News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:45PM (#3236042)
In the past, I've spent a fair bit of time criticizing Google for calling Android "open source", but not releasing the source. Now that it appears that they are actually doing it, let me be the first to say that this is great.

Well done, Google.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by vladd on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:59PM (#3236095)
What people criticized about them was the delay of an open source release to sustain their business strategy (commoditize their products' complements via open source but keep a integrated experience by proprietary early-access agreements - see also http://www.joelonsoftware.com/articles/StrategyLetterV.html ).

This release doesn't change Google's strategy nor the fact that they will continue to release Android's source code in the future with a significant delay compared to early-access partners. There's no reason to congratulate them now nor complain louder some months from now, they'll continue to do what makes sense for them from a business standpoint. The only news are the yet-to-be-discovered jewels in the just-released source code.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by generalk on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:57PM (#3236945)

  > This release doesn't change Google's strategy nor the 
  > fact that they will continue to release Android's source 
  > code in the future with a significant delay compared to 
  > early-access partners.
As of today there is not a single phone on the market that runs Android 4.0. Besides, open-source does not mean open-development. They have every right to release the code to whomever they want, whenever they want. And because they release the source to most (as of now, 3/4) major releases, that absolutely counts as "open source."
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by greyish_water on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:38AM (#3237423)
Besides, open-source does not mean open-development.

Google has done a lot to confuse this by referring to everything as just "open". They were still calling Android open even when it didn't meet Andy Rubin's own tweeted 'definition of open'.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by bad_user on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:41AM (#3237557)
"open" is an overloaded term that doesn't mean anything nowadays. "open source" on the other hand has a clear definition and Android definitely fits that definition.

Even yesterday, when Android 3/4 was not available as open-source, Android 2.2 and 2.3 which are the most deployed versions were definitely available as open-source.

And this is relevant, because that's the power of open-source. If you're unhappy with how Google is managing the project you do have the right to fork it. Amazon did just that. Xorg also came into existence that way, amongst other projects.

And yes, it takes resources and you've got to make it popular somehow and that ain't easy and I also fear that Google may close future versions of Android completely, but is it mature enough for a fork to be possible and to survive? Hell yes. Can the parent (Google) attack forks based on patents? No, because the Apache license protects you from that scenario (it's a little ironic that a pro-commercial license is safer than GPL v.2)

Which is why I consider Android to be a lot more "open" than the other 2 alternatives floating around, iOS and WinMo. That's my own definition anyway, which is why I began by highlighting the meaninglessness of the word.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Supermighty on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:18AM (#3238222)
The GPL v.2 was written in a time when it was rare that patents were wielded as weapons.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by fluidcruft on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:03PM (#3238960)
Yeah, it's too bad that people won't just migrate to GPLv3. The GPLv3 codified the FSF's working practice of allowing continued use if the offender comes into compliance. Following the letter of the GPLv2 is much more severe. Fortunately, I don't think anyone's ever really insisted on enforcing GPLv2's termination clauses and Linus and most other major GPLv2 projects seem inclined to follow the FSF's model. I don't think FSF will cause trouble--but lawyer-led asshole behavior seems to be on the rise.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by roflharrison on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:42PM (#3236393)
Some people criticized AOSP because they believe the delayed release is unfair (a reasonable criticism). Other people (sheep) criticized them because they actually believed Google was never going to release more source or because needed an arguing point against the OS.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by zobzu on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:38PM (#3236551)
Actually until Google releases the source you can never be sure if they're going to release it.

They release this time.. you and I can only hope that they keep doing it in the future. It wouldn't be all that surprising if it would go closed source (except for key partners) at some point (and except for the GPL content).

Specially when any company could just rip the source, make it nicer looking and release their own version of Android and close the source on that... oh look it has a name, it's called MIUI!

Imagine if many cheap Chinese manufacturers release decent phones with it, that cost 3x cheaper than the rest, and no Google stuff inside, no control, yada yada. Well, personally I'd get one :-)

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by bad_user on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:06AM (#3237615)

     It wouldn't be all that surprising if it would 
     go closed source
As with anything in life, there are forces that prevent them from doing that. Also, the whole point of open-source is the right to "fork" which trumps all other freedoms you might have.

