring here is, fundamentally, a consumer transaction no matter what Pine wants to call it, and that comes with certain responsibilities which cannot be disclaimed, period.
I confused why somebody would claim them despite knowing that the only reason they can get a device in the first place is because they are ordering something that is not meant to be ordered by consumers. They arent priced in. You used a mechanism and involved yourself into an interaction you werent supposed to be in. Because the fix for the problem at hand is no longer allowing just anyone to get a devkit. Because the whole point is to get the device to developers as cheap as possible.
edit: Or differently put, the problem here isnt that OP got damaged hardware but that he ended up in an interaction he wasnt supposed to be in. And keeping people from accidentally ending up in there is one problem you can work on, but what motivates people to do this consciously?
They ship it from Hong Kong with no packaging foam, so it arrived with a broken screen. I contacted them about it and they gave me some trouble shooting things which didn't work and then told me I could pay to ship it to their service center, even though it shipped to me broken. They referred me to their return policy which at the time basically says the buyer assumes risk for the product if they ship it broken (which is a violation of Visa and Mastercard's seller's terms of service)
I then had to fight them for months to get my chargeback, the whole time they were threatening me in childish ways and only after I won (because obviously, I don't know why they thought they had a chance) did they politely offer to pay for a return label.
Horribly run company, if you order from them be sure to use a credit card or something with a chargeback capability