News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:42AM (#32164294)
There is no "road tax" in the UK, is it? It's a fee for polluting, not using the road. I hate that it's being used as an argument against cyclists: "get off the road, you don't pay road tax". This of course also ignores that most adult cyclists also own a car..

Norway have the same issues now. Almost all new cars are electric. You don't pay purchase tax / vat when buying it. Pay less on toll roads. Cheaper to use. Etc. etc.

Which was great to get the initial people to convert, and get the infrastructure in place. But now it's time to tax them. Lots of budgets are now off because they estimated X amounts from cars using toll roads, but half of them don't pay the price.

While they don't emit carbon dioxide, they are just as deadly as normal cars. Also pollute more from the tires being heavier. Just as noisy. Need the same expensive roads. And as all cars they ruin the city.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by analog31 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:23AM (#32164714)
>>>> I hate that it's being used as an argument against cyclists: "get off the road, you don't pay road tax". This of course also ignores that most adult cyclists also own a car.

Indeed, here in the states, cyclists pay for the roads that we use. For instance most local roads in cities and counties are paid for with property taxes. Income taxes cover a fair amount of road construction. The county bike paths have a fee. We're not allowed to ride on the Interstates, and we tend to avoid "big" roads for safety / comfort reasons.

My hunch is that if one were to look closely at the funding of roads, one would find that they represent a net subsidy for heavy trucking.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by unglaublich on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:14AM (#32165317)
Some motorists seem to forget that cyclists don't need a 30m wide, 40cm thick, heavily reinforced highway with stabilized foundation that has to be revised every year to account for the damage caused by heavy vehicles.

The costs of a cycling path that support the same flow of people is negligible compared to that of a corresponding highway.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by asdff on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:22PM (#32170023)
No one ever says "why don't we charge pedestrians fees for sidewalks," for good reason. Bike infrastructure should be thought of as the same way. A paved bike path is going to be like a sidewalk: it will last as long as the elements permit it no matter the amount of usage it sees. Versus a road used for vehicular traffic that is heavy enough to degrade the road, that sort of usage makes a lot more sense to tax.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ars on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:40PM (#32170296)
That isn't true. Pedestrians put more pressure on the ground than cars do. Google it if you don't believe me.

The reason sidewalks last so long is they're made of cement rather than asphalt. If you made roads out of cement they would last just as long if not longer.

And the reason they make sidewalls out of cement is they have to. If they made then out of asphalt they would decay very quickly.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by unglaublich on Friday July 22, 2022 @05:33AM (#32190200)
"Google it if you don't believe me."

Or, just calculate it?

Car contact patch is 4 x 160cm2. https://www.tirerack.com/tires/tiretech/techpage.jsp?techid=... Car avg. weight is 1800kg. https://www.bankrate.com/insurance/car/average-car-weight/

Pressure = 28kPa

Human is 100cm2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pedobarography Average human weight is 75 kg.

Pressure = 8.5kPa.

So it's simply not true what you say.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ars on Friday July 22, 2022 @10:05AM (#32191967)
People don't normally walk barefoot.

Run the numbers for high heels, and keep in mind they might put their entire weight on the heel.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by asdff on Thursday July 21, 2022 @01:43PM (#32182411)
Have you ever seen an asphalt bike lane age? It never gets potholes. The top layer just expands and contracts or is invaded with tree roots. Over time the elements wear out the tar and the gravel loosens.

Compare that to a road where the truck literally forms grooves into the asphalt. It ripples like the viscous material it is in those conditions under multiple tons of weight. An intersection by me looks like its plaid with the grooves from perpendicular trucking traffic. And cement roads do last a long time but they aren't indestructible. I live on one. Trucks damage them and crack them up over time and the city has to fill in potholes. The more construction going on the more damage. Any big apartment build just destroys the concrete apron and sidewalk on the lot with the equipment because its that heavy. Orders of magnitude heavier than any human on a bike can be.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by salty_biscuits on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:20PM (#32185235)
Only if they are all wearing high heels... It isn't pressure that typically causes damage though, it is shear stress or frictional power.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by makomk on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:57AM (#32165866)
The thick, heavily reinforced roads with stabilized foundations generally have much nicer surfaces to cycle on than narrow cycle paths though, at least around here. Probably because a lot of the deterioration is caused by weather rather than traffic and the cost reduction is mostly through having lower standards and accepting more deterioration.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ehnto on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:56AM (#32166633)
I'd take a rough separated cycle path over a shared car road any day.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by timellis-smith on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:30AM (#32167211)
Depending on what type of bike you have. On a mountain bike, anyday. On a road bike with paper thin tyres that easily puncture, maybe not so much.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by analog31 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:51PM (#32170446)
Bikes are a lot less delicate than people seem to think. My daily driver has road bike rims and tires. They're quite durable. The region has some bike paths that are crushed limestone on hard clay, and sometimes I find myself on gravel roads, off-road shortcuts, or even "easy" mountain bike trails.

The main issue is comfort. Riding rough roads on hard tires gets old after a while. Also, real MTB'ing, where the trails are designed to be challenging, is its own beast.

I also prefer avoiding car traffic if possible.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ehnto on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:16AM (#32176662)
It's me that is not durable, if I had to ride daily on 80psi road tires I'd shake to bits!

Funnily enough I do MTB, and I have a full suspension and a fully rigid frame both offering their own challenges.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by jacquesm on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:02PM (#32167694)
Road bikes aren't really designed for being in traffic in the first place so that places some of the downsides of that on the user. I've used one for many years, so don't get me wrong, I love riding one but it is abundantly clear to me that when my bike tires fits into the slots of a drain that that is my problem and not the problem of whoever designs and maintains the road.

In many places a road bike isn't actually street legal (no bell, no fenders, no lights, of course you could add those).

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:09PM (#32170682)
It sounds peculiar that some places would have requirements for bells and fenders in order for a bike to be "street legal"; this strikes me as more of a quaint historical holdover than anything else. Some cyclists might be more comfortable with ringing their bell a than raising their voice if they need to urgently signal the attention of another road user, but a requirement for a bell on any bike is mystifying to me. Likewise fenders; cycling on wet roads can cause dirty water to be sprayed onto a vehicle that is driving close behind a cyclist, but people don't tend to cycle on road bikes in wet weather in the first place (unless their bike has been adapted), and people should maintain a safe stopping distance, especially in wet conditions. But the use of lights when cycling at night is a perfectly reasonable legal requirement (more or less universal in my experience), and perfectly effective temporary lights can be easily attached to road bikes if necessary.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by asdff on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:25PM (#32170070)
Just put some good tires on your road bike and you wont deal with flats. I have used gatorskins which have always been indestructable, tubes last for years and are only replaced when I put new tires on the bike. I'm moving to the continental gp5k for the next set because apparently the puncture resistance is good enough these days in those more standard road bike tires. Unless you manage to hit an upright nail you shouldn't worry too much.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:56AM (#32167594)
Usually the concern is getting hit by car traffic.

At least in the US, drivers don’t drive well around cyclists, and sometimes that’s intentional to boot. Better to not share the road with people who are actively trying to hurt you with a metal object weighing several thousand pounds.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ehnto on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:24PM (#32168074)
Definitely concur, for commuting I ride a pretty wide tire for that reason. I've actually really enjoyed cross-bikes for city commuting, since they're designed for a bit more of a pliable ride and more comfort while still running pretty fast overall.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by imtringued on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:26AM (#32167130)
No they don't, cyclists prefer concrete bike paths which both last longer and have a smoother surface.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ars on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:37PM (#32170267)
> The costs of a cycling path that support the same flow of people is negligible compared to that of a corresponding highway.