Xorg came into existence because of disagreements with the XFree86 license, while XFree86 died ... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X.Org_Server#History

     Specially when any company could just rip the source
Few companies can do that because few companies have the resources to do it. Nokia is a monster amongst phone makers and they weren't able to make their own OS, even when their own survival depended on it. These companies using Android depend on base Android to remain open-source, they made an investment in Android because it was supposed to be an open standard, which is why Google must also play nice, otherwise they risk forks. And in case you haven't noticed, Amazon just forked Android, so it's not unheard of.

You see, forks from small players cannot survive because they'll lack the advantages of the main branch (especially the Marketplace). On the other hand, Google must play nice because a fork coming from an alliance between several of these players can kill the main branch.

    Imagine if many cheap Chinese manufacturers release 
    decent phones with it, that cost 3x cheaper than 
    the rest
Considering that most phone manufacturers are assembling their phones in China, what would prevent them from also releasing cheap phones?

Also, most people don't want cheap. Most people want reliable and affordable, which is why iPhones and Galaxy S2 are selling quite well, even though there are cheaper alternatives on the market, even from trusted brands. Consumers don't want the cheapest products, instead they want the best value/price ratio (as long as they can afford it). Making an analogy with cars, there's always going to be a big market for Audi, BMW and Mercedes. Some people even prefer to buy second-hand cars from these brands, instead of a cheaper but out-of-the-factory alternative. That says a lot.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by stouset on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:42PM (#3240407)
> Also, the whole point of open-source is the right to "fork" which trumps all other freedoms you might have.

No. That is the whole point of free software. The point of open source is just that the source code is made freely available.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by hetman on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:39PM (#3237052)
I'd like to understand why Google didn't use a copyleft licence.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by wmf on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:01AM (#3237106)
Phone makers were afraid of copyleft for various reasons, mostly irrational. Also, copyleft probably wouldn't help Google's goal of getting as many Android devices in the market as possible.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ConstantineXVI on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:26AM (#3238256)
A viral license actually could have been a much more effective carrot/stick tool for Google vs. their current situation (early source access, carrier contracts, etc.). Play ball with us (Market, etc.), and we'll give you a full closed-source license. Otherwise, we expect to see full source of your modifications made available per the GPL.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by megablast on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:29AM (#3237660)
No, what the OP and I have criticized them for is not releasing the code for 4. If you are unable to understand this, that is your problem. Google have done good. What you are talking about is another issue, and an important one, but it does not change the fact that WE HAVE CRITICIZED them for exactly what the OP said.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by shareme on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:13PM (#3236299)
ahem if you check mobile dev history you will find Nokia did the same thing with open source Symbian, etc..

No viable successful open source mobile OS gives equal access to public and OEM partners to a private tree

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by hrktb on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:35PM (#3236371)
Well, if Nokia boasted about Symbian's openness, they were in the position to be criticized too. It's mostly a PR problem.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Steko on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:50PM (#3236406)
"No viable successful open source mobile OS gives equal access to public and OEM partners to a private tree"

This is a true statement but you've set the bar pretty low there with 4 qualifiers.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by foobarbazetc on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:12PM (#3236468)
And look how well that turned out for Nokia.

Oh, wait...

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by cookiecaper on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:56PM (#3236084)
You know that Honeycomb was the only distribution for which Google did not release the source, right?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ubernostrum on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:17PM (#3236665)
So... call me crazy, but I think it's wrong to praise a project which claims to be open-source for, um, actually releasing source. And honestly, the fact that we've come to this indicates just how completely Google has failed at being an open-source citizen.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by jeffdavis on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:12AM (#3237252)
"And honestly, the fact that we've come to this indicates just how completely Google has failed at being an open-source citizen."

If you can download the source, distribute it, modify it, collaborate, and install the modified version easily on your device; then it's a quantum leap forward from any other mass-market mobile device.

In my opinion, that's huge. Right now, google is offering you the ability to actually know what your phone is doing (a huge issue when it comes to government or corporate surveillance), and puts everyone on a level playing field when it comes to writing applications and improvements, and it will likely speed up the convergence of networks so that everything is data (thus eliminating the separate billing for voice and SMS).

