News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by dmje on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:30AM (#32126214)
I think I'd amend the piece a bit. Personally I think we're playing a high price for mobile phones. Granted, much of the harm is being done by social, but really it's the addictive nature, the "always on-ness" of this that concerns me the most, in all the reading, research and life experience I'm doing.

My son, who is now 17, spends - I would imagine, he doesn't know because he's too frightened to switch on Screen Time - maybe 10-14 hours a day glued to his phone. He's now at an age where I have no agency over him - he's an adult in 6 months and he's got to figure out his own way - but it worries me.

In his specific case I'm actually less worried than with many of his friends. He's bright, and uses the internet to figure out and watch some pretty rad stuff. It isn't all shit, and although a fair proportion of his use is Insta, it's using it as an instant messaging tool rather than a pure "social media" tool. He rarely posts, and I suspect may be different to his (female) friends in that regard.

But here are the two points that are rarely talked about that are actually the most important ones to consider:

First, if anyone was doing anything for 12 hours a day, it's probably an issue. If my kids played football for 12 hours a day, or made Lego, or cooked, I'd be concerned. It's just not healthy to be that ensconced in a thing, let alone when that thing is as hugely, highly addictive as phone use / social media. Even if that thing was the healthiest thing in the world - say someone I knew went out running for 12 hours a day - man, I'd be concerned.

Secondly, it strikes me as "out there in the world" that this is the biggest issue. To me, as a 50 year old man, it's bloody weird anyone spending this much time online, but to be outdoors, or at a bar, or a restaurant with your partner, or looking after your kids, or looking at a sunset, or on the beach - and be constantly in your phone - this is insane.

Living a life, a real life, with real relationships and real sunsets and real beaches - is an enormous privilege. Many of us are wasting it. Life is short. Leave your phone at home, and truly live it.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by actionablefiber on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:15AM (#32126488)
> My son, who is now 17, spends - I would imagine, he doesn't know because he's too frightened to switch on Screen Time - maybe 10-14 hours a day glued to his phone. He's now at an age where I have no agency over him - he's an adult in 6 months and he's got to figure out his own way - but it worries me.

I have to ask, do you live in the suburbs? I was in a similar place as your son growing up, I had an extreme screen addiction (although some of it was productive). There was nothing to do or see within several miles of home and I was dependent on my parents for transportation, which added enough friction that I didn't really even know where to begin when it came to making friends or planning outings beyond school. It was just significantly easier to stay at home playing video games or surfing online all the time, and that habit spilled over into anything I did outside the house as well. That all changed when I moved somewhere walkable with good transit/bike infrastructure.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by timmytokyo on Sunday July 17, 2022 @02:07PM (#32129367)
As a 50-something man who grew up in a pretty boring suburb, I rarely found myself lacking for things to do. I spent most of my time hanging out with friends, even if it was at the local arcade, strip mall or a friend's house. We'd ride our bicycles all over the city, explore the local creeks and hillsides, or play video games together (Atari, Intellivision, etc.). Eventually a few of us got home computers (Apple II or Commodore) and spent a huge amount of time playing games or programming, but there was always a desire to get together and do things outside. (The suburban experiences of the kids on E.T. reminds me a lot of my own childhood, minus the alien.)

Most of us had chores and/or jobs. I had a paper route from age 12 to age 14. When I was at home, my parents were always kicking me out of the house to go do things outside or with friends. Most kids in my neighborhood were what you would classify today as "free range". That seemed to be the norm in those days.

Today I look at kids with their heads buried in smart phones and feel a real sense of pity.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by actionablefiber on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:28PM (#32133099)
A few major things have changed in the intervening time that have worsened the problem.

First, the suburbs have expanded, greatly. This means they're farther out in the periphery on average, there are far more highways, roads, and parking structures needed to support them (with far more lanes and traffic), and it's consequently more difficult and dangerous to go places on your own, especially without a car, in any place that is in or connected to suburban developments. For reference, when I was going to elementary school in the late 2000s, my school was half a mile away on the other side of a five lane highway that had no sidewalk on the other side. It wasn't until later that a pedestrian/bike accessible trail was put in to allow access to getting downtown and even then it would still take 30-40 minutes walking or 10-15 minutes cycling and it sucked the whole time. And this was a less exurban development than many of the ones that have sprung up in the last decade.

Secondly, perhaps in part as a reasonable reaction to the first and in part as an unreasonable reaction to fearmongering, parents are unwilling to let their kids venture out on their own without supervision, and even police each other, by calling the actual police on parents who let their kids travel alone.

