News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by bink on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:35PM (#32400211)
> When we learned about this, we immediately investigated and fixed it. At that time, we had no evidence to suggest someone had taken advantage of the vulnerability.

> In July 2022, we learned through a press report that someone had potentially leveraged this and was offering to sell the information they had compiled. After reviewing a sample of the available data for sale, we confirmed that a bad actor had taken advantage of the issue before it was addressed.

Yikes. Sounds like they either didn't dig deep enough to see if it was exploited or they don't keep records long enough to be sure.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by AvImd on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:50PM (#32403291)
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by brian_cloutier on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:51PM (#32407389)
This link is not particularly relevant, as it talks about how the phrase "no evidence" is used within a specific community and that community has little overlap with the community which writes press releases after security incidents.

Security incident response teams do not have the same strange distinction between "real" evidence and the non-published non-peer-reviewed evidence which cannot be relied on or even really mentioned.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by londons_explore on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:41PM (#32400293)
Probably the latter - all companies operating in the EU have had short (ie. 30 days) retention policies on anything user-identifiable (ie. http logs) for a while now.

But if they didn't keep sufficient logs, they should have alerted the users back then, not now.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by grogenaut on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:48PM (#32403256)
AFAIK there are exceptions for many purposes, taxes, law enforcement, "critical business functions", etc of the 30 day window. Tax records, which can be quite PII and personal, need to be kept for ~7 years in the US for instance. Anything that needs to go to law enforcement stays around until the court case is over which can be longer.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by bink on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:23PM (#32400907)
AFAIK there is an exception for security purposes. They could be hashing or "anonymizing" the IPs and keep the data longer.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by AtNightWeCode on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:53PM (#32403337)
For security reasons IP addresses needs to be available in plain text. There is no time limit for how long time you can store the data, but you need to be able to motivate why.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by tick_tock_tick on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:27PM (#32401859)
No that's not valid at all! You must remove any trace of your ability to backwards engineering the IPs. Hashing isn't sufficient since it's so easy to run over the whole IPv4 space. This is one of the trade offs.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by 0x0 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:55PM (#32403379)
You could probably make the argument that you need to store http logs with cleartext IP addresses for more than 30 days for operational security and fraud detection reasons. I would certainly consider 180+ days of cleartext IP addresses quite necessary to be able to react to any security or abuse incidents.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by zaarn on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:38PM (#32402064)
You can if the hash collides within the IPv4 address space; ie it's a hash of less than about 16 bits. Enough to let your roughly see if something fishy is going on but you can't reverse engineer to any specific IP, only a set of 64 thousand.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by tick_tock_tick on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:30PM (#32404583)
That isn't good enough. By taking that hash and old request data combined with your current request logs it's enough to de-anonymization a significant portion of those logs making you not in compliance.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by zaarn on Wednesday August 17, 2022 @04:36AM (#32493830)
Data from the past few days we do have a legitimate interest in; protecting our network. If someone is spamming us we need to be able to find out who did it and the only way to do that is deanonymized logs to begin with. Atleast in my workplace we have worked with the DPA to ensure that we are in compliance and there is no issue in keeping around 7 days of IP logs without further anonymization. All or long term logs are hashed below the bit minimum, and that can't be paired with old request data as easily since we strip all but major version identifiers from User Agents, for example.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by heurisko on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:51PM (#32402251)
Wouldn't salting mitigate this?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by 0x457 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:09PM (#32403551)
If something uniquely identifies someone, it's considered a PII and a salted (but still useful) hash of the IP address is that. At least under GDPR. That means you will need to throw away the salt and have different salt for every instance. At that point, you might as well replace with a random string, and that isn't very useful.

"In the context of the European GDPR the Article 29 Working Party has stated that while the technique of salting and then hashing data “reduce[s] the likelihood of deriving the input value,” because “calculating the original attribute value hidden behind the result of a salted hash function may still be feasible within reasonable means,” the salted-hashed output should be considered pseudonymized data that remains subject to the GDPR."