Eventually there will be more open, collaborative development. But let's have some patience -- PC's took a long time to be liberated (even now, many people think linux is "not ready for the desktop" and it has a small share). What google is doing is bringing linux to everyone on a new platform and already getting real market share. That's no small achievement.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by orangecat on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:37PM (#3236724)
And honestly, the fact that we've come to this indicates just how completely Google has failed at being an open-source citizen.

Actually it just indicates the large number of analysts/trolls who were confidently proclaiming that Google would never release Android source again.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by roflharrison on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:53PM (#3236937)
The code we are talking about is under an Apache 2.0 licence, they didn't have to release anything.

"open-source citizen" is in the eye of the beholder, if you are a die hard FOSS advocate then yes, they have failed. If you are happy with code being released when it is deemed ready (of course readiness in this case might have been influenced by marketing factors) then they have been quite successful.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:31PM (#3236707)
Yeah, I see your point. But I think it would be lame for me to make fun of them for a year (or however long Honeycomb has existed in closed-source form) and then not at least acknowledge that they did finally release the source. I said "well done," but maybe "at least you're in compliance with the GPL" would be more appropriate.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ubernostrum on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:32PM (#3236711)
"Well done, you've put in the bare minimum amount of effort required to still get away with the open-source moniker" is not particularly flattering...
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:40PM (#3236731)
You are correct. That is approximately my feeling about the situation, but, like giving a dog a treat when it behaves well, I think it's good to praise companies for behaving adequately because I think it increases the chances that they will keep doing it.

You hear that, diBona? Keep releasing the code!

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by orangecat on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:38PM (#3236728)
They've always been in compliance with the GPL; the Honeycomb kernel sources were always available.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:43PM (#3236737)
I hadn't heard that. Is that verifiable by any means at this point?

It still doesn't justify the "open source" moniker, but it's still good.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by wmf on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:14PM (#3236843)
The kernel source was at http://android.git.kernel.org/ but that server was subsequently destroyed in an unrelated incident and at this point you'd need a time machine to verify that it was really there and hasn't just been backdated, but yeah, it was available.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by dtparr on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:53PM (#3237087)
I suppose they could have backdated google groups, but here is JBQ's announcement of the 3.2 GPL's parts being released in July. http://groups.google.com/group/android-building/msg/6410b447...

And here's a thread discussing building the 3.1 GPL'd code in May. http://groups.google.com/group/android-building/browse_threa...

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:37AM (#3238013)
Thanks for the links; they're convincing. I'm surprised that Google hasn't made their GPL compliance here more prominent. It's something I've heard criticized, but it sounds like the criticisms are illegitimate.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by kennystone on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:33PM (#3236365)
Right, no coincidence a year's backlog of updates comes out on the same day Amazon ships their tablet. Good luck to Amazon with merge.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by fpgeek on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:35PM (#3236541)
Of course it isn't coincidence. It's not like there's a major shopping season (when people often buy new electronics) that might be influencing both Google's and Amazon's schedules or anything.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by roflharrison on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:16PM (#3236472)
Interesting point, especially considering Google specifically said the source would not be available until the Galaxy Nexus was out.

>year's backlog

This is inaccurate, they have been releasing patches and updates for other versions of the platform over the last year.

They did skip Honeycomb, which fits your Amazon theory, mind you, from the reviews I have read the Fire would not benefit greatly from ICS as they Frankensteined the Android experience.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by fpgeek on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:42PM (#3236564)
The Galaxy Nexus is hitting stores in the UK on the 17th so the release is only a few days early. It wouldn't surprise me to find out that they got done a little early and decided to "push the button" anyway.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by snotrockets on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @10:14AM (#3238434)
Just received an email from clove.co.uk stating that the UK release (at least for the SIM unlocked version) was pushed back to the 23rd.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ConstantineXVI on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:30AM (#3238268)
It won't be any more difficult for Amazon than it will be for any other OEM; phones are merging in from 2.3 as well. And that's making the assumption Amazon actually cares about being in sync with AOSP.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by s00pcan on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:00PM (#3236098)
I never had any doubt that they would.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Iv on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:05AM (#3237237)
I doubt they released the 3G stack part though.

