For thousands of years of our existence, progress was very slow and sometimes we went in reverse in some regions.
Economic growth plus innovation resulted in progress and pulled the 99% who were not wealthy out of utter subsistence poverty over the last few hundred years.
Also, we cannot grow forever (unless we figure out how to colonize other planets). We have to figure out how to live in a worldwide demographic "Japan" zero to negative pop growth, decline and be comfortable and work with it. New generations don't have to be richer than the last. We can achieve some maintainable level of comfort and be okay with that.
Of course the assumption of growth underpins most modern societies, as far as I know, but we will have to find a new model for a new reality.
I think 1950s USA middle-class was probably comfortable enough, certainly it was far far from "utter subsistence poverty" -- if the entire world population can live at 1950s USA middle-class levels, without destroying the ecology that sustains us, we should count ourselves lucky (it's not clear we can).
Note that was without computers, cell phones. It was much more expensive clothing you'd keep until it wore out. Maybe only one car per family (or less) with more public transportation. Fewer airplane flights. Etc.
Will Apple say “Sorry, no more new iPhone versions. All out of ideas?” And all their competitors agree?
I think we can agree that we have resource limitations (whether it be livable space or ploughable land).
Modern economies work on the premise of growing markets. Whether creating new markets or taking over old markets. With a steady state or shrinking population, you can value add and you can innovate, but there are no new "China market(s)" to expand into. If growth were not fundamental, then companies would not look to expand beyond their borders (whether local, regional, national or international).
How would companies in modern economies survive if they should predict shrinking markets? Consumerism buys you some time (you need the iPhone umpteenth), at some point a hammer is good enough --with corner-case exceptions.
Matter doesn’t become a resource unless it’s economically useful. 5 kilotons of cadmium may or not be a resource depending on your business.
The world is full of ex resources we haven’t exhausted. There’s no shortage of bat guano or saltpeter. Mercury used to be vital, now it’s value is usually negative.
There’s plenty of raw matter that’s useless now that will he extremely valuable in the future. And will eventually have awkward afterlife as an ex-resource. Like bat guano.
Physics and humans shortsightedness.
There are limited resources on Earth and by the looks of it we're stuck here for the long haul.
Economic growth isn’t dependent on a certain amount of mass, energy, or entropy.
It is though, you might be making the same mass and energy more efficient on a dollar terms, but there is an upper limit and that upper limit is dictated by entropy. There are only so many things that matters on Earth can do under the current physics. We're not that close but not too far away either.
we have 4 magnitudes to go before our energy consumption match all renewable energy source here on Earth.
That's a curiously unsupported hypothesis.
When Hobbes said life would be 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short' he was referring to life outside of the outcast's society.
The "conventional account" of human history they describe is one that I personally have never heard espoused and I am not quite sure if anyone really ever believed.
I think I would prefer to read the general source material, I find professional "essayists" often tiresome to read.
Retiring off of pensions is a zero sum game. Companies charge more to pay pensioners. Customers don't get any additional value, they just pay higher costs for the same goods and services. Owners get lower returns from the company. Retirees are stuck on fixed income, which is devastating during an inflationary period.
The problem here is that there's no grand conspiracy to pursue growth. People make the individual decision to pursue growth because of the individual benefits.
In countries where population growth levelled off it seems to have recently resulted in raising of the retirement age ever higher. It's basically a state run ponzi scheme. I frankly wish we had a tax free investing account option available instead.
I wish they raised the limits.. it’s woefully inadequate after years of inflation.
The main difference between this and a 401k is that the money you pay into it isn't yours and doesn't affect what you get in the end, only your work years fed into some chart determine that. The taxes go directly to current payouts as it would be in a literal ponzi scheme.
>>I frankly wish we had a tax free investing account option available instead.
> isn’t that a 401k?
Guaranteeing financial security to anyone is impossible.
Plenty of countries have done just fine. What you described is horrible mismanagement and not the only way to do things.
