News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by postalrat on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @08:45PM (#32573621)
Eventually this and similar technology will be able to generate unlimited porn of all types. Including CP. Should or even could it be made illegal?

To me that kinda feels like if it was made illegal then you are basically acting as the thought police.

Edit: are people just uncomfortable talking about this or do they think downvoting is going to somehow prevent it?

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by nikkwong on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:24PM (#32574636)
The question of whether or not machine generated CP is ethical or not is a confusing one to me, since the crux of problem of CP is that it's violating the rights of a child. If you get rid of that fact, CP becomes a 'victimless crime', in a sense, and it becomes hard to pinpoint what the actual perpetration is. (Ignoring the fact that a CP model has to be trained on real images, which destroys this argument outright, for now).

Nobody wants to be a pedophile, but if you are unfortunately hardwired that way the impulses are impossible to ignore—similar to any other sexual impulse that 'healthy' adults have.

I think the goal is how to create the least amount of harm for children, and it's theoretically interesting to consider the possibility that machine generated CP could be used to ultimately end the real-life CP black market.

I'm sure this won't ever happen because nobody wants to touch this subject with a 10-foot pole; and our species tends to favor solutions that are idealistic rather than rational in many ways. But the European approach to criminal justice is something like: "humans are not perfect, and we can't fix them, so let's try to engineer solutions which make living together more pleasant". Nobody likes an icky solution like this, but the alternative is a lot of children suffering (although I'm not saying those two options are perfectly substitutable).

On the other hand, it could be a completely stupid idea outright. Just an interesting thing to think about.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Alex7845 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:31PM (#32574681)
>(Ignoring the fact that a CP model has to be trained on real images).

that's not how this tech works.

Did you think actual guinea pigs had to be trained to do household chores for these pictures to be generated? (dailywrong.com/new-course-teaches-guinea-pigs-household-chores/)

I had a lot of fun creating pictures of llamas in space. I'm pretty sure no llamas have ever walked on the moon.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by nikkwong on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:36PM (#32574713)
I think it is how the tech works; though. The model knows what a guinea pig looks like, and it knows what household chores looks like, so it can concatenate the two. I don't think the model knows how children look like unclothed, and I don't think it can posit that by looking at nude human adults. But I could be very incorrect there; and these techniques will certainly evolve over time.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Alex7845 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:46PM (#32574759)
I think generating CP with AI would be 10000x easier than most of what I have personally made with with dall-e.

creating a llama wearing a space suit and walking on the moon is a lot harder than filling out the very limited amount of skin hidden by a swimming suit.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by mc32 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:34PM (#32574703)
Question is does it reduce demand from the real world or does it serve as demand multiplier in the real physical world?
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by nikkwong on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:44PM (#32574750)
I think these are the right questions to ask; and these types of things would need to be studied in order to pose a potential solution. But I can't imagine any modern day institution beginning to pose these questions without facing public outlash. The sensationalized headlines that would spin out of this would probably stop any research in this area in its tracks.

In that way our species is very primitive. We're trigger happy in our outrage and often unable to focus on a larger shared goal, much to our own demise.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by mc32 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:50PM (#32574779)
We can study near-like issues to get a hint of the phycological effects.

Have people into bestiality to play in their VR worlds and see if it suffocates demand or increases demand and we see spillover into the real world. (find a jurisdiction where the above is tolerated)

Maybe Thailand can produce some data given their apparent tolerance for certain behaviors.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Viliam1234 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:09PM (#32584286)
I think the research shows that availability of normal porn reduces rape. (Don't have a link at hand, sorry.) So I would guess the effect would probably be the same here.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by mc32 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @04:34PM (#32585373)
It's the age-old dilemma: is it a safety valve or a gateway to worse things?
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by numpad0 on Thursday August 25, 2022 @02:10AM (#32590171)
But what exactly are those worse things?
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by wraptile on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:44AM (#32575095)
It's not entirely a new issue, see the discussions around "loli erotic japanese manga" etc. Though I agree with you, nobody is touching this tech anytime soon (at least publically) even though you can easily imagine safe applications like MRI with AI generated images to study exact brain patterns for potential treatments and so on.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by girvo on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:30PM (#32574677)
I don’t think you can ignore the fact that the model would have to be trained on child sexual abuse material, though. That’s pretty important.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by nikkwong on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:49PM (#32574776)
I view that currently as a technical limitation that will likely be lifted as the technology progresses. Our species has been hard at work on the field of AI-image generation for only a decade, and we have thousands of years to go. So I would posit that this barrier is probably a short-term one.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by girvo on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:51PM (#32574785)
I agree. But what do we do about the models that are trained on CSAM prior to this inevitable breakthrough? Because you and I both know it’s likely to happen.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by bhedgeoser on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:16PM (#32582595)
What about writing a blog post about raping and killing people. We have to draw the line somewhere and for CP the line is at the first step.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by ignoramous on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @08:57PM (#32573719)
Unfortunately, don't think folks watching CP would stop at that. Porn is an addiction (or compulsion?) and I don't see how CP makes it any better for folks with pedophilic tendencies.