Thirdly, tech has just gotten better, in ways that make it higher quality and in ways that make it addictive. Browsing the internet and playing vidya is a better value proposition these days in many suburbs than going outside to navigate asphalt and private lawns as far as the eye can see.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by stevenicr on Monday July 18, 2022 @05:06PM (#32143710)
I had similar experiences around a similar time frame.

I had no idea how lucky I was.

As an adult I moved to another city - what I found after moving is that there are no sidewalks, lots of hills, and virtually no where is safe to bike. (sadly this is still pretty much the case 20 years later around here, although they have added some 'bike lanes' and laws.. you couldn't pay me to bike around here.

Arcades have closed, no skateboarding and similar trespass rules are common now to deter hanging out at strip malls and such.

I keep recalling the news story some years back where a mom was arrested for allowing her kids to go to the park without a parent (maybe it was chicago or similar?)

Friend's houses have become a worry about all the stories you see in the news / social feeds about drugging / raping / guns / unfiltered porn / hidden cams etc..

I too have pity for today's youth with heads in phones - however seeing what some of the other hoodlums are doing with idle hands these days, on top of the rampant dangers outside the homes, I'm glad there are all these screen options today.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by sha256sum on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:45PM (#32134002)
Those days don’t exist anymore. You shouldn’t feel pity for those kids, you should feel shame in being part of the generation that robbed all of those good experiences away. It’s no joke that a lot of these kids are depressed and have no skills or resources to find entertainment.

Before smart phones many of their parents watched TV for 4+ hours a day. What did you expect the kids to do?

Re:The high price we pay for social media by dazc on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:41AM (#32127221)
I was just thinking the same. I live 10 minutes away from the coast and have just enjoyed a few hours sat by the beach where most people were sunbathing, paddle boarding, taking a dip, etc. I didn't notice anyone gazing at their smartphone.

As a kid I lived inland and a casual trip to the beach just wasn't an option. I look back and remember a lot of boring Sundays where the option of staring at a phone screen all day would have been a luxury.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by dmje on Sunday July 17, 2022 @01:28PM (#32128930)
I’ve literally just now got back from having a dip in the sea, and was laughing to myself at the guy standing in the surf looking at his phone. Beautiful evening, stunning weather, and his dog standing there looking bored waiting for him to throw his ball, and he’s on his phone…

My experience is very different to yours - I’d say as I walked across the beach yesterday when I was really paying attention, maybe 20-30% of the people I passed were looking at a screen.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by shapefrog on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:30AM (#32127666)
Beach trips these days are normally for the gram not for the day at the beach.

https://fun107.com/dads-embarrassing-their-daughters-in-the-...

Re:The high price we pay for social media by dmje on Sunday July 17, 2022 @01:25PM (#32128907)
By the sea, in a small town in Cornwall. Loads to do, and he does a lot of it - he surfs, rides his bike, climbs, hangs with his mates. He’s an excellent fellow, and I hope nothing I’ve said suggests otherwise. When he’s not on his phone, he’s an incredibly balanced chap. Even when he is on his phone, he’s brilliant - as I said, he looks at some seriously interesting stuff, much of it about space and rockets and physics, as this is the stuff that sparks him.

But my wider worry is still there - not just for him, but for all of us. A world seen through a 5” screen is just a poor facsimile. It’s not the world, full of the gnarly stuff - and the beautiful stuff - that goes on out here.

Boredom is another thing - actually (as we hopefully all know by now..), boredom and downtime is useful. It lets the brain make sense of the world, it’s where the ideas happen. If your “downtime” is a constant buzz of notifications, or dopamine hits, what happens to inspiration, or those “tada” moments?

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jstarfish on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:39PM (#32134363)
Interesting point.

I find my only "boredom" moments occur as I'm getting out of bed or as I'm trying to sleep.

This might explain why I find myself chronically uninspired...and unproductive.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by gernb on Tuesday July 19, 2022 @01:12AM (#32147775)
I know things are different now but I grew up in the suburbs and yet went all kinds of places. Got my driver's license at 16. Parents let me borrow one car or another all the time. Even before that though, rode bikes all over.

This, even though I was a nerd making programs on home computers. We didn't have the internet or even BBSes though. We did have video games.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jader201 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:37PM (#32128325)
Don’t most parents of children live outside of cities?

Obviously there are many families that live in cities, but cities seem to mostly draw younger professionals that don’t (yet) have children, and often once these people start having families, they relocate outside of the city (if they’re able to).

