Success for the Carbon Language requires it to successfully be an independent and community driven project. We may not succeed (this really is an experiment), but we're working hard to engage broadly and early in large part because of this being such an important goal and priority for us.
Projects like this have to start somewhere, but can grow and become community endeavors. We are also already seeing strong interest from other companies and organizations in participating in this experiment.
In Rust for example, `unsafe {}` blocks are not just "local unsafety". They can freely operate on all memory, so they are infectious and are essentially a marker for "dangerous code below, be extra careful and audit lots".
But if all code can freely interoperate with C++, how do you improve upon C++, apart from relatively isolated features like a better generics system?
To what extend can a Carbon compiler that is deeply aware of C++ semantics mitigate the pitfalls?
You can definitely massively improve upon C++ without touching its actual computation model.
Power C++ Syntax Plus Edition
C&₹π÷×√
Why use these stock index abbrevs (or whatever they are) in this context here? GEEZ!
To the topic, it sounds a bit grumpy. If we look at languages and how many evolve... many suffer the phenomenon that they almost all are Turing complete, and try to gain concise (or simple understandable) expressiveness somehow, and then they try to not break compatibility too much to varying degrees - net result: they grow and grow where at one point they feel like too big, too much legacy dragged around (C++), the "one obvious way" lost (Python) when they cater for use case after use case.
Limiting can be good in that regard. So having key goals defined and not to cater to every small new usecase by someone is a valid attempt to not let this happen, so while I dislike Googles power, I wouldn't feel to bad with attempting this by anyone on their fresh language?!
> That said, our experience, use cases, and needs are clearly not those of every user. We aren’t pushing to directly build consensus on these points. Rather, this is presented as a vehicle to advertise our needs from C++ as a high-performance systems language.
The point of the non-goals is simply stating things they don't care about, which is pretty reasonable. After all, it's easy to say what you want, but what are you willing to give up for it?
Implementing a coherent vision might lead to a better language even if most stakeholders might disagree with every single change.
I was frankly shocked by that goals and priorities document. The non-goals section reads like an open declaration of war against anyone whose use cases for C++ differ from GOOG and NVDA. My interpretation of Carbon is that since GOOG failed to take over the standard in favor of its narrow use cases, that they are building a new language optimized specifically for them.
> I have no idea ... how open to non-Google ideas it will be.
The most-generous attitude to take is that it will be managed similarly to Go. If your use cases and priorities are well-aligned with theirs, then feel free to use it. But while they may listen to third-party feedback, it will be their own use cases and opinions which dominate the language's development.