That's not true The ground pressure of a bicycle is higher than the ground pressure of a car.

Some bike tire pressures exceed 100 psi. Only the largest trucks have ground pressures that high. A typical passenger vehicle has a pressure of around 36 psi.

The ground pressure of someone in heels is even higher than that. There's a reason sidewalks are made of cement while roads can be made of cheaper asphalt.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by adrianN on Thursday July 21, 2022 @12:44AM (#32175863)
Ground pressure is not the only way a road wears.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dotancohen on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:24PM (#32168084)

  > My hunch is that if one were to look closely at the funding of roads, one would find that they represent a net subsidy for heavy trucking.
Road wear grows at the 4th power of vehicular weight, assuming similar tire pressures. An F-150 that weighs one and a half times what your Mazda 3 weighs, does 5 times the road wear.

Would you like to calculate how much those tomatoes would cost, if everybody were paying their fair share of road wear?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by jeroenhd on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:19PM (#32169981)
Based on [1] this first result on Google, a truck can carry about 300,000 tomatoes. I don't think those tomatoes are going to add up very soon. A loaded truck of about 80,000 pounds (11.5 times the weight) would have 17490 times the road impact compared to the same trip driven back home. Distributed over 300,000 tomatoes, the cost wouldn't be all that much. Despite inefficient engines and truck construction, bulk transport is actually very efficient. Generally speaking: the bigger the trailer, the better, even with the weight increase.

Even better would be using this as an incentive to expand and improve the quality of the much more efficient rail network (or transport over waterways, where available) to improve the entire supply chain. That would require the government to act in the interest of its people, though, so I don't think we'll see the effects of such a programme too soon if it ever makes it.

Every tax-paying citizen is already paying this heavy price! Only instead of the damage inefficient transport causes to our infrastructure being reflected in our everyday expenses, it's hidden from plain sight in taxes.

The only industry I'd expect to see killed by paying for road damage would be package delivery vans. They're driving long distances with comparatively almost no weight at all for the convenience of not needing to go to a centralized store to pick up your stuff. With the way Amazon and friends have their drivers pee in bottles, I don't see why we should subsidize those vans.

[1]: https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1999-oct-26-mn-26434...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dotancohen on Thursday July 21, 2022 @02:20AM (#32176368)
The issue isn't that 17490 / 300000 is a small number. The issue is that the road wear is not being paid by the entity creating that wear, and is disproportionately being borne by those actually trying to solve climate change problems by driving smaller, electric vehicles.

If there is currently not enough taxes being collected to maintain the roads, then start taxing those who do the most damage. That entity can then amortize the tax over their 300,000 tomatoes.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by jeroenhd on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:28AM (#32176725)
The problem with that is that the heavy electric cars are actually damaging the road more than their ICE counterparts because of their huge batteries. For some countries this isn't much of a problem, just buy a normal car instead if an SUV and you should get the cost difference back, but for others the mileage of current smaller electric cars just isn't practical.

We could make exemptions for electric vehicles powered by green energy like we do right now for trucks and other large equipment, but that'll mostly hit the poorer populations who can't afford an electric car. Tacking road maintenance costs onto other general goods in the form of taxes disproportionately hits people who try to avoid using a car for the environment and the liveability of their city, for example by taking public transport or a bike.

A future where everyone drives electric is going to be more expensive because of electric car technology. I'd say pay the difference with two different taxes: one for car weight/wheel load, another for pollution through (similarly hefty) gas taxes. Heavy EVs pay extra for the road damage, ICEs pay for their pollution to encourage cleaner cars, and heavy SUVs/pickup trucks pay both.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dotancohen on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:00AM (#32177150)

  > Tacking road maintenance costs onto other general goods in the form of taxes disproportionately hits people who try to avoid using a car for the environment and the liveability of their city, for example by taking public transport or a bike.
Those general goods will reflect the cost of actually getting them to the store. Why should I subsidize pornography magazines, canned pork, and other items that I don't use? Just have everybody pay their fair share of road wear, or at least as close to it as possible, and let the costs trickle down. If some items, e.g. baby diapers or bread, are deemed to be worthy of subsidy then directly subsidize them.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Ajedi32 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:54PM (#32170483)
> Would you like to calculate how much those tomatoes would cost, if everybody were paying their fair share of road wear?

The cost is already there, it's just extracted through taxes rather than through increased prices of transported goods.

The advantage of shifting maintenance costs over to those creating those costs in the first place is that it allows the market to properly optimize for those costs. If transporting those tomatoes by rail is actually cheaper overall once you factor in road maintenance costs, but you aren't charging those costs to the trucking companies, then they're just going to keep shipping tomatoes by truck even though it's less efficient. The invisible hand of the market cannot optimize for costs it doesn't know about.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Flockster on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:33PM (#32168249)
That sounds interesting, do you have some more infos about this, how the 4th power comes about? I don't have any intuition why it would be that "high". Or some keywords to lead my google searches ;)
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brianwawok on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:11PM (#32168892)
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by renewiltord on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @04:50PM (#32172131)
Study is here https://onlinepubs.trb.org/Onlinepubs/sr/sr61g/61g.pdf

But raw data is hard to find

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by mateo411 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @04:47PM (#32172098)
> Road wear grows at the 4th power of vehicular weight, assuming similar tire pressures.

That's fascinating, is there an equation for road wear in relation to vehicle weight and other factors?

--- EDIT ---

Ten seconds after I posted this, I see somebody else also asked this question and there is this link.

https://www.insidescience.org/news/how-much-damage-do-heavy-...

The fourth power rule, I guess it was empirically measured.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by analog31 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:53PM (#32170474)
Don't worry, I wasn't opposing the subsidy, just calling it for what it is. In a sense I'm helping reduce road wear by riding a bike. ;)
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by wil421 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:11AM (#32165287)
> Indeed, here in the states, cyclists pay for the roads that we use. For instance most local roads in cities and counties are paid for with property taxes.

Not true for a lot of states. Property tax is not used for roads. Georgia pays for roads using gas taxes and road use fees like registration (tolls contribute a very small amount). Florida is similar but they are much more toll heavy. Alabama is similar as too. All 3 states are in the top 10 roads in America[1]. I believe Georgia plans to charge higher registration fees for EVs at some point.

[1] https://www.consumeraffairs.com/automotive/us-road-condition...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by zip1234 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:13AM (#32166917)
Georgia is 3rd in Federal road subsidies: https://www.ajc.com/news/feds-transportation-spending/ Usage/registration fees pay for less of roads than people think.

There is also this: https://taxfoundation.org/states-road-funding-2019/

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by vel0city on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:29AM (#32167197)
It really depends on the road in question. I've absolutely voted for city bond projects paid for by property taxes which paid to redo intersections and sections of roads maintained by the city. There are county roads which are maintained by the county which gets most of its funding from property taxes, sales taxes, and vehicle registration taxes. Sure, some funding for some of these projects also come from the state's budgets which is often backed by gas taxes, some funding is from federal sources often by gas taxes, but some of it does come from my property taxes.

Then there are state roads, which are almost entirely funded from state and federal (gas) taxes, and federal roads which are almost exclusively funded from gas taxes.

