News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kentrado on Sunday July 24, 2022 @06:35AM (#32212049)
France wanted revenge for Haiti's independence and to send a message to its other colonies. So, Haiti had to pay huge amounts of money to France until 1947. In order to fund this, they began harvesting wood at an unsustainable pace which led to deforestation. This in turn led to a decrease in agricultural output which started a cascade of other problems.

It has been essential for the development of almost every country in a similar situation, to initially rely heavily on agriculture. If you remove that, then that's a recipe for disaster.

There wasn't knowledge/investment in the country to jump to an industrial economy so they got stuck in their developmental phase, because of the massive deforestation.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tchalla on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:14AM (#32212298)
And unfortunately, it's not just France

> For decades to come, the United States was the dominant power in Haiti, dissolving parliament at gunpoint, killing thousands and shipping a big portion of Haiti’s earnings to bankers in New York while the farmers who helped generate the profits often lived near starvation.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/20/world/americas/takeaways-...

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by PontifexMinimus on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:02AM (#32212209)
You say it was a huge amount; the article says it was a small amount. Unfortunately neither of you states the amount, so it is hard for me to assess how big it was.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tchalla on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:19AM (#32212323)
> After reviewing thousands of pages of archival documents, some centuries old, and consulting with 15 of the world’s leading economists, our correspondents calculated that the payments to France cost Haiti from $21 billion to $115 billion in lost economic growth over time. That is as much as eight times the size of Haiti’s entire economy in 2020.

https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/20/world/americas/takeaways-...

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by makomk on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:48AM (#32212518)
That's not the actual size of Haiti's reparations to France though - it's completely imaginaary, hypothetical money that the New York Times is claiming Haiti would've made if not for the evil colonialists ruining their economy through reparations. The actual total reparations according to that article were $560 million in today's dollars, or between a fortieth to a two hundreth of how much the NYT is claiming it really cost Haiti. That claim should probably be taken with a massive pinch of salt given the quality of their reporting on race, slavery and colonialism of late.

Just the way they seem to be comparing the supposed cost of those reparations over all time to one year of GDP here seems pretty slimy. The part you quoted is clearly intended to make an inattentive reader think Haiti's GDP would've been eigth times larger if not for reparations, but not only is that not what it actually says, it's impossible to tell how big the supposed loss is compared to the size of their economy - the two are stated in incomparable ways.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tchalla on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:41AM (#32214515)
> But the loss to Haiti cannot just be measured by adding up how much was paid to France and to outside lenders over the years.

> Every franc shipped across the Atlantic to an overseas bank vault was a franc not circulating among Haiti’s farmers, laborers and merchants, or not being invested in bridges, schools or factories — the sort of expenditures that help nations become nations, that enable them to prosper.

The cost of reparations versus the impact is different. The impact is a guesstimate, the cost isn’t.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by booblik on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:24PM (#32215609)
In fact, the money not paid to France would be simply stolen by local kleptocrats
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by faeriechangling on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:51AM (#32212534)
The debt with France does not have any explanatory power as to why the DR's and Haiti's economic fates diverged though. Even if the debt held Haiti back from the glory it would have otherwise seen, or stagnated its economic development by many decades, we would still expect Haiti's economy to grow AFTER the debt was paid off to a much greater extent than it did.

There to me, is clearly more afoot here than the evils of France.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Spooky23 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:52AM (#32212983)
It’s not like the entire country worked weekends to pay this off.

The debt skimmed the cream from the country, and the political maneuvering by various parties introduced pliant, corrupt leadership. Haiti has been a failed state for a long time.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by EUROCARE on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:57AM (#32213036)
No we wouldn't, if the debt caused destruction of the local environment (which it did) there's no way how they could've started making money. Just importing food and other basic goods would starve their resources and give them no room for investment.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by faeriechangling on Sunday July 24, 2022 @06:24PM (#32218378)
Looking into the stats, Haiti had 60% of forest cover in 1923 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deforestation_in_Haiti. If the debt made deforestation inevitable, why did Haiti have so many forests far into the servicing of the debt? I feel there MUST be something which happened in the 20th century which really accelerated deforestation aside from the debt.