Re:The high price we pay for social media by actionablefiber on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:56PM (#32128540)
Growing up in car-dependent suburbs is not conducive to a healthy, balanced, independent childhood. You’re right that many parents raise their kids in car-dependent suburbs, at least in North America, which just means that this is a very large problem affecting a lot of people.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by MisterMower on Monday July 18, 2022 @12:04AM (#32134528)
As opposed to the concrete jungles and public transit terminals typical of your larger US cities?
Re:The high price we pay for social media by actionablefiber on Monday July 18, 2022 @09:58AM (#32138428)
No, not as opposed to them. The U.S. has a radically bimodal development pattern with very few developments that lie in between "dense cramped highrises" and "suburban wastelands of cars, asphalt, strip malls and large private homes with large lawns." This development pattern, which is exceedingly rare elsewhere in the world, excludes the kind of developments that are most needed, which are multifamily housing developments that offer decent private space to individuals while being dense and connected enough to offer public amenities and transit.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by tremon on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:22AM (#32126538)
doing anything for 12 hours a day

But there's a problem with multifunctional devices like computers and smartphones: it's highly unlikely he's doing the same thing for those 12 hours. Obviously I don't know exactly what your son is doing, but I think it's highly unlikely those 12 hours are filled with a single activity. And in that case, grouping all those activities as "spending time on phone" is less helpful than you think.

Taking my adult self as an example: on work days, I use the computer for more than 12 hours a day, easily. That time is divided between coding, research, monitoring existing systems, communicating with team members, having meetings, reading news sites (for various definitions of "news"), watching movies, and listening to music.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by skeeter2020 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:37AM (#32126634)
>> it's highly unlikely he's doing the same thing for those 12 hours

This may seem like a safe assumption but if we abstract to the core of "continually monitoring a loose network of 3+ degrees removed people for fear of missing out" I don't think they are doing anything diverse with their phones. Your own use of a computer is far different: kids and young adults are doing no coding; research (beyond asking Siri random, shallow questions); or monitoring, communicating, meeting, media consumption outside of these social networks. The homogeneous, consumption-focused all-consuming aspects are my real concerns. It's the Fentanyl of the 3-channel TV universe that I grew up with.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by bonoboTP on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:07AM (#32126880)
That nitpick is a bit like when people say BMI is invalid as an indicator for overweightness because bodybuilders are also categorized as obese by BMI. Except the confusion is impossible in case of a regular person.

Similarly, there can be good reasons for being 12 hours on screens, but it will be obvious and exceptional. Yes an 18 year old may be a successful entrepreneur, video maker podcast host influencer who is reading ebooks for research or sending out emails or editing videos or programming a website in those hours but we are clearly not talking about that, but FOMO social media scrolling.

There can be good reasons for hyperobsessing over a single issue in life, but you better have a damn good reason for it, like being a successful athlete or chess player or e-sport player or whatever. And it will still be a sacrifice that's only worth it if you are truly exceptional and there's a high chance you aren't.

The question is, are those hours bringing an improvement to your life, are they bringing you closer to achieving meaningful life goals or are they a distraction from focus and life organization, and a suppression of quality of life and achievement.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by NoraCodes on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:00AM (#32127396)
> Yes an 18 year old may be a successful entrepreneur, video maker podcast host influencer who is reading ebooks for research or sending out emails or editing videos or programming a website in those hours but we are clearly not talking about that

Aren't we? I heard the same comments from my parents when I was learning to program and even when I was going to school online.

I think a lot of older folks genuinely don't understand how many different activities are mediated by computers.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by awillen on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:30AM (#32127108)
I struggle to take anyone seriously who says that "being on your phone" is some sort of enormous problem. "Being on your phone" isn't an activity - complaining about it is like saying that someone's going too many places. If they're driving around to different strip clubs all day, maybe a problem. If the places they're going are their kids' soccer games and doctors appointments and picking up groceries and having dinner with friends, that's perfectly fine.

My phone has basically the entire recorded history of human knowledge. It has the ability to communicate instantly with people all over the world. That's a lot!

I own an ecommerce business, and on a typical day I'll check in on sales via the Shopify app, correspond with customers via Gmail and maybe take some photos to post on my business' social media accounts. I also use my phone to call and text my parents, wife and friends. I probably spend at least an hour every day reading news on my phone. And yeah, sometimes I fritter away time on Reddit.

People love to criticize when they see others on their phones in public, but you know what? If I'm sitting somewhere for a few minutes with nothing to do, I can pull it out, fire off a few emails, and then have a few more minutes to pet my dogs when I get home. My dogs deserve those extra minutes. They're very good dogs.