On an average day the roads I personally drive on are probably at least 50% funded from property and sales taxes paid by my neighbors and me. Most of my miles driven are almost exclusively on streets managed by my city. For my neighbors commuting deeper into the city driving on a US highway, its probably closer to 5-10% coming from property and sales taxes.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:38AM (#32165628)
EV fees are already much higher than the state gas tax they replace in many places, especially considering the extra sales tax on the battery, tax on electricity, and even personal property tax on the battery. The idea EVs get a free pass is a myth.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dahfizz on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:09AM (#32166017)
> especially considering the extra sales tax on the battery, tax on electricity, and even personal property tax on the battery.

I don't understand, do you pay an extra tax on the battery? Sales & property tax on a $60k car should always be the same, regardless of powertrain.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by sokoloff on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:58AM (#32166666)
The electric car I drive (LEAF) costs about $12K-15K more than the roughly comparable ICE car (Versa). Taking the lower estimate, the sales tax difference in my state is $750, which is the state gas tax on just over 3100 gallons or about 100K miles of gasoline purchased for the car.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:53PM (#32169623)
Yup, and consider that sales tax applies any time the car is sold, and often cars are sold multiple times in their lives.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by xur17 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:23AM (#32166166)
I'm guessing the argument is that EV's cost more upfront (since they include a battery, etc), but have a lower cost of use. Since you get charged sales tax on the upfront cost, EV's get charged sales tax on a larger percentage of the overall "ownership cost" of the car.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:58AM (#32166665)
Exactly. With gas cars, you pay for gasoline over time. With electric cars, you pay about 50/50 upfront on battery & over time on electricity. EV owners are being punished for paying for part of the “fuel” costs upfront. For whatever reason, capital costs for consumers are penalized with taxes more than incremental operating costs.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:01PM (#32167684)
I mean, we don’t charge lower gas taxes to luxury cars because they pay more upfront, so I don’t know why this is now an expectation for EVs. And we’ve never had flat taxes for sales; gas is actually the only exception in the US I’m aware of, but that’s probably because of the price volatility of gas making a percentage tax hard to budget for.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:05PM (#32167749)
> For whatever reason, capital costs for consumers are penalized with taxes more than incremental operating costs.

How so? Is the gas tax lower than the purchase taxes?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:39PM (#32169406)
Yes, plus personal property tax. If I own the car for 8 years before selling it and the battery is about $10,000 In value and the sales tax rate is 6% or so, the tax I’m paying is already equal to the gas tax I already typically would pay driving a 30mpg the average number of miles per year in a typical state. And some localities have personal property taxes, and that $10,000 battery often puts the car in a higher bracket, so you end up paying a 4% personal property tax EVERY YEAR on the battery, which is about 5 times what state gas tax would be.

And keep in mind many states already charge EV owners a high registration fee that more than makes up for the lack of state gas taxes. So sales tax plus personal property tax plus EV registration fee… you’re already paying nearly an order of magnitude more than the typical consumer pays state gas tax.

It’s a pretty stupid idea to charge far more taxes for far lower emissions vehicles if you think climate change is real. Regardless of your rationale about use taxes or whatever. It’s just stupid.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Thursday July 21, 2022 @05:30AM (#32177307)
Well I'd never heard of personal property tax before! So people are taxed for owning things, that they paid tax on when they bought them? I can see how that devalues an electric car vs an ICE alternative.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Thursday July 21, 2022 @10:17AM (#32179704)
Yes, it’s pretty bad. It’s like a wealth tax for the middle class, and a pretty high rate, too.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:43AM (#32167389)
At the state level, sure, but local roads are paid for by local governments using local general taxes, no? A random suburban residential street is not usually getting gas tax money.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by asdff on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:27PM (#32170110)
A random suburban residential street could get away with being repaved every 100 years. The ones in my neighborhood bear contractor stamps from the 1920s at least. A big source of road wear is trucking traffic and usually truck routes are along state routes that get state gas tax funding for maintenance at least.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by shkkmo on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:56AM (#32165853)
The amount of road funding in the US that comes from gas taxes and road fees varies by state between 1/3 to 2/3. Georgia is one of the lower and funds 40% of road spending from gas taxes, road fees, and tolls (using 2017 numbers.) [0]

[0] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2017-07-20/mapping-h...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by innocentoldguy on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:13AM (#32166060)
> Indeed, here in the states, cyclists pay for the roads that we use.

This isn’t true where I live. Taxes on gasoline purchases pay for the roads.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by frosted-flakes on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:54AM (#32167560)
Gas taxes are a small portion of road costs, and are only for state roads. Cities generally don't receive road subsidies from the state. Cyclists drive on city roads, and city roads are generally paid for with property taxes or local sales taxes (if your city has them). And cyclists cause zero damage to roads, unlike cars or trucks

Really, cyclists are getting shafted because they have to pay for so many roads they can't use.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by innocentoldguy on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:54AM (#32176850)
I'm pretty sure I know more about my area than you do and we do NOT use property taxes to pay for roads here. Property Taxes are used for things like:

* The general fund.

* Grants.

* Costs associated with assessing and collecting taxes.

* Justice Courts.

* Education.

Not maintaining local roads.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by frosted-flakes on Thursday July 21, 2022 @10:18AM (#32179712)
Then your city is the exception to the rule and can be dismissed as an outlier.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by innocentoldguy on Friday July 22, 2022 @04:40PM (#32196862)
Ah, I see. I’m wrong, unless I’m correct, in which case I’m irrelevant.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by frosted-flakes on Friday July 22, 2022 @05:31PM (#32197354)
Now you got it.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:36AM (#32164844)
>My hunch is that if one were to look closely at the funding of roads, one would find that they represent a net subsidy for heavy trucking.

Which is itself a net subsidy for all sorts of other economic activity.

It's subsidies all the way down.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:06PM (#32167783)
Indeed - if heavy trucking is subsidised then eventually the prices you're paying for something are lower.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by belorn on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:00AM (#32164475)
bicycle and pedestrians could be exempted from a road tax based on fairly simple assumption: the wear and tear is minimal compared to a car. It wouldn't even surprise me if the wear and tear is so small that it can't even be measured.

But I could be wrong. It would be interesting to hear if heavy bike/pedestrian roads have higher road maintenance than those that are used lightly. My guess would be that the major wear and tear comes from nature, water in particular, which mean wear and tear isn't based on usage.

When it come to tire pollution those would be better taxed on the tires themselves. Bike tires tend to be much much smaller than cars so the taxation wouldn't be that big of a deal to cyclists.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by 7952 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:10AM (#32164584)
I think road wear is axle weight to the fourth power. So lorries are massively more damaging than cars. And cars are massively more damaging than bikes. Anecdotally the issue with bike and pedestrian paths is intruding vegetation which slowly narrows the width.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:47AM (#32166499)
It's not just a matter of "massively more" -- with those numbers the damage from anything other than large commercial vehicles is a rounding error which, if accounted for proportionally, would cost more money to collect than the amount collected.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:23PM (#32169104)
It's the fourth power of axle load according to the AAHSO report (https://camdencyclists.org.uk/2020/06/the-fourth-power-rule-...)