Unless I can't make a 3G equivalent to wireshark I'll have a hard time calling the platform open.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by mcs on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:19AM (#3237386)
I don't know of any phones being sold that have open source basebands.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ansible on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:56AM (#3237704)
I can say with some confidence that an open source baseband will never happen. The carriers won't allow it, and there is good (technical) justification for that. Basically, it is easy to mess up some "tiny" detail of the standard, and disrupt the local network for all nearby users. The compliance testing needed for any phone is huge and expensive.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Iv on Friday November 25, 2011 @03:23AM (#3276574)
That doesn't change my point : none of them are completely open source.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by drivebyacct2 on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:49PM (#3236230)
They've open sourced every version but Honeycomb and had reasons for doing so.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by rwolf on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:32PM (#3236530)
The only stated reason I've heard is "the code is ugly," which was found to be... unconvincing here on HN. Are you aware of another reason, specifically one which would be convincing?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by enjo on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:27AM (#3237397)
It had everything to do with fragmentation. Honeycomb (by Googles admission) was a stop-gap to get something out for tablets. They chose not to release the source as they wanted to limit the number of devices shipping with honeycomb in favor of a more compatible (and developer friendly) version in ICS.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:50AM (#3237578)
How is that related to fragmentation?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by esrauch on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @03:55PM (#3240169)
If you are writing an app for phones you don't have to target honeycomb at all, that is reduced fragmentation.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by drivebyacct2 on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @05:42PM (#3240701)
Ah, I assumed enjo was saying it as a negative.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by adgar on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:00PM (#3236615)
The stated reason wasn't that the code was ugly, it's that it didn't translate to phones at all; Honeycomb was only ever really good for tablets. There was concern that manufacturers/homebrewers would put it on phones and that doing so would make android look like shit.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by burgerbrain on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:37PM (#3236894)
By that logic they should have never released the source code for any of Android, since Android is shit on desktop PCs.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by hetman on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:45PM (#3237069)
Which would be true if everyone was clambering to run Android on their PCs.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by imurray on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:29PM (#3235994)
[dead] comment by cdibona: "Please don't sync yet, it's currently in a mixed state. The 'repo for-all git push' is still running and will take some time to complete, so if you sync now you'll get some parts with Gingerbread and some parts with ICS."

(If you accidentally post something twice, be careful about deleting one. The other one may be automatically killed, but you don't see it when your posts are killed.)

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by angryasian on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:31PM (#3236182)
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by wx77 on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:48PM (#3236052)
It looks like it happened because he posted the same thing twice in different threads, not because he deleted it.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by cdibona on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:30PM (#3236179)
That's correct. It wasn't clear which one was going to end up on the front page and I was covering the bases.

Stand by :-)

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pasbesoin on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:31PM (#3236000)
Why is Chris DiBona's comment in this thread dead? What he said is "from the horse's mouth", i.e. Google Open Source.

Comment: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3235947

Profile: http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=cdibona

Personal site (includes mention of his job): http://www.dibona.com/

P.S. Chris, you have http://dibona.com in your HN profile, but it just redirects.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by hollerith on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:03PM (#3236107)
>Why is Chris DiBona's comment in this thread dead?

He posted the same text in 2 comments (in two different threads). Probably the second of the 2 was a victim of an automatic dup detector/killer.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pasbesoin on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:04PM (#3236112)
Interesting. I wasn't aware that HN checks comments across threads. Makes sense.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by cdibona on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:31PM (#3236181)
I guess I'll start salting my dupe comments :-)
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by bostonvaulter2 on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:55PM (#3236600)
You can salt them by including a link to the previous comment you made :)
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by cppsnob on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:12AM (#3237251)
Related: how's Apple's "open" FaceTime specification coming along? Still waiting on just the specification here. Not even code.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by greyish_water on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:18AM (#3237384)
Troll.

(Edit: You'll downvote me, but not the troll? WTF?)

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by wgren on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @06:37AM (#3237877)
One word (or few word) posts like "Troll", "Fanboy", "This", or "LOL" are frowned on at Hacker News because they don't add anything to the discussion.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by decklin on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:20PM (#3236671)
There are two links to this post on the front page right now. This one, https://groups.google.com/forum/#!topic/android-building/T4X... , loads fine on my computer and comes up in the "new" Google visual design. It completely fails on my phone (Android 2.3), displaying "Loading..." for a while and then bumping me to the front page of Google Groups with a little message saying I am now logged in (I tried several times). The other link, https://groups.google.com/group/android-building/msg/c0e01b4... , just works, everywhere, but shows the old Groups interface.