A phone is a multi-functional tool that can be incredibly useful (or also a way to waste a ton of time), and criticizing people for using that tool without any idea of how or why they're using it is silly.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by helloworld11 on Monday July 18, 2022 @06:12AM (#32136472)
Agreed for the most part. In my case, I use an app on my phone to read books from a filed collection of dozens that I really want to finish at some point. Sure, it might not be great for my eyes, but if my phone is with me most of the time in random places and situations where waiting suddenly comes around here and there, I can plough through lots of literature.

Of course, to a passing observer, it wouldn't look like that. Because most people associate phones with social media scrolling, they automatically assume that's what you're doing with one. My phone thus has one major thing in its favor at least: it's let me read more full blown novels, literature and non fiction tomes than I ever did before having one, and I read a lot even then. Phones aren't an activity by themselves, what thing you use them for is the activity and its nature makes a difference.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jader201 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:48PM (#32128457)
It seems like there is enough studies and science backing that too much phone use can cause problems — especially doing a lot of multitasking.

I say “seems like” without saying definitively, since I’m not quoting sources. But I’ve seen enough articles/studies come through HN that seem to suggest there is likely a link between phone addiction and things like anxiety, depression, attention span, etc.

Yes, phones are useful for a lot of things, and are in some cases required for doing some functions for business and social connectivity.

But the speed of information being fed and consumed, and the constant context switching can’t be good for us.

E.g. when I view my Twitter feed, I can have 20-40 completely different thoughts go through my head in a matter of minutes. I can’t imagine how that could be beneficial.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jjav on Sunday July 17, 2022 @07:31PM (#32132624)
> My phone has basically the entire recorded history of human knowledge.

I'd say you're overstating by a large amount the quantity of quality information on the web. Sure there's a lot, but also much is missing and in terms of percentage most of the online content is garbage.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by dmje on Sunday July 17, 2022 @01:29PM (#32128946)
Agree. I’d say it’s worse - those hours are sporadic, endless distraction. Every few minutes, a buzz, a ding, something taking you away from whatever else you were doing…
Re:The high price we pay for social media by indymike on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:45AM (#32126299)
> 50 year old man, it's bloody weird anyone spending this much time online, but to be outdoors, or at a bar, or a restaurant with your partner, or looking after your kids, or looking at a sunset, or on the beach - and be constantly in your phone - this is insane.

You have a great point here.

Thinking about this. When I was young I spend an unnatural, lot of time in front of screens. Here is what I did: I learned BASIC, REXX, C, x86 assembler, Pascal, and Prolog. I learned to make software for a home comuputer, then for a real PC. It was productive, made money for me, and helped me develop a skillset that has resulted in six companies created, a couple hundred people having jobs, and a decent life for my family. I have exactly zero regrets for spending time with the computer.

What if the device was a phone? You can't even create software for a mobile phone with the phone. I guess I would have consumed a lot of content, and posted a lot of videos. Maybe I'd be able to build an audience, and make some cash from my gofundme or patreon. Maybe.

> Living a life, a real life, with real relationships and real sunsets and real beaches - is an enormous privilege. Many of us are wasting it. Life is short. Leave your phone at home, and truly live it.

This is really great advice. Or at least delete all the distraction as a service apps. The best feature on a phone is the camera and maps app. One is for capturing and sharing memories, and the other is for finding your way to friends and adventure to make those memories.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by NalNezumi on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:55AM (#32126352)
It's easy now in retrospect to say "those hours glued in front of the PC turned out good" and jump to "but that's not the case for todays kids" with a rose tinted glass.

It reminds me of something a friend told me about a youtuber called mister beast(or something); how in an interview he said he was practically raised with youtube as his sole life, spend all waking hours thinking "what would buzz on YouTube?" and not just him, he would talk about this with his fellow content creator, like they were obsessed.

Afaik the guy is doing really well. Now replace "YouTube" with whatever programming language you mentioned and you can see a similar story.

And the other side of your coin "glued in front of PC" is people like me who spent 16h a day of my Highschool year playing online games that lead to absolutely nothing except maybe a little bit better English knowledge.

When you're looking at kids glued to the phone, you're looking at how the generation above me/us looked at me,and not you. And I think I'm in the majority of people that was glued in front of the PC; Nothing "productive" really came out of it

Re:The high price we pay for social media by formerkrogemp on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:32AM (#32126603)
> It reminds me of something a friend told me about a youtuber called mister beast(or something); how in an interview he said he was practically raised with youtube as his sole life, spend all waking hours thinking "what would buzz on YouTube?" and not just him, he would talk about this with his fellow content creator, like they were obsessed.. Afaik the guy is doing really well.