A 30-ton 5-axle HGV would be 6 tons per axle, a BMW 7-Series would be 1 ton per axle, and a heavy cyclist on a heavy bicycle would work out to around 0.05 tons per axle, so while a car might cause ~1/1000th of the wear of a heavy truck, a bicycle would cause less than 1/100000th of the wear that is caused by a car, and that's before you consider the wear that's caused according to the speed that a vehicle is traveling (it is roughly linear). So while it might conceivably be possible to tax motorists according to the level of damage that they cause to roads (with trucks paying far more than they do now, and with revenues not exceeding the costs of collection), it certainly wouldn't be possible to tax cyclists.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:08PM (#32169834)
The point is that it's not worth doing even for cars. If the toll for the truck was $50, the proportional toll for the car would be one half of one cent.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:48PM (#32170404)
On the other hand, trucks are often speed-restricted and the tax might need to be on the order of $50k for a 60-foot truck (which would still equate to around $50 for a car). The costs would be passed down to all of the things that trucks are used for, so I suppose the average person wouldn't really pay any less for combined transport+groceries+fuel+household goods, but it might incentivize the use of smaller trucks with lighter axle loads, but that would also mean more drivers/poorer fuel efficiency/more accidents per ton per mile. At the least we should be mindful of the way that motorists are providing a subsidy to the logistics industry (which we indirectly benefit from, as well).
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:59PM (#32174506)
It most certainly would not cost $50k for any size truck to travel down one road once, which is what matters if you're paying the cost to build infrastructure to track usage.

It might cost a semi truck $50k a year, but this also points in the direction of not tracking specific usage even for trucks: Just check the odometer during the annual inspection and then distribute the highway funds to states proportionate to estimated use.

Toll collection is stupid inefficient and privacy invasive.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Thursday July 21, 2022 @12:33PM (#32181416)
Yes, obviously I was talking about an annual charge ("a tax") based on vehicle road wear; I don't think anyone had suggested that we charge a truck driver $50k for driving down one road, once. It's very common for the odomoters of heavy goods vehicles to be checked and for mileages to be logged regularly (this is probably a legal requirement in many cases, if not just a standard industry practice). I agree that toll collection would be unsuitable. My point was that charges for the use of large goods vehicles would need to be orders of magnitude higher than they are now, but that the charges for cars would still be sufficient to more than cover the cost of collection.

And if people wanted, the President of the National Cycling Federation could present the Secretary of Transportation with a $5 bill in an annual ceremony.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by diordiderot on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @06:34PM (#32173291)
I'd rather pay costs where they're owed personally
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by belorn on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:38PM (#32171065)
Dealing with government and taxes there is one additional factor to consider. The government can give tax cuts to targeted groups if they consider it beneficial to society.

So let say the truck has a $5000 tax to pay for yearly wear and tear on roads, but they also get a $5000 tax cut to reduce costs in the transportation sector. That will leave cars to still pay their road tax, even if in comparison they would be a tiny portion of the total road tax.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:51PM (#32174446)
But if you want a general subsidy then you collect the money from a broad based tax like general income tax or sales tax, not low-efficiency road tolls.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by pengaru on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:25PM (#32169152)
Except not all roads are built to handle heavier vehicles, such roads experience significant wear from common weight automobiles. I don't think the cost of maintenance for such roads is a rounding error.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:03PM (#32169767)
Most roads are built to handle heavier vehicles and the few exceptions rarely if ever see enough traffic to result in maintenance costs not dominated by nature and weather.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by pydry on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:18AM (#32164665)
There is no road tax, only vehicle excise duty which bicyclists dont pay. It goes straight into the treasury so it's not even really "used" per se it's just a way of exerting downward pressure on inflation (which is how it should be, IMHO).
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tomgp on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:53AM (#32166597)
thats a strangely abstract way of looking at it. i think of it as a way to capture some of the externalities of car use, the environmental, social and public health damage.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:19PM (#32167993)
The obvious way to do that is via the fuel tax, where the more you pay the more you use.

The reality is probably that it's not that well coupled to any cause, and really it's just a way to farm money from the majority of the country, who need to use motor transport to live their lives. The advertised political reason will change depending on the concerns of the populace at the time.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by lol768 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:16AM (#32165345)
> bicycle and pedestrians could be exempted from a road tax based on fairly simple assumption: the wear and tear is minimal compared to a car. It wouldn't even surprise me if the wear and tear is so small that it can't even be measured.

Isn't car wear and tear minimal to HGV wear and tear?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dahfizz on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:36AM (#32166340)
It also depends highly on your local weather, I imagine. I'm willing to bet that a harsh winter does more road damage than all traffic combined.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by cogman10 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:20AM (#32165386)
Yup.

Though cars still put out a fair bit more pollution from tire wear than bicycles do.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tzs on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:09AM (#32166856)
> bicycle and pedestrians could be exempted from a road tax based on fairly simple assumption: the wear and tear is minimal compared to a car. It wouldn't even surprise me if the wear and tear is so small that it can't even be measured.

That is the case, which came as a surprise to me.

For things like the road bed, where the force from the surface is going to be spread out more, I'd expect the car to do more damage because total weight would be all that mattered.

But for damage at or near the road surface I'd have expected bikes to do more.

My reasoning was simple: although cars weigh a lot more they are spreading that weight over a larger contact area.

My car for example has four tires each at a pressure of 32 PSI. My bike, before I replaced the tires with wider tires, had two tires each at 110 PSI. Any given small patch of road I drive or ride over would only get about 29% as much force on it from the car as it would from the bike at any given time a tire is on that patch of road.

It would get that force for more time from the car than from the bike if the car is going less than ~3.4 times the speed of the bike and for less time if the car is going faster than that, and more different small patches of road would get force from the car than would get force from the bike.

This is similar to why if I were to put a flat metal plate on my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would not hurt, but if I were to set hold a dagger against my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would likely hurt a lot.

But something is wrong with my reasoning, and it turns out that road damage goes as something like the fourth power of the vehicles axel weight. Whether the tires are narrow high pressure tires or wide low pressure tires, from what I've read, is not relevant.

I'm not sure if that is because I was just wrong about top layer damage, or if it is just that lower level damage is just much more important and expensive, so any difference in top layer damage due to tire size is lost in the noise.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:03PM (#32167711)
> Any given small patch of road I drive or ride over would only get about 29% as much force on it from the car as it would from the bike at any given time a tire is on that patch of road.

...

> This is similar to why if I were to put a flat metal plate on my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would not hurt, but if I were to set hold a dagger against my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would likely hurt a lot.

This is because your chest is weak and soft in comparison to the incompressible metal plate or dagger blade, which is not analogous to the situation on the road. A better analogy would be poking yourself with the tip of an al dente noodle compared to the load transmitted by a large, spongy slice of bread. Neither is going to hurt you in any way.

Whether your tire is transmitting 110 psi or 32 psi doesn't matter much because the compressive strength of Portland cement concrete is ~4000 PSI and the compressive strength of bituminous pavement is ~500 PSI.

However, soil bearing loads are on the order of 15-50 psi under constant loading, and can act as a spring or can yield at much lower transitory loads. The dirt beneath the pavement (or rather, the dirt beneath the gravel beneath the pavement) gives easily, so instead of asking the concrete to survive the compression forces caused by the contact patch, you're asking it to form a beam/plate that spreads the loads over a broad area, and asking that beam to resist deflection rather than crushing. The real damage, and the reason that damage scales with the fourth power of axle loading, is caused when a large truck rolls over the road, the ground shakes, and the roadbed flexes down into the soil under the axle and back up after it passes.

