News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by 01100011 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:17PM (#32255345)
Such a monumental scam and a gross theft from taxpayers. Companies making billions of dollars in profits don't need free money. I could be onboard with a subsidized loan, but handouts are not needed.

FWIW, I work at a company that stands to benefit from this bill.

Does the US need to secure reliable semiconductor supply chains free of China? Sure. This is not the most cost effective way to do it.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Alupis on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:25PM (#32255460)
Clearly, handouts are needed to force/incentivize these companies to build new fabs in the continental US. Otherwise they would have built them under their own gumption by now.

When there is no clear benefit for the company to fab chips in the continental US, and a lot of clear negatives (cost, regulations, etc) - you have to do something to outweigh the cons. If the US had been an amazing place to fab chips already, hand-outs would be completely unnecessary and we would already have a bustling chip fabbing industry. But... we don't.

Perhaps after handing out all this "free" money, lawmakers need to take a long hard look at why our chip fabbing industry has nearly vanished.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by nerpderp82 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:11PM (#32256195)
Fabs are only a small part of the supply chain. Any one of the thousands of critical components that go into maintenance or manufacturing put the whole thing at risk. Just dumping money on industry will not solve this. Having a dirt to package solution with everything domestically produced would and it doesn't need to be the latest process node, that is ridiculous and folks that advocate for that don't see the forest for the trees.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by arrosenberg on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:09PM (#32256161)
> Clearly, handouts are needed to force/incentivize these companies to build new fabs in the continental US. Otherwise they would have built them under their own gumption by now.

I don't have a problem with government subsidy for jumpstarting industry, but it's absurd to give the money to Intel and AMD. They profited massively from offshoring their production. If we are going to spend money (and I agree we must), it should be invested in new competition so that Intel and AMD have to spend their largess on fixing their business model to compete.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by lettergram on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:29PM (#32255536)
Alternatively, you add a 20% tax on CPUs made outside the US. That would incentivize the fans manufactured in the US even if it’s a foreign company.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Alupis on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:31PM (#32255556)
Or, chips just become 20% more expensive in the US and the consumer loses... and the US still doesn't gain supply chain security.

I don't think tariffs will work when the alternative requires massive outlay of capital and decades to recoup.

Not to mention, there is no reality where manufacturing these chips in the US costs less than Taiwan, for example. There is no reason to build a fab in the US with the current economic and regulatory climate. So... we have to force it to happen... which is what this bill does.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by ZetaZero on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:03PM (#32256060)
Intel had profits of $20B last year. They could easily build a new modern fab every year if they wanted to. But it makes more sense for them to spend tax payers money instead.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by thfuran on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:09PM (#32256157)
Easily as in "if they feel like wiping out all their profits", which is not really how public companies tend to feel.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by 01100011 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:15PM (#32257077)
Amazon went years basically making no money because they were reinvesting and in a growth stage. Intel could do the same. They just need to convince investors of the new narrative. Wall Street doesn't demand profits if you deliver promises.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by BeetleB on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:11PM (#32256196)
> They could easily build a new modern fab every year if they wanted to.

And they are, and have always been.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by phkahler on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:52PM (#32255917)
>> Or, chips just become 20% more expensive in the US and the consumer loses... and the US still doesn't gain supply chain security.

Push it up 50 percent. This quarter trillion dollars is going straight on the debt pile so it will hurt a lot, just not today.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Alupis on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:00PM (#32256019)
Without getting political - does it even matter anymore? Trillions of dollars were just thrown out the window to whoever could catch some... and few if anyone has any idea where most of it actually went.

At least this money will have a tangible, appreciable outcome. Supply chain security for such critical things such as chips is really hard to overstate the importance of for the US.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by gscott on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:21PM (#32256350)
We inflate away our national debt anyway so in future dollars that is a few hundred billion at most.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by StillBored on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:37PM (#32255673)
I think in this case the US is different than say Chile because its such a large market. AKA its large enough to support home grown manufacturing if the incentives aren't out of wack.

The chicken tax, as been an incredibly efficient way to assure that car's are manufactured in the USA, so much so that the cost difference between a Ford manufactured in Mexico and a Toyota manufactured in TX is basically 0.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Alupis on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:42PM (#32255753)
How is this not the consumer still losing, though?

