News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by codefreeordie on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @11:30PM (#32421240)
The difficulty with gifted/talented education is that offering it requires inherently accepting that some people are not gifted/talented (or, at a minimum, less gifted/talented).

This is a very unpopular idea in the current culture.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by photochemsyn on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:52PM (#32441112)
I see a lot of similarities to British trends in the late 19th century with the'public school' (posh/aristocrat) vs state-run (prole/serf) system. By definition, the aristocratic class was considered to be universally gifted, and the serf class was considered to be universally inferior, so having a 'gifted program' in the school for the proles risked the danger of breaking class lines.

However, the collapse of the British Empire was due in large part to greed and incompetent management (not that Empires are all that desirable) but the 20th century history of technological development in Britain isn't all that great. In contrast, looking at the biographies of many leading American scientists and entrepreneurs of the 20th century reveals that a great many of them came from places like impoverished MidWest farming communities and were only able to move on to higher academics, research centers, etc. because of their access to 'advanced learning programs' in their local areas.

If the argument is that bias exists in who gets into advanced/gifted programs in the K-12 public schools because there is a limited number of slots, the solution is obviously to expand the number of slots, not to eliminate the programs altogether.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:56PM (#32441159)
Expanding slots isn't itself a solution, because ultimately you end up with gifted programs that are targeting people mildly above average. I've heard of some school districts in Virginia where 50% of students are in gifted programs. This waters down the curriculum so that people in the top 5-10% are no longer challenged and engaged.

What we need is fine grained tracking and the ability to appropriately serve children at all levels. This includes, btw, people at the bottom of the distribution: if you're teaching material targeting people at the 50% percentile of preparedness, you're not serving the kids at 25% or 10% at all and are setting them up for failure.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by bnralt on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:04PM (#32441271)
At the very least schools should be trying to meet children at their level. I've seen children go an entire year without learning a thing in certain subjects, simply because the curriculum for that year is below their level. Not only is it a waste of time, but it also makes students detached from a school where they feel like they're only getting busywork.

It's good that these schools are focused on trying to help children who are struggling in certain areas. But they seem to be fine with providing poor service to the children who are ahead, which should be unacceptable. It isn't possible to meet every child at their level, but at least there should be some effort made to fit each child's needs. The attitude I see a lot of the time is "You're doing well, so shutup and sit there while we ignore you."

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarby2 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:17PM (#32441426)
> But they seem to be fine with providing poor service to the children who are ahead, which should be unacceptable.

This is one of the reasons I hated school, when you can read the book, understand the material and complete the work in 20 minutes and you have an hour allotted and then just have to sit there it makes you dread going in every day.

This wasn't the case in every subject but when it came to maths and science it was just painful.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:17PM (#32441428)
Also note that schools provide poor service to children who are behind. It's unfair to expect a teachers to provide good instruction to anyone in an 8th grade classroom where they have been tasked with instructing a group that includes students from a 6th grade level to a 9th grade level.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by gnicholas on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:16PM (#32442101)
Our experience (in Menlo) has been that almost all of the teacher's small-group or 1-on-1 time is spent with kids who are behind. It is understandable to have a goal that is bringing up the lowest performers. But if a school is going to do that, they should not steadfastly refuse to let kids be tracked.

Allowing tracking would let kids who are not behind actually grow to their capacity. As it is currently structured, the kids at the top are never challenged, and they may not even realize that so many of their peers are also talented and unchallenged.

Teachers shouldn't have to teach a span of 3-4 grade levels. But in our district, the teachers and administration are the ones who are fighting hardest against tracking. It's not fair of them to fight tracking and then complain that teaching advanced kids would be too hard. It's only hard in the current system, where tracking (in our district) is not allowed.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:28PM (#32442249)
Kids who are behind, even if they get the majority of teacher attention, still suffer, because in an appropriately tracked classroom all the teacher's efforts would be targeted toward them (and targeted toward getting them to step n+1, not putting heroic efforts into getting them to step n+2).