I just don't buy the "debt destroyed all future economic/agricultural output" angle at all. If you just showed people a bunch of chart of different countries economic information and agricultural output devoid of broader context, nobody would probably EVER come to the conclusion that the debt led to the stagnation in agricultural output in Haiti from the numbers alone. If you compared the debt vs deforestation, again, nobody would conclude the debt caused the deforestation from the actual data. People would only ever conclude that if they're being shown unblinded data.

Let me stress here - I'm not even saying this must all be Haiti's fault, or that debt didn't have a profound impact which have shrunk Haiti's economy many times over. I'm saying the debt doesn't explain what happened. I feel like I'm getting a fraction of the picture here. All sorts of wild shit happened in Haiti in the 20th century, the United States occupied the country for instance and the deforestation correlates MUCH more strongly with this occupation than it does the debt.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by bluepizza on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:41AM (#32212469)
Not only that range is wildly imprecise, it also happens to not answer the question.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by dantondwa on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:49AM (#32212527)
I will post here the first paragraph of [1], as it directly provides this bit of information:

"The Haiti indemnity controversy involves an 1825 agreement between Haiti and France that included France demanding a 150 million franc indemnity to be paid by Haiti in claims over property – including Haitian slaves – that was lost through the Haitian Revolution in return for diplomatic recognition, with the debt costing Haiti $21 to 115 billion of economic growth over a period of two centuries and affecting the nation to this day. The payment was later reduced to 90 million francs in 1838, comparable to US$21 billion as of 2004, with Haiti paying about 112 million francs in total.[4] Over the 122 years between 1825 and 1947 the debt severely hampered Haitian economic development as payments of interest and downpayments totaled a significant share of Haitian GDP yearly, constraining the use of domestic financial funds for infrastructure, public services and ultimately making the nation ungovernable."

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haiti_indemnity_controversy

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by onphonenow on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:09AM (#32212261)
It’s not clear they fell behind during the debt period. The timing is off isn’t it. They fell behind later

Aren’t there other crazy divergences out there? Singapore and mylasia or something?

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by thematrixturtle on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:05AM (#32212626)
Singapore is a compact city-state, Malaysia has almost 500x the land area split across two major land masses to boot.

The classic divergence is North vs South Korea, which were practically identical until the Korean War. Historically the North was richer, now the South is orders of magnitude wealthier.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tut-urut-utut on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:05AM (#32213613)
Obviously two Koreas had different priorities. What you said is true, but on the other hand, North Korea is an independent nuclear power, while South Korea is a kind of corrupt vassal state hosting foreign army on their soil.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by laverya on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:25PM (#32216730)
> North Korea is an independent nuclear power

South Korea, like Japan, is a "latent" nuclear power - meaning they have the ability to quickly (likely a matter of months) produce nuclear weapons given current resources and expertise.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_latency

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ianhawes on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:21AM (#32213754)
“Independent” if we pretend China doesn’t exist.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by everybodyknows on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:34PM (#32215703)
> vassal state hosting foreign army on their soil.

By that criterion, Japan and Germany are likewise "vassal states".

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tut-urut-utut on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:12PM (#32216619)
Of course they are. When was the last time Germany actually did something against the interest of the Empire?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by laverya on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:25PM (#32216739)
When they decided to rely on Russia for their energy security?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tut-urut-utut on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:50PM (#32218114)
They did not really decide. What was the reasonable alternative?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by laverya on Sunday July 24, 2022 @06:10PM (#32218271)
Not shutting down their nuclear power plants is an easy first step. Building more nuclear, developing local fossil fuel sources, and building LNG offload terminals would all be good second steps, though of course also more expensive.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by tut-urut-utut on Monday July 25, 2022 @06:23AM (#32222569)
That's not a reasonable alternative.

More nuclear - after Fukushima not a realistic option.

LNG - would be useleff today, since the Empire decided to limit LNG exports. And even if the Germany could claim complete LNG world export capacities all for itself, it would still not be enough.

local fossil fuel sources - there are none that are not already in use

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by laverya on Monday July 25, 2022 @11:34AM (#32225834)
Fukushima may have been bad (this is debatable, it was bad in public opinion more than anything else), but viewed in comparison to "not having enough power leading to industry shutting down (happening now) or people freezing to death (this winter)" or "not being able to oppose Russia" perhaps it's not quite so unrealistic.