I understand what you're trying to say about this generational view of youngsters being into the latest fad tech not being viewed as productive by the older people in their lives. I think mr. beast is an awful example. You picked one of the most successful and well known youtubers. For every one of him, there are millions of unsuccessful individuals with youtube channels or other social media "jobs." Survivorship bias is real here. The income distribution is extremely top heavy and unfair.

> When you're looking at kids glued to the phone, you're looking at how the generation above me/us looked at me,and not you. And I think I'm in the majority of people that was glued in front of the PC; Nothing "productive" really came out of it.

You're right that for the most part nothing productive comes from consuming entertainment as such for the vast majority of consumers of social media, especially when young. I'm still unsure of where I stand on this issue, but I'm certainly more cognizant of the costs of social media and so forth than the benefits.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by skeeter2020 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:50AM (#32126736)
>> Afaik the guy is doing really well.

He has like 100M subscribers and 16.5 billion views and counting. So yep, doing "OK". It's very, VERY dangerous to look at the peak of a mountain and try to extrapolate ANYTHING from a single data point. Comparing the history & outcome of someone like this with your personal experience isn't likely to be very valuable, but nothing you've presented discredits that neither of these approaches are likely to lead to enjoyable, fulfilling lives.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by shrimp_emoji on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:18AM (#32127536)
>spending time at a PC can lead to a career in software engineering

>spending time on YouTube can lead to being an e-celebrity

Two differences are that of those is a casino, and it's probably not the healthiest or most sustainable path for most people.

>When you're looking at kids glued to the phone, you're looking at how the generation above me/us looked at me,and not you. And I think I'm in the majority of people that was glued in front of the PC; Nothing "productive" really came out of it

The argument here is that the PC offers an onramp for some percentage of people to something really good, while the phone intrinsically doesn't. Or, if it does, it's an onramp to being an influencer. Nuff said. :p

Re:The high price we pay for social media by indymike on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:04AM (#32126846)
> It's easy now in retrospect to say "those hours glued in front of the PC turned out good" and jump to "but that's not the case for todays kids" with a rose tinted glass.

That isn't really the point... but it is easy to read that out of my comment. The point is the devices don't offer the possibilities that a PC did. The only thing you can really create efficiently on a phone are short messages, photos and videos.

> And the other side of your coin "glued in front of PC" is people like me who spent 16h a day of my Highschool year playing online games that lead to absolutely nothing except maybe a little bit better English knowledge.

I probably did that more than a little bit as well ;-) and I do not reget a minute of it.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by GekkePrutser on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:25AM (#32126569)
As well as that, YouTube is more accessible for most people. Programming will never be for everyone. It requires a certain mindset.

Personally for me making YouTube videos is very hard, much harder than programming. I hate making them and I hate watching them just as much. But I'm an outlier and I realize that.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by skeeter2020 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:44AM (#32126682)
>> The best feature on a phone is the camera and maps app. One is for capturing and sharing memories, and the other is for finding your way to friends and adventure to make those memories.

I agree strongly with the rest of your post, but then you highlight the two biggest offending aspects of our current society: (1) Everyone is so busy capturing and sharing "memories" they're not actually experiencing them in the first place, (2) When we're trying to get somewhere we don't even look up to ask where are we right now IN RELATION to where we'd like to go before pulling out our device. The second is particularly odd to me, as my father (now in his 70's) did all sorts of adventure travelling as I was growing up with nothing more than paper maps and I now watch him routinely ask for gps directions to places he's been dozens of times. It makes me sad.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by prmoustache on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:12AM (#32126923)
Agree on this one. I went to a concert this week. When the concert started, thousands of smartphones were raised in the air and many people spent an awful amount of time grabbing ugly videos with saturated sound. I was guilty of grabbing a 1min one.

Do we really enjoy the moment as well when grabbing everything. I doubt it.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by bonoboTP on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:26AM (#32127068)
Taking some pictures is great. Having some pics to look at a vacation years down the line is good for refreshing memories and emotions and to relive those moments. But that's achievable with a few pictures a day, whereas many people now take hundreds or more and never even look at them again. It's like hoarding behavior or bookmarking web pages or buying books you never end up opening.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by prmoustache on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:09PM (#32130723)
My experience is that taking pictures is only worth it if you print them quickly and put them in an album with comments. I and my daughters will very often grab a photo album randomly in the living room and enjoy remembering those moments. The digital albums? They only serve as a backup thanksfully synched remotely in case my house burn.