But broadly we're in agreement, and the resistance you mention speaks to a broader, uncomfortable-to-discuss issue with the priorities educators have.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by quartesixte on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:57PM (#32441179)
>solution is obviously to expand the number of slots,

Exactly! And then perhaps as we continue to raise the bar and challenge our students and teachers to higher academic levels earlier, we’ll raise the bar on education everywhere and start catching up to our peer nations.

The anti-intellectualism that pervades the entire spectrum of US political beliefs is astounding.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by sidlls on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:06PM (#32441300)
I went through grad school and taught in university in the US. My perspective is a bit different. I agree in many ways the US is behind. But in some regions outside the US there seems to be a strong emphasis on rote/mechanical memorization that provides the appearance of good education, but it falls far short when a person is tasked with actually demonstrating an understanding of the material. Me and my US taught peers (of whatever ethnicity) almost always performed better on exams where the problems were similar to but novel compared with the homework, while these rote/memorizing people almost always did better on exams where the problems were essentially lifted from the homework (perhaps with irrelevant changes, such as slightly different numbers or what have you). It was an incredible eye opener, as I had always assumed the US had a trash education system in general. It’s more nuanced than that.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by quartesixte on Friday August 12, 2022 @05:24PM (#32444099)
An interesting problem for sure, but perhaps a result of self-selection bias?

You and your other US peers represent the very tip of academic achievement in the country and perhaps are either the result of great teachers and/or programs that fostered that independent thinking, or were naturally inclined to do so anyways and your academic predispositions led you to where you are today.

But let’s face it. The average American school never gets that far. And public schools in the US (based on the miles of anecdata published on the internet) seem to enforce rote memorization anyways. Standardized testing, teaching to the test, “my way or highway” teachers. So not only are we doing the same as our peer nations, but doing it worse. And any attempt to do critical thinking type teaching (a la Finland) gets lost in a sea of terrible schools, incompetent teachers, mediocre curriculums, and an education system that fatalistically lowers rigor and standards in favor of not challenging students to do better.

No this is not a funding problem. Schools in the US have some of the highest per-student funding in the world. And those are also paradoxically the worst performing ones.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by fragmede on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:04PM (#32441283)
This is no less evident than in online discourse sitting the Internet agree. Users see fit to shame other users for learning and making use of the knowledge available to them. You're god damn right I read the shit out of Wikipedia to figure out the basics of whatever thing is on the news today.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by jrs235 on Friday August 12, 2022 @03:40PM (#32443030)
People just want you to tell them the answer you're looking for. They don't want to think, research, or defend a position they choose or chose to take.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by agileAlligator on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:41PM (#32442398)
> By definition, the aristocratic class was considered to be universally gifted

Private tutoring probably had a large role to play in this perception

https://erikhoel.substack.com/p/why-we-stopped-making-einste...

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by betaby on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:04PM (#32441269)
Interestingly enough in Canada/USA is very OK and cool to say 'gifted athlete' or 'talented goalkeeper' but totally no-no to say 'mathematically gifted student'. Speaking from the personal experience of kids being in high school.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by okaram on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:12PM (#32441365)
I've no clue what you are talking about. It is perfectly OK to say mathematically gifted student
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:22PM (#32441488)
From the new Mathematics Framework for California Public Schools:

> All students deserve powerful mathematics; we reject ideas of natural gifts and talents... The push to calculus in grade twelve is itself misguided... An important goal of this framework is to replace ideas of innate mathematics 'talent' and 'giftedness' with the recognition that every student is on a growth pathway... There is no cutoff determining when one child is 'gifted' and another is not.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by gnicholas on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:17PM (#32442117)
I thought they pulled back the "reject ideas of natural gifts and talents" in the most recent draft, after massive public outrage?
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by quartesixte on Friday August 12, 2022 @05:29PM (#32444148)
As someone who has friends in education PhD programs this is not an ironic statement these are true beliefs held by the institutions that train our teachers today.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by untalentedturd on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:51PM (#32441101)
In my experience it doesn't require accepting that at all. Most students in my GT program were average at best with ambitious parents. A minority of us had no tutors, study programs or other leg up for the standardized test used to select GT students. But most students were there for their parents' prestige.