There is no reality where manufacturing a car in Mexico costs the same as in Michigan. We've artificially increased the cost of the Mexico product... that is what will happen if you try that approach with chips - they will be more expensive for no real good reason.

It also appears to cost many multiples more capital to build a chip fab than a car plant according to these sources[1][2].

[1] https://www.exacthowmuch.com/how-much-does-it-cost-to-build-...

[2] https://builtin.com/hardware/american-made-semiconductor-cos...

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by StillBored on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:00PM (#32256024)
Well its MX, vs TX, so maybe that is part of it, but I suspect there are other more significant differences, like for example ford sells ~7x the number of F-150's as Toyota sells Tundra's and that is only reflected in a ~3K difference in base price.

Its hard to have an exact 1:1 comparison, but I think most people would agree they are roughly the same price for roughly the same product. And yet one is largely designed and manufactured in the USA (the Toyota).

So, maybe they it costs more to employ someone in San Antonio, but maybe that doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things vs flying engineers to MX to work out kinks in the assembly line.

And its probably the same with semiconductor manufacturing. Intel isn't behind because it costs more to manufacture things in the US, they are behind because they didn't invest in EUV, and made some technical mistakes, as well as business mistakes around contract manufacturing and refusing low margin deals.

I think if you look at the results of the IBM/Lenovo deals its abundantly clear that where the manufacturing was located had nothing to do with the success of the products (It was outsourced to Lenovo long before it became their business). The American management was the problem, and kicking it to the curb allowed them to grow the business 10X+.

And lets not ignore Samsung which has a large fab just down the road from me. So it can't be a terrible environment for USA based semiconductors if a Korean company is willing to fab things here.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by kube-system on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:40PM (#32256614)
Depends on how much money the other countries are handing out to build CPUs there.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by stevenjgarner on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:43PM (#32255766)
How significant is the US market to foreign manufacturers?
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by pessimizer on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:04PM (#32258235)
> Clearly, handouts are needed to force/incentivize these companies to build new fabs in the continental US. Otherwise they would have built them under their own gumption by now.

That doesn't make sense. I could declare that lollypops are needed, or a third sequel to Space Jam on the same evidence. It's just affirming the consequent. I think that these companies aren't building new fabs because I personally am too poor, so the best way to get us out of this rut is to hand me the billions.

edit: the government needs to stop giving wealthy people money. Buy equity in the companies and get on their boards, don't just hand wealthy people cash and pretend it's capitalism.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by colechristensen on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:23PM (#32255433)
The opposite direction of motivation is to tariff semiconductor imports and still I doubt a quarter of a trillion dollars would be invested so fast.

Geopolitical issues forcing this aren't the fault of the semiconductor providers, decades of policy are at fault for letting the situation get this bad.

And to be fair future taxes will recoup some of this, as will the value provided to the state of an increased reliability of sourcing semiconductors.

It may not be the most cost-effective solution but it's the solution we need at this point because China isn't our friend and increasingly seems like won't be.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by WebbWeaver on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:34PM (#32255618)
>This is not the most cost effective way to do it.

Agreed. The alternatives should have been presented. Maybe include this in partnership with canada, mexico and others. Where the wonks at?

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by tdhz77 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:21PM (#32255404)
Cost is not the only consideration. I fear for people who only focus on one issue and ignore the rest. Rarely do we see congressional leaders agreeing on this scale. I would say they find that reliance on China to be a threat to National Security. US and China communications is zero and even lower than it was during the Cold War. Pelosi story on visiting Taiwan should give you an idea of the stakes that are play. China siding with Russia should be the final consideration of the United States commitment to Democracy and people. Cost is really just one data point and should not be the only consideration. This concept can be applied to many more things, and I think you should rethink.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by 01100011 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:47PM (#32255833)
You can't wave the magic wand of national security and justify any inefficient or ineffective attempt at stealing from the future to goose the present.

The short term goal should be to diversify critical US supply chains away from a country that is currently considered by the US to be an competitor. I'm sure you remember that US official policy since the 70s is the "One China Policy" which admits that Taiwan is a part of China and that only attempts to reunify by force will be responded to(*). So the US needs to move supply chains out of PRC/ROC, but moving them to S. Korea, Japan, or dozens of other friendly nations is an acceptable goal from a national security standpoint.

