News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by joelthelion on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:18AM (#32352794)
I also find it very interesting to hear them say that they're listening to user feedback. Perhaps the years of outrage are finally paying off.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by moultano on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:13AM (#32355625)
I work on Google search, and have been posting in threads about it for quite some time here taking feedback, asking for examples to debug, and passing them on when I get them.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by horsawlarway on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:49AM (#32356085)
If you're here taking feedback: This is sincerely my number one desire -

Please let me turn on verbatim mode and leave it enabled. Ideally across my google account, but I'd settle for just that device/application.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by ratww on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:14AM (#32356379)
I would also love that.

One request from me would be for them to bring back the + operator and favour it instead of quotes, since Google Plus integration doesn't seem to be a thing anymore.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by moultano on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:18AM (#32356432)
Honestly I think using quotes for that is probably better, even though + was a bit less typing. You wouldn't believe how many people search for [tar -xvf] and are confused as to why none of their search results contain the string xvf. It's hard to come up with operators that are easy to type and will never collide with their normal meaning in language, and I think quotation marks work much better for that than + did.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by MerelyMortal on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:34PM (#32364282)
How about foo -"bar" to search for foo without bar?
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by ratww on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:37AM (#32356728)
That's a good point. Quotes are definitely better for some cases.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by dannysullivan on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:37AM (#32356727)
I explained elsewhere that it's very unlikely to come back because we actually do try to match + in queries now for thing like international phone numbers, and also as someone else noted, there's any number of names that make use of it (Disney+ for example).
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by solarkraft on Saturday August 06, 2022 @07:23AM (#32367081)
That's actually a change I appreciate. I'm delighted short words and characters don't just get dropped unseen anymore.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Karellen on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:25PM (#32362682)
I've been thinking about this.

How about a heuristic of: If the user phrases their search as a natural language query ("what is...?", "how do I...", etc...) then use whatever weird relevancy metrics and search word substitution your research suggests will answer the question best. OTOH, if the user appears to phrase their search as just a list of keywords, search for all the words verbatim.

They already do query classification for things like Google Calculator. Extending the classifier to switch between "natural language query" and "strict keyword search" seems like a reasonable extension of that idea.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by horsawlarway on Saturday August 06, 2022 @10:31AM (#32368431)
Ok - I totally understand the intent, but NOOOOOOOO!!!! (or more clearly: I have no problem with them trying this, but it doesn't solve my use case)

The entire reason I ask is because I don't want google to try to interpret my search query and change it - I don't want it to guess what I'm looking for using [insert classifier of choice] - I want it to do as close to a text scan for the exact search query as I can get.

Inconsistent tools are much harder to use. I really don't want to have to play a cat and mouse game with my search tool, and I don't want to have to have memorized all the "games" google is playing with my query and understand how to turn them off.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Fabricio20 on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:55AM (#32357944)
While we have you here, can you guys take a look at why the Google Cache feature is very hard to find nowadays? It's almost as if most big sites don't have an option to see the cached version, and even when they do, finding the "Cached" button on desktop seems impossible, this started happening ever since the "More :" menu got redesigned (to show "about this result"), the cached button just isn't there sometimes. (Ex: Amazon).
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by groffee on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:10PM (#32363821)
Even better is when they do show the 'cache' button but don't actually have anything cached, so if the site is down their 'cache' is broken. They think users are too stupid to notice.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by katbyte on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:56AM (#32357043)
Please remove Pinterest, or at least lower their relevancy. So often when searching for images the are higher up then the source page the Pinterest image is from and don’t link back to it.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by aantix on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:25AM (#32357490)
Why isn't there a reasonably priced Google Search API?

Besides being overpriced, the last I checked, the results returned for the custom search didn't reflect what was returned from the normal search product.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by nradov on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:49PM (#32358684)
Remove the recency bias, or at least allow users to permanently disable it. There is no correlation between content age and quality.

Allow users to permanently remove trash sites like Pinterest from all their search results on both web and mobile.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Der_Einzige on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:58AM (#32357072)
I remember you and other from Google search trying to gaslight us in the comments, claiming that there was no problems with quotes.