Normal non pro photographs human beings have very little energy to organize/tag/process their pictures, they mostly lie forgotten until google photos remember them of those moments, more often than not showcasing the ugiest badly framed photos.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jstarfish on Monday July 18, 2022 @12:16AM (#32134596)
There are two types of hoarders though-- those who take 1000 pictures of things they find interesting, and those who take 1000 pictures of things they think everyone else will find interesting.

The former is a good way to relive any experience. It's literally training data for the photographer to reconstruct their own memories.

The latter group will never have reason to look at the pictures they took. There is a lack of connection.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by dazc on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:46AM (#32127263)
When I think back to such experiences I tend to remember how annoying other people were rather than the event itself. As a consequence I rarely go to concerts, the theatre or the cinema any more.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by bertr4nd on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:19AM (#32127006)
Re: maps. Eh. Some people tend to romanticize the pre-GPS era with stories of serendipitous adventures, but that doesn’t match my experience at all. My recollection is that wandering around lost was time-wasting, frustrating, and sometimes downright scary. I’m not sure I can recall a single positive unexpected experience that resulted. I don’t miss it one bit. If the price is that I sometimes ask for directions to a place I’ve been before, I’ll take the trade.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by m3047 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:39AM (#32127755)
I used to do a lot of solo hiking / scrambling in the (PNW) Cascades. I rarely looked at maps when actually hiking, except to identify some landmark in the distance. I spent time (hours) casually perusing an open topo map laying somewhere at home; sometimes I'd discover that overflight photos were available at one of the libraries. =)

When in the field I rarely looked at a map to see where I was going. I never carried a compass.

Today I can get satellite photos on the internet, (quality? meh. some of the overflight photos were stereo. I suppose I could pay) but "up and down are forever".

Re:The high price we pay for social media by GekkePrutser on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:24AM (#32126555)
> Thinking about this. When I was young I spend an unnatural, lot of time in front of screens. Here is what I did: I learned BASIC, REXX, C, x86 assembler, Pascal, and Prolog. I learned to make software for a home comuputer, then for a real PC. It was productive, made money for me, and helped me develop a skillset that has resulted in six companies created, a couple hundred people having jobs, and a decent life for my family. I have exactly zero regrets for spending time with the computer.

Didn't you get pushback from that from your parents or family?

In the 80s spending so much time on the computer was much more 'weird' than spending as much time on a phone is now.

Remember people calling us nerds and saying we'd get square eyes? I don't hear anyone complaining about this in regards to mobiles now.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by indymike on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:09AM (#32126897)
> Didn't you get pushback from that from your parents or family?

No, my parents were ok with it as long as I took care of the lawn (my Dad had MS and couldn't chase the mower) and didn't flunk out of high school. I also got a job programming at age 16 (writing medical diagnostic aids), and so they saw me making very good money for a 16 year old.

> In the 80s spending so much time on the computer was much more 'weird' than spending as much time on a phone is now.

I really don't have a good reference on what normal was. I spent a lot of time with the computer, put a lot of miles on training for cycling, and played soccer and went to school in between. I just did my thing, and didn't really worry about it.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by GekkePrutser on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:29AM (#32127097)
> I really don't have a good reference on what normal was. I spent a lot of time with the computer, put a lot of miles on training for cycling, and played soccer and went to school in between. I just did my thing, and didn't really worry about it.

Well it was kinda normal for nerds. But nerds were not really 'normal' (though very common anyhow!). I think for people born later it's hard to understand since IT is now taken in much higher regard. I mean if I tell people I'm in IT/Cybersec at a meetup they're usually like "wow cool" which exactly the opposite of what would happen in the 80s :D You'd be viewed as a total dork wasting their time.

You don't sound like a typical nerd though. Most of my nerd friends (and certainly myself) would not do any kind of sports. Especially teamsports.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by indymike on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:58AM (#32127372)
> You don't sound like a typical nerd though. Most of my nerd friends (and certainly myself) would not do any kind of sports. Especially teamsports.

I think the definition of a nerd is to be atypical. I'm glad it's celebrated now, as it should be.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by SiberianDweller on Monday July 18, 2022 @05:22PM (#32143945)
Yes, it's almost impossible to create software from smartphone. But it is possible to create some civil disorder, class action or at least a little shitstorm in Twitter.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by deepsquirrelnet on Monday July 18, 2022 @01:44AM (#32135092)
> real beaches

Several years ago, there I was, on an incredibly beautiful beach in the bay of Thailand. The sun was warm, the water was mild and below the surface were a great number of vividly-colored creatures.