I'm still a fan of GT though, at least it means the school system has to provide a decent education to some students. Plus it was a pretty big deal for those of us not coming from privilege.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by dwater on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:59PM (#32441216)
That was my experience as well in the 90's. The biggest difference was the behavior of the students, which allowed the class to move at a faster pace. Gifted and Talented was certainly a misnomer, but the environment that behavior enabled was a benefit to everyone in the classroom across all levels of gifts and talents.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by empressplay on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:22PM (#32441492)
This was also my experience in the early 90s, which was frustrating (at the time) because in the 1980s admission was based on IQ tests and in those programs we did a lot of cool things! (computer programming, robotics, rockets, chemistry, biology etc. etc.) High-achieving students could skip grades if they wanted to, but the program itself wasn't just doing more of the same, and I valued that.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by no_wizard on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:48PM (#32441056)
I don't know that it is. I think we all accept on some level that some people are more advanced and some aren't. What I think people take issue with is when getting access to programs like this - that can drastically change the future of your child - has gatekeeping and politics around it, and no "path" that every family can uniformly follow to get accepted into such a program. This is where most of the tension is.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by psi75 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:05PM (#32441287)
The issue is that while (a) society absolutely needs these programs, (b) they, by definition, can't be made available to everyone. Some people are going to get in, and some are not. No matter what we do, there are going to be results we don't like, both at an individual and aggregate level.

For example, it has become fashionable in liberal circles to argue for abolishing the SAT because, while it is not intrinsically racist, its results reflect our racist society: people with less access to education and tutoring perform poorly, and this results in measurable racial disparities. Problem is, the world becomes even worse without it. Under our current regime, very few people from underprivileged backgrounds can get into college and advance, but without the SAT, almost no one would be doing so.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by throwfh80h82 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:13PM (#32441377)
Yeah I think the identification of "gifted" children is pretty imprecise and error prone.

Also it's unclear the kids doing well (better than everyone else, I imagine) are the ones who'd most benefit from special treatment, versus the struggling kids.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:39PM (#32441710)
I agree that a binary gifted/nongifted is not really descriptive of reality or useful.

No kid should get special treatment; every kid should get treatment appropriate to their level. It's not even strictly speaking a matter of resources: you don't need fancy equipment to teach a more advanced class. It does mean you need more teachers and a larger school, so that people can be placed into classes of roughly equal levels of ability.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by candiodari on Friday August 12, 2022 @07:58PM (#32445407)
Then there's only 1 solution: 1 teacher per child. Half that would make the education budget exceed the total tax income of the state ...

Or put differently: for this suggestion we can't pay. And we choose not to pay for even mild improvements to the current situation.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by veilrap on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:54PM (#32441140)
I think the problem is that the measurement, detection, and access to so-called gifted and talented programs is a major issue. The more exclusive the programs are the more it restricts the access to advanced studies to students not lucky enough to make the cutoff. The differences of students on one side of a cutoff and the other side of a cutoff are negligible.

I prefer systems that make advanced coursework and guidance available to anyone willing and able to put in the work. And the "who" may vary from year to year or course to course based on the individual student interest.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by peyton on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:25PM (#32441524)
> The differences of students on one side of a cutoff and the other side of a cutoff are negligible.

Well, there’s a bar. One side figured out how to exceed the bar. The other didn’t. That’s a pretty big difference that I wouldn’t attribute to “luck.”

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by karmajunkie on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:51PM (#32441094)
that’s not at all true. as a data point, i can certainly accept that some students have more aptitude in one subject or another than some other students.

the reason i have problems with GATE is that it supposes than only those students benefit from or should have access to these opportunities, even in fact all students can benefit from them, depending somewhat on the program. for example, when i was in one of these programs, our overwhelmingly White class (in a school that was about 60% Black) got to learn about the stock market by simulating a working exchange. There’s nothing about the notion of buying and selling that can’t be understood by any student—yet this was part of the curriculum only for the small number of students deemed intellectually worthy of the extra attention.