Try to imagine riding your road bike over a piece of cardboard laid on the sand. That wrinkling and creasing is much closer to actual road wear patterns than a dagger cutting your chest.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bagels on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:41AM (#32167361)
This analysis based on tire pressure seems faulty. If you place your hand on a bike tire, you do not experience thousands of pounds of force.

To estimate the pressure exerted on the road, you want to compare vehicle system weight/tire contact area. Velocity also plays a role.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by vel0city on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:34AM (#32167257)
Sure, the contact patch is a good bit smaller on a bike than a car, but people don't usually weigh 5,000lbs.

I'd much rather get run over by average person on a bicycle than get run over by a car.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:10PM (#32167844)
That's because you aren't a smooth surface :) Because of your shape (and I admit I'm making an assumption here) you will experience pressure spikes due to the fact that different bits of you stick out. E.g. knees due to their shape will experience much higher pressure. A road won't do that.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by kingaillas on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:23AM (#32167076)
>My car for example has four tires each at a pressure of 32 PSI.

The air pressure of your car/bike tires doesn't matter - all tires could be flat. Try comparing (vehicle weight + your weight) / (vehicle contact surface area) where vehicle is either your car or your bike.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tzs on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:00PM (#32167663)
For tires that support the vehicle via air pressure in the tires, contact area is roughly weight supported by tire / air pressure in tire [1].

[1] http://ffden-2.phys.uaf.edu/211_fall2013.web.dir/connor_matt...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ars on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:44PM (#32170356)
When the tire is flat it is being supported by the sidewalls and by the wheel.

And if you notice the contact patch of a flat tire is much larger.

The ground pressure of any vehicle is almost exactly equal to the psi. With the exception of force carried by the sidewalls.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:58AM (#32167633)
Having lived in New York with really high rates of pedestrians, sidewalks are never being replaced from normal wear and tear from use.

Usually it’s

* retrofitting for ADA compliance

* fixing heaving from freeze-thaw

* fixing heaving from the root systems of trees in street planters

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by DrBazza on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:44AM (#32167399)
> There is no "road tax" in the UK, is it?

Vehicle Excise Duty since 1920 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicle_Excise_Duty

Road funding in the UK is just from the general pot of tax money.

There are a lot of anti-cyclist types in the UK that always incorrectly (or ironically, correctly) claim that cyclists don't pay road tax (no one does) and therefore shouldn't use the road, even though just about every cyclist is an adult that pays UK tax.

I certainly expect the UK, and every other country to tax EVs by mileage within a decade, and additionally toll charge on major routes, almost certainly via cameras (to also fine you for speeding), or require all cars to have a GPS blackbox (which let's face it, isn't expensive now).

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ehnto on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:53AM (#32166598)
In Australia and I imagine the UK, infrastructure is paid for by the municipalities from their own budgets, a portion of which is granted to them from the federal government. Larger projects are usually taken on by the state. These budgets come out of general tax revenue, which is paid by everyone via GST and income tax. So cyclists absolutely pay, and in many many cases, they're paying to build infrastructure they don't even use. The unfair burden usually goes toward the cyclist, who's historically been shortchanged on infrastructure for cycling.

Registration goes toward running the registration apparatus, not into infrastructure. That's another misconception. The other contribution is from fuel sales taxes/excises, and that goes into general tax revenue as well, so is not explicitly set aside for road projects. Negating the potential income from fuel sales taxes, is all the fossil fuel subsidies, what once was 15bil income, after subsidies of 12bil, is now just 3billion in income from fuel taxes. So the money comes in from the consumer, and goes straight out to the fossil fuel industry through industry fuel tax credits. Absolutely bullshit, but it also means there's not much left of that fuel tax income to pay for infrastructure.

https://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Depart....

Ultimately a cyclist will pay the same amount of tax, minus the fuel taxes, and get just a scrap of that tax spent back on cycling.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by martin-adams on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:48AM (#32164350)
It's very odd they used the term Road Tax. It's always been known as Vehicle Tax for the very reason you've pointed out. Hence why you don't need to pay tax to ride a bicycle on the road.

The other area they are losing out not mentioned in the article is Benefit in Kind tax for EVs used as company cars. At some point, that will also need to end and be more in alignment with ICE vehicles.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:49AM (#32164365)
It's a handy dog whistle so we know they are part of the car lobby

edit: spelling

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:02AM (#32164502)
When you try and look for dog whistles everywhere the world becomes a useless cacophony of high pitched screeching. Road tax and vehicle tax are used pretty much interchangeably and I wouldn't read into the word choice any more than I'd read into the results of the coin toss.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:16AM (#32164640)
*listen
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:36AM (#32164857)
You're being pedantic. Odds are your brain parsed the article from visual input not audio. It could go either way depending on which linguistic hard line you want to take.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by blibble on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:00AM (#32164486)
or it could simply be that the commonly used term for Vehicle Excise Duty is "road tax" (even if it's technically incorrect)

not everything is a conspiracy

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:16AM (#32164636)
commonly used by people who disingenuously use it's etymology to imply that all 'road users' (by which they mean cyclists) rather than 'vehicle users' should pay it
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by blibble on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:23AM (#32164711)
I don't see anything in the article that suggests the author wants that to happen?

these hysterical responses say more about you then the people you're demonising

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:35AM (#32164840)
I dont think a carsalesman is going to feel overly demonised by being reffered to as part of the car lobby. He does know better than to conflate road and vehicle tax however.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by blibble on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:49AM (#32164994)
when you can't get the name of the duty right (it's a duty, not a tax), it seems a bit rich to complain about others getting it wrong

let alone accusing them of dog-whistling

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by efaref on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:42AM (#32167369)
You also don't need to pay it to own a vehicle. You are allowed to own a vehicle without paying this tax as long as you promise not to drive it on the road (SORN). So by that logic it's not a vehicle tax either.

Also, bicycles are vehicles. So surely they should pay Vehicle Tax as well?

A more accurate name would be the "Using a Motorized Vehicle on the Public Road Tax". Let's abbreviate it by dropping all but the last two words. :)

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by standardUser on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:19PM (#32168008)
"Which was great to get the initial people to convert, and get the infrastructure in place. But now it's time to tax them. "

Maybe in Norway, and only Norway. Every other nation should be quadrupling-down on EV incentives. Or 10 fold. Or 20.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Originami on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:20PM (#32169996)
Road tax needs to be morphed into road-usage tax, based on time of day, location, axle weight, and distance.

It should be prohibitively expensive to use congested freeways and city streets during peak hours, but free at all other times.

Road expansion is justified based on peaks of usage - so by smoothing out these peaks, we can save significantly on the need to build more roads. Trip length can also scale non-linearly based on congestion: 10-20% more cars than capacity can result in 50% longer trips.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by megablast on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:26PM (#32170086)
Why?? EVs aren’t good for the environment at all. Why push for them??

Why are we continuously subsidising the car industry?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by gpmcadam on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:47AM (#32164347)
It's a combination. Revenues gathered via road tax have a provision for older/more polluting cars so you pay less the newer your vehicle, essentially. Some of the money is used to fund the maintenance of highways, though.

Local roads are funded by council tax, so this probably dispells the anti-cycling argument because presumably the cyclists do pay council tax (unless they're on motorways which is another issue.)

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by semanticist on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:20AM (#32165398)
> Some of the money is used to fund the maintenance of highways, though.

