News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by moomin on Sunday August 14, 2022 @05:13AM (#32457745)
The elephant in the room here is that VFX, unlike many other film professions, isn’t properly unionised. Half of the practices that make VFX a hell-scape to work in and produce so many poor results are due to the simple fact that the workers are not treated the same as other parts of the crew. As long as it’s cheaper to fix it in post than retake the shot you can look forward to much more of this.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by bsenftner on Sunday August 14, 2022 @05:39AM (#32457873)
How to unionize when the studios create VFX divisions in 3rd world countries and then tell you if you want to continue your career you'll follow the jobs overseas? I was at Rhythm & Hues Studios thru two Oscars, transitioning thru programmer, digital artist and then financial analyst. I was a lead game developer before doing VFX, and I thought the games industry was bad. Well, at least in film the people are vastly more diverse, but the work is still 6-7 days a week, 10-12+ hour days.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by true_religion on Sunday August 14, 2022 @08:15AM (#32458618)
A lot of third world counties have pre existing unions, and a culture of unionization especially against foreign influence.

Uber for example has always struggled to operate in my country because anytime it tries to push driver wages down, drivers go on a nation wide strike and protest outside its offices. This prevents them from reducing costs without hurting themselves, so they can’t undercut the competition and reap the reward of becoming a de facto monopoly.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by raverbashing on Sunday August 14, 2022 @06:10AM (#32458019)
Thanks for your insight

> when the studios create VFX divisions in 3rd world countries and then tell you if you want to continue your career you'll follow the jobs overseas

This is one of the things that has to get worse before it gets better. You let them, but you don't go there (or maybe you go, who knows). You start growing a spine

Then let them realize that they "can't come knocking" when the studio is somewhere else. Start putting the foot down with deadlines and revisions (nobody said it was going to be easy). Let them see how the quality suffers with an offshore team with much less skin in the game

"Oh but I might lose my job if I don't do how they tell me how to do it", well, yes. But the way things go you'll lose the job eventually when the company go bust

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by d4nt on Sunday August 14, 2022 @06:48AM (#32458196)
I see so many similarities with the freelance web/mobile developer space. And having run a small dev shop (3-6 people) for 7 years I agree that the _only_ way forward is to hold your nerve, fire the shitty clients and only ever do work you can feel proud of. Yes, there will be tens of thousands of people on (the VFX equivalent of) upwork who charge 1/3 your price, and clients will put immense pressure on you because of it. But if you’re know for honesty and quality, the work will come.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by j-bos on Sunday August 14, 2022 @06:39AM (#32458149)
I'm curious, if you've been a programmer, one of the most in demand proffesions out there, Why would you tolerate 10-12 hour days 6 days a week? What motivates you to not get a more time balanced job?
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by bsenftner on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:14AM (#32458315)
Everywhere I go, the issues to be solved are critical and the deadlines are present so I do the work that needs to be done, and (as I mention above) non-entertainment tech jobs think I'm either too expensive, or something... basically, it's a nepotistic world, and I developed my network in abusive industries, so to the non-abusive places I apply, I look like an alien. I get replies like "wow! we've love to have you, but you're clearly too expensive and would not be happy doing the non-shiny things we do." And I never even mentioned salary.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by boppo1 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @08:16AM (#32458623)
Have you ever said "try me, throw out a number"?

I was under the impression graphics programming is low-paid relative to similarly difficult programming (or even less difficult like framework CRUD).

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by datavirtue on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:14AM (#32459402)
That sounds desperate.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by ehnto on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:39AM (#32460140)
I have the best luck just being honest and concise, know your number and ask if they can meet it. If not, no-one wastes their time. If they say the can but low-ball you, not a big deal, decline and move on.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by paulcole on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:44AM (#32459667)
> I get replies like "wow! we've love to have you, but you're clearly too expensive and would not be happy doing the non-shiny things we do." And I never even mentioned salary.

This could be like when a romantic partner says, “Let’s be friends.”