Under CCPA, I think that is enough, HOWEVER, business must implement business processes that specifically prohibit reidentification. So again, not useful at all in this case.

The question should be is IP address a PII or not. Under CCPA and GDPR it is, but only if it “identifies, relates to, describes, is reasonably capable of being associated with, or could reasonably be linked, directly or indirectly, with a particular consumer or household.”

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by hertzrat on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:31PM (#32403856)
Out of curiosity, why is it only 5M and not 500M? You would think the same vulnerability applied to every server, not just one or one cluster, if they are using automated deployments
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by uncletammy on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:44PM (#32404750)
Could be a time intensive exploit. Maybe they didn't have enough time to mine the other 455M.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by alex_young on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:58PM (#32404928)
The rest are bot accounts right?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by LegitShady on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:13PM (#32406384)
Doing it slowly over time to not raise an alarm and collect the information, rather than twitter noticing a massive upticks in password resets that don’t go through?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by addingnumbers on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @12:58PM (#32400542)
"We have no evidence that this was exploited" is a standard psychological trick they pull in vulnerability announcements to give an unfounded impression that it hasn't been exploited.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by hunter2_ on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @01:16PM (#32400809)
I always wonder who "we" refers to in that usage, legally speaking. Does it refer only to a subset of employees / board members who are authorized to speak for the company? Because then even if someone analyzing logs sees something damning, if middle management is trained to stop that knowledge from reaching the top, then those speaking for the company can continue saying "we" didn't know it.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by gonzo41 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:12PM (#32406800)
Tech needs regulation like the finance industry in this regard. Regulation that can push responsibility for breaches up the chain. There must be ways to escalate and if something is seen and reported but not acted on, then liability goes upwards. CEO's in Finance and Banking do A LOT of compliance work and it does catch a lot of problems.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by lrvick on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:41PM (#32404003)
I have 100% seen this happen.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by johndhi on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:08PM (#32404326)
really? what do you mean 'middle management is trained to keep that from getting to the top'? intentional malfeasance?

where I work people are trying their best but dealing with complex systems, memories, and methods of communication. because of this, security issues are sometimes missed, sometimes poorly communicated, and sometimes poorly remediated.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by NikolaNovak on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:09PM (#32406347)
I guess to poster's claim, "I have seen this happen" is an existential claim, not a universal one.

Fwiw, I've ended up being "middle management" at a large company, with deep technical background, and I'm trained and incentivized to report, escalate, inform, communicate, share, and otherwise ensure its addressed up the bloody wazoo. I get slapped on the hand for not communicating / informing enough, never for communicating too much. Over 2 decades, I've never seen my executives try to cover something. "Manage the narrative", sure, but that's largely about how they craft a sentence, not about not reporting.

However, I have also witnessed corporate culture in other places (as embedded consultant) where each layer is terrified of layer above, and each layer is heavily punished for reporting "bad news". They were institutionally set up to fail project deployment as risks are not escalated and they proudly plunge forward. They're not sure much top-down knowingly obstructed to hide stuff, as much as electroshock therapied that it's a bad experience. Taking the most cursory log at the most basic logs and saying "whee, no evidence of exploit!!" Would be par for the course :-/

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by hobs on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:12PM (#32404396)
Almost all companies operate with an extremely low level of trust and most places are blame, shame, and ultimately game the system all the way down.

Hiding something often takes years to uncover and by then management has moved on, maybe even to their second company!

