News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by objclxt on Sunday August 21, 2022 @12:23PM (#32541677)
> As such, it seems like there should be some kind of legal obligation to keep it public.

The challenge here is royalties. You have to pay people royalties for broadcasting their work. You could take the position that publicly funded media should be in the public domain, but then it's going to cost considerably more because you'll have to compensate people for the royalties they won't receive.

> I might be wrong in this particular case though — maybe the public funding was always indirect, through the broadcasters?

Yes, Sesame Street wasn't commissioned by PBS, it was originated by the Children's Television Workshop which was funded via grants (some from the state, but mainly by non-profits like the Carnegie Corporation). And originally it aired on the precursor to PBS (National Educational Television), which was funded by the Ford Foundation.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by umeshunni on Sunday August 21, 2022 @04:59PM (#32544381)
> You have to pay people royalties for broadcasting their work.

Might be a dumb question - but is this a contractual thing? Why do people still need to get royalties for broadcasts of something made 40 years ago vs just paying them for it back then?

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by ghaff on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:17PM (#32544541)
>is this a contractual thing

Yes. In general the content owners (less often so actors, screenwriters, etc.) work on a combination of upfront fees and royalties. This is true of book authors as well who typically get an advance against royalties. Purchasers generally won't pay a fee commensurate with "if this is a big hit" so the content owners are willing to accept a smaller fee in exchange for a cut of the big hit proceeds--even if those often don't come about.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by smelendez on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:18PM (#32544545)
It’s similar to startups paying in stock and options. It allows for more speculative projects since the upfront cost is lower.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by fncypants on Sunday August 21, 2022 @07:44PM (#32545657)
Yes, it's contractual because of copyright. If someone (and many parties in the process) created it back then, there is a web of copyrights that require royalties to the creators. Contracts would control who this obligation is owed to (if anyone) years later.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by shalmanese on Sunday August 21, 2022 @11:31PM (#32547004)
What? It has nothing to do with copyright. It's a provision negotiated by unions for the benefit of members which means you can't employ anyone in certain unions without a minimum royalty schedule.

Notably, live action productions covered under SAG-AFTRA and WGA get residuals while animated works under IATSE did not until very recently.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by anotherman554 on Monday August 22, 2022 @08:15AM (#32550278)
Copyright law does not require royalties to anyone. People can negotiate for royalties or not negotiate for royalties.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by pirate787 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:07PM (#32542157)
Nonprofit funding is, in significant measure, a form of public funding as the organization's income is not taxed and its donors receive a tax deduction.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by dwighttk on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:16PM (#32542247)
If the public wants that credit, tax ‘em and pay for the programs. Otherwise I’ll give you the government didn’t discourage the effort.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by IncRnd on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:04PM (#32544424)
By that logic, your posting uses public funds. The government could have taxed your comments, but they didn't.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by MichaelCollins on Sunday August 21, 2022 @02:19PM (#32542890)
By that logic, a pack of cigarettes taxed at 500% is "publicly funded" because it could have been taxed at 1000%.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by nwah1 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @04:45PM (#32544220)
There is no functional difference between a tax break and a subsidy. And everything is private property only if a sovereign authority says it is. Much of it is not even remotely justifiable even by the most generous Lockean assumptions. But it remains private property because an entity with the power to do so has deemed it so.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by pyuser583 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:02PM (#32544409)
> everything is private property only if a sovereign authority says it is

This is simply untrue. Private property proceeds the existence of the modern state.

Many parts of the world have extremely weak states, yet a distinction between private and public property remains.

Arguably, the states role is to ensure private property protections are available to the weak and the powerful, not just the powerful.

“The commons” - in the European and British sense were/are public property long before a meaningful state became involved.

Both s public and private property proceed modern states, and can have their origin in customary law as much as legal statutes.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by specialist on Sunday August 21, 2022 @07:26PM (#32545542)
Claims of ownership are only as legitimate as the potential to do violence to assert such claims.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by pyuser583 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @07:56PM (#32545730)
Authority isn’t always rooted in force or threat of force.

“The commons” is/was publicly owned, but without any real threat of force behind it.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by nwah1 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @08:14PM (#32545827)
The commons was managed in a decentralized manner, but indeed there were consequences for violating the written or unwritten rules.

And government was often involved in managing them historically.

Hence the poem:

>The law locks up the man or woman

Who steals the goose off the common

But leaves the greater villain loose

Who steals the common from the goose.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by emmelaich on Sunday August 21, 2022 @09:08PM (#32546176)
That's great. Here's it set to music.

https://mainlynorfolk.info/folk/songs/thegooseandthecommon.h...

and wikipedia on the Enclosure acts: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inclosure_Acts

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by Schroedingersat on Monday August 22, 2022 @06:22AM (#32549523)
> Private property proceeds the existence of the modern state.