They usually don’t want to be friends.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by joezydeco on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:56AM (#32459281)
Could the other Hollywood unions refuse to work on jobs when non-union VFX work is being used?
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by agileAlligator on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:22AM (#32459034)
Thing is, unions usually proliferate in industries where you are more or less replaceable. That isn't the case in industries that can't be easily automated.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by 0xRusty on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:49AM (#32460233)
Or creative industries where 20% of the people do 80% of the heavy lifiting work. As a vfx and cg supervisor at a large vfx company myself I work extremely long hours, picking up the slack for the 80%'ers who can barely simulate a piece of cloth or match a plate's key light direction. Why on earth would I choose to unionize and equalize my pay and benefits to those that are objectively poor at their job in an industry where successful results to tasks are so subjectively measured.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by rperez333 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @03:06PM (#32461959)
You are likely deluding yourself about your skill level; I’ve had the habit of tracking my peer's productivity (on Shotgrid) to stay above their metrics, and even if I could say objectively to be the faster in my dept., that is irrelevant. VFX needs different kinds of people, and I can’t count how many times “less” productive artists came up with very beautiful and ingenious solutions that I haven’t thought about it.

Also, we don’t stay long hours because we failed to put a light on the correct place. as the article points out, the issue is the director/production has no financial penalties for their lack of planning and indecisiveness. This is just the Parkinson's law of triviality [0] that happens in most businesses, but since VFX studios don’t put a hard cap on the number of revisions, artists end up absorbing that. One of my recent crunches was due to production going through 43 versions of a magic wand effect. IMO, by version 15, we already had multiple and more interesting looks than what was approved for final. [0] https://bwiggs.com/notebook/queens-duck/

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by BeFlatXIII on Sunday August 14, 2022 @01:53PM (#32461334)
> so subjectively measured

There's your answer. Equalize pay and benefits because there's no telling whether those in charge of assigning pay have any good sense at all for quality. It's the argument of salary vs. hourly vs. per-item all over again.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by agileAlligator on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:40PM (#32465626)
> because there's no telling whether those in charge of assigning pay have any good sense at all for quality

They'll pay what they think you are worth, and you are free to leave if you think they aren't paying you enough. It's not like there are only two software companies in the entire world and you gotta work for one of them.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by narrator on Sunday August 14, 2022 @06:45AM (#32458179)
I think the reason programmers don't unionize is some are 10x better than others, so they don't want to get the same wages as 1x programmers. Conversely, something like airline piloting or being a factory worker or nurse can be done much more equally by everyone in the field, so they are more likely to unionize. Are there wild variations in talent of VFX professionals?
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by true_religion on Sunday August 14, 2022 @08:10AM (#32458583)
Programmers don’t unionize because they are well paid, and there is no structural barrier stopping people who gain skills and experience from getting better paid in the future.

To contrast that look at medicine. Doctors have no union. They have a huge barrier to entry but once you are already a doctor then how much you get paid is determined by your skills and where you work. Doctors can get paid millions with enough prestige on them.

Nurses on the other hand have a terminal limit. Every pay increase is gated by another nursing exam giving an additional certificate. Then in the end, the only upgrade is to doctor. However that means losing all benefits, retraining, and starting in a new track despite both professions being medical. Nurses therefore need a union.

Another thing that stops unionization is the ability to work on your own. Nurses with high enough qualifications can work on their own, but in most cases they still need a supervising doctor even if that doctor is only a warm body. VFX pros are much the same. They need a team with them to work on a big budget movie.

Programmers and doctors though can break away and start their own practice, serving the public directly and no one can stop them. With a little business savvy they can even rival the agencies that would have hired them as employees. If your profession can double as a stand-alone business then you rarely get a proper union.

Even in cases (e.g. electricians) where a union is formed, it will still conduct training and certification which positions it somewhat like a guild.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by mountainb on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:56AM (#32459283)
Doctors have a guild: the AMA. Lawyers have a guild: the ABA. Neither are the same things as unions but they have similar effects. The ABA and AMA also have large roles in professional education. Both also have major roles in accreditation and regulation of the profession. Unlike unions, they do not collectively bargain on behalf of individual workers. They aren't subject to the many regulations associated with organized labor.

They also enjoy broad exemptions to antitrust law which would otherwise apply. It's why other classes of worker cannot have the same type of protective guild -- it's legal when the ABA or AMA do it and illegal when someone else does it.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by ghaff on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:34AM (#32459581)
The situation with doctors and lawyers is considerably different however.

Doctors, whether MDs or otherwise, tend to be pretty well-compensated in US broadly.