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by t-3 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @07:38PM (#32406083)
Probably not 'trained' as much as 'heavily incentivized'. Nobody wants to be the messenger that gets shot for bringing bad news. Much easier to cover up and tell the big boss what they want to hear as long as you can.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by throwawaylinux on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:21PM (#32406432)
This certainly happens. If you speak to a corporate lawyer about a potentially sensitive issue, they will encourage you to use the phone, don't put anything in writing, and don't tell anybody especially not higher ups in the company, until you sort things out with them first.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:54PM (#32406670)
> don't tell anybody especially not higher ups in the company

As a non-lawyer, that sure sounds like sketchy advice, even beyond the rest.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by throwawaylinux on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:04PM (#32407107)
How so?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by kadoban on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @12:44AM (#32407927)
Seems both ethically questionable and maybe not the best strategy for the individual if they're being instructed to keep information to themselves instead of passing it up the chain in the company. Is that intended to keep just that employee responsible for whatever mess?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by throwawaylinux on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @03:31AM (#32408798)
> Seems both ethically questionable

Right, but how so? A person or company can get into trouble with things being written down or made known to others. Having a lawyer consider it first is legally prudent and is entirely reasonable and common advice given out to any person (don't speak to police/regulator/other party/internet/newspaper/etc before consulting your lawyer). If you think that's ethically sound advice for a person, then what changes the calculus for a corporation?

> and maybe not the best strategy for the individual if they're being instructed to keep information to themselves instead of passing it up the chain in the company. Is that intended to keep just that employee responsible for whatever mess?

Probably less instructed to keep it to yourself, more encouraged to stick to "official" reporting channels, and then when you do that or come into contact with such issues by other means, more encouragement to use the phone.

And it completely depends on what it is as to the intention I guess. Initially so that the lawyers are able to consider and advise. But sure you aren't paying the lawyer so they are only taking care of your interests so far as that coincides with the company's interests. So if you had a concern that you would be responsible for a legal problem, or are a victim of a criminal or civil legal matter from the company or another person in it, then I would say you should consider discussing that with your own lawyer.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by redler on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @07:41PM (#32406108)
It means silos and information hiding are baked in — as a matter of corporate culture — at least in part to preserve the option of plausible deniability for statements like Twitter’s.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by Dudeman112 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:28PM (#32401873)
It doesn't have to be a psychological trick. Sometimes you don't actually have evidence it was exploited - at which point what are you meant to say?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by addingnumbers on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:50PM (#32402229)
It would be more honest to say "We aren't able to determine whether it was exploited" which could better brace potentially impacted users for the possibility they might be affected.

This is a relatively benign case but the same language is used in other breaches when people should be taking measures like freezing their credit or reviewing financial transactions.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by sangnoir on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:37PM (#32403061)
How can anyone make any assertions about unknown unknowns?

It's one thing to say "My car was stolen", and another to declare "I am unable to determine if it's en route to the Taliban."

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by upsidesinclude on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:06PM (#32403514)
That isn't a reasonable analogy in any way.

The only thing that could happen with the data would be that it is exploited.

The only thing that happens to stolen cars is not going to the taliban.

These are not even similar in nature. They aren't saying "the data was stolen". They also aren't saying "the data was available for exploit we are unable to determine if that occured."

What if they never looked for evidence of unauthorized access? They wouldn't have any!

This is the same as modern science and medicine frequently using this academic phrase, no evidence, when what they mean is that there has been no investigation.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by autoexec on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:01PM (#32404239)
It's more like saying "I left my car in a shady neighborhood unattended for 72 hours with the doors open and the key left in the ignition but I haven't been keeping track of the millage or the fuel level so I'm not aware that anyone used it while I was away."

Nothing would have stopped someone from using it. Probably best to assume that they have.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by execveat on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:13PM (#32403612)
You can make positive assertions though. E.g. attack might have been simple in which case it's possible to produce indicators that cover 100% of variants. Or it could have been complex and indicators either don't cover every possible attack or they produce large number of false positives.

Another thing to mention would be how long in the past you were able to look. E.g. in this case they have found out that the bug was introduced in 2021, were they able to inspect logs covering all of that period or did they only had limited logs/other evidence so it's impossible to know whether anyone used this opportunity or not?