No problems huh? Why does this article exist? Lol the hubris at Google...

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by moultano on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:30AM (#32357578)
The article describes UX changes to make it clearer that quotes are working as designed.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by solarkraft on Saturday August 06, 2022 @07:20AM (#32367064)
Thanks for doing so! Are you doing it in an official capacity (i.e. wait ... do they actually care? google? talking to users?!?)?

Maybe this is my chance to repeat something I asked the DuckDuckGo CEO today (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32366664): Are you doing anything about SEO spam?

It seems like Google often rewards low quality results: Sites with tons of ads or where I'm being shilled to buy a product that I'm looking for information on because I already have it. It's so bad that I've half-concluded it's due to misaligned incentives - keeping the user looking at the search results keeps Google collecting ad revenue and steering users to crappy sites full of ads also keeps Google collecting ad revenue.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by d0100 on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:40AM (#32356770)
I want to be able to search with wildcard POS and synonyms

Person <verbs> blue chair

Should return any text where someone does something to a blue chair (and it's synonyms or similars)

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Geonode on Friday August 05, 2022 @10:08AM (#32356298)
Please put image search back the way it was. Are the lawyers really afraid of Getty? Just buy them. :)
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Kye on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:02AM (#32357133)
I don't think the Getty family is hurting for money. Getty Images is likely a prestige business for them.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by sixothree on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:24AM (#32357476)
Let me hide pinterest results. Or just hide them yourself.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by onychomys on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:44PM (#32358608)
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by moultano on Friday August 05, 2022 @11:27AM (#32357532)
This is more typing, but if you append -site:pinterest.com to your search, it will hide them.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by pdimitar on Saturday August 06, 2022 @01:52PM (#32370155)
That approach obviously doesn't scale. There are many content farms. You need to start hitting them, HARD.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by yccs27 on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:47AM (#32352974)
Or maybe they realize people are starting to leave for DuckDuckGo etc. because Google no longer has better results.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by sirius87 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:44AM (#32354728)
If we are speculating why Google is now caring to pay attention to user reports, I strongly feel such things usually precede a wave of user monetization.

I would not be surprised if the ads situation gets worse or some other egregious action takes place, as if to say, "Remember how we fixed search results for you? Well, here's how we plan to pay for it".

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by sdoering on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:16PM (#32360654)
> Well, here's how we plan to pay for it.

I would change one little word:

Well, here's how we plan _you_ pay for it.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by joaogui1 on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:53AM (#32354805)
Not just DDG, there has been an increase in search engine startups, some with pretty well-known people taking the lead, that probably got them worried
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by rr888 on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:06AM (#32354918)
Any good ones? I'd love to experiment.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by mminer237 on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:21AM (#32355731)
Brave Search is quite good. They basically trained their model to give the same results as Google, but they give prioritized sections to real discussions. Plus they have a cool goggles experiment.

Mojeek is hit or miss, but occasionally does better than Google.

I haven't really used it myself, but I've heard good things about Kagi.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by maronato on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:44AM (#32355276)
Kagi has been pretty great in my experience
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by gabrielgio on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:03AM (#32355499)
I started using as a test drive (as I have been a happy DDG user before that). I really like the fact that there is no ad, I can easily rank the pages or even block them (be gone w3schools) and ultimately I don't ever have to go to google anymore. The result are quite solid, even for local non-english searches which DDG struggles a bit.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Johnythree on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:17AM (#32355665)
Very much This. It's good that google is now doing a panic because of Kargi.

Too little, too late. Pity they didn't listen years ago.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by rr888 on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:18AM (#32355686)
Ooof you have to pay? I guess I can't complain about ads any more. I'll try it out.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by permo-w on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:07AM (#32353961)
after a few weeks of trying all the different (free) options, I found that anything longer than 3 keywords and Google is the only option. duckduckgo doesn’t even have [consistently working] quote search
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by felipemnoa on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:51AM (#32356110)
Personally I find myself using bing more. Nothing against google search, but a lot of times I just cannot find what I need in google so I go over to bing to see if I have better luck. Sometimes I do. Although, google search is still better, for now.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by sh4rks on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:22AM (#32353622)
I sometimes find that duckduckgo has better results than Google for a particular query, and other times it's the opposite.