As far as I know the USA has not restricted LNG exports. LNG is still very cheap in the USA in comparison to the rest of the world because our export terminals are operating at capacity. (To be fully effective, more global LNG export capacity may need to be developed - this is very possible as the US has excess capacity, but it is of course more expensive than just importing from Russia)

There are local fossil fuel sources! Lots of coal, for instance. Yes, this option sucks, and releases a ton of pollution! But you can still do it!

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by selimnairb on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:58AM (#32213554)
Isn’t this just path dependence in action (a least in part). If Haiti hadn’t paid reparations to France for a century plus, they would have had more resources to invest in building their own industries/capacity.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by user3939382 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @06:53AM (#32212168)
That France could extract this high a price really puts the concept of “independence” into perspective.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:13PM (#32215501)
I think it rather puts the competency of Haiti's government into perspective... if needed be.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by prvc on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:11AM (#32212665)
Do you have a source for your claim that the imposition of reparations was motivated by a desire for "revenge"?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by fredestine on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:22AM (#32212339)
south korea also paid huge amounts of money to developed nations in exchange they applied policies that were favoring those countries. they are now one of the most developed countries on earth.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by rurban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:29AM (#32212393)
sure, the power of fascism. as long as you engage in fascist politics, you will be rich.

in Haiti the US ensured that nothing much changed in the last century. this article is the typical mouthpiece of such propaganda

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:11PM (#32215477)
France is used as a scapegoat. The situation of Haiti today has nothing to do with France.

Haiti has, and has had, an utterly corrupt and incompetent government/state. That's why they are in the situation they are in.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kentrado on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:47PM (#32216414)
>Haiti has, and has had, an utterly corrupt and incompetent government/state. That's why they are in the situation they are in.

So does the Dominican Republic government.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by mytailorisrich on Sunday July 24, 2022 @03:44PM (#32216936)
There are different levels in everything and you'd be hard-pressed to find worse than Haiti.

According to Wikipedia, the Dominican Republic has the fastest growing economy of the Americas while Haiti is the poorest country in the Americas (And neither has anything to do with France, and since the US meddled in both and even occupied both they probably have little to do with either as well)

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kentrado on Sunday July 24, 2022 @04:13PM (#32217223)
The difference is not that Dominicans are smarter Hatians (which I think is what you are dancing around). The DR has enjoyed more political stability due to the amount of foreign investments in the country which would have never happened if the DR was stuck in a precarious developmental stage, as it was the case with Haiti.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by mytailorisrich on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:45AM (#32221250)
Please don't be disingenuous and accuse others of racism when you run out of arguments.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by TMWNN on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:38PM (#32216326)
>Haiti has, and has had, an utterly corrupt and incompetent government/state. That's why they are in the situation they are in.

Relevant Reddit post: TIL that Haiti has had 23 constitutions since 1801, with the most recent being enacted in 2012. At least two have declared the country to be an empire.

<https://np.reddit.com/r/todayilearned/comments/3t5wzt/til_th...>

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by leereeves on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:27AM (#32212780)
> deforestation ... in turn led to a decrease in agricultural output

Can you explain your theory here?

Deforestation happened all over the world and usually increased agricultural output (by creating more farmland). Why do you think deforestation led to a different outcome in Haiti?

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kentrado on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:53AM (#32212987)
This was excessive deforestation due to the pressures of the debt. Which led to desertification. This excessive deforestation didn't happen in the Dominican Republic, which explains the difference. If you visit Haiti and the Dominican Republic you would be able to tell the difference in climate and soil.

"To the west of the island of Hispaniola is Haiti, only 3% of which now has forest coverage. Although the Dominican Republic that makes up the east of the island still has 23%. At least 90% of Haiti’s soils have been severely degraded by deforestation and inappropriate cultivation as compared to 40% for the Dominican Republic." [1]

[1] - https://www.researchgate.net/publication/269670285_A_Case_St...

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by EdwardDiego on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:25AM (#32213272)
Not sure if desertification is the right word for "all the fertile topsoil washed off the hills in the rains, and without trees to moderate drainage, river flood more often, and those floods cover productive land downstream in infertile silt".
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kentrado on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:48AM (#32213481)
Those things aren't mutually exclusive. Did you take from what I said to mean that the entire country turned into a desert?

