News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by belorn on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:00AM (#32164475)
bicycle and pedestrians could be exempted from a road tax based on fairly simple assumption: the wear and tear is minimal compared to a car. It wouldn't even surprise me if the wear and tear is so small that it can't even be measured.

But I could be wrong. It would be interesting to hear if heavy bike/pedestrian roads have higher road maintenance than those that are used lightly. My guess would be that the major wear and tear comes from nature, water in particular, which mean wear and tear isn't based on usage.

When it come to tire pollution those would be better taxed on the tires themselves. Bike tires tend to be much much smaller than cars so the taxation wouldn't be that big of a deal to cyclists.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by 7952 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:10AM (#32164584)
I think road wear is axle weight to the fourth power. So lorries are massively more damaging than cars. And cars are massively more damaging than bikes. Anecdotally the issue with bike and pedestrian paths is intruding vegetation which slowly narrows the width.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:47AM (#32166499)
It's not just a matter of "massively more" -- with those numbers the damage from anything other than large commercial vehicles is a rounding error which, if accounted for proportionally, would cost more money to collect than the amount collected.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:23PM (#32169104)
It's the fourth power of axle load according to the AAHSO report (https://camdencyclists.org.uk/2020/06/the-fourth-power-rule-...)

A 30-ton 5-axle HGV would be 6 tons per axle, a BMW 7-Series would be 1 ton per axle, and a heavy cyclist on a heavy bicycle would work out to around 0.05 tons per axle, so while a car might cause ~1/1000th of the wear of a heavy truck, a bicycle would cause less than 1/100000th of the wear that is caused by a car, and that's before you consider the wear that's caused according to the speed that a vehicle is traveling (it is roughly linear). So while it might conceivably be possible to tax motorists according to the level of damage that they cause to roads (with trucks paying far more than they do now, and with revenues not exceeding the costs of collection), it certainly wouldn't be possible to tax cyclists.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:08PM (#32169834)
The point is that it's not worth doing even for cars. If the toll for the truck was $50, the proportional toll for the car would be one half of one cent.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:48PM (#32170404)
On the other hand, trucks are often speed-restricted and the tax might need to be on the order of $50k for a 60-foot truck (which would still equate to around $50 for a car). The costs would be passed down to all of the things that trucks are used for, so I suppose the average person wouldn't really pay any less for combined transport+groceries+fuel+household goods, but it might incentivize the use of smaller trucks with lighter axle loads, but that would also mean more drivers/poorer fuel efficiency/more accidents per ton per mile. At the least we should be mindful of the way that motorists are providing a subsidy to the logistics industry (which we indirectly benefit from, as well).
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:59PM (#32174506)
It most certainly would not cost $50k for any size truck to travel down one road once, which is what matters if you're paying the cost to build infrastructure to track usage.

It might cost a semi truck $50k a year, but this also points in the direction of not tracking specific usage even for trucks: Just check the odometer during the annual inspection and then distribute the highway funds to states proportionate to estimated use.

Toll collection is stupid inefficient and privacy invasive.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by brippalcharrid on Thursday July 21, 2022 @12:33PM (#32181416)
Yes, obviously I was talking about an annual charge ("a tax") based on vehicle road wear; I don't think anyone had suggested that we charge a truck driver $50k for driving down one road, once. It's very common for the odomoters of heavy goods vehicles to be checked and for mileages to be logged regularly (this is probably a legal requirement in many cases, if not just a standard industry practice). I agree that toll collection would be unsuitable. My point was that charges for the use of large goods vehicles would need to be orders of magnitude higher than they are now, but that the charges for cars would still be sufficient to more than cover the cost of collection.

And if people wanted, the President of the National Cycling Federation could present the Secretary of Transportation with a $5 bill in an annual ceremony.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by diordiderot on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @06:34PM (#32173291)
I'd rather pay costs where they're owed personally
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by belorn on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @03:38PM (#32171065)
Dealing with government and taxes there is one additional factor to consider. The government can give tax cuts to targeted groups if they consider it beneficial to society.

So let say the truck has a $5000 tax to pay for yearly wear and tear on roads, but they also get a $5000 tax cut to reduce costs in the transportation sector. That will leave cars to still pay their road tax, even if in comparison they would be a tiny portion of the total road tax.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:51PM (#32174446)
But if you want a general subsidy then you collect the money from a broad based tax like general income tax or sales tax, not low-efficiency road tolls.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by pengaru on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @01:25PM (#32169152)
Except not all roads are built to handle heavier vehicles, such roads experience significant wear from common weight automobiles. I don't think the cost of maintenance for such roads is a rounding error.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:03PM (#32169767)
Most roads are built to handle heavier vehicles and the few exceptions rarely if ever see enough traffic to result in maintenance costs not dominated by nature and weather.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by pydry on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @08:18AM (#32164665)
There is no road tax, only vehicle excise duty which bicyclists dont pay. It goes straight into the treasury so it's not even really "used" per se it's just a way of exerting downward pressure on inflation (which is how it should be, IMHO).
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tomgp on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:53AM (#32166597)
thats a strangely abstract way of looking at it. i think of it as a way to capture some of the externalities of car use, the environmental, social and public health damage.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:19PM (#32167993)
The obvious way to do that is via the fuel tax, where the more you pay the more you use.

The reality is probably that it's not that well coupled to any cause, and really it's just a way to farm money from the majority of the country, who need to use motor transport to live their lives. The advertised political reason will change depending on the concerns of the populace at the time.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by lol768 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:16AM (#32165345)
> bicycle and pedestrians could be exempted from a road tax based on fairly simple assumption: the wear and tear is minimal compared to a car. It wouldn't even surprise me if the wear and tear is so small that it can't even be measured.