This is a really sad state of affairs. If Google can't guarantee that their fancy new Javascript-dependent links won't work everywhere, they should not be used as permalinks.

I really don't care about any arguments people might want to make about the visual redesign, or how to properly implement #! paths, or the extra effort involved in generating resilient URLs, or Google paying special attention to how the Android browser handles pages, or what evil things my phone company might be doing my my data stream, and how that's not their fault, or whatever. Permalinks should work. Everywhere. Period.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by rst on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:14PM (#3236994)
Not _quite_ full source code --- some proprietary graphics drivers are supplied in binary-only form. It won't matter much for most uses of the source code, but purists will be displeased.

http://source.android.com/source/building-devices.html

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Maakuth on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:50AM (#3237694)
That is probably not in Google's hands to change. It's the same with the vendor-supplied GPU drivers in desktop Linux as well.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Iv on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:09AM (#3237246)
I guess that the netowrk modules that handle GSM and 3G packets are out of the open source code also. That is disappointing too.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by juliano_q on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:20PM (#3236672)
Google releases every source code except Honeycomb. I think the code was really ugly, released urgently to support tablets. I cant blame Google, we who works with software in big companies know how pressure and strict timelines can be a pain, but I am glad that things are back on track.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:33PM (#3236717)
I agree that pressure and strict timelines can be a pain, but compliance with the GPL is not optional.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by guelo on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:57AM (#3237225)
Only Android's modifications to the Linux kernel and a few other tools are under GPL. Most stuff is Apache 2.0.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by vog on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:55AM (#3237459)
That's what Google used to tell us, but according to the guys of gpl-violations.org, this has always been a flat-out lie. Those "few other tools under GPL" are quite a lot and in no way negligible.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by recoiledsnake on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:39PM (#3236730)
They released the GPL parts.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:45PM (#3236742)
I hadn't heard that. Is that verifiable at this point by some means?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ben1040 on Monday November 14, 2011 @11:44PM (#3237065)
They've made posts in the android-building Google group when making GPL code drops. Here is the most recent, corresponding to GPL portions of Android 3.2.1.

https://groups.google.com/d/topic/android-building/IrFiwQ-hL...

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by pingswept on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:39AM (#3238019)
That's good and convincing. I stand corrected.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by shn on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:12PM (#3236295)
while I found the opportunity that many commenting and interested in this topic, let me ask a question. Can one upgrade any android phone by himself? (I do not own one), or one need to wait for the carrier and or manufacturer need to do it?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by jtreminio on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:32PM (#3236362)
If your phone is rooted, or rootable, there's a bunch of devs over @ XDA-developers forum that create custom ROMs for most Android phones.

The most famous of these is CyanogenMod, which works across most Android phones out.

Once they port it to your phone you can flash the ROM and run ICS on your phone!

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by shn on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:59PM (#3236430)
Thanks for the reply. Using the keywords like "custom ROM", "rooting" you mentioned in your reply I am also able to google for more.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by melling on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:13PM (#3236300)
Now the only thing missing is a winning strategy for desktops/laptops. :-)

Seems like Chrome OS should be folded into Android and many people would be comfortable using it at home. Same apps could run and sync on all devices.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by chimeracoder on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:31PM (#3236354)
Unfortunately the two systems are very different and largely incompatible.

Merging them would not be impossible, but it's not easy.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Maakuth on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:53AM (#3237698)
I don't know about that. Certainly there are large differences under the hood, but isn't Chrome OS just supposed to run browser apps really well? I don't think that's a very hard compatibility measure for Android to match.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Andrex on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:45AM (#3238026)
The entire point of Chrome OS is that it's only the browser. Saying you want Chrome OS merged with Android is the same as saying you just want a Chrome APK. Chrome OS's key tenets of security and simplicity are simply not compatible with traditional operating systems.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by redthrowaway on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:55PM (#3236419)
Google seems to be trying to position itself as the Microsoft of the post-PC world. I doubt ChromeOS, as an operating system designed for the now-defunct netbook, plays much of a role in that strategy.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by adgar on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:08PM (#3236639)
> I doubt ChromeOS, as an operating system designed for the now-defunct netbook

Actually, ChromeOS isn't just for netbooks. It's for a world where everything you want to do on your computer is available via a web service. Netbooks happen to be suitable for ChromeOS now because the web services available today generally don't require much heavy lifting client-side. Especially if NaCl/PNaCl takes off (who knows?) that very well may change soon.