Only in the sense that some of all tax money is used in that way - VED just gets pooled with all tax income, none of it is 'ring fenced' for any specific purpose. That's why the idea of 'road tax' is so annoying, since it implies it's to be used for a specific purpose.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by efaref on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:38AM (#32167315)
"Road tax" is a _tax_ you have to pay in order to use the _road_. It's the most natural name for it, which is why people call it that.

Despite the words they use, it's not a vehicle tax: you can own a vehicle without paying it as long as you declare that you will not use the vehicle _on_the_road_ (a.k.a., make a Statutory Off Road Notification). It's a tax for using the roads. A road tax.

That the government don't ring-fence it to use on road maintenance is irrelevant.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:20PM (#32168015)
> That the government don't ring-fence it to use on road maintenance is irrelevant.

It's not irrelevant to the quoted section, which is the only thing the previous poster was replying to.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:50AM (#32164375)
motorways, not highways
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by gpmcadam on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:51AM (#32164393)
No, it's highways because not all highways (major roads and motorways) are motorways.

See: https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/highways-england

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by mytailorisrich on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:54AM (#32165825)
It's a vehicle tax.

It's depending on emissions at the moment as a way to encourage vehicles with low/no emissions but there is no reason for EV to keep being exempt.

The issue in term of tax revenue is fuel duty and VAT on fuel. I'm suspecting that once transition is advanced enough they'll find ways to add tax on charging points/electricity used for charging, or an actual road tax on mileage or whatnot.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:37AM (#32165604)
The “pollute more from the tires being heavier” is a myth, by the way. There was an article that circulated claiming this, but they never actually measured the tire pollution of electric cars, just extrapolated from ICE cars with really terrible and ultimately false arguments. Electric cars tend to use low rolling resistance tires (potentially less wear… if you’re experiencing less rolling resistance, that means less energy ends up being used to produce wear, so less wear occurs… in part due to geometric effects and partly due to composition of the tires). Electric cars are also fairly comparable in curb weight due to massive weight reductions elsewhere, plus improved traction control (and the more gentle regenerative braking) means less wheel slippage and wear. And it assumes ICE cars are operating at full emissions-control mode which is also untrue especially on startup or in cold weather or if using diesel. It also assumes tire wear mass is all minute particles of the same problematic effects of ICE exhaust particles, which is a bad assumption for multiple reasons (for one, it ignores empirical measurements of particle sizes), and it ignores gaseous emissions entirely in the calculation, many of which are very problematic like carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxides of various types, components of gasoline such as benzene and xylene and toluene, ozone (a major component of smog), etc. It also ignores the near absence of break wear in electric cars, thus the absence of silica dust (or iron oxide dust, or whatever the brakes and the rotors are made of, etc).

In short, it is misinformation.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dahfizz on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:23AM (#32166168)
> Electric cars are also fairly comparable in curb weight due to massive weight reductions elsewhere,

Seriously, this meme needs to die. A Tesla model 3 is the same weight as a BMW 340, and the model 3 is hundreds of pounds lighter than an SUV like the BMW X3.

Batteries are heavy, but so are gas engines & transmissions.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:52AM (#32166571)
> A Tesla model 3 is the same weight as a BMW 340

Sure, but its also 500-1200lbs heavier than a Civic depending on the trims of each which has very similar utility to an M3 and is much closer in TCO to a model 3 than a 340 or an X3 is.

We shouldn't be having our cake and eating it too by saying "electric cars are more expensive but the TCO so much lower than ICE that its worth it" and then make comparisons to ICE vehicles at the MSRP of the EV.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dahfizz on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:17PM (#32167966)
The point is that ICE cars and electric cars are comparable in weight. There are some ICE cars lighter than an electric car, and some ICE cars heavier than an electric car. Some of that is just due to the fact that electric cars are new, and haven't moved into the "ultra light sporty car" segment with the civic or Miata.

The point is you don't see a BMW go down the road and freak out about how heavy it is. But there is this meme in everyone's mind that EV's tire polution is much much worse than ICE because EVs are much much heavier. They aren't.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:49PM (#32169560)
> The point is that ICE cars and electric cars are comparable in weight.

My point is that this just isn't true in the general sense. I didn't choose the Civic because its an "ultra light sporty car" I chose it because it's in a very similar class of car to the model 3 and moves a lot of units, but you could look at the Camry, Corolla, Accord, or Altima and see that the heaviest trims of all 5 (including hybrids) all weigh less than the lightest model 3 currently available.

Those 5 cars cover every sedan on the top 25 sales list other than the Model 3. I'm sure there are tons of luxury sedans that weigh more than the Model 3, but their total number of units is much smaller than any of the 6 cars we're talking about and their TCO is massively higher as well. So if you weigh the average comparable vehicle on the road the Model 3 will weigh more, and the Model 3 is one of the lightest 250+ mile EVs! the Polestar 2 weighs 4400 lbs!

FWIW I agree that the tire pollution thing is a silly aspect to focus on when comparing EVs and ICE, especially considering a lot of people who believe the lie that it makes EVs worse overall are probably driving a mall crawler or bro-dozer that weighs 5000+ lbs.

https://insideevs.com/news/527966/electric-cars-from-heavies...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by cogman10 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:59PM (#32170549)
It should be noted that weight has been dropping YoY and is expected to drop further when M3 gets a structural battery pack. Those drop the weight not only because there's now no longer a structure the battery is bolted to, it is the structure, but also because the weight drop lowers the batteries needed to get comparable range (further reducing weight).

Model Y is the first tesla vehicle with a structural pack.

I expect that other EV manufactures will eventually follow suit. Why wouldn't they? Less batteries and materials is a win win.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:25PM (#32170888)
Unfortunately most of the benefits of structural battery packs haven't materialized yet based on the stats Tesla submitted to the EPA. The Austin Model Y is 25 lbs lighter but has 14kWh less capacity and 51 fewer miles of range. Part of this is probably the battery chemistry being used in the current 4680 cells and as the chemistry improves they may catch back up in range to the non-structural 2170 packs but they have a really really long way to go before they get to the range increase and weight decrease they promised at battery day. That or some aspect of the EPA numbers are massively wrong but I feel like we would have heard from Elon about that by now.

https://old.reddit.com/r/teslamotors/comments/u1926z/confirm...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @06:29PM (#32173245)
They’re going with cheaper (but safer and longer lasting) 100% Cobalt and Nickel-free LFP cells, right? That could explain it.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by Robotbeat on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:00AM (#32166702)
It’s comparing to a similar performance ICE vehicle. Model 3 is much higher performance than the civic, more comparable to the BMW.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:19AM (#32167015)
Sure, and the Civic Type-R has a 0.8 second faster 0-60 than an SR+ M3 while weighing 550 lbs less and beats the Model 3 Performance at Nurburgring by over a minute while weighing over 1000 lbs less. All while having a $10k-20k lower MSRP. the Type-R is only 15 seconds behind a model S plaid at nurburgring which is more than 50% heavier.

But beyond that, if the only thing you ever try to compare is 0-60 performance then EVs always have an upper hand because it is one of their primary strengths, and that's great! But cars are much, much more than their 0-60 (as evidenced by a fwd car with a 5.0s trouncing an awd car with 3.1s on the track) and for many people TCO, utility, creature comforts, reliability, etc. are more important comparisons.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by google234123 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @04:46PM (#32172086)
> All while having a $10k-20k lower MSRP

Civic Type-R is a 40k car, just like the model 3 and it probably has high markups above the MSRP on average.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @05:29PM (#32172604)
The cheapest model 3 on Tesla's website right now is $47k MSRP, the 2021 Type-R MSRP was $38k (there is no 2022) and the Performance Model 3 is $63k.