As I sat on the white sand, appreciating every moment I observed two beautiful French-speaking women rent snorkeling equipment and proceed to the water. They walked in, not much more than knee deep, and posed for some cellphone photography in the snorkeling gear. After getting the photos they wanted, they returned the gear and left.

I thought about how funny it was to be witnessing social media happening in real life. The veil is so real to those who don’t get to see behind it. When you do, it’s sad, and something to be pitied.

The dream those women were selling didn’t even exist for them. They didn’t enjoy the beach. They didn’t swim out to see the incredible ocean creatures. It existed for me. Average me was living their best life that day. I did the things they wanted people to believe they were doing, and they didn’t.

It’s really fascinating social behavior. My conclusion is essentially that social media creates a sort of fantasy that perfection is just barely out of reach… and feeding the addiction of continually moving onto the next thing, hoping to find it.

It’s probably the same reason people become serial online daters, and the reason for the success of those platforms. It causes people to become inflexible toward enjoyment or appreciation of reality… even in cases where reality is pretty damn near perfect.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by stevenjgarner on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:45AM (#32126692)
> First, if anyone was doing anything for 12 hours a day, it's probably an issue.

A good yardstick, but it depends on the activity. 12 hours on SnapChat daily => probably excessive. There are days when I have hiked 12 hours a day (definitely excessive!). The difficulty with a phone is the myriad uses a phone has in our lives. GPS-mapping (not just for driving, cycling or walking, but for hiking too - e.g. alltrails.com), star-gazing/charting at night, creative writing, recording/listening to music, programming (yeah using ssh apps), photography, video, email, texting, audiobooks (as a traveling executive, I often drive 5+ hours using G-Maps, while I am listening to an audiobook, while I get interrupted with dozens of phone calls), health/fitness/workout monitoring, sleep apps, games, banking/finance/credit, monitoring my home/AirBnB's etc, boarding passes, Uber, shopping, way too many hours on HN, you get the idea.

As has been said, we are cybernetic organisms, and the mobile phone is an extension of us (soon one day inside us). Whether we use it to enrich the diversity of our lives or to dumb-down and become mono-active, I think that is the issue.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by nemo44x on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:55AM (#32126347)
> Personally I think we're playing a high price for mobile phones.

I do sometimes wonder if Steve Jobs was the antichrist or devil, or whatever. Introduced the revolutionary smart phone complete with an icon of forbidden fruit with a bite taken from it. And then disappeared from Earth shortly after.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by fritztastic on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:39AM (#32126653)
According to Western European culture, sure. Apparently people started thinking of it as an apple because of a choice in translation.

Realistically, scholars believe the forbidden fruit referred to is a pomegranate- because geographically it makes more sense. Apples originally come from the region around Kazakhstan- much further East than where the garden of Eden was supposedly located.

Some people also think it was a fig. Ultimately the way it was originally written, it's impossible to know for sure but it's unlikely that it was an apple.

I don't know about the choice for logo and intent behind the symbol, but I find the geographic origins of plants interesting.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by nemo44x on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:05AM (#32126854)
In terms of intent, the designer has spoken about this. One story is the forbidden fruit. Another is that Alan Turing killed himself by taking a bite from a cyanide laced apple. The original rainbow logo showing support for gay people.

But he says none of these are true. The logo was an apple because that’s the company name and a bite was taken out of it to make it clear it’s not a cherry. The rainbow colors were because they shipped color graphics with the Apple ][ which was rare for the time.

They also proposed a logo without a bite taken out and solid color and metallic versions of the logo that were used in certain marketing.

https://creativebits.org/interview/interview_rob_janoff_desi...

But then if Steve was the devil then this is good cover.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by skeeter2020 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:53AM (#32126765)
thanks for the interesting background info, and I really like the OP's (devilish in it's own sense) interpretation. My understanding is that the choice of an apple was nothing more than the prevalence of orchards in the area when they started. Of course if Jobs WAS the devil, the first requirement would be plausible deniability...
Re:The high price we pay for social media by germinalphrase on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:03AM (#32126838)
Apples are neither “a” forbidden fruit nor “the” Biblical forbidden fruit (it’s unnamed).

Jobs was a self proclaimed fruitarian - so choosing a fruit seems straightforward.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by 29083011397778 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:41PM (#32128367)
Choosing "Apple" was because he wanted to be ahead of his former employer in the phone book [0].

[0] https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2011/12/apple...