To think that porn reduces sexual tendencies may be true (in the short to mid term), but eventually, as the addiction intensifies, those hooked have the urge to seek more novel, more aggressive versions of it (in reel or for real).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Effects_of_pornography#Sexual_...

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by version_five on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:50PM (#32574427)
Otoh, I have read articles worrying that young men aren't going out looking to meet women like they used to, because they are satisfying their desires though porn.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by deepdriver on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:10PM (#32574545)
Not at all contradictory. Opioid addicts need higher and higher doses for their fix. In the worst case they too drop out of society, committing crimes such as theft and prostitution to service their addiction.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Viliam1234 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:36PM (#32584659)
I agree that people addicted to porn want more porn. The question is whether they also want more real-life sex, or less real-life sex. It seems weird to have simultaneously a moral panic about both options.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by hoseja on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @04:13AM (#32576274)
Oh no the engine of society is losing fuel to burn through, how awful. How will the necrarchy ever afford their servants if the subjects have dodged the exploitation of their reproductive urge.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by orestarod on Thursday August 25, 2022 @06:53AM (#32592023)
If you fear your reproductive urge is being exploited, I think eradicating the exploitators is a better course of action than withholding having children. There are better reasons not to have children than using it as a way to harm your overlords.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by psyc on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:47PM (#32574076)
Add reefer into the mix, and you've got a recipe for madness.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Throwaway556655 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:25PM (#32574284)
I don't know if you're being sarcastic here or not, but I've mixed porn with stimulants and the result is definitely pretty. I've went through 16-hour masturbation sessions and have done things I would havje never imagined. The thoughts still haunt me. Porn addiction is not a joke.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by whiddershins on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:33PM (#32574333)
It is a terrible idea to compare pedophilia to drug use.

One might be a victimless crime.

The other never can be.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by johnny22 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:00PM (#32574488)
perhaps it was just in response to the second part

> To think that porn reduces sexual tendencies may be true (in the short to mid term), but eventually, as the addiction intensifies, those hooked have the urge to seek more novel, more aggressive versions of it (in reel or for real).

and if so, it's a joke about the reefer madness movie and moral panic

[dead]
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by dang on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:08PM (#32582474)
Would you mind reviewing the site guidelines at https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html? You broke quite a few of them here—especially this one:

"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith."

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by 8f2ab37a-ed6c on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:39AM (#32575070)
Is that any different from the argument about violent videogames back in the day? Or Dungeons & Dragons before that?
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by komali2 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:13PM (#32573854)
I wish people would explain why they're downvoting these ethics-related comments so aggressively, because I'm interested in these conversations and not sure why other users find them irrelevant.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by dang on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:00PM (#32582350)
The guidelines specifically ask you not to post like this: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html. It's completely off-topic and, what's worse, repetitive.

It's frustrating not to be able to know why someone downvoted a comment, but it's the nature of the beast. Sometimes people think we should require explanations, but you can't change the way people are by demanding they jump through a hoop.

If you see unfairly downvoted comments, give them a corrective upvote (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...). Other users will hopefully do that too.

A lot of the time, that happens and then posts like this end up as uncollected garbage in the thread, complaining about something that doesn't exist anymore.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by ignoramous on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @03:49PM (#32584808)
I've personally noticed that the collective upvotes start right after someone posts "why downvote" rant like gp did.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by dang on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @04:41PM (#32585451)
Yes, I'm sure that's a thing too.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by noduerme on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:55PM (#32574127)
I think it demonstrates why it's so easy for technology to run ahead of ethics. No one wants to hear a public safety announcement when they get the keys to a new car.

OTOH, I think the risk of CSAM from this kind of thing is overblown, because either (1) it wouldn't actually involve real children in any way, or (2) the model would have to be train on actual CSAM, which there are already laws against.

If no humans are harmed by it at any stage, then how's it any different from the CGI murders all over movies and TV? In the absence of harm, the only reason to consider it a crime is that it's disgusting. But we don't prosecute people for having sick thoughts, just for acting on them. If you take the child and abuse out of the equation, the only argument left is that seeing CSAM (artificial or not) is a "gateway drug" to commiting child abuse. If that's the case then why shouldn't we prosecute people for watching Dexter, on the grounds that they're on their way to becoming serial killers?