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by Lutger on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:08PM (#32404332)
Its not an unknown unknown. If there's a vulnerability and you're a hot target, you know there's a decent chance of getting exploited.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by dumbfounder on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:11PM (#32406360)
How about we don’t use terse language and a short blog post to describe a complex thing and instead talk about what happened, what you did to investigate, WHY you couldn’t determine if it was exploited, and what the heck you intend to do about it? How about some facts and transparency? How about some real honesty?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by Sebb767 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:03PM (#32406737)
> instead talk about what happened, what you did to investigate, WHY you couldn’t determine if it was exploited, and what the heck you intend to do about it?

This will be read by optimistically 1% of people, the rest will just catch the summary. This way, you at least get to write the summary.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by TecoAndJix on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:11PM (#32406791)
"At this time, there is no obvious evidence of malicious activity"
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by roughly on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:40PM (#32402087)
Well, “after investigating by <insert actual efforts taken here>, we were unable to find evidence it was exploited” would be a good start, as it would indicate some effort was put into disproving the hypothesis.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by kbenson on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:56PM (#32402319)
It provides close to nothing, because it doesn't indicate whether there was no evidence because there could be no evidence - you keep no logs - or whether there was no evidence in spite of the fact there definitely should be if it was exploited because of copious information kept that would show it.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by posix86 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:54PM (#32402295)
I'm 100% certain they did put in actual effort. If you're so keen on knowing, there's a form at the bottom you can use to ask them.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:59PM (#32406704)
Then they should share a bit about what they researched and how confident they are one way or another.

Seems like a fair expectation to have, to me.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by jazzyjackson on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:43PM (#32402138)
"we have no way of knowing" is a much more informative statement than "we have no evidence", but it belies fallibility on the part of the speaker.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by redler on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @07:52PM (#32406224)
“We have no evidence” strongly implies some sort of extensive forensic dance was performed, and was fruitless. “We have no way of knowing” sounds much more like epistemological resignation. “Evidence” is a pretty loaded word to use.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by mewpmewp2 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:25PM (#32403774)
"We have no way of knowing" may not be correct statement. There could always be a way to know that you may have missed. It would be inhuman to claim "we have no way of knowing" in circumstances like this.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by jazzyjackson on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:15PM (#32404434)
Fair enough, perhaps to be more specific they could say "we have not kept sufficiently detailed logs to determine what happened"
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by diego_sandoval on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:38PM (#32403077)
The burden of proof should fall on them to demonstrate that it wasn't exploited.

Otherwise, the reasonable thing to do is to assume that it was exploited, because they have no evidence to show that it wasn't.

The phrase is a psychological trick because it creates the illusion that the burden of proof falls on the other side.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by res0nat0r on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:40PM (#32403114)
You can't prove a negative.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by bandrami on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @11:01PM (#32407443)
There is no greatest prime number.

If there were, call it p, and let q = Π(P), P∈N:P is prime (Eratosthenes showed this is computable)

Then q+1 % 1 modulo every lesser prime, meaning q+1 is prime, and p is thus not the greatest prime.

There you go. We have just proven a negative.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by mannykannot on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:17PM (#32403648)
In which case, the second paragraph applies.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by kadoban on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:03PM (#32406732)
But then you might as well just assume everything is compromised, at all times, even if there's been no announcement. They could just not be telling you.

Which is maybe not the worst strategy, but it's going to be pretty exhausting.

I'd suggest that instead we should just expect and enforce a certain amount of openness and honesty from companies when they fuck up in this way, so we can make informed decisions.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by mannykannot on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @08:32AM (#32410829)
Well, yes - this is the dilemma which is not resolved with empty platitudes, even though "you can't prove a negative."

