News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by harryf on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:23AM (#32262885)
It's a nice idea to things like this _in theory_. Medium has something similar they called Snowflake - https://github.com/Medium/snowflake ... but note the disclaimer...

> Heads up: Medium isn’t using this tool anymore, but you’re welcome to!

The problem with things like this is the typical engineering mindset, when shown a graphical or numerical analysis of their performance will zoom into analyse every detail and in the end it's just backed by the managers impressions and judgement.

For similar reasons I have a strong opinion that engineers shouldn't be paid performance related bonuses, because no matter what happens, it's just going to upset them - the best case - maximum bonus - just equates to a "meh". Better to pay a good base salary upfront ...

Anyway use tools like this with caution IMO.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by sokoloff on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:37AM (#32262988)
> Better to pay a good base salary upfront ...

Bonuses that are variable with company performance are a common way to manage the reality for many businesses of “some years we have more money than others”. It seems better to pay bonuses that vary than to set high base salaries and lay people off in cyclical lean years.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by kqr on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:40AM (#32264956)
That can work, if the scheme is (a) fair, and (b) transparent. I.e. something like "this is the formula we apply to the quarterly report to get everyone's bonuses".

Anything else just ends up being a lottery that helps no-one.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by twblalock on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:05PM (#32266231)
> Anything else just ends up being a lottery that helps no-one.

I've seen several occasions when corporate bureaucracy has prevented or delayed raises and promotions because of policy or budget wrangling, but not bonuses or stock grants. Bonuses are a tool for managers to reward and retain their high performers when those other options are not available during that fiscal year.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by TameAntelope on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:16PM (#32269582)
Oh it's not usually "fair" per se, but it's not like some people would get more than others (if done well), it's more like you don't always control all of the factors that get used to determine your bonus.

Like a QA engineer probably isn't directly tied to overall revenue, but it is a topline number that can be applied to everyone generally, so it can get used (in a general sense, I'm sure there are lots of specifics and nuances here).

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by nerdponx on Saturday July 30, 2022 @10:19AM (#32287007)
Profit sharing is a great idea, and a lot more equitable than a "bonus" for individual performance.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by dasil003 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:38AM (#32264927)
> The problem with things like this is the typical engineering mindset, when shown a graphical or numerical analysis of their performance will zoom into analyse every detail and in the end it's just backed by the managers impressions and judgement.

The point of leveling frameworks is not to magically make everything objective and quantifiable—though I agree that is what many smart young people want and expect (after a decade+ in our Victorian education system)—it's to channel and provide a rubric that many different engineering leaders' (both EMs and ICs) impressions can be compared and contrasted in a structured and relatively fair way. The last thing you want to do is remove expert judgement from the equation, but in a medium to large org it shouldn't be one person.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by maest on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:29AM (#32262931)
> the best case - maximum bonus - just equates to a "meh"

Can you elaborate on this? I find it surprising since bonus pays are very commonly used in many industries (and, in fact, relied on very heavily in e.g. finance)

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by kqr on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:48AM (#32265086)
Performance bonuses the way they are commonly done doesn't work in finance and sales either -- they're just so in-grained in the culture that it's impossible to hire a finance or sales person without offering bonuses the common way.

The problem is that individual performance is a much smaller factor of outcome than commonly believed. Organisational structure, luck, social standing in the organisation, etc play a much bigger role. So in the end, performance bonuses usually reward random variation more than individual prowess (as much as the recipients would like to think otherwise.)