I don’t really understand your last paragraph; it feels to me like it is written from a very American perspective. There seem to exist countries that achieve economic growth while having sane healthcare, childcare, etc, and it feels clear to me that U.S. issues are more related to the current local optimum the political system has come to rest in than to some obsession with growth. So what is the argument here about growth? Is it that the other countries don’t actually have growth or that they don’t actually provide stability on social issues or what?
One can argue for a well-fare state that provides all guarantees one wants.
But you're flipping the issue here. First, you have a risk of not aging. But most people are inevitably going to age and retire. This risk is inherent to the individual. Now we can offload that risk to the government (please, it's not the other way around), but it's going to have costs. And I think offloading it to the government is even riskier, because governments make stupid decisions and are subject to massive corruption.
A small handful of the super-rich have already pointed out the only thing "we" can do about it: revolution. Inequality that continues for too long leads to overthrow. The rich get eaten, the poor become a rabble, monarchy/autocracy/totalitarianism eventually returns, and the cycle starts over. That's where we're headed. The funny thing is, our social ills might be the cause before our economic ones are.
The growth obsession phenomenon also happens in countries which demonstrably put more effort into caring about the elderly and the poor. They still get left behind, albeit at marginally lower rates than in a country like the US.
It's the juiced economic statistics and obsession paper growth that's the core problem, not necessarily "rich people have influence"
Not really, half retired Americans live off Social Security alone, and another big chunk I'm guessing a quarter rely on it. Many others have property, business or keep working. I'm guessing its about 10-20% of Americans really have enough 401k savings to live off.
The majority of retirement the average middle class has is their home.
If history repeats itself, real estate valuations should revert to a long term mean which would make homes somewhat more affordable. There are some early indications that this is happening.
Physical laws do not give a fuck about our philosophy. Accept figurative death, cowards.
Steal from people who intentionally changed the rules to deflate our wealth. The laws and their interpretation are no accident.
What this debate is is deference to the elderly or the youth.
Tacit ageism against the future or well reasoned action against the past.
Gramps; you had a good run. Bye.
Edit: I have an MSc in elastic structures, used to work in high powered switching equipment. I understand rates of change in high energy systems like a planets climate. This is not an emotional argument from a place of ignorance.
Perishable goods still exist. People will still work to create perishable goods to consume. They will still change cultures and create solutions in areas where the game is not (pseudo-)zero-sum.
You also can't grow everything forever, as real estate is showing. If your concern is people stealing, that's an obvious target.
People will always work because work needs to be done. Food, shelter, power, all of it requires active work by people. No stealing necessary. The laissez-faire rhetoric of "no growth, nobody to work" is exactly the problem mindset this economist is trying to address.
"The biggest problem is the rich have created a system in which people's future (retirement) is basically linked to "the market" growing over their lifetime." ah so trade and supply/demand that are moved by "standard persons" = rich people, ah yes.
"This system of course is built 100% on governments/employers not wanting to guarantee financial security of elders and offload the risk to the individual." great idea, have people at governments mercy and build a voter block that is going to put the tick where they're going to be told to for some of that extra pension plan dough.
"...the rich benefit insanely more by market movements than a standard person does..." while also contributing the most tax revenue...
Nice of you to imply that only "the rich" can buy/sell assets, especially in a post-Gamestop world.
The biggest problem is the rich have created a system in which people's future (retirement) is basically linked to "the market" growing over their lifetime. And the hopes that if they get lucky enough with the market they can retire early (or at all). This system of course is built 100% on governments/employers not wanting to guarantee financial security of elders and offload the risk to the individual. Also the rich have a massive incentive for everyone to "invest" (cough) and drive prices up, because the rich benefit insanely more by market movements than a standard person does.
Maybe the system will explode in our lifetime, maybe not. But all this insanity focus of growth, profits, etc with no genuine regard to real social issues (providing basic stability to people whether it be healthcare, housing, food, childcare) is so sick I can barely even think about it. And there's almost nothing to do about it- that's the way things currently "work" and it seems insurmountable to do anything about it.