I think 1950s USA middle-class was probably comfortable enough, certainly it was far far from "utter subsistence poverty" -- if the entire world population can live at 1950s USA middle-class levels, without destroying the ecology that sustains us, we should count ourselves lucky (it's not clear we can).
Note that was without computers, cell phones. It was much more expensive clothing you'd keep until it wore out. Maybe only one car per family (or less) with more public transportation. Fewer airplane flights. Etc.
Will Apple say “Sorry, no more new iPhone versions. All out of ideas?” And all their competitors agree?
I think we can agree that we have resource limitations (whether it be livable space or ploughable land).
Modern economies work on the premise of growing markets. Whether creating new markets or taking over old markets. With a steady state or shrinking population, you can value add and you can innovate, but there are no new "China market(s)" to expand into. If growth were not fundamental, then companies would not look to expand beyond their borders (whether local, regional, national or international).
How would companies in modern economies survive if they should predict shrinking markets? Consumerism buys you some time (you need the iPhone umpteenth), at some point a hammer is good enough --with corner-case exceptions.
Matter doesn’t become a resource unless it’s economically useful. 5 kilotons of cadmium may or not be a resource depending on your business.
The world is full of ex resources we haven’t exhausted. There’s no shortage of bat guano or saltpeter. Mercury used to be vital, now it’s value is usually negative.
There’s plenty of raw matter that’s useless now that will he extremely valuable in the future. And will eventually have awkward afterlife as an ex-resource. Like bat guano.
Physics and humans shortsightedness.
There are limited resources on Earth and by the looks of it we're stuck here for the long haul.
Economic growth isn’t dependent on a certain amount of mass, energy, or entropy.
It is though, you might be making the same mass and energy more efficient on a dollar terms, but there is an upper limit and that upper limit is dictated by entropy. There are only so many things that matters on Earth can do under the current physics. We're not that close but not too far away either.
we have 4 magnitudes to go before our energy consumption match all renewable energy source here on Earth.
That's a curiously unsupported hypothesis.
When Hobbes said life would be 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short' he was referring to life outside of the outcast's society.
The "conventional account" of human history they describe is one that I personally have never heard espoused and I am not quite sure if anyone really ever believed.
I think I would prefer to read the general source material, I find professional "essayists" often tiresome to read.
For thousands of years of our existence, progress was very slow and sometimes we went in reverse in some regions.
Economic growth plus innovation resulted in progress and pulled the 99% who were not wealthy out of utter subsistence poverty over the last few hundred years.
Also, we cannot grow forever (unless we figure out how to colonize other planets). We have to figure out how to live in a worldwide demographic "Japan" zero to negative pop growth, decline and be comfortable and work with it. New generations don't have to be richer than the last. We can achieve some maintainable level of comfort and be okay with that.
Of course the assumption of growth underpins most modern societies, as far as I know, but we will have to find a new model for a new reality.