That's why ChromeOS as designed is, in my opinion, actually unlikely to become defunct anytime soon: I personally suspect the percentage of consumers for which ChromeOS's capabilities are sufficient will continue to rise over the next few years.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by bri3d on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:50PM (#3236232)
Why don't they just tag all of Honeycomb?

If the reason is that there's no combination of project commits that can create a building Honeycomb, they should just admit to it and explain why.

The current approach seems like a weird attempt to snow something over - I understand that Honeycomb was a rushed, trashy Android release, and that there's some pride involved, but supposedly all of the rushed, trashy code is in the tree now, and hence there's no going back. The first thing everyone on xda-developers is going to do is go hunting for bad Honeycomb code anyway.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by RobAtticus on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:34PM (#3236368)
I don't know that it was so much "bad" code as they didn't want other groups to try and put Honeycomb on devices that it did not work on (i.e. phones). This would hurt the brand and fill the tech blogs with "Honeycomb is unstable and buggy!" when it really didn't belong on those devices in the first place.

There's a new release now that is stable for all kinds of devices, is it worth it to concern ourselves with what exactly is or isn't Honeycomb? I don't think they were trying to snow something over, I think this was their plan. Release Honeycomb after ICS since device manufacturers will use ICS anyway since it's new.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by blantonl on Monday November 14, 2011 @07:52PM (#3236411)
I've heard so many complaints from developers about the delayed source release, however I've never known Google to withhold source code for Android.

Could the slight delay in release simply be due to legal issues such as scrubbing patent issues and verification that OSS code isn't infringing?

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by icarus_drowning on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:27PM (#3236514)
They're probably talking specifically about Honeycomb, which started showing up in devices in Feb. 2011 according to Wikipedia, but only now is being open-sourced. So that does seem to have been withheld.

Not that missing that deserves the downvoting you're getting though.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by feralchimp on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:49PM (#3236584)
Honest question from a maybe-future Android dev: is it notably more challenging to develop for Android during periods when the source is not yet public? For example, is a lot of platform doc written from the POV of someone who expects you'll just peep the code when questions arise?

Update: +1 to everyone thinking 'man, I bitch about google sometimes, but this kind of thing is totally legit and awesome'

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by jasonostrander on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:03PM (#3236629)
I do Android dev full time and it's pretty rare to actually need to look at the source. The only time is when encountering a strange bug that you suspect is caused by the underlying implementation.

Google has generally been good about releasing emulator images prior to releases, though usually it's only a few weeks. Luckily, it takes time for Android versions to achieve large market share, so any bugs can be squashed before it's a big problem.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by babebridou on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @04:32AM (#3237665)
Sometimes when I'm in a bad mood, the API and online doc are not cutting it - I start wondering why it doesn't work the way I'd expect it to, and from there I have multiple options, from StackOverflow to Google Groups to ordering a book on Amazon.com, and this is the true productivity killer because of, you know, the internet.

The definitive and fastest answer will always come from reading and understanding the source code, as I don't have to hope that someone had the same problem I'm having and someone else had an answer, or that someone will reply to my question before I give up. Eclair, Froyo and Gingerbread sources were enough for 99% of my needs though, but there was always this shadow of doubt for Honeycomb-specific features...

For the most part, having the latest source readily available will greatly reduce the amount of open browser tabs, and for that I'm thankful :)

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by orangecat on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:33PM (#3236713)
is it notably more challenging to develop for Android during periods when the source is not yet public?

Not really. It's occasionally convenient to have the source, but it's not at all required and the documentation doesn't assume that you do.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by roflharrison on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:57PM (#3236944)
I'm not sure why any developer would need access to source code with such a well documented SDK.