That said, many GT programs today are based on differentiated instruction, where students are not pulled out of the classroom but given different assignments depending on their demonstrated ability, such as maths worksheets/assignments that are a bit more difficult than the “normal” one, and i think these programs are significantly more equitable.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by tbihl on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:20PM (#32441456)
>for example, when i was in one of these programs, our overwhelmingly White class (in a school that was about 60% Black) got to learn about the stock market by simulating a working exchange. There’s nothing about the notion of buying and selling that can’t be understood by any student—yet this was part of the curriculum only for the small number of students deemed intellectually worthy of the extra attention.

It's all well and good to point out that buying and selling are fundamentally simple concepts, but that's not the same as saying that the instruction could be given universally. First, students have to be stable enough personally and in their lives that they can show up and pay attention for all the instruction that makes the exercise get off the ground at all. Then, students need to care about the material and believe that there is justification to learn it, or it's casting pearls before swine. In my public school experience, you've just lost 80-90% of the student body with those two factors.

Then, if you have all that, you need teachers who are confident enough with stock markets to teach the material and go beyond a narrow track of reciting facts, and that goes way further than just 'buying and selling'. On top of that, the teacher needs to be able to make or facilitate a simulation that moves at the right pace and adjusts as necessary, including getting all the students to work well together.

From the perspective of a school administration, you only get a few teachers who will have those skills and personality, and it's pretty important to have them doing work like that, because teaching-as-remedial-fact-recitation for a standardized test will get rid of those good teachers pretty quickly, and now you have no one left to teach the kids who could have benefitted from the differentiated curriculum.

Source: I went to public school and now teach and manage at a school that focuses on a lot of simulations and role-playing.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:04PM (#32441276)
There's plenty about the notion of buying and selling that can't be understood by any student. An appalling number of kids in public school aren't able to answer questions like "how do you make change for $5.67 if you're given a $10 bill."

Differentiated instruction is a crock; a teacher who fails to be able to teach a classroom of roughly equal abilities is going to fail even harder to teach a classroom of mixed abilities. Giving extra worksheets with slightly harder problems doesn't cut it, when a significant minority of kids are one or more grade levels above grade (and a significant majority of kids are one or more level below grade).

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by tomp on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:50PM (#32441088)
It’s only unpopular to the extent it correlates with (or against) certain racial groups.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by ch4s3 on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:53PM (#32441127)
The sense I've gotten from talking to vocal opponents is that they are philosophically blank slaters and strongly, fundamentally believe that people do not have fundamentally different aptitudes.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by tomp on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:14PM (#32441395)
I doubt they’re arguing in good faith.

There is an argument to be made that we should improve education and bring more people up to speed (e.g. a lot of top10% of high schoolers can learn integration but it required a once-in-10-generations genius to figure it out for the first time).

But even the most fervent blank slaters should recognise that people have different interests, and come from different educational backgrounds.

The only reason to support equality of outcome is to repress high-performers.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by ch4s3 on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:14PM (#32442076)
I've heard a bunch of different flavors of the argument, and some dumber ones. I think it all boils down to a one size fits all model being bad for most students.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by infamouscow on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:50PM (#32441090)
Not accepting the reality that some people are more or less gifted/talented is objectively worse.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by drewcoo on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:55PM (#32442558)
Citation needed.

In my state I was in Talented and Gifted (TAG) programs.

My own experience is that TAG-style teaching would have helped everyone I knew, certainly in grade school. And when it's doled out unevenly, that creates a caste system if it wasn't there and reinforces it if it already existed.

On the one hand, it harms all the non-TAG kids by withholding education. Curricula to withhold education in schools - the irony!

On the other hand, it harms the TAG kids by creating social barriers. And those students, in my experience, are one of the groups in school most likely to have existing problems with socialization.

TAG as it exists in US public schools harms all students.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by infamouscow on Friday August 12, 2022 @03:38PM (#32443020)
You've constructed a straw-man rather than address the central point some people are more or less gifted/talented.

