By capping that upside, any vesting option package is worth less in expectation, so employees would have demanded higher base salaries knowing that they wouldn't fully participate in a huge win.
It's a weird problem that I think is only there because Zynga grew so freaking fast. Normally an early employee's 4 years are up way before a company is worth billions of dollars. Even in the last year or two of a 4-year option plan, the employer's implicit choice is "is it worth another .1% for me to keep this person for one more year?", and .1% might be worth 20k or even 50k, and so the employer doesn't even consider ways of reducing that cost because it's tiny compared to the early employee's value. But when the cost is $10m or $25m or $50m a year, it's definitely something to think about. And only the hyper-grown companies that popped up recently (Twitter, Zynga, Groupon) have had to face this problem.
It's not Zynga's money. Zynga wants it to be, but it isn't.
The 2-5 or so guys at the very top of Zynga want it to be, because they think Zynga should create a few more billionaires, instead of several dozen more millionaires. To wit, they think THEY should be made into billionaires rather than paying the folks who created the value of the company.
Hard to be shocked by this, since this has been the direction American business has been traveling in for a few decades now, but usually the PR side of it is handled better.
It's a fundamental concept of contract law that the damages for breaching a contract are what are necessary to put the aggrieved party in the same position he would've been but for the breach. The rule exists precisely for this sort of scenario: when people bargain up front about highly uncertain things like this, they come to an understanding about risk/reward, potential cost and potential upside. In retrospect one party or the other is almost certainly going to get more or less than he or she expected. If courts didn't hold people to their promises, one party would nearly always have an incentive to back out, and nobody would ever enter into uncertain transactions.
What Zynga is doing is at best unethical. The rub here is that we're dealing with unvested options. If it were trying to force employees to give up vested options it wouldn't be just unethical, it would be straight-up illegal. An options contract is a property interest, and can be readily valued in this circumstance.
Even dealing with unvested options Zynga might've opened themselves up to liability. "At will employment" doesn't mean "anything goes." Also, the contract the employees had re: the options could be a second source of liability.
Instead it is about compensation for said employment. If lawyers get involved, I bet this is where it will go. Also understand the last thing Zynga should want is for lawyers to get involved in this for two reasons:
1) It's distracting to management and
2) From what the WSJ says about it, this sort of thing hasn't gone much before the courts so there is a lot of uncertainty as to what the law allows and Zynga could lose big.
If the affected employees are smart they will use these factors to their advantages and get lawyers involved right now, forcing Zynga to back off or fight.
At-will employment does not mean without reason at any time, and while I am not a lawyer, I believe making a threat of termination if you don't sign over your unvested options would be a good case for wrongful termination.
See also: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/At-will_employment#Covenant_of_...
I had a phone call interview scheduled with Zynga today, but I read this story first. I didn't even pick up the phone when they called me.
Future options are precisely what was on the table when negotiating and subsequently accepted an offer form a startup.
This is equivalent to employees taking options for a company that had failed then three years in going back to the ceo and saying, "You know, I'd like to trade these worthless options for the $20K/year of salary that I gave up. Thanks"
Here's a possibly analogous scenario: Imagine this was salary instead of stock: an employee was hired because he was the foremost expert on technology X. To entice him to join, the employee was offered $1m/year for each year that he stayed, up to 4 years. Now it's 2.5 years in, and for various reasons the employee is no longer worth $1m/year to the company: perhaps X is no longer a useful technology, or expertise on X is no longer needed, or there has been an explosion of experts on technology X who would be happy with $200k/year. Would you say it was unethical to tell the employee that while the $2.5 million he has earned so far is obviously his, you can't justify paying him another 1.5 million in the next year and a half, and that he can either accept a pay decrease or be asked to leave?
Here's another analogous scenario: Imagine that you are hired under a contract that says "We don't have the cash on hand today to pay you full market rate today, so we're going to pay you $X per month (which is significantly below market rate), plus $250k bonus at the end of each full year that you're working for us, up to $1m over 4 years, assuming the company lasts that long". Two years pass, and they come back and say "You know what? We decided we don't want to pay you your remaining $500k in promised compensation over the next 2 years. Forfeit that part of your compensation package, or we're going to fire you." You accepted the original compensation deal because the year-end bonuses were adequate compensation for the monthly pay cut you were taking. Stock options aren't just icing handed out on top of already perfectly-acceptable contracts just because.
Employees got these options in exchange for something -- less salary, or risk. Your hypothetical didn't give up anything for that salary -- it's not like the employee turned down $1.1M for $1.0M. I refer you to the symmetric situation in my previous comment: if Zynga hadn't worked out, would Pinkus be giving long term employees the cash they gave up for their options?
My gut instinct was that was a jerk move, but after thinking about it I'm not so sure. Here's my answer from Quora... I'd love to know what others think.
(On a side note, the article cited on Quora mentions that employees were asked to give up some unvested options, but that their vested options are not affected.)
==============
This is a slight oversimplification, but a typical stock option grant of, say, .4% of a company is akin to the CEO telling you, "for every year that you work for us, I will give you .1% of the company." For early startup employees who typically take below market salaries, this kind of stock grant is one of the things that makes working at a startup more worthwhile (financially speaking).
It's exceedingly rare that a startup grows to a billion dollar valuation within a few years of founding, but when that happens, it makes sense for the company to re-evaluate whether it's worth giving someone an extra .1% for one more year of work. When a company is young and not worth much, giving someone $10k in paper value as a loyalty bonus is a no-brainer; when a company is worth billions, giving the same person a 50 million dollar loyalty bonus requires a lot more thought. It might still make sense if they're the COO or CFO or something like that, but does it make sense if they are a "Lead Software Engineer" or "Senior Product Manager"? How many "Lead Software Engineers" could you hire with 50 million dollars of stock? Put this way, I think it's reasonable that Zynga wants to let some early people go at their current compensation rates (and California has at-will employment, so you can quit or be let go without reason at any time.)
Note #1: I think this sucks for the early employees, and I certainly would not want to work for a company whose founders have a history of these kinds of practices, but that doesn't make the practices unethical.
Note #2: My answer would be very different if Zynga were trying to take back options that had already vested.
I am not a laywer, so my assumptions about how at-will employment works might not be 100% correct.Edit