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by kbenson on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:18PM (#32574602)
> If no humans are harmed by it at any stage, then how's it any different from the CGI murders all over movies and TV? In the absence of harm, the only reason to consider it a crime is that it's disgusting. But we don't prosecute people for having sick thoughts, just for acting on them.

You say that, but created from scratch drawn material is illegal in some countries. What you've stated is a nice ideal but often doesn't match reality, and I'm on the fence as to whether that's a necessarily a bad thing in this case (I'm not sure we really know enough about sexual drive and how it interacts with the subconscious to know whether it's actually benign or has a societal cost).

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by varajelle on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:31AM (#32575013)
> You say that, but created from scratch drawn material is illegal in some countries.

Homosexuality is illegal in some countries.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by kbenson on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @10:54AM (#32580241)
My point was the last sentence of what I quoted doesn't quite match reality. We do prosecute people for sick thoughts in some of these cases, regardless of whether we should.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by noduerme on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @05:14AM (#32576809)
Well... just because some countries prosecute drawings (or homosexuality... or homosexual drawings) doesn't mean there's any logic behind it. There can be enormous, totally illogical public will whipped up in favor of banning all sorts of things people consider abnormal. We can definitely have that discussion, as to what thoughts or creativity cross the boundary to criminal behavior, because likely at least some of them toe the line. But let's at least acknowledge the gradient of criminality between crimes with victims and those without, and not muddy the waters by pretending that every victimless crime is a stand-in or call to arms for a violent one. That way lies totalitarianism. Let's call it what it is when we want to jail people for having sick ideas - or for creating disgusting art: it's persecuting bad aesthetic choices. It's Thoughtcrime. Either this actually harms humans (crime) or not. Either it leads to a crime (prosecutable) or doesn't. The rest is in the realm of policing people's minds, or the future. And while some countries do that, they tend to be places people who have unique ideas to contribute don't want to live, because that type of control is never limited to one particular type of image or another, but mainly serves as an excuse for imprisoning political enemies. Those countries end up poorly because they shoot themselves in the foot by driving away anyone who might paint edgy art or say things like the earth revolves around the sun, or that God doesn't exist, for example. I'm not saying a society can't make the choice to prosecute thoughtcrime, I'm just saying it's a bad idea. And it's especially bad to mix it up with prosecuting real crime, because criminalizing thought is the onramp to the corruption that lets neighbors turn on each other, everyone bribe the police to arrest their petty enemies, and brings societies down. CSAM is an actual evil, one of the most evil things on earth. Using that fact to prosecute people for drawings or offensive speech or thought (since there is no limit to what can be found offensive - even this conversation is criminal somewhere!) is really cynical and purely for power, if you think about it.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by kbenson on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:36AM (#32580805)
My main point was to note that regardless of reason, we do seem to punish thoughts in some cases, so the last part of the statement I quoted doesn't quite match with reality.

The second part of my comment was more along the lines as to whether exposure to material such as this (material depicting children sexually) affects desire for material such as this, or behavior, for those that already desire it and/or have urges along those lines. I don't know the answer to that, and so an unwilling to make a blanket statement that it should or should not be allowed. There are plenty of things we restrict as a society through our government because we think it's bad for the whole. Sometimes there's little real reason for that, sometimes there is, and thus I'm on the fence until I know more.

My layman's understanding is that some aspects of sexuality are not well defined until puberty and what you're exposed to at that time, and then those are fairly fixed for life. If that's true, there are aspects to consider beyond an individual's desire, and a nuanced informed decision is worthwhile. It's possible the right answer here is not just "freedom of speech and expression" nor "protect the children", but a middle path with the most benefits and least drawbacks.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by fragmede on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:39PM (#32574014)
I'd bet that downvoting is a kneejerk response to the claim "porn is an addiction".
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by moomoo11 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:52PM (#32574102)
Anything can be addiction. Hell I got addicted to weed. At first for years it was fine but then I got into some rough patches when the pandemic started and I was blazed all day every day. It was a temporary escape where I could still do my job but beyond that I had zero motivation for months besides getting more weed.

Took months to kick the habit, completely.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by pnt12 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @11:21AM (#32580585)
Is it knee-jerk?

Alcoholism is pretty serious, but you wouldn't say "beer is an addiction". Same with video game addiction and many other things.