So my bad its $9k-$25k MSRP, not that the minutiae of pricing is that important for this comparison. It was just to note that Honda isn't winning on weight by spending a fortune on materials or manufacturing like if I had compared the Model 3 to some supercar.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by google234123 on Friday July 22, 2022 @04:10AM (#32189728)
The Model 3 was still just $39,490 in 2021. So 1K MSPR difference and it did 0 - 60 in about the same time as the type r (5.3s)
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:23PM (#32168064)
Performance isn't relevant.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:38AM (#32166373)
> Electric cars tend to use low rolling resistance tires (potentially less wear… if you’re experiencing less rolling resistance, that means less energy ends up being used to produce wear, so less wear occurs… in part due to geometric effects and partly due to composition of the tires). Electric cars are also fairly comparable in curb weight due to massive weight reductions elsewhere, plus improved traction control (and the more gentle regenerative braking) means less wheel slippage and wear.

Do we need to go this deep into our analysis? I would think ((pi*radius^2)-(pi*(radius-tread_depth)^2))*width/miles would tell us pretty much everything we need to know about tire emissions, and most EV owners in my experience will acknowledge spending much more on tires for the same # of miles or spending the same for a good bit less # of miles. I'm not sure what the dimensional differences are on your average EV tire purchase versus your average ICE tire purchase, but if we look at model 3 base tires vs civic touring tires (biggest stock civic tire sold):

M3: 235/45R18 10/32 (Primacy MXM4)

Civic: 235/40R18 9/32 (Eagle Sport A/S)

so at least as far as stock tires M3 should have more total tread than a similarly sized/similar TCO vehicle given the larger aspect ratio and deeper tread depth. Unfortunately I can't find any non-anecdotal data on how many miles they would each get.

Of course I agree with pretty much everything you said but I do think tires are an important conversation to have around EVs, particularly when prices come down and budget conscious buyers start putting cheap, loud, fast wearing tires on their EVs.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bagels on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:47PM (#32170394)
I don't think torque, tire compound and driving habits can be ignored in a serious analysis.

Also, cheap tires tend to have harder, longer lasting compounds.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by enragedcacti on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @05:45PM (#32172833)
I was including all three of those in the "per mile" piece of the equation since we are looking at products in aggregate. If EVs generally cause people to accelerate harder than if they bought an equivalent ICE then that would be reflected in the reduced tire life and if chosen tire compound decreases wear then that would be reflected as well.

That said tire compound could be more or less dense or have more or less of an effect on the environment per unit so that wouldn't be captured, and low torque EVs would most likely have less wear/mile so the categorization of just EV vs ICE might be too broad.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by josefresco on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:27PM (#32169172)
> Lots of budgets are now off because they estimated X amounts from cars using toll roads, but half of them don't pay the price.

Citation needed.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:14PM (#32170763)
Income from toll roads in Oslo was 1 billion NOK lower per year than budgeted, after the electric car boom and their free/subsidized passing.

https://www.nrk.no/osloogviken/vil-fjerne-bompengerabatten-f...

That alone almost collapsed the whole Oslo city government, actually. As they had to negotiate with the national government and neighbor districts on how various infrastructure projects could be finished.

Was quite a big deal this spring.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by chrisco255 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:47AM (#32164336)
The point of road taxes is to pay for maintenance and expansion. Roads break down over time if you do not maintain them.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:48AM (#32164359)
this is paid out of local taxation. Which is why pedestrians, cylists, equestrians, tractors, cows and ducks are allowed to used the road.

There is no such thing as road tax.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by chrisco255 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:43AM (#32166442)
Dunno how it works in UK, but in US, there are local roads, state roads, and federal roads. There are also local, state, and federal gas taxes that vary by jurisdiction. The funds from these gas taxes are used to finance new highway and roadway construction and maintenance of existing roads. Sometimes, a special tax is levied at the local level for specific local roadway projects. But the big infrastructure projects are almost entirely paid for by gas taxes.

Either way, the point of the tax has never been to "punish pollution".

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by zip1234 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:14PM (#32167908)
> the big infrastructure projects are almost entirely paid for by gas taxes. About 50% is probably correct: http://www.financingtransportation.org/funding_financing/fun...
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by asdff on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:30PM (#32170148)
There is such thing as a road tax and not all roads allow cows and ducks and lions and bears. Note the sign on the highway onramp that says something like "no pedestrians or cyclists" and the fact that every car on the road has to pay a yearly fee in order to not be impounded by the local government for neglecting to pay for fees that go on to maintain the roads.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by blibble on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:12AM (#32164607)
trunk roads and motorways are definitely not paid out of local taxation
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by WorldMaker on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:12PM (#32168922)
Roads break down over time primarily as a function of vehicle weight. Most road taxes (especially gas taxes) are poor proxies for vehicle weight taxes. It's probably time to reconsider vehicle weight taxes.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by innocentoldguy on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:12AM (#32166051)
> This of course also ignores that most adult cyclists also own a car.

What does owning a car have to do with it? If you own two cars, or a car and a scooter, you still have to pay taxes for both to be on the road, don’t you?

EDIT: I forgot to mention, where I live taxes aren’t collected as a “fee for polluting.” They’re to keep roads maintained and improve them. This often includes special bike lanes that bicyclists do nothing to pay for.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:18PM (#32170810)
That's my point, though. When I'm on a bike and someone shouts at me to get off the road because I don't pay for it and they do, they are wrong. I pay the same as they do, I just choose to use my bike every day to commute.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by innocentoldguy on Thursday July 21, 2022 @03:58AM (#32176864)
But that isn't what you said. You said that people who were complaining that bicyclists don't pay their fair share for the roads are wrong because most bicyclists own a car too. I responded to that argument and not the moved goal post you're presenting here.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Friday July 22, 2022 @03:48AM (#32189593)
I have honestly no idea what you're trying to convey. I didn't move any goalpost, I tried to restate my point since you missed it completely. Don't argue in bad faith, please.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by redeeman on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:57AM (#32165107)
so perhaps its also time for the government to admit that the prior taxes didnt have ANYTHING to do with environment, but just a way to justify money grabbing to spend on their own worthy causes?
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by unglaublich on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:09AM (#32165259)
Cars are a huge burden on health, safety, environment and quality of life. It has never been a secret that governments tax cars to subsidize causes that should partially compensate the indirect damage that cars do to their countries.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by mbg721 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:43AM (#32166438)
We saw this play out with the money from tobacco settlements a few decades ago; states see sin taxes as a windfall that can substitute for sustainable budgeting.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:28AM (#32165505)
No, it's the opposite. You don't want people to drive because of the environment, health, noise, road "accidents" killing people, how it destroys cities etc. So the taxes are a direct incentive to find alternative modes of travel.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by redeeman on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @07:25PM (#32173745)
step 1: ICE cars are bad for the environment! we must add taxes

step 2: ICE cars are bad, electric cars good. We remove taxes for electric cars

... too many people get electric cars ...

step 3: its time to start taxing electric cars... reasons!

translation: governments likes to take money from its citizens that it can spend on whatever it deems worthy, and will happily come up with a reason, sometimes justified, sometimes not.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:21PM (#32168033)
Not really. They exist because cars are required. If we all became able to live our lives purely with cycling then cycling would be taxed.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by pif on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:29AM (#32166256)
> There is no "road tax" in the UK, is it? It's a fee for polluting, not using the road.