Isn't car wear and tear minimal to HGV wear and tear?

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by dahfizz on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @10:36AM (#32166340)
It also depends highly on your local weather, I imagine. I'm willing to bet that a harsh winter does more road damage than all traffic combined.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by cogman10 on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @09:20AM (#32165386)
Yup.

Though cars still put out a fair bit more pollution from tire wear than bicycles do.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tzs on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:09AM (#32166856)
> bicycle and pedestrians could be exempted from a road tax based on fairly simple assumption: the wear and tear is minimal compared to a car. It wouldn't even surprise me if the wear and tear is so small that it can't even be measured.

That is the case, which came as a surprise to me.

For things like the road bed, where the force from the surface is going to be spread out more, I'd expect the car to do more damage because total weight would be all that mattered.

But for damage at or near the road surface I'd have expected bikes to do more.

My reasoning was simple: although cars weigh a lot more they are spreading that weight over a larger contact area.

My car for example has four tires each at a pressure of 32 PSI. My bike, before I replaced the tires with wider tires, had two tires each at 110 PSI. Any given small patch of road I drive or ride over would only get about 29% as much force on it from the car as it would from the bike at any given time a tire is on that patch of road.

It would get that force for more time from the car than from the bike if the car is going less than ~3.4 times the speed of the bike and for less time if the car is going faster than that, and more different small patches of road would get force from the car than would get force from the bike.

This is similar to why if I were to put a flat metal plate on my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would not hurt, but if I were to set hold a dagger against my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would likely hurt a lot.

But something is wrong with my reasoning, and it turns out that road damage goes as something like the fourth power of the vehicles axel weight. Whether the tires are narrow high pressure tires or wide low pressure tires, from what I've read, is not relevant.

I'm not sure if that is because I was just wrong about top layer damage, or if it is just that lower level damage is just much more important and expensive, so any difference in top layer damage due to tire size is lost in the noise.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by LeifCarrotson on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:03PM (#32167711)
> Any given small patch of road I drive or ride over would only get about 29% as much force on it from the car as it would from the bike at any given time a tire is on that patch of road.

...

> This is similar to why if I were to put a flat metal plate on my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would not hurt, but if I were to set hold a dagger against my chest and set a bowling ball on top it would likely hurt a lot.

This is because your chest is weak and soft in comparison to the incompressible metal plate or dagger blade, which is not analogous to the situation on the road. A better analogy would be poking yourself with the tip of an al dente noodle compared to the load transmitted by a large, spongy slice of bread. Neither is going to hurt you in any way.

Whether your tire is transmitting 110 psi or 32 psi doesn't matter much because the compressive strength of Portland cement concrete is ~4000 PSI and the compressive strength of bituminous pavement is ~500 PSI.

However, soil bearing loads are on the order of 15-50 psi under constant loading, and can act as a spring or can yield at much lower transitory loads. The dirt beneath the pavement (or rather, the dirt beneath the gravel beneath the pavement) gives easily, so instead of asking the concrete to survive the compression forces caused by the contact patch, you're asking it to form a beam/plate that spreads the loads over a broad area, and asking that beam to resist deflection rather than crushing. The real damage, and the reason that damage scales with the fourth power of axle loading, is caused when a large truck rolls over the road, the ground shakes, and the roadbed flexes down into the soil under the axle and back up after it passes.

Try to imagine riding your road bike over a piece of cardboard laid on the sand. That wrinkling and creasing is much closer to actual road wear patterns than a dagger cutting your chest.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bagels on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:41AM (#32167361)
This analysis based on tire pressure seems faulty. If you place your hand on a bike tire, you do not experience thousands of pounds of force.

To estimate the pressure exerted on the road, you want to compare vehicle system weight/tire contact area. Velocity also plays a role.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by vel0city on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:34AM (#32167257)
Sure, the contact patch is a good bit smaller on a bike than a car, but people don't usually weigh 5,000lbs.

I'd much rather get run over by average person on a bicycle than get run over by a car.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by robertlagrant on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:10PM (#32167844)
That's because you aren't a smooth surface :) Because of your shape (and I admit I'm making an assumption here) you will experience pressure spikes due to the fact that different bits of you stick out. E.g. knees due to their shape will experience much higher pressure. A road won't do that.
Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by kingaillas on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:23AM (#32167076)
>My car for example has four tires each at a pressure of 32 PSI.

The air pressure of your car/bike tires doesn't matter - all tires could be flat. Try comparing (vehicle weight + your weight) / (vehicle contact surface area) where vehicle is either your car or your bike.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by tzs on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @12:00PM (#32167663)
For tires that support the vehicle via air pressure in the tires, contact area is roughly weight supported by tire / air pressure in tire [1].

[1] http://ffden-2.phys.uaf.edu/211_fall2013.web.dir/connor_matt...

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by ars on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @02:44PM (#32170356)
When the tire is flat it is being supported by the sidewalls and by the wheel.

And if you notice the contact patch of a flat tire is much larger.

The ground pressure of any vehicle is almost exactly equal to the psi. With the exception of force carried by the sidewalls.

Re:Electric Cars – fuel duty and road tax: how to replace £3... by bobthepanda on Wednesday July 20, 2022 @11:58AM (#32167633)
Having lived in New York with really high rates of pedestrians, sidewalks are never being replaced from normal wear and tear from use.

Usually it’s

* retrofitting for ADA compliance

* fixing heaving from freeze-thaw

* fixing heaving from the root systems of trees in street planters