Lots of hackers would like the source so they can poach the some code, make a few enhancements then make a quick buck though...

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by thristian on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @01:25AM (#3237267)
So, the Android website is packed full of information about how to clone the Android repository and build it from scratch, but I just want to browse it online. Is there some official "gitweb" site or something that I can poke at?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by asmosoinio on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:02AM (#3237353)
Android sources get mirrored to https://github.com/android/, which allows browsing of the code. The latest release is probably not be there yet, though.

For example, source of the MMS conversation list:

https://github.com/android/platform_packages_apps_mms/blob/m...

-- update: Another great place to browse the source, with working links to other classes, multiple versions etc, is grepcode:

http://grepcode.com/file/repository.grepcode.com/java/ext/co...

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by eslaught on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:26PM (#3239719)
github.com/android seems be a mirror of kernel.org, which isn't where Android is hosted any more...
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ConstantineXVI on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:33AM (#3238277)
Used to be; they haven't got their gitweb back online yet though. They're still in the middle of moving all their infrastructure internally after the kernel.org breach.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by DonnyV on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:53PM (#3236772)
I'v never seen so many people BITCHING about getting free code. No less an entire OS that runs on hundreds of devices. Maaahhhh you didn't release it fast enough. Stop whining!!
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by tomlin on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @12:10PM (#3239014)
Meanwhile at Daring Fireball

crickets http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K8E_zMLCRNg

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by xxiao on Monday November 14, 2011 @10:30PM (#3236876)
I criticized google for holding back honeycomb, now it's finally releasing the code again. Great! Thanks Google.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by cnxsoft on Monday November 14, 2011 @09:57PM (#3236793)
That source tree is huge. Over 6GB of data and it takes several hours to sync on my machine (not done yet).
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by zobzu on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:34PM (#3236537)
'bout time !
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Srirangan on Monday November 14, 2011 @08:48PM (#3236582)
Well done Google!
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ErikRogneby on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:30PM (#3235997)
Only the Honeycomb GPL modules are available. The entire platform source is not available. see here: http://source.android.com/source/build-numbers.html
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by ZeroGravitas on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:53PM (#3236077)
I think that link is just outdated, it doesn't mention ICS at all.

The link for this submission says:

"This release includes the full history of the Android source code tree, which naturally includes all the source code for the Honeycomb releases. However, since Honeycomb was a little incomplete, we want everyone to focus on Ice Cream Sandwich. So, we haven't created any tags that correspond to the Honeycomb releases (even though the changes are present in the history.)"

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by martey on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:46PM (#3236049)
Is it possible that specific page of documentation has just not been updated yet? The linked thread has Jean-Baptiste Queru stating:

> This release includes the full history of the Android source code tree, which naturally includes all the source code for the Honeycomb releases.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by abrahamsen on Monday November 14, 2011 @05:51PM (#3236069)
From Jean-Baptiste Queru's announcement

http://groups.google.com/group/android-building/msg/c0e01b46...

I gather that the "complete" Honeycomb source is available as part of the git history, but without tags.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by vog on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @02:48AM (#3237447)
Many thanks to http://gpl-violations.org/! Without their pressure this would have taken considerably longer. (Or wouldn't have happened at all?)
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by vog on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:11AM (#3237956)
To the person who downvoted this comment: Could you explain what's wrong with it?
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by roflharrison on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @09:02AM (#3238185)
From what i can see there is no pressure being put on Google from gpl-violations.org (presumably because the haven't made any violations).

Plenty of heat being put on manufacturers with Android devices but that is hardly Google's fault or related to the ICS release.

Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by vgrichina on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @08:34AM (#3238118)
GPL'ed code has been already released by Google, what was released now is under Apache license.
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by Andrex on Tuesday November 15, 2011 @07:47AM (#3238029)
Probably because it was always the intent to release the ICS source code, and gpl-violations didn't factor into the decision whatsoever. (I didn't downvote your comment though.)
[deleted]
Re:Google releases full Android 4.0.1 source code, includes ... by drivebyacct2 on Monday November 14, 2011 @06:50PM (#3236234)
Flash has nothing to do with Google's reasons for not open sourcing Honeycomb.