In the US and elsewhere, there are already some penalties for covering up a problem, and they should be expanded commensurately with the potential harm.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by Tenobrus on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:44PM (#32402143)
I mean in practice what it tends to mean is the logs only had a 3 month ttl so really could be either way. "no evidence" implies there is at least a place there could have been evidence, they looked, and didn't find any, which is a weak but nonzero update towards it having not happened. It would be nice if they clarified exactly what they checked.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by autoexec on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:10PM (#32404359)
> "no evidence" implies there is at least a place there could have been evidence, they looked, and didn't find any

Yeah I'd never assume that any of that is true. Sure, there probably are ways twitter could find out if something has been being exploited like evidence in server logs or new batches of accounts showing up for sale on the black market, but I wouldn't trust that they looked for them, or that they looked very hard, or that the person making press statements was told about it either way.

If a company has a financial incentive to not find information it's weird to assume they'd seriously look or be trusted to be honest about what they found.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by lewantmontreal on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:40PM (#32402088)
’We have no proof this wasn’t exploited’
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by JuettnerDistrib on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:02PM (#32407101)
Other purpose than being a psychological trick, what purpose could pointing out the lack of evidence at the time have? Instead they could have written something like "We found the problem in 2021 and promptly fixed it. We first learned that it has been exploited in 2022."
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by throwaway292939 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:01PM (#32402410)
The phrasing is a bit more specific.. "At that time, we had no evidence.."

It could also mean "oh I spent five minutes looking into it and didn't see any evidence"

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by htrp on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:08PM (#32402545)
thats a lawyered up comment
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by jacquesm on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:27PM (#32402886)
As are most PR statements by companies when discussing breaches publicly.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by themitigating on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:31PM (#32401928)
No, that's a normal statement when there's no evidence something occurred.

"I have no evidence he murdered someone"

As opposed to

"He might have murdered someone, or not, I just don't have any evidence"

"It's possible he murdered someone I don't have any evidence though"

"I don't have any evidence he murdered someone but that doesn't mean he didn't, I'm just asking questions"

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by diffeomorphism on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:12PM (#32402618)
That is not a normal statement if it is your company's fault the question even came up.

"We left a giant tub filled with cyanide completely unsupervised in front of our door for months. We have no evidence that it was used to murder someone."

Has an entirely different sound to it, no?

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by pcthrowaway on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:00PM (#32403433)
More like the tub was filled with water and "we have no evidence it was used to drown someone (but also we didn't check for floating bodies)"
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by lostcolony on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:15PM (#32403635)
"We left our gun outside, unsecured, but no one has complained they were shot with it and we didn't detect any fingerprints on it when we finally noticed it wasn't locked up properly"
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by themitigating on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:16PM (#32407187)
Now you're claiming they didn't investigate properly which a completely different situation that you also don't have evidence for.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by rrix2 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:20PM (#32403709)
or: "keeping fine grained indexed API logs around for months on end is too expensive so we threw out the body with the bathwater"
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by themitigating on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:15PM (#32407185)
How does it have a different sound?

"We left a giant tub filled with cyanide completely unsupervised in front of our door for months. We have no evidence that it was used to murder someone."

No one would say that second sentence, if you don't have evidence of something you don't state that because of the set of objects and events that didn't happen is infinite.

"We left a giant tub filled with cyanide completely unsupervised in front of our door for months. We have no evidence that someone accidentally fell into it, an animal died in it, it was used in a bank robbery, someone's cell phone slipped it in............"

"That person owns a gun legally, we have no evidence that he used it to murder someone"

Why not

"

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by diffeomorphism on Wednesday August 10, 2022 @02:00AM (#32408247)
What was your train of thought from "we made a giant mistake. We have no evidence of consequences, yet." to "that person owns a gun legally"?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by execveat on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:03PM (#32403472)
It doesn't tell you whether they have actively investigated the incident though. And if they did, how thorough they were.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by asddubs on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:47PM (#32404062)
I wonder, if you destroy all the evidence this was exploited, can you still claim you don't have any evidence this was exploited? Asking for opinions from non-lawyers only please
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by Bedon292 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:48PM (#32404790)
Don't currently have? Sure. The quote says "At that time, we had no evidence" so I think that would be harder to argue. You could maybe make the case the statement means: At that specific moment we didn't have any evidence because we already destroyed it. But it certainly implies they mean they had not found any before that point in time.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by Lutger on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:05PM (#32404283)
To be sure, use a clean room implementation: let IT destroy all the evidence, always. Then legal can claim 'we don't have any evidence'.

source: I am not a lawyer

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by procombo on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:24PM (#32404525)
Works the same way with government. The "I am not aware of ..." is a great trick for when your organization is intentionally silod. The folks who get subpoenaed are left out of detailed info. It's a complete non-statement.