Haiti has become more desertic in some parts due to the deforestation and that causes a number of things to happen that affect soil quality including floods.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Spooky23 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:55AM (#32213012)
Perhaps try googling “Haiti deforestation” at a bare minimum.

tl;dr, they needed cash crops, the forests were cut down to grow coffee.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:27AM (#32213298)
Might also be worth stating, that it was a restored French Monarchy, in conjunction with other European Monarchies that extorted this money with a threat of invasion.

Since they were basically doing the same all across Europe in the same period, putting down the first tentative steps into modern European democracy, we don't really need to frame it as Haitians Vs French, but (literally) right-wing vs democracy.

https://www.history.com/.amp/news/how-did-the-political-labe...

Which also would appear to be the basis for the current split in opinion too.

[dead]
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by nosianu on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:12AM (#32212278)
> genocide

> confiscation of their property and land

Which is how they got it too, so at the very least I would be careful about using that as justification.

From https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Haiti#Spanish_histo...

"Following the arrival of Europeans, La Hispaniola's indigenous Taino population suffered greatly to near extinction, in possibly the worst case of depopulation in the Americas."

I don't think that just because it's different people now on both sides makes it possible to use such actions to argue from a moral high ground, the power difference and who oppressed whom remained in place even though the peoples changed.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ambrozk on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:01PM (#32215967)
With Haiti, you don't have to go all the way back to the settling of the island for brutality. The closest analogue I've read to the behavior of the French who ruled Haiti was the treatment of camp inmates by the Nazis. Haiti was the worst colony in the Caribbean. It made the antebellum South look like a utopia in comparison. The life expectancy for slaves sent to Haiti was abysmal. Most of them died on the plantations within about 10 years of stepping on the island. So many died that in order to sustain the slave population, the French had to import tens of thousands every year. They wanted to create a native slave population, but it didn't work because they worked the slave women so hard that they made them infertile. They ruled by means of terror. The stories are sickening. They executed disobedient slaves by stuffing their rectums with gunpowder and blowing them up. They strapped them down and poured boiling cane sugar over their heads. They buried them up to their necks and smeared them with honey so that they'd be eaten by insects. For punishment, they cut off their slaves' limbs and poured hot wax on the stumps. This had gone on for a century prior to the revolution. By that time, there were about 500,000 slaves being ruled over by 30,000 whites (as well as, partially, 40,000 mixed-race Haitians).

It was not smart or good for Dessalines to massacre the 4000 or so whites that he did, but that act is so minor in comparison with the horror that the French visited on Haiti for 100 years that it's barely worth talking about.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:31AM (#32212411)
You forgot to mention that it was due to diseases carried by europeans, it was not voluntary. The 5000 white killed the day of independence of Haiti was voluntary.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by EdwardDiego on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:35AM (#32213383)
Yeah, the Spanish were renowned for their moderation in Central and South America... they never killed anyone on purpose...

Seriously?

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kzrdude on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:43AM (#32212485)
How many voluntary mass killings of thousands of people did the europeans not commit in their clash with the new world?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by randunel on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:35AM (#32212834)
As a European whose country suffered and was enslaved for long periods of time, I take offence in the rhetoric of "Europeans" committing such crimes. Be specific, a subset of European nations, a subset of American nations, and a subset of Asian nations try to dominate others through violence.

So, name your country if you've done such deeds, but keep mine out of it.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by orangepurple on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:09AM (#32213130)
To add to this, there are 87 distinct peoples in Europe (Pan and Pfeil (2004))
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by EdwardDiego on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:34AM (#32213373)
Your country joined the Axis, massacred Jews, fought alongside Nazi Germany in Ukraine, and annexed Transnistria.

Really weird hill you've chosen to take offense and die on. But sure, a subset of European nations try to dominate others through violence.

And your country is in that set.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:06AM (#32214167)
Don't put every european nation on the same scale when it goes to mass killings. Here the subject is Haiti, now please tell me how many voluntary mass killings happened.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Nesco on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:10AM (#32212664)
This is textbook whataboutism
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by kzrdude on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:15AM (#32212698)
That starts with nosianu's post a few levels up, not here, don't you agree?