Lawyers are much more of a mixed bag. White shoe law firms--mostly hiring students from top-tier schools with prestigious clerkships? Big bucks though either make partner or are mostly eased out. Some decent corporate law and successful private practices. But it's generally not a particularly well-compensated profession for someone from a mid to low-tier law school. And lots of people who graduate law school and even pass the bar don't actually end up practicing law.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by cma on Sunday August 14, 2022 @03:10PM (#32461989)
Doctors are well compensated in large part because their unions (professional associations) restricts the number of new doctors unreasonably and advocates against certifying foreign doctors to practice in the US.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by pclmulqdq on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:15AM (#32459929)
My understanding is that in many places, the trade unions (electricians, plumbers, etc.) operate more like the AMA than the UAW. There is a spectrum of unionization.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by ravenstine on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:41AM (#32459159)
In addition, programmers have a decent shot at striking it out on their own if they can't stand W2 employment or if they think they can make more money starting a business.

That's one big reason why I am unlikely to support unionization for the foreseeable future. If an employer treats us like crap, we just leave and either find a better opportunity or start our own business with blackjack and hookers. As a programmer, you can start your own business today by simply offering your services and looking for clients. We aren't nearly as enslaved to our companies as many other professions are.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by Archelaos on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:12AM (#32459912)
> Doctors have no union.

In Germany doctors are heavily unionized. The largest union, Marburger Bund has 131.000 members.[1] The second largest, Hartmannbund has 70.000 members.[2] For comparision: At the end of 2020, there were 409,121 practising doctors (not including dentists) in Germany.[3]

[1] Source: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marburger_Bund

[2] Source: https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hartmannbund

[3] Source: https://www.bundesaerztekammer.de/baek/ueber-uns/aerztestati...

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by imglorp on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:45AM (#32459191)
> they still need a supervising doctor even if that doctor is only a warm body.

This is a good thing for standard of care: it's a chain of accountability. Medical supervision is supposed to set local policies and quality gates across a range of different providers. This also extends to EMT's in the field, for example: their supervision says what drugs or procedures they can use, which affects what the ER is expecting when patients arrive.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by barry-cotter on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:52AM (#32459746)
> This is a good thing for standard of care: it's a chain of accountability.

This is classism in action. There’s no reason a nurse practitioner can’t bear legal responsibility for their actions. As long as it’s unambiguous who is the responsible party whether they are a physician, nurse or physiotherapist there’s a chain of accountability.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by imglorp on Sunday August 14, 2022 @01:19PM (#32461008)
Not disagreeing that you need to enable all levels of provider, that's not what I'm saying. I also agree all levels of provider should have an easy career path to the top.

The point is there's a system requirement for interfacing one provider to the next, so that if you're receiving a handoff from someone else you know they prepared the patient for the next guy. There's also a malpractice/liability component.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by kurupt213 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @08:49PM (#32464632)
NPs don’t have near the experience of a doctor (who needs something like 8,000+ hours of supervised experience before they can practice unsupervised).

You are saying a NP is the equivalent of an attending physician, which is absurd.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by barry-cotter on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:09PM (#32465114)
Saying an attending physician and a nurse practitioner are in every way similar would seem unlikely, given the radically different environments they work in. When we compare outcomes they look as good or better than physicians but that’s not to say they can completely replace them.

> A meta-analysis of nurse practitioners and nurse midwives in primary care

> This meta-analysis was an evaluation of patient outcomes of nurse practitioners (NPs) and nurse midwives (NMs), compared with those of physicians, in primary care. The sample included 38 NP and 15 NM studies. Thirty-three outcomes were analyzed. In studies that employed randomization to provider, greater patient compliance with treatment recommendations was shown with NPs than with physicians. In studies that controlled for patient risk in ways other than randomization, patient satisfaction and resolution of pathological conditions were greater for NP patients. NPs were equivalent to MDs on most other variables in controlled studies. In studies that controlled for patient risk, NMs used less technology and analgesia than did physicians in intrapartum care of obstetric patients. NMs achieved neonatal outcomes equivalent to those of physicians. Limitations in data from primary studies precluded answering questions of why and under what conditions these outcomes apply and whether these services are cost-effective.

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7501486/

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by classichasclass on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:40AM (#32459153)
There are most definitely physician unions, especially in government-operated clinics which are often union shops. I was involuntarily in SEIU for a number of years as a result, though I thought striking was unethical for a doctor myself. See also UAPD and NAVAPD.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by kurupt213 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @08:46PM (#32464614)
You are sadly mistaken if you think nursing is even close to what being a doctor is.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by closewith on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:33AM (#32459109)
> Doctors have no union.

Citation needed.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by dsr_ on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:45AM (#32459192)
The AMA controls medical school certification, and size, and therefore controls the number of new entrants, keeping earnings high.

It doesn't organize medical doctors for working conditions, salary and benefits negotiation, insurance, or most of the other features of a union. A hospital chain doesn't negotiate with the AMA on behalf of their surgeons and hospitalists.

