Here's a possibly analogous scenario: Imagine this was salary instead of stock: an employee was hired because he was the foremost expert on technology X. To entice him to join, the employee was offered $1m/year for each year that he stayed, up to 4 years. Now it's 2.5 years in, and for various reasons the employee is no longer worth $1m/year to the company: perhaps X is no longer a useful technology, or expertise on X is no longer needed, or there has been an explosion of experts on technology X who would be happy with $200k/year. Would you say it was unethical to tell the employee that while the $2.5 million he has earned so far is obviously his, you can't justify paying him another 1.5 million in the next year and a half, and that he can either accept a pay decrease or be asked to leave?
Here's another analogous scenario: Imagine that you are hired under a contract that says "We don't have the cash on hand today to pay you full market rate today, so we're going to pay you $X per month (which is significantly below market rate), plus $250k bonus at the end of each full year that you're working for us, up to $1m over 4 years, assuming the company lasts that long". Two years pass, and they come back and say "You know what? We decided we don't want to pay you your remaining $500k in promised compensation over the next 2 years. Forfeit that part of your compensation package, or we're going to fire you." You accepted the original compensation deal because the year-end bonuses were adequate compensation for the monthly pay cut you were taking. Stock options aren't just icing handed out on top of already perfectly-acceptable contracts just because.
Employees got these options in exchange for something -- less salary, or risk. Your hypothetical didn't give up anything for that salary -- it's not like the employee turned down $1.1M for $1.0M. I refer you to the symmetric situation in my previous comment: if Zynga hadn't worked out, would Pinkus be giving long term employees the cash they gave up for their options?
This is equivalent to employees taking options for a company that had failed then three years in going back to the ceo and saying, "You know, I'd like to trade these worthless options for the $20K/year of salary that I gave up. Thanks"