I wish there was a way to aggregate the two results together.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by wakeupcall on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:03AM (#32353933)
There is. Look at SearX.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by russellbeattie on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:21AM (#32353207)
Google defines what good search results are. Any company trying to compete with them is just tilting at windmills. They'll always be a step behind, forever. "Hey, why does Google show me x and DDG doesn't?", "Why is it so hard to find x on DDG, it's on the first page of Google." Etc. It will never be the reverse for 99% of users.

And face it, for all its flaws, Google's index is larger, it has more servers, has way more signals to use - including its own web browser, DNS and ads - more money to spend and actual computer scientists who've been banging away at the problem for decades. Bing is just Microsoft's way of siphoning off some search revenues from the most technically illiterate users who don't know better and never change their defaults on their Windows box they bought at Walmart. MS has zero incentive to improve the results.

DDG is a cute little boutique web site. Good for them. But their impact on Google Search is so small as to be non-existent.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by Beldin on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:00AM (#32353487)
That used to be the case. It's why they rose to dominance (that and the "no extra crap on the page"). Nowadays, Google's search results are pretty meuh. However, the domain has become much more adversarial with many companies devoted to manipulating search results for a fee. Not sure, perhaps "meuh" is the best we can hope for nowadays.

If a service can consistently deliver good results on the first page (like Google used to, 20-odd years ago), they could definitely dethrone Google. Of course, the moment that appears to be the case, all SEO spammers start focusing on the new rival and the newcomer's job becomes a lot harder.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by permo-w on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:09AM (#32353978)
google results seem meh when you compare them to google results. go and try and use duckduckgo or brave search for anything more than basic one or two keyword searches, and you’ll be back to google like a shot
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by eino on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:28AM (#32354101)
That's just not true. I switched from google at least two years ago (first to cliqz now DDG), and haven't looked back ever since. And I run pretty technical queries. When I try google again, it's not better, and many times it's worse.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by cassianoleal on Friday August 05, 2022 @07:41AM (#32354704)
I've been setting DDG as my default search engine on all browsers for at least 4 or 5 years.

Sometimes I get terrible results and add a !g to my search query to see if le gouglè gives me something better. Almost every time it's just as bad. Usually because of SEO crap.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by permo-w on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:43AM (#32356016)
lack of quote search is a huge downside for me
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by cycomanic on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:28PM (#32358392)
When was the last time you tried. It is somewhat topic dependent but I've been using brave for a couple of month and have not missed any (except for significantly less content farm results). I sometimes revert back to Google, but at the same time I also used other engines for better results when on Google.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by permo-w on Sunday August 07, 2022 @09:08AM (#32376200)
I tried a couple of weeks ago. my conclusions were solidly in favour of google, despite reluctance on privacy concerns

I felt that for technical searches past a certain number of keywords (2 or 3), ddg and brave tend to lose focus where google doesn’t, a problem exacerbated by the lack of quote search on either

google also much better answers local questions, like “[supermarket] [location] opening times”, and indexes wikipedia more usefully, plus ten other integrated features you don’t miss until they’re gone (e.g. imdb)

I didn’t notice a change in SEO spam between the alternatives. I would imagine brave have made an effort here, but as far as I know, duckduckgo filters their content less than google does

finally, brave lacks maps, which is incredibly annoying

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by richardsocher on Sunday August 07, 2022 @09:08PM (#32381486)
Would love to hear from you if we succeeded with both at you.com - we've worked a bunch on these issues you outline.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by hulahoof on Friday August 05, 2022 @09:49AM (#32356093)
I find DDG to be better than anything other than finding local stores, but I just use (google) maps for that anyway.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by roelschroeven on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:21AM (#32354065)
I started using DDG a number of years ago out of principle, even though its search results were clearly worse than Google's (but still mostly acceptable). Quite often I fell back to Google to get better results.

