Yet I find the layout in Sourcehut really confusing and not self-explanatory.
Not having a bugtracker UI and having to jump around different FQDNs related to the same project is a usability killer for me.
I don't expect forges to copy github. E.g. trac is very different but still has a rational and friendly layout.
EDIT: I also like that codeberg.org is non-profit and community-driven. If the sourcehut UI was to become usable I wish codeberg would run an instance of sourcehut.
Another aspect I would love to see is federation.
I'm eager to see that implemented, because it will be a good step forward.
> "bloated Javascript"
> "pointless javascript"
> "javascript-free UIs"
I don't know how much people have worked in UI and with front-end code (HTML/CSS/JS) but... the commenter criticised the UI. Javascript is not a UI language. Being a front-end language it's used a lot in close conjunction with UI components to control interactivity and data flow, but it has no responsibility for their appearance. In terms of aesthetic visual design, the amount of Javascript you have behind it isn't really relevant.
I do see a lot of people mentioning performance (which is a great feature of Sourcehut's), but is also a separate topic.
(fwiw I also love Javascriptless interfaces, not arguing that)
That's why people were mentioning JS. If you've worked on frontend UI then you can't tell me you don't know what I'm talking about.
(And yes, I know it can be done with just CSS instead of moving an absolutely-positioned header with JS in scroll events. Tell that to the websites that do it, not to me.)
Noone was talking about whizzbangs here, least of all the gp.
It's like that so that page sizes are as a small as possible, to cater for all users on all platforms in all locations. Not everyone is American or European with a gigabit connection. No pointless theming, no pointless javascript, no trackers and so on.
it feels all too common for folks to rage against bloaty interfaces (i agree, they're terrible!) but swing wildly back towards clunky browser-default randomness. you can have a consistent, polished interface without javascript and tons of images!
one thing w/ sourcehut that i find adds confusion is their choice to make their various services (source vs tickets vs mailing lists) completely separate apps. start on this page:
https://sr.ht/~martijnbraam/photoflow/
when you click on the "source" tab what do you expect will happen? i expect i'll go to a page with a source tree, listing files and directories. i also expect that i'll now be on the "source" tab at the new page, and will have the option to click back to the "summary" tab or any of the others that i currently see.
instead, you're taken to basically the same exact summary page (displaying README content) but with some git commit info on top. the highlighted tab is now... SUMMARY, AGAIN and there's a completely different tab set available to you. there is no way to click anywhere to get back to the previous version of the summary page and explore that tab group further.
i'm sure this makes sense to some folks (and they'll explain why i'm wrong below), but to me it feels like a cohesive user experience is not being prioritized here, and that's something i value ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
A sourcehut project can have as many as them as there are required. Therefore the Source tab takes you to the main git/HG repo that you have added for your project.
That's also the reason why the descriptions are different, one is of the project, the other is of the repository.
It's only confusing if you dismiss everything that's not a clone of github without investing the little time it takes to learn about the differences.
However reviewing now I’ll say that for whatever reason it seems things are much improved. Still not my personal favorite but significantly more clear.
The register link is actually: https://meta.sr.ht/register. You pointed to meta homepage. When you proceed to enter your info (username/password) you'll see the layouts are consistent.
Even if we compare, https://meta.sr.ht/register/step2 and https://meta.sr.ht/login, the widths of the layouts are different (730px vs 920px).
e.g.:
The current homepage has an odd out-of-place looking blue banner. This is largely down to uneven margins and paddings applied to the banner content - in particular vertical paddings aren't optically aligned with horizontal.
This same issue was once common through sourcehut's content but it's already clear how much that's improved looking at how much better the primary homepage content looks in contrast to the banner.
There's little tiny niggling issues like that everywhere - often related to vertical alignment not matching horizontal alignment - and while each is individually negligible, the cumulative affect is a bit jarring. But I still see it improving all the time.
Or maybe it's just a matter of taste? Personally I find many popular proprietary applications (including web "applications") as comfortable and enjoyable to use as walking on two hands backwards while blindfolded. Yet most people around me seem quite satisfied.
Edit: As a commenter suggested, I will elaborate a little:
I'm a big fan of minimalist and lightweight UIs, that's not my issue with SourceHut's design. My issue is the disregard for several established UI principles (balance, proportion, repetition, etc.). Some examples:
- The login[0] and register[1] pages have completely inconsistent layouts (left aligned vs centered aligned, one has a header and the other not, etc.).
- The margin between the top navigation and page content is inconsistent from page to page.
- Inconsistent styling of links. Some links have an underline that disappears on mouseover, while for some other links, it's the opposite[2].
- Inconsistent use of margin/padding all over the place.
Etc.
[0] https://meta.sr.ht/login
[1] https://meta.sr.ht/
[2] https://sr.ht/~martijnbraam/photoflow/ see "View project feed" vs "public-inbox" links at the top.