* - I'm not a fan of this, but it is what it is. I didn't realize it until recently.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by LAC-Tech on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:20PM (#32257141)
One of the most pernicious myths about this situation out there is that there is a single "One China Policy" shared by everyone on earth. This is not the case. The One China Policy of the US is different to that of the PRC. And I quote:

- The United States did not explicitly state the sovereign status of Taiwan in the three US-PRC Joint Communiques of 1972, 1979, and 1982.

- The United States "acknowledged" the "One China" position of both sides of the Taiwan Strait.

- U.S. policy has not recognized the PRC's sovereignty over Taiwan;

- U.S. policy has not recognized Taiwan as a sovereign country; and

- U.S. policy has considered Taiwan's status as unsettled.

Next time you read a news story about this issue, take note of the fact that PRC officials use the term "the One China policy" while US officials use the term "our 'One China' policy".

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by 01100011 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:49PM (#32259965)
Correct. I was still surprised to see how far the US OCP goes towards appeasing the PRC though. In spirit, it seems well out of line with how Taiwan policy is proceeding these days. As far as I understand it, there is no outcome where the US will recognize a permanently independent Taiwan. That's unfortunate.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by lapcat on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:08PM (#32256131)
> Rarely do we see congressional leaders agreeing on this scale.

There has been widespread bipartisan support for the military-industrial complex for as long as Eisenhower (correctly) warned about the military-industrial complex.

Partisan disagreements just tend to make the headlines more often.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by tdhz77 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:23PM (#32267493)
This bill is about the private sector creating microchips. Nothing about the bill is about the military industrial complex. Intel, Apple, AMD
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by lapcat on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:34PM (#32267655)
I was just giving an example of common bipartisan issues.

Corporate welfare and bailouts are also big ones.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by trasz on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:57PM (#32255973)
>China siding with Russia should be the final consideration

If it happened, which it didn't.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by tdhz77 on Thursday July 28, 2022 @01:23PM (#32267483)
China has the best chance of ending the war by aligning itself with the western world and imposing sanctions. They are trading partners and could threaten and stop to buy gas/oil/goods from Russia and Putin would have no choice but to retreat. By turning a blind eye, it certain China is supporting Russia.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by trasz on Thursday July 28, 2022 @06:44PM (#32270936)
They are imposing sanctions - they have pulled of from some strategic investments, they limited electronics sales, they just don't make much fuss about it, because they aren't Americans.

As for the gas - it's quite probable that even before the war Russians were selling it at loss, purely to stay relevant. Which means China buying it hurts Russian economy more than keeping away. And of course it benefits China.

Besides - what exactly would be the point of isolating Russia altogether? A new USSR? Because that's precisely what Rashists want. China wants a pacified, but functioning vassal state instead. Or perhaps states, because there's no reason really for anything east of Ural to remain with Russia.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by yieldcrv on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:33PM (#32255608)
Often times the people in any individual nation don't want to hear it, but nations are in competition with each other to attract business.

This undermines any other function of what people think a government is there for and the system that government operates under. If people were told anything else, they were told a lie.

There are different people operating under more effective set of rules, and they can pit countries against each other to sweeten the deal of operating within that country.

Its just simply a more effective set of rules than whatever people were taught in their civics class, or by an animated sheet of paper singing about how bills are formed.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Drblessing on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:01PM (#32256029)
It's as simple as this: If companies could manufacture chips profitably in America, they would be.

American Laws & Regulations prohibit domestic semiconductor manufacturing without Government subsidies.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by jszymborski on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:07PM (#32256117)
Another way of looking at this is that under regulation of competing industries in other countries requires intervention (be it via tariff or subsidy).

I think people here have argued the strengths/weaknesses of each approach. The best solution is likely some nuanced mix of the two, but nuanced policy is hard to create and I rather we eat the costs of any of the two approaches that are more likely to be adopted today rather than continue to take no action.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by qaq on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:20PM (#32255389)
What would be a good way?
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by skywal_l on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:29PM (#32255531)
Have the DOD force its suppliers to make their things in the US? Only allow them to import raw materials or low value manufactured elements. Just throwing ideas, might not be practical...
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:50PM (#32255878)
There are already trusted foundries for sensitive silicon.

https://www.dmea.osd.mil/otherdocs/AccreditedSuppliers.pdf

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Alupis on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:36PM (#32255656)
People already complain about the infamous "$5,000" wrenches and other silly ITAR compliance shenanigan's the DoD plays and drains their coffers... leading to increases in funding over the past many decades.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by Goronmon on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:47PM (#32255818)
Have the DOD force its suppliers to make their things in the US? Only allow them to import raw materials or low value manufactured elements. Just throwing ideas, might not be practical...