My response is trying to poke a hole in what Glawen said to deflect.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by nosianu on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:54PM (#32216471)
Not quite sure about where we ended up here, but just to clarify, just in case.

I don't think it is whataboutism when it is relevant. I think it should have been considered in the initial argument, the one I replied to, to begin with.

The "genocide of its white population and confiscation of their property and land." - from the comment I replied to - was preceded by terrible atrocities by the people then in power against those who revolted (also see the comment from ambrozk). I think that is relevant to the discussion. Whataboutism brings in stuff that is not relevant and unrelated, to distract. I think I'm still right inside the same topic, one leading to the other.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:13AM (#32212288)
Confiscation is a strange word to use if the "Property" included slaves:

> France demanding a 150 million franc indemnity to be paid by Haiti in claims over property – including Haitian slaves

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by zajio1am on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:17AM (#32212703)
It is not all or nothing. From today viewpoint, slave freedom and compensation from slaveowners is a legitimate goal, while confiscation of property (especially of non-slaveowners) and genocide is not defensible.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by wittycardio on Sunday July 24, 2022 @04:51PM (#32217583)
Killing of slavers is perfectly defensible actually.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by throwawaycities on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:27AM (#32212373)
The old and rarely used we stole your land and enslaved you fair and square defense.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by mandmandam on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:42AM (#32212476)
Not that rarely used, unfortunately. I've heard this argument delivered genuinely from kind old ladies who care a lot about ethics, history, anthropology etc.

It seems to be the "Godwin's Law" of political discussion. At some point it always goes back to might making right.

... Apologies if that was your [ought to be obvious but these days sure af isn't] point.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by throwawaycities on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:41AM (#32212876)
> I've heard this argument delivered genuinely from kind old ladies who care a lot about ethics, history, anthropology etc.

You ever ask them how many wars they fought?

It’s one thing to champion might is right, it’s another to draw a line in the sand once the slaves revolt and overthrow the slave masters.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ambrozk on Sunday July 24, 2022 @01:38PM (#32215746)
Note that the "property" that the Haitians had confiscated from the French included, in the opinion of the French government, the Haitians themselves. So the French, in effect, forced the Haitians to pay for the right not to be slaves.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by VictorPath on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:10AM (#32212269)
> confiscation of their property and land

Observe the colonial/imperial mindset - gun-trotting French sail to the Caribbean and steal land from Taino Indians, and kidnap and enslave Africans to do the work. Then back home, the king is guillotined and eventually even Danton is guillotined. The enslaved Africans eventually rebel against the slave masters, and they get into a sanctimonious huff about how "their land" was confiscated.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:40AM (#32212468)
As you mention, it is also not the slaves land either as they came from Africa. So why is it more slaves land than french land?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by boomboomsubban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:52AM (#32212543)
Ignoring the evidence that the enslaved Taino to some extent integrated with the imported slaves, the slaves made up 90% of the population and likely an even higher percentage of the workforce. That should give them the best claim to the land
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:52AM (#32214051)
So once we reach 90% of the population we can rightfully claim the land? That's how it works? Let me take note for the future then.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by boomboomsubban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @11:38AM (#32214488)
I mean yeah? If your people spend a century integrating with the locals and working the land to the point where you make up the overwhelming majority of the population, it's pretty fair to say you have some right to it.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Glawen on Monday July 25, 2022 @02:51AM (#32221302)
Well that is one way of achieving it, the other being killing the local population and get more settlers.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by concordDance on Sunday July 24, 2022 @06:42PM (#32218528)
Doesn't every modern nation have the land owned by a tiny minority?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by zajio1am on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:26AM (#32212773)
Stealing land from Taino people is as much unacceptable as confiscation of land of french citizens, and i am sure if there were some large Taino empire then it could protect property rights of Taino people against colonialists, but that is centuries before Haiti revolution, and since that property rights were clearly established.

If you look on individual level, then it is clear that person A cannot just stole property from person B and defend that by the fact that great-grandfather of person B stole it from person C.

[dead]
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:43AM (#32212484)
I heard they rounded up the elites and chopped off their heads in front of cheering crowds, the savages.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reign_of_Terror

Of course, some modern historians suggest that the real terror was on the other side and that it was mostly propaganda.