Stop intimating that private and personal property are the same. Private property is enforcable only by coordinated violence. Its manifestations in the past (serfdom, slavery etc) have been universally agreed to be negative.

> Both s public and private property proceed modern states, and can have their origin in customary law as much as legal statutes.

You're still conflating personal and private property here.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by nwah1 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @06:56PM (#32545331)
Sovereign authorities also precede the existence of states.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by MichaelCollins on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:14PM (#32544520)
Da comrade, even "your" life belongs to the state, and you should feel fortunate they permit you to keep it!
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by imgabe on Sunday August 21, 2022 @07:48PM (#32545671)
This presumes that all income belongs to the government by default, and not being taxed is some special favor.

That’s backwards, all income belongs to the people who earn it by default. We agree to use a portion for the common good to fund the government. Since a nonprofit is presumably already working for the common good, there is no reason to take any of their income to fund the government.

[dead]
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by lotsofpulp on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:28PM (#32542360)
Then why does society allow someone to reduce their tax liability for “charity”?

Of course, it would be better if there were no deductions in the first place, and the government just paid for content if it wanted to pay for content which was then automatically in the public domain.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by pyuser583 on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:00PM (#32544387)
The idea is that when you donate to charity, the money is never “yours” - you never benefit from it.

Analogously, if part of your compensation was a donation to charity, you wouldn’t be taxed on it.

> it would be better if there were no donations in the first place, and the government just

A lot of Democrats in red states and Republicans in blue states disagree.

If America removed the charitable tax deduction, the big losers would include churches, Planned Parenthood, Human Rights Campaign, ACLU, etc

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by HWR_14 on Monday August 22, 2022 @01:00AM (#32547551)
> The idea is that when you donate to charity, the money is never “yours” - you never benefit from it.

Of course you do. If you didn't benefit from the donation, you wouldn't have made it.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by endominus on Monday August 22, 2022 @01:38AM (#32547742)
Just for clarification, do you mean this tautologically? As in, if I produce examples of people not materially or socially benefiting from their charitable donations (such as by donating anonymously in countries without charitable tax deductions) would your argument reduce to "They only give to charity to feel better about themselves, therefore they benefited and would not have made the donation otherwise"?
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by HWR_14 on Wednesday August 24, 2022 @07:16PM (#32587157)
I'm willing to give up the tautological definition in the edge case of "donated food anonymously to the poor" type cases. But I think that the number of ways of selfishly donating are both the vast majority and far broader than "material or social" benefiting.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by endominus on Thursday August 25, 2022 @03:12AM (#32590574)
Okay, now I'm more interested. Your original claim was;

>If you didn't benefit from the donation, you wouldn't have made it.

If I understand you correctly, you are claiming that the vast majority of charitable donations a) do not materially or socially benefit the donater, b) are still selfish (in that donating the money offers greater personal advantage than using the money in other ways), and c) would not be given if those benefits were not received in return. Could you give some examples of what kind of donations you're talking about, because I'm not sure we're communicating from the same basic understanding of what a charitable donation is.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by pyuser583 on Monday August 22, 2022 @09:14AM (#32550860)
That would be true if people only do things that benefit themselves.

But that’s just not how humans are.

Soldiers volunteer to throw themselves on grenades.

Humans are social creatures who have evolved to be willing to sacrifice for others.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by ghaff on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:55PM (#32544848)
>Analogously, if part of your compensation was a donation to charity, you wouldn’t be taxed on it.

Which is basically how corporate gift matching works.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by ghaff on Sunday August 21, 2022 @04:36PM (#32544130)
Do you really want government as the primary arbiter of what goes on PBS? At that point, it might as well be a government news channel. Though for better or worse, broadcast channels--including PBS--are less and less relevant. The federal government in the US is perfectly within its rights to commission and host content on .gov--which in general would be public domain.
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by qubex on Sunday August 21, 2022 @01:53PM (#32542634)
Because lobbyists receive a healthy sum to achieve and defend their benefactors’ ability to influence societal development by indulging in subsidised philanthropy they can focus on issues and aspects they desire (rather than going through the State and governmental assignment of funds).
Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by IncRnd on Sunday August 21, 2022 @05:07PM (#32544455)
> Of course, it would be better if there were no deductions in the first place, and the government just paid for content if it wanted to pay for content which was then automatically in the public domain.

You are arguing in favor of government propaganda, because that's what will happen in your scenario.

Re:HBO Max pulls nearly 200 ‘Sesame Street’ episodes by brigandish on Sunday August 21, 2022 @08:54PM (#32546066)
> What twisted logic hahaha

Try to remain respectful, this isn't Twitter or Reddit.