Are there controls on what suppliers charge? If not, what prevents them from charging as much or more than would be spent on subsidies? If so, what prevents suppliers from just choosing to opt out of the transaction entirely?

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by bushbaba on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:35PM (#32255637)
*And force all US Federal spending to not purchase computer equipment made outside the US with non US made components.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by WebbWeaver on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:36PM (#32255648)
Yes but without a foreign policy economic investment may be difficult.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by colinmhayes on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:37PM (#32255672)
Pretty sure that’s already the case.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by alldayeveryday on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:56PM (#32255970)
Nationalization, imo. Nationalize semiconductor manufacturing, such that the profits flow back to the people.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by qaq on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:38PM (#32257367)
Yep that always works out great
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by frgtpsswrdlame on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:26PM (#32255491)
United States Semiconductor - aka spinning up a nationalized firm.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by drexlspivey on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:28PM (#32255521)
And that’s gonna be cheaper?
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by dangrossman on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:34PM (#32255613)
The goal isn't to be cheaper, it's to have a reliable domestic supply chain.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by drexlspivey on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:51PM (#32255888)
Which the bill will provide for a fraction of the cost
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by alldayeveryday on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @03:59PM (#32256002)
Agreed with this. Has many benefits, including that the profits flow back to the taxpayers rather than to corporations and shareholders. Semiconductors are too important to national security to be controlled by profit seeking corporations whom have little allegiance to the nation or the people.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by onepointsixC on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @06:44PM (#32258034)
So what is the most cost effective way to do so? China's pouring hundreds of billions in subsidies into fabs. South Korea is pouring hundreds of billions in subsidies.

Tariffs alone would only allow for domestic balancing of those subsidies but lose you the global market. So again, what would you recommend instead.

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by pessimizer on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @07:09PM (#32258282)
China is going to insist on a lot of control over the companies that it subsidizes, and South Korea is just hopelessly corrupt. If we went the China route, that's fine, but instead we do welfare for billionaires again.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by sbf501 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:36PM (#32256537)
The reason why non-US cities manufacture so many semiconductors is that there is simply no profit. Capitalism has pushed manufacturing overseas. There are roughly 100-1000 more ARM chips than Intel chips in the world, but the profit margins are miniscule compared to Intel. If Intel made commodity chips, their shareholders would lose value. This bill basically subsidizes the already wealthy to get more wealth and probably won't do much since China will continue to expand while US fabs come online. Free hand of the market my ass.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by maerF0x0 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:31PM (#32257284)
I'd like to see a matching consumer side tax. Basically forced on shoring and user pay taxation (instead of taxing my grandma who uses about 0 chips, lol more than amazon who uses millions/billions of chips but pays next to no taxes)
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by verdverm on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @05:40PM (#32257375)
We don't need the most cost effective way, something that costs a bit more and will make it happen (faster) is preferable
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by goatcode on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @04:06PM (#32256098)
>This is not the most cost effective way to do it.

What would you recommend?

Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by 01100011 on Wednesday July 27, 2022 @10:54PM (#32259994)
Opening up the possibility that other countries, friendly to the US, could also produce some of our semiconductors. We can work to expand S. Korean capacity, for instance. We also don't need to dump money on a problem that would respond to more gentle incentives like low interest rate loans, laws favoring government purchasing of chips from aligned nations, and incentives to boost the infrastructure needed to manufacture chips. One big piece of bringing back mfg to the US is considering expedited environmental review in limited economic zones and commitments to improving our energy and chemical industries which feed into semis. You could write a book on ways to do it, but stealing money from the future and raining it onto companies that already make billions in profits is comically short sighted.
Re:Senate passes bipartisan bill to subsidize U.S.-made semi... by goatcode on Thursday July 28, 2022 @11:21AM (#32265540)
Would there be a domestic target for the same ideas that you'd propose a foreign one(s), or do you believe there to be something more virtuous about South Korea et. al that'd make them better recipients of such things?