Re:Hispaniola's great divergence
by nosianu on Sunday July 24, 2022 @02:54PM
(#32216471)
Not quite sure about where we ended up here, but just to clarify, just in case.
I don't think it is whataboutism when it is relevant. I think it should have been considered in the initial argument, the one I replied to, to begin with.
The "genocide of its white population and confiscation of their property and land." - from the comment I replied to - was preceded by terrible atrocities by the people then in power against those who revolted (also see the comment from ambrozk). I think that is relevant to the discussion. Whataboutism brings in stuff that is not relevant and unrelated, to distract. I think I'm still right inside the same topic, one leading to the other.
I don't think it is whataboutism when it is relevant. I think it should have been considered in the initial argument, the one I replied to, to begin with.
The "genocide of its white population and confiscation of their property and land." - from the comment I replied to - was preceded by terrible atrocities by the people then in power against those who revolted (also see the comment from ambrozk). I think that is relevant to the discussion. Whataboutism brings in stuff that is not relevant and unrelated, to distract. I think I'm still right inside the same topic, one leading to the other.