For millions of students the education system is the only ticket out of poverty for themselves and their families. To ignore that because it might make some people feel uncomfortable is absolute nonsense and misses the point entirely.

The people uncomfortable with that should be asking themselves why they feel that way, repeatedly.

Denying everyone these opportunities because some students aren't gifted/talented is deranged, unnatural, and genuinely evil.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by candiodari on Friday August 12, 2022 @08:05PM (#32445451)
> Denying everyone these opportunities because some students aren't gifted/talented is deranged, unnatural, and genuinely evil.

So we should deny everyone opportunities because some people are denied opportunities even when we try to give them?

You know, some people drown, others don't. It's often just not fair. I'd hate to hear your solution to this.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by MengerSponge on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:52PM (#32441111)
There are people who believe that. There's also the fact that wealthier (read: white) parents can doctor shop around and force little Brayden into the Gifted track. The result of those forces is wildly regressive, especially when schools are so underfunded. Poor kids and minority kids wind up in classrooms that are doubly starved for resources.

Funding education to the point where schools have tracks that students can move between (advanced, normal, remedial) would be much more equitable and much better pedagogically too.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by photochemsyn on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:59PM (#32441208)
This claim about wealth == white isn't all that accurate. Last I checked the sub-poverty population in the USA has an ancestral breakdown of 45% european 25% african 25% south/central american 5% asian/native north american. While the wealthiest 1% is overwhelmingly european those people uniformly send their children to private schools with lots of resources and hire private tutors for their college entrance exams.

In any case, nothing in your comment justifies eliminating advanced learning programs in any school, even if some parents want to push their kids into such programs even if they're not really ready for it.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by rhino369 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:11PM (#32441349)
The problem is many people don't want to admit that the privileges of wealth and status don't just create bias, but they actually make better students. So you'll never have equality of outcome--never.

Sure some bribery and networking occur. But they also send their kids to tutors, set high expectations, don't let them watch too much TV/tablet, have better diets, etc.

Nothing about gifted programs requires that non-gifted classrooms need to be underfunded.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by DaveExeter on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:25PM (#32441528)
>The problem is many people don't want to admit that the privileges of wealth and status don't just create bias, but they actually make better students. So you'll never have equality of outcome--never.

This is confusing cause and effect. People of higher intelligence end up with wealth and status, and since intelligence is genetic, their children generally have higher intelligence then average.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by hellisothers on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:10PM (#32442044)
I don’t think the OP was talking about genetics, I think they’re referencing that wealthy families are able to focus more resources on learning/education and thus generate “better students” via nurture not nature.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by rhino369 on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:44PM (#32441778)
Intelligence is far far far from 100% genetic.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by DaveExeter on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:59PM (#32441940)
Nope! Intelligence is 100% genetic.

Ok, obviously ingesting lead or not being fed can lead to a decrease in IQ.

Just as not being fed as a child can lead to a decrease in adult height, but we can still say that height is 100% genetic.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by smcin on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:08PM (#32441327)
Why is "doctor shopping" in any way related to admission to the Gifted track? For everyone unfamiliar with the unique peculiarities of the US setup on GATE (Gifted-and-Talented Education). Are you referring to doctor-shopping for ADHD or autism diagnoses, esp. in 4-7-year-olds, as is rampant in the US? Or something else? And how numerically does that influence GATE admission rates? (In the past I've looked for (aggregate) statistics on autism/ADHD diagnoses influencing SAT scores or college admission rates, but the industry increasingly invokes "healthcare privacy" to hide even reporting anonymized aggregate statistics, per-zipcode/per-school/per-college). I believe the record is held by one zipcode in Connecticut where 18% of schoolchildren have autism diagnoses.

> Funding education... would be much more equitable...

Again the US setup is peculiar: most (public) school funding comes from local (school-district) and state level, with a tiny amound of federal funding. Hence zipcodes are a strong proxy for much of this.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by scarmig on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:52PM (#32441854)
Doctor shopping isn't necessarily the best analogy, but it's also true that parental pressure on school bureaucracy can result in their student being placed into a program they otherwise wouldn't have.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by bnralt on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:20PM (#32441463)
> Poor kids and minority kids wind up in classrooms that are doubly starved for resources.