This one-armed bandit type compensation, when disguised as a performance bonus, creates confusion, weird incentives, limits creativity and experimentation, and breeds bad blood.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by blowski on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:33AM (#32262966)
I remember going through performnace-related bonuses. If somebody tried super-hard and got a "level 5", they got a £5K bonus. Somebody ticking along without being outstanding got £3K. Most people realised the extra £2K wasn't worth the extra effort required to get it.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by yakak on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:47AM (#32263070)
A raise of even a small amount makes a big difference over time because raises continue and even compound a little. Consequently, a cheap company will try to make the near certain portion of a bonus feel like part of your negotiated salary and extract effort with bonuses as ephemeral raises.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by quickthrower2 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:09AM (#32263224)
It doesn’t compound at all. If the going rate is $200k and I switch jobs my previous salary doesn’t matter, and therefore compounding doesn’t matter.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by vikingerik on Thursday July 28, 2022 @12:02PM (#32266184)
Raises that are a percentage will compound over multiple iterations, that's what he meant.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by quickthrower2 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:23PM (#32272804)
Only given the following conditions:

* You stay at the same company

* They are happy to pay above market rates and keep giving you raises even if you are paid over market rates.

This would be the exception, and probably for some real specialist stuff.

If I get a 10% raise today, it will have no impact on my 2030 salary. Getting more stock might be a different thing if you are very lucky and the ducks line up.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by dzolvd on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:16AM (#32263273)
in what industry does your previous salary not matter? (Not a snarky ask btw.) I have never entertained an offer blow my current salary, so personally find them highly correlated (sw eng).
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by jasongi on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:49AM (#32263578)
Previous salary can’t affect future salary unless you let the previous salary be known.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by artwr on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:49PM (#32271463)
There is a bit of a bias to this.

Higher salaries will get disclosed more, because if I get an offer below my current salary, then I can disclose and at the very least get a match or refuse the offer. At a lower salary, there is a higher probability that the offer is higher, and my current salary does not matter.

I believe that people more rarely accept a downgrade in salary, so the probably of acceptance is also conditioned on the current salary. What this means is that the effect is biased and probably non-linear, but I wouldn't qualify it as non effect.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by pc86 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:48AM (#32263564)
Nobody is talking about previous salary, the $3k/$5k thing was about yearly performance bonuses.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by quickthrower2 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:22PM (#32272797)
My argument is general enough to cover that case too. Performance bonuses don't compound long term for the same reason.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by pc86 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:47AM (#32263550)
We're not talking about raises, we're talking about one-time performance bonuses.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by yakak on Thursday July 28, 2022 @09:06AM (#32263749)
We are talking about performance bonuses, a trick to avoid permanent raises.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by pjbeam on Thursday July 28, 2022 @08:48AM (#32263568)
The bonuses where I am now are a % of the employee's base salary. A mid-level "meets" engineer can expect something like $20-25k during an average year for the company. Up to twice that for a strong year.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by romanovcode on Thursday July 28, 2022 @07:43AM (#32263029)
It's different in finance because a finance guy can go to his boss with hard proof and say "I made your company 10 million last year" and ask for 500k bonus.

But developers do not have hard proof and they will be getting 10k bonus instead.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by wizofaus on Thursday July 28, 2022 @04:24PM (#32269671)
Except it's not hard proof at all - no one person in a company can ever be even the primary reason for that 10 million profit. Further what happens in the years that by the same metric they lose a company 10 million...

Btw my current company offers bonus vacation days instead of financial incentives, and they go to every one in the team responsible for achieving product goals. I feel a little guilty as I'm enjoying that benefit today despite not having been at the company at the point the goals were met! I like the idea though...

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by romanovcode on Friday July 29, 2022 @06:59AM (#32275423)
Sales, stock traders and I assume many others definitely have a hard proof of how much money they made.

Regarding when they lose money - at best they get no salary or they just get fired.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by HPsquared on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:14AM (#32264582)
See also, sales.
Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by rufius on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:58AM (#32266113)
I think your point is a good one. Though I'd say, that's why it's good to describe these as frameworks. They set the rough bounds of expectations, but much like API frameworks, the business logic is specific to your company and its culture.

Anyway - agreed that you cannot just blindly follow one of these. Also, this level of complexity in leveling is something that is best left to bigger organizations. It's almost limiting to impose it on smaller orgs.

Re:A Framework for Engineering Managers by charlie0 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @10:53AM (#32265167)
I agree, pay them more. Nowadays, the best "bonus" is switching jobs.