I find it a pretty prude generalization: it's a catch phrase for people who get offended by sex.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by pid-1 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:22PM (#32573908)
Developers like pretending technology is always good and/or inevitable, I think this sort of question is uncomfortable to many folks.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by dang on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:00PM (#32582341)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32573719.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by dragonwriter on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:39PM (#32574012)
The GP comment made largely unsupported fact claims, rather than ethical ones.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by psyc on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @09:50PM (#32574095)
Ethics? Please. It's moral panic. The putatively ethical folks having a "harmless" academic discussion about which nice things everybody is or isn't allowed to have, according to them.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Throwaway556655 on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:28PM (#32574295)
Now it's clear to me you're not being sarcastic. It's not about morals, I'm all in for you to have access to as much porn as you want, as long it's legal. If that's healthy or not for your mind, that's an entirely different story.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by psyc on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @01:46AM (#32575352)
I don't trust you concerned "we live in a society" types any further than I can throw yous.

(This is tongue in cheek. I'm not upset.)

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by int_19h on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @10:30PM (#32574310)
Many countries already ban painted or rendered CP.

US did that for a few years, as well, until the Supreme Court struck it down: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ashcroft_v._Free_Speech_Coalit...

So as far as the output goes, there's already some kind of precedent in most countries. Or are you asking about the model that performs the generation?

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by mgdlbp on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @06:38AM (#32577509)
What? That's about things that _aren't pornography_.

US convicted for written obscenity just in 2013: https://www.techdirt.com/2013/05/20/court-finds-fantasy-stor...

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by int_19h on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @04:04PM (#32585030)
The Miller test applies to all pornography, not just CP. If you look around, you can find federal cases about "transportation of obscene matters" for adult stuff, e.g.:

https://www.networkworld.com/article/2276921/porn-producer-s...

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by goolz on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:12AM (#32574900)
I’ll bite. The issue is it will take all of 5 seconds for an enterprising CP producer/admin/consumer to mix AI content into their stash and then claim they’re being persecuted when the feds come knocking.

It’s like lolicon, sure, you can sit there and pretend it’s a 2000 year old demon warrior… but she is still dressed, posed and drawn to mimic a small child.

Don’t get me wrong, it’s a conundrum, that’s for sure. I hate the idea of the thought police. I love free speech. But in the end, I believe any material, whether it is “art” or computer generated, should be barred if it contains images that can be construed as a child in a sexual act (ancient art gets a pass?). Lolicon does not stop pedophiles from being pedophiles. Nor would this. It would simply act as a gateway and a scapegoat imho.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by rpigab on Friday August 26, 2022 @09:40AM (#32607376)
There's prolly gonna be a big controversy when pedos start using it that way and proof is posted on mainstream websites. I've just discovered lexica.art and I love all picture generator AI tools, but when stumbling upon some pictures of young Emma Watson topless, it didn't seem ok, and reading the prompt for these images showed that the user didn't go for tags like "young" or "topless", it's just StableDiffusion randomly selecting these features, maybe because there's wierd content about Emma Watson online on shady sites, maybe something else.

I'm not sure I want all of them to close access to these tools, stop providing open source capabilities, or prevent specific keywords like Dall-E does, but it's the easy solution for providers. This is why we can't have nice things (there's so many interesting, funny and beautiful things that aren't illegal or even controversial but that are blocked as side-effects of Dall-E's restrictions).

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by schuke on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:50PM (#32574780)
This would be extremely controversial but I remember The Economist mentioned porn for pedophiles as part of the solution (the premise being it's a genetic condition that criminalization doesn't work very well against). AI generation would remove some the moral issues.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by anigbrowl on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:48PM (#32574772)
That will definitely happen; I suspect the criminal offense will be adjusted toward making distribution illegal, but possession might be tolerated (in some societies) if an artificial origin can credibly be established.

It's very hard to predict how this will shake out. I personally doubt that looking at extreme/contraband porn is a good strategy for coping with highly illegal desires but obsessive behaviors aren't something that's easy to model reliably. Considering that weaponizing false claims of predatory behavior as a coercive social/political tactic is a big thing at the moment, you probably shouldn't hold your breath hoping for any sort of consensus to emerge in the short term.

Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by Beltalowda on Tuesday August 23, 2022 @11:08PM (#32574537)
Watching CP tends to reinforce paedophilic tendencies. Many folks seem to "common sense assume" that it's a safe outlet and it would be nice if that were true, but it's not.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by radu_floricica on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @12:00AM (#32574827)
The problem is that you can find common sense arguments both ways. It's just civilization inadequacy that we aren't capable to work on finding objective arguments here, because it doesn't seem like a particularly difficult problem. But yet again, politics is the mind killer.
Re:Show HN: Pornpen.ai – AI-Generated Porn by throwaway675309 on Friday August 26, 2022 @02:50AM (#32604066)
I hear this repeated verbatim a lot as if it were objectively true, along with the idea that watching porn in general is psychologically unhealthy, but I have yet to see any legitimate peer reviewed studies to corroborate either of these positions.