People always assume this to be the case, but it doesn't seem to be true whenever I look at specific school districts. For example, D.C. and Baltimore public schools have a student body with _many_ more poor and minority children than the national average, and the per pupil spending at these schools is also well above the national average.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by peyton on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:29PM (#32441584)
It’s effective rhetoric to direct funding to underperforming schools, as the data shows.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by tbihl on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:24PM (#32441522)
>Funding education to the point where schools have tracks that students can move between (advanced, normal, remedial)

I obviously don't know anything about your educational background, but the two run-of-the-mill public schools I attended growing up both let people move into and fall out of the top tracks. Having said that, it became progressively rarer over time as the work required to catch up became greater and greater, and, on the other hand, as the cohort increasingly committed to and identified with their schoolwork.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by DaveExeter on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:59PM (#32441222)
I don't think that is the problem. The problem is that the gifted/talented are disproportionally Asian.

That is the real problem. Accepting that some ethnic groups have a higher average IQ than others goes against the American ideal of equality.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by com2kid on Friday August 12, 2022 @12:52PM (#32441110)
> This is a very unpopular idea in the current culture.

Let's be clear.

When I went to a gifted program in the 90s, it was only offered in the nicer part of town. My mother had to repeatedly threaten and read the district's own rules to them to eventually force them to send a taxi cab to pick me up in my poor neighborhood and take me up to the rich neighborhood so I could attend the gifted program.

The school district had since ended such services, and now requires parents transport their own children, something that working class families will be unable to do.

Even at the time, funding was tight (it is worse now), and teachers did not have enough resources to run classrooms. It was well into the 90s before I learned the soviet union had fallen, as all of our history books and atlases still had the USSR on them[1].

The district is now going to shut down all their gifted programs, but honestly I feel that is due to the district not having enough teachers, money, or any other sorts of resources. There are schools with lead in the pipes where students shouldn't drink the water, managing a gifted program may just be beyond the district's capabilities at this time.

To return to my overall point, the gifted program here was designed around racism and classism. Poor students and minority students, even if they tested in, had barriers put in place so they could not attend.

The unpopular idea in the current culture is that rich white people should get a better education than everyone else.[2] (One can argue that a counter force is rich white people who think their kids are gifted even if their kids are not at all gifted...)

Of course the closure of the gifted programs means all the parents who give a shit about their kid's education are either moving out of the city, or going into private schools. When I was in school, I saw parents move their kids out of private schools to go to the public school's gifted program!

[1] At one point we got new math textbooks that were so bad our teacher gave us extra credit for going through the book and finding math errors in it. It was incredibly easy for a bunch of 12 year olds to find errors on seemingly every page. Another time we got corporate sponsored history books where all historical events had been sugarcoated to hell and back. Slavery, banana republics, revolutions, nothing bad had ever happened in human history according to that text book! And yes it did have the corporate sponsor's name all over the back cover.

[2] Gifted programs also largely self select for families who care deeply about education, and who are therefor more involved with their child's education. This is reflected in the behavior of the children who themselves actually care about being at school. The single largest difference in the gifted classes I attended vs the mainstream classes was the attitude of the students. Students in the gifted program listened to the teacher and were actively involved in the classroom, in lessons, and in all aspects of learning, they wanted to be at school and to learn. I am 99.9% sure that a large percent of students would move at least a bit to the right on the bell curve if everyone had that same attitude about education.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by tbihl on Friday August 12, 2022 @01:33PM (#32441631)
>Poor students and minority students, even if they tested in, had barriers put in place so they could not attend.

>My mother had to repeatedly threaten and read the district's own rules to them to eventually force them to send a taxi cab to pick me up in my poor neighborhood and take me up to the rich neighborhood so I could attend the gifted program.

>Even at the time, funding was tight (it is worse now), and teachers did not have enough resources to run classrooms.