I could bring up examples across both sides of the isle. It's all a big game.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by johndhi on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:09PM (#32404343)
haha. I am a lawyer so sorry, but while you might be able to claim that, you are legally and ethically obligated to also divulge the intentional spoiling of hte evidence.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by justinclift on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @05:56PM (#32404912)
As if the people giving orders at some of these companies care about ethics... ;)
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by harry8 on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @09:13PM (#32406802)
It would be a lot more convincing if they said they put a team on to it to investigate extensively and didn't find anything indicating it was exploited.

Absence of evidence IS some evidence of absence if you look thoroughly. It sure isn't anything of the kind if you haven't actually tried to gather the evidence or are aware of giant holes in what you were able to gather.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by resonious on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @08:52PM (#32406646)
Yes, potentially a euphemism for "we did not check to see if this was exploited, and thereby have no evidence it was exploited."
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by drivebycomment on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:42PM (#32403153)
Suppose Twitter did all it could to investigate and found no evidence. What would you rather have Twitter say in that case ?
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by i_s on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:52PM (#32403315)
Saying there is an absence of evidence (of a leak) isn't useful by itself unless they also indicate whether that is evidence of absence (of a leak). I.e., they should indicate whether it is likely that they would have caught it if a leak had occured (e.g., via extensive logging).
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by addingnumbers on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:46PM (#32403225)
"We are unable to determine if the vulnerability was exploited."

How hard they looked is not of any consequence if they can't tell it wasn't exploited.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by thayne on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:05PM (#32403487)
Provide some level of detail on how they looked for evidence. "We have no evidence" could mean "we didn't bother looking for evidence", or "we looked extensively for evidence, but didn't find any." In fact, the company has an incentive not to keep logs or collect evidence specifically so they can truthfully claim they don't have any evidence of a breach
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by criddell on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:27PM (#32403811)
"We assume it was exploited and you should too."
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by behringer on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:12PM (#32403587)
How many man hours they spent investigating would be good.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by badrabbit on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @10:41PM (#32407336)
It's not a trick. Incident response (not vulnerability announcement) is all about evidence. If you can't prove it, it didn't happen. They can probably stil take precautionary measures though which the announcement is part of.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by cush on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:05PM (#32403502)
Absolutely. That said, it's very very hard sometimes to prove a negative.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by antisthenes on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:17PM (#32401700)
"an absence of evidence is not evidence of absence"

Isn't that taught in..uh..I dunno, middle school science class?

Just because you don't see the rabbit, doesn't mean it doesn't exist.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by themitigating on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:33PM (#32401962)
No, that's insane. That means I can just tell people you might have raped someone, I don't have any evidence but that doesn't mean it didn't happen.

https://medicine.uq.edu.au/article/2019/04/you-look-do-not-f...

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by addingnumbers on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:53PM (#32402277)
That's why I referred to it as a psychological trick.

They should be open and forthcoming about their level of confidence, instead of using the least worrying language they can offer while remaining technically correct.

Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by intelVISA on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @04:45PM (#32404044)
The database just dropped itself automagically
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by nolok on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @02:23PM (#32401793)
You seem to believe "we had no evidence to suggest someone had taken advantage of the vulnerability" implies "we looked for any evidence of it", it doesn't, not in that case nor in any similar situation.
Re:An incident impacting 5M accounts and private information... by grogenaut on Tuesday August 09, 2022 @03:41PM (#32403132)
Or they don't monitor that system for that type of access at all and so literally don't know.