[dead]
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by ZeroGravitas on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:00AM (#32212588)
It tells you in the article, the White Terror killed him, and then started calling what he did "The Terror" to discredit him, while they killed lots of their political enemies.

Don't mess with powerful people or they will kill you, and make you the villain of the story.

> The term "Terror" being used to describe the period was introduced by the Thermidorian Reaction who took power after the fall of Maximilien Robespierre in July 1794,[1][2] to discredit Robespierre and justify their actions.[3] Today there is consensus amongst historians that the exceptional revolutionary measures continued after the death of Robespierre, and this subsequent period is now called the "White Terror".

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by deepdriver on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:14AM (#32212691)
I'm struggling to follow your analogy. The Reign of Terror (slavery on Haiti?) fed into a reactionary White Terror (1804 massacre?), which in turn led to the rise of another brutal dictator and the return of all that was bad about the monarchy. Is that right?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by boomboomsubban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:43AM (#32212486)
The 1804 Hatian Massacre was a tragic event that killed about 5000 whites. For the century of slavery in Saint Dominique, around 10000 slaves a year died due to the oppression of slavery. So why did the French deserve revenge and not the Hatians?
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by JumpCrisscross on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:45AM (#32212502)
> why did the French deserve revenge and not the Hatians?

Nobody deserves revenge. We deserve justice. But slavery and massacres are fundamentally unjust. Revenge perpetuates cycles of misery—that’s the story here.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by alex_smart on Sunday July 24, 2022 @08:13AM (#32212682)
Everybody deserves justice, but some people deserve justice more than others.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by deepdriver on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:02PM (#32218692)
Do the Tutsis "deserve revenge" against Hutus for the Rwandan Genocide, including women and children and Hutus who had nothing to do with the killing? According to your logic, yes. Fortunately for all involved, a counter-genocide in Rwanda was avoided. 30 years later Rwanda has comparitively low levels of corruption, high tourism, good international relations, and a rapidly developing economy. Compare that to Haiti in 1834, or Haiti today.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by boomboomsubban on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:42PM (#32220027)
You're the one who seemed to be saying the French deserve revenge based on the 1804 massacre. I find the treatment of slaves in Haiti, the massacre, and the indemnity to all be abhorrent acts that should never have happened.

And I don't get your further point. The Hatians taking revenge is what caused their problems, despite the French also taking revenge without similar problems?

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by deepdriver on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:48PM (#32220048)
I think you’ve mistaken my point for something it’s not. The “revenge” demanded by the French was financial indemnity, hardly equivalent to genocide. As it happens, I also don’t think the Haitians should ever have agreed to pay it (not worth diplomatic recognition in my view), but I do understand why the French were upset after the bloody and unnecessary Massacre of 1804. That doesn't mean they deserved revenge, but it does explain their motivation. The desire for such a harsh indemnity cannot be understood without this context, which the article and OC left out. The massacre and its consequences had profound effects on Haiti’s early development and international relations.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by upofadown on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:40AM (#32212464)
Not really a genocide as such. The people were not being massacred because they were European, they were being massacred because they were slavers. That doesn't even strike me as particularly unjust, particularly for an era where serious crimes resulted in capital punishment. Slavery steals lives too and in a more horrific way than straight up murder.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Paradigma11 on Sunday July 24, 2022 @07:53AM (#32212549)
From what i remember reading up on it last time many of those massacred fought on the side of the slaves for an independent haiti.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by deepdriver on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:05AM (#32213614)
I also remembered that quote from the Wiki page, but it seems there's controversy over the source:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:1804_Haiti_massacre#Sympa...

I don't know if I agree with the editor's rationale for removal, but they list the source book's title if you're interested to dig deeper.

Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by legalcorrection on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:44AM (#32213449)
Wrong. They killed every white person they could possibly find.
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by Apocryphon on Sunday July 24, 2022 @10:08AM (#32213648)
Re:Hispaniola's great divergence by legalcorrection on Sunday July 24, 2022 @09:43AM (#32213439)
The reparations were not for independence, but for the genocide the revolting slaves committed against every white person they could find in Haiti.