>but honestly I feel that is due to the district not having enough teachers, money, or any other sorts of resources. There are schools with lead in the pipes where students shouldn't drink the water, managing a gifted program may just be beyond the district's capabilities at this time.

Below your accusation, I've quoted you in three places: the first, where a school district committed extra resources to accommodate you outside of their normal competencies; the last two, where you point out that schools are constrained in resources and may not be up to the task of providing accelerated programs. How does any of that show a basis of racism?

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by com2kid on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:25PM (#32442205)
> How does any of that show a basis of racism?

I also mentioned the district shut down that transportation program a few years after I stopped using it. Rather unfortunate for everyone who came after me...

Barriers:

1. Placing gifted programs in traditionally (rich!) white neighborhoods and not providing transportation for minority students to those schools even if a student qualifies to attend

2. Having a limited number of spaces in programs so that not everyone who qualifies to attend can attend

The schools lack of funding is a separate issue, especially given the 16k spent per student each year.

In regards to #2, if you run the math, if you do entry by qualification, poor students who may have passed the entrance qualifications, but not by the same margin as students from families with $$, will not get a spot. On the surface it sounds fair, the best get in, but in reality tests are always +/- a few points given day to day performance, and students who have worse home life (inadequate nutrition, lack of private educational resources, etc) already had to work harder to earn a passing score, so little Johnny who hasn't had breakfast in 2 years being 5 points behind Jennifer who has a private nanny with a degree in early childhood education, is not a fair comparison.

But hey, limited spaces so...

Lottery systems are slightly more fair, but they also hurt disadvantaged groups. The real solution is to build enough gifted classrooms, in enough areas of the city, so that anyone who qualifies can attend, full stop.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by gnicholas on Friday August 12, 2022 @02:51PM (#32442503)
Yours is one experience. When I grew up in Sacramento, the best gifted programs were not in the wealthiest/whitest areas. My high school was in an area that had large black and Ukranian immigrant populations, and it also had the IB program. Some of the kids in the IB program were from that area, but others came from other areas, mostly wealthier. Same for my middle school and elementary school. They were not in 'desirable' areas, and most people who attended were from more well-off areas.
Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by com2kid on Friday August 12, 2022 @03:01PM (#32442636)
Agreed, the location of gifted programs is different in different cities.

Limited spaces and biased test results tend to be more universal problems.

IMHO NYC's solution of opening up more spaces is the best way to go.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by tbihl on Friday August 12, 2022 @09:17PM (#32445959)
>On the surface it sounds fair, the best get in, but in reality tests are always +/- a few points given day to day performance, and students who have worse home life (inadequate nutrition, lack of private educational resources, etc) already had to work harder to earn a passing score, so little Johnny who hasn't had breakfast in 2 years being 5 points behind Jennifer who has a private nanny with a degree in early childhood education, is not a fair comparison.

The point of these tests isn't to make fair comparisons of students' whole lives. They are designed (and succeed to varying degrees) to make fair comparisons of a particular skillset across students, hopefully in a way that is highly correlated to the task at hand. In a finite world, that is how you make good use of scarce resources.

Yes, this results in uneven outcomes. If we only have so much of a given resource (teacher time, facilities, learning resources, etc.) to dedicate, then putting the difficult but tailored material in front of Jennifer is a better use of resources than trying to accumulate enough second chances so that Johnny can eventually achieve escape velocity from his circumstances by happenstance.

Re:The unclear future for gifted-and-talented education by com2kid on Saturday August 13, 2022 @12:39AM (#32446951)
> If we only have so much of a given resource (teacher time, facilities, learning resources, etc.) to dedicate, then putting the difficult but tailored material in front of Jennifer is a better use of resources than trying to accumulate enough second chances so that Johnny can eventually achieve escape velocity from his circumstances by happenstance.

Except Jennifer is likely to do alright in life no matter what, while the opportunity afforded to Johnny can mean he escapes generational poverty.

Or we could just build enough classrooms so everyone gets the best education possible. As a bonus, this is long term profitable because Johnny goes on to pay a metric ton of taxes that pay for his education many times over.