(It would probably be a very good thing if interns and early residents had a union supervising working conditions.)

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by closewith on Sunday August 14, 2022 @12:01PM (#32460317)
Ah, so doctors in the US aren't unionised at all? If so, they're a global outlier.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by moomin on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:07AM (#32458283)
Honestly I think the real reason programmers don’t unionise is that we’re not smart enough to realize we’re Labour.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by booleandilemma on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:29AM (#32459536)
This is the answer.

A lot of programmers I've met are either narcissists or autists bereft of self-awareness.

If you're a normal person you go into product management.

A coworker once told me that we are "society's elite". That's the level of delusion we're talking about here.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by ma2rten on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:23AM (#32458360)
This doesn’t make sense to me. Why wouldn’t just the 1x programmers unionize? I’m sure they would be in the majority as 10x programmers are rare.

I also do not really believe in this concept in general. Programming skills are not one dimensional, people have different strengths and weaknesses.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by ceejayoz on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:35AM (#32458411)
The 1x programmers - which is virtually all of us - all think they’re 10x programmers.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by datavirtue on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:04AM (#32459337)
My number of X's adapt to fit the possibilities and potential of the environment. Right now it's 1x. Actually that's a lie, it's my 1x effort but the company I work with is floating on cloud 10x because I know more of the requirements than they do.

Still have no idea what this mythical 1x - 10x number scale maps to. Inspiration can up anyone's game.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by emptyparadise on Sunday August 14, 2022 @07:52AM (#32458499)
That just makes us the greatest fools of all.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by Foobar8568 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @09:53AM (#32459259)
Or we are all well paid diva who, if bored, would just switch companies without much problems nor thinking. I am unsure if being in union (as in the US type of unions) would bring a lot of wage benefits.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by throw0101a on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:22PM (#32461562)
> I think the reason programmers don't unionize is some are 10x better than others, so they don't want to get the same wages as 1x programmers.

Tom Cruise makes (e.g.) $10M for being in a movie, and Jane Doe who plays Waitress #2 gets paid $10K for being in the same movie, and yet they're both part of SAG.

You can create union/guild structures which have a minimum pay scale but not a maximum.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by mook on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:00AM (#32459308)
That doesn't make much sense — some actors make much more than 10x over other actors (and they bring the kind of audience to command that extra compensation), and yet they're definitely unionized.
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by johnthescott on Sunday August 14, 2022 @10:21AM (#32459469)
but did they unionize after getting rich or when they were broke?

for screenwriters, most studios will not even review scripts without going through SAG, according to an awarding screenwriter/director who is a good friend on mine.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by analog31 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:45AM (#32460201)
I can't speak about actors, but there was a time when a major benefit of being in the musicians union was the standardization of contracts that might cover complicated issues such as credit, royalties, re-publishing, and so forth. So it wasn't necessarily the magnitude of the money, but making it humanly fathomable how the money would actually be distributed.

I've heard people say to freelance musicians (like myself), that you don't really need the union until you start working in recording or broadcast.

I've not seen a screen actor's contract but I'll bet the provisions for working conditions and rights are a bigger deal than the pay scale. Also, I've read that in general, unionization efforts tend to be triggered by working conditions rather than pay. Even programmers could benefit from that.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by kurupt213 on Sunday August 14, 2022 @08:52PM (#32464644)
I think you have to be a union member to be able to work. Without a SAG card you are SOL, even if you are Tom Cruise
Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by carapace on Sunday August 14, 2022 @02:10PM (#32461473)
Years ago I felt that programmers didn't need unions because we are so in-demand and already highly paid. Then the whole "no poaching" scandal came out, and now I definitely do think we need some sort of union-ish something. I hate to say it because many of the individuals are actually good people, but the managers/execs as a class are amoral bastards who will do whatever they think they can get away with to make a buck. To me the extraordinary thing is that Apple has more money than Scrooge McDuck and still screwed over their own engineers.

It reminds me of the scene from the Simpsons: Homer and Mr. Burns are chilling together in what will become the rocket-house:

Homer: Oh Mr. Burns, you're the richest man I know.

Mr. Burns: Ah yes, but I'd trade it all... for a little more.

Re:Hollywood’s visual effects crisis by 0xRusty on Sunday August 14, 2022 @11:50AM (#32460241)
Absolutely 100% agree. I work in a senior role in a vfx company. The adage that 20% of the workers do 80% of the work is more true in vfx than you'd likely believe.