After a while, things started to change. I don't feel the need to fall back to Google nearly as often anymore, and when I do I'm very unhappy with the results from Google. They're often worse than what I get from DDG.

YMMV of course. And yes, DDG's impact on Google Search is probably negligible, but market share is often only verly lightly related to quality.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by russellbeattie on Friday August 05, 2022 @02:21PM (#32359883)
Good morning! Always fun to come back and see a pretty straightforward comment getting downvoted to oblivion. :-)

To be clear, I wasn't saying the current state of affairs was a good thing, I was simply stating in detail that Google is still a gargantuan machine. Unless a competitor is somehow able to fire a couple of torpedoes down a hidden exhaust port, they're all going to be outgunned for the foreseeable future. But sure, the unpredictable vagaries of public sentiment could somehow turn against them, I guess. I mean, it's going to be a while. Their company name is a verb.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by pschuegr on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:48AM (#32353399)
Yeah, I'm going to have to disagree with you on that. I was part of the Kagi beta test and I think the results were on average better than Google, and not just for lack of ads. I'm not a Google hater either, but their systems are just not as far in front as they used to be.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by russellbeattie on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:02AM (#32353502)
What's the fundamental rule to get users to switch products or services? Answer: 10x.

When a competitor's results are 10 times better than Google's - not a little better, or sometimes better, or better if you add a special character to your search, or subjectively better based on your personal preference, but an actual order of magnitude better - then and only then will Google even begin to start worrying about its dominant position in search.

"But Russ," I can hear you say, "How can a search result be 10x better? That's a straw man. What does it even mean to be 'better'? Faster? More accurate? More contextual? More personal? More predictive? Less spam? More niche sites? Less niche sites? More photos? More videos? More news? Less photos? Less videos? Less news? More languages? Less languages? More international? More local? More convenient? More customizable? How can you even measure something like that?"

Exactly.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by andrelaszlo on Friday August 05, 2022 @08:01AM (#32354877)
For me, not feeling spied on was the big part and the search results were also much more consistent and less frustrating. The final parts were the ads, and that I simply try to avoid Google products. 10x sounds like a lot but for me personally Kagi is probably like 30x when you take all the factors into consideration.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by erichocean on Saturday August 06, 2022 @02:05PM (#32370250)
> but an actual order of magnitude better

Well, when you can't get the result on Google no matter how you finesse your query, but you can get it on another search engine, is that infinity better?

Because that's the situation.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by joelthelion on Friday August 05, 2022 @04:49AM (#32353408)
Disagree. I use DDG because I'm frustrated with Google search results. And granted, sometimes Google is better, so I just add "!g" to my query and let DDG redirect me to Google.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by permo-w on Friday August 05, 2022 @06:13AM (#32354010)
for me I’d be very happy to just use google through a proxy service. google now hides images and maps behind a cookie consent page, so if you’ve got their cookies blocked, you can’t access then
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by wrp on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:10AM (#32353547)
Have to disagree. I've tried DDG and was never impressed enough to switch from Google, but I have found Yandex to increasingly give better curated results, especially for stuff originating in Europe. Bing has also gotten much better, but I don't find it adds anything to Yandex+Google.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by cycomanic on Friday August 05, 2022 @12:33PM (#32358450)
Sorry, but as critical as I'm of Google I'm not going to exchange it for a Russian propaganda instrument.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by bambax on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:40AM (#32353741)
I agree with you, but I also think that it's bad that they are unbeatable. It can only lead to complacency and monopolist behavior.

I think as a society we need to think what it means to have one private company control access to all information.

Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by russellbeattie on Friday August 05, 2022 @03:48PM (#32361077)
Thanks. I don't think it's a good thing either. Was just pointing out that their dominance is pretty unassailable.
Re:We're improving search results when you use quotes by spaniard89277 on Friday August 05, 2022 @05:18AM (#32353600)
Maybe, I'm fine over here though, using both ddg and brave search