It is not what you call it, but what you spend it on.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by youngtaff on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:46PM (#32171182)
And it’s part of general taxation…

Roads are funded partly out of local taxes, and partly out of general taxes - there’s no hypothecation of ‘road tax’ paying for roads

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by nemo44x on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:33AM (#32166300)
> I hate that it's being used as an argument against cyclists: "get off the road, you don't pay road tax".

It's really more that many cyclists are in the way and aren't going the speed limit. You end up holding up a lot of traffic that is forced to go slower and that's annoying to everyone. to be frank, when you're driving a car a person on a bike taking up the entire road is annoying. This is why people really dislike bikes - they get in the way of people trying to get somewhere.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ehnto on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:04AM (#32166773)
That's a nasty bias you have. Cyclists are clearly also "people trying to get somewhere". I'd argue they're trying harder than you are.

I won't defend all cyclists, some of them have bad etiquette for sure. I certainly don't have traffic piled up behind me. But I'd argue they've inconvenienced you far less than your car infrastructure has inconvenienced them. I promise if they had a separated fast bike lane to use, they'd be using that instead of getting blasted by cars and trucks and dealing with people angry they're late for their next stoplight.

If you want cyclists off your road, then you should be lobbying for better cycling infrastructure.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ApolloFortyNine on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:42PM (#32168400)
The cyclists in the US I see in a suburban area are almost all doing it for exercise (pretty obvious from the getup), not to get somewhere.

In a more downtown area it's obviously different.

>dealing with people angry they're late for their next stoplight.

Sounds like you have some nasty bias yourself.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by yohannparis on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:41PM (#32169440)
Few people cyclists in the U.S.A. suburs are cycling for transport instead of sport... because of the infrastructure. Only mad cyclists dare their life for it!

The danger while cycling is not the bike or falling down, it's the motorized users.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ecnahc515 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:40PM (#32169409)
> The cyclists in the US I see in a suburban area are almost all doing it for exercise (pretty obvious from the getup), not to get somewhere.

That might change if there was more dedicated bike lanes.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:21PM (#32170845)
And why are people driving? Is their goal so much holier than whatever reason the bicyclist is out biking?

Don't live your life thinking everything revolves around you.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ehnto on Thursday July 21, 2022 @08:53AM (#32178711)
> Sounds like you have some nasty bias yourself.

Like most bike commuters I also drive, I know exactly what's waiting for anyone who's decided to be aggressive on their way past, and it's the next stop light. I'll probably see them there, and it'll be super awkward.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by _vertigo on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:48AM (#32166513)
As a cyclist, I am also trying to get somewhere, and I don't enjoy being on the road with motorists either.

Based on your comment, I have to assume we live in different areas. I live in the city, and generally it is better and faster to bike because one can bike almost as fast as a car due to not needing to wait for traffic and there's no need to find parking at the destination. From my POV, the motorists I have to share the road with are driving on low throughput streets and generally don't belong on the streets I am traveling down.

Do you live out in the country with 2 lane roads? A small town?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by nemo44x on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @04:42PM (#32172024)
I take the subway when in the city or a taxi if it’s faster. People on bikes get hit all the time and police investigations nearly always find the bike rider at fault.

The town I’m in outside the city is not a small town. There’s very little that’s more annoying than a group of spandex clad Tour de France wannabes taking up the entire road so they can cosplay.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by matsemann on Thursday July 21, 2022 @04:08AM (#32176909)
> police investigations nearly always find the bike rider at fault.

Source please. Sounds like a confirmation bias on your part.

> There’s very little that’s more annoying than a group of spandex clad Tour de France wannabes taking up the entire road so they can cosplay.

You sound jealous. Get a hobby yourself, perhaps?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by yohannparis on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:43AM (#32166436)
> many cyclists [...] aren't going the speed limit.

It's a speed upper limit, not a minimum. Are you upset when an agricole machine is using the public roads?

This "annoyance" against people not travelling at the speed limit on public roads is based on a lack of time management and the expectation that the road is empty. This is a selfish point of view.

When I want to control my travelling time, I walk or cycle. When I want comfort, I use public transportation or my car.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dahfizz on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:45PM (#32168437)
> Are you upset when an agricole machine is using the public roads?

Nope.

1) Any tractor I've been behind on a public road will pull over to let traffic pass by when possible.

2) Tractors obey all traffic lights and laws and behave predictably.

3) I've never seen a tractor driver act aggressively towards a car.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bluecalm on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:05PM (#32169803)
Cyclists are are smaller and easier to pass than tractors. Cyclists are better than obeying traffic laws than drivers. Multiple police surveys confirm it. Finally cyclists are subject of so much abuse and straight up murder attempts on the road that it's reasonable to expect them "acting aggressively towards a car". I mean if you come swinging a heavy object next to me I may lose my cool as well.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by yohannparis on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:45PM (#32169489)
1) Cyclist are on the right side of the road (not against the ditch/gutter/curb...), and easy to see past them to know if you can safely pass them.

2) Most cyclist do, some do not, same as drivers 3) Same as 2), and cyclist can be aggressive when your life is at stake. I think drivers mostly forget they are in charge of a dangerous machine.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:03AM (#32166762)
>It's a speed upper limit, not a minimum. Are you upset when an agricole machine is using the public roads?

This is an infantile way of framing it. 99.9999% of road users (all types) DGAF what you do as long as you meed expectations for your type of traffic.

Pretty much nobody gets angry at slower traffic (tractors, cyclists, commercial vehicles) so long as it is meeting their expectations for what it is. If you drive a normal car and try and act like something slower don't be surprised when it pisses people off. Likewise if you cycle or have to operate heavy machinery on road and try and act like a car outside of some narrow circumstances don't be surprised when it pisses people off.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by prmoustache on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:44AM (#32166464)
But then you look at the average speed of cars and you realize that in most urban area it is roughly the same as the cyclists.

How many stupid motorists kept screaming their engine when I was commuting just to pass me then come to a screetching halt behind other cars at the next traffic light while I just pass them back to the front of the line.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tomgp on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:50AM (#32166549)
leaving aside the fact that the speed limit is an upper bound on speed not mandatory… on my bike i’m more regularly held up by cars (often a single occupant) than i am by cyclists when driving my car. but overwhelmingly its cars holding up other cars.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by techterrier on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:34AM (#32166315)
hell hath no fury like a mildly inconvenienced motorist
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by prawn on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:59PM (#32174502)
You could spend eternity studying how some people feel aggressively about cyclists. Would be great to understand the crux of it. Fairness (road taxes), jealousy (skipping lights, getting ahead of traffic), shame (should I be exercising too?), otherness.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by supertrope on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:18PM (#32174628)
It seems to mostly be annoyance that they have to share the road. Cyclists aren't zooming along at 44MPH on a 35MPH road. Other motorists are also in their way. Automobile commercials always depict an idyllic empty road just for you.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by prawn on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:42PM (#32174788)
Not sure it's just an annoyance at sharing the road - like you said, there are other motorists. You don't see epic forum rage-discussions about garbage trucks holding up traffic, street-sweepers, buses, parking lanes that revert at rush hour. Those get discussed, but there always seems to be a special rage reserved by some people for cyclists - the quiet, small road users. I think you could explain a lot about a large segment of people by isolating and understanding this.

If I'm held up by a cyclist, I think "Good on them, they're braver and fitter than me."