Re:The high price we pay for social media by isleyaardvark on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:56AM (#32126789)
Somewhat ironic that Jobs limited his kids' screen times.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by cloutchaser on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:10AM (#32126443)
I’m surprised this is the first time I’ve heard this, at least the symbolic part of the bitten apple is pretty wierd.

Did anyone ever talk about this seriously?

Re:The high price we pay for social media by Karellen on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:15AM (#32126490)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple_Inc.#Logo

Note that the logo was introduced in 1976, more than 30 years before the introduction of the iPhone.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by cloutchaser on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:19AM (#32126516)
Ok, but it’s still really strange symbolism to pick.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by Gare on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:13AM (#32126932)
The first logo was Newton with an apple over his head.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/fa/Apple_fi...

And the bite was supposedly put in to identify the simplified logo as an apple, people thought it was a cherry.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by formerkrogemp on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:34AM (#32126619)
Others have pointed this our before. It's strange how few people notice or know however.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by nonrandomstring on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:09AM (#32126428)
The price we pay is different according to viewpoint/scale.

Individual impacts are to eyesight, posture, mental health, concentration, cardio-vascular fitness and so on.

Interpersonal relationships are affected in a different way, dissolving the bonds of meaningful friendship and family ties.

At the societal level we experience unrest, radicalisition, corrosion of democracy and shared values.

I've tried to document the evolution and psychology of this in Digital Vegan [1]. Many supporting papers can be found here in the "ledger of digital harms" [2]

[1] https://digitalvegan.net

[2] https://ledger.humanetech.com/

Re:The high price we pay for social media by nabla9 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:02AM (#32126384)
Great points.

Earlier generations grew up in the front of television (or PC) but even if you spend 3-6 hours per day watching television, once you are not in front of it, you are separated.

Now people are experiencing every moment in their life with a mobile phone.

Some people feel "walking naked" -type anxiety without a phone even for a short term. Just recently I saw a person forgetting to take the phone into a trip to a nearby shop (20-30 minute trip max). They turn around at 5 minute point instead of going trough the trip without a phone.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by lapcat on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:13AM (#32126480)
> Some people feel "walking naked" -type anxiety without a phone even for a short term.

I've started to take long walks deliberately without my smartphone, and it feels very liberating. I had always brought it along "just in case", but no case has ever actually arisen. I realized that it was just fear, and before smartphones were ubiquitous, I used to go around all the time without one and without fear. I enjoy having that feeling again.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by nradov on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:07AM (#32126878)
For some people a smart watch with LTE connectivity can be a useful middle ground. The screen is too small to really use for anything interactive, but you can still call for help in an emergency.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by lapcat on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:01AM (#32127410)
This would defeat the purpose of leaving the smartphone at home, which is to not live in fear of an unlikely emergency.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by nradov on Sunday July 17, 2022 @06:09PM (#32131911)
There's a difference between living in fear versus taking prudent precautions. I've never had a fire in my house and I'm not particularly afraid of fires, but I keep fire extinguishers on hand. I do a lot of running and cycling, and I've had to use my cell phone to call emergency services several times to assist others.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by lapcat on Sunday July 17, 2022 @07:27PM (#32132595)
> I've never had a fire in my house and I'm not particularly afraid of fires, but I keep fire extinguishers on hand.

But you don't carry a fire extinguisher around with you everywhere you go, which would be the analogy here.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jstarfish on Monday July 18, 2022 @12:25AM (#32134648)
I get that feeling despite hating phones.

My own reason is that phones have replaced keys and wallets in some cases.

I don't give a shit what people are saying online, but I'm going to be pissed if I'm out and about and a transaction is declined because the bank app is fraud-prompting me.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by fairity on Sunday July 17, 2022 @04:27PM (#32130887)
> Living a life, a real life, with real relationships and real sunsets and real beaches - is an enormous privilege. Many of us are wasting it. Leave your phone at home, and truly live

You seem to have found a mode of life that's been deeply satisfying, which is great to hear. However, you now seem to want to impose your 'how' on others. If your goal is to help others, they'll be much more receptive if you focus on the 'why' instead of 'how'.

If you inspect the reasons 'why' your life has been so satisfying, you'll arrive at a set of values that you can share with your son & his friends. Then, they can take these values and figure out 'how' to achieve them given the new world they're growing up in.

Using this approach, I think you may be surprised that there are a myriad of approaches to achieve your values in the 'digital' world as well as the 'real' world. And, as such, there are many ways of 'truly living' in addition to yours.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by paulryanrogers on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:21AM (#32126529)
This comes off as judgemental and condescending. I'm not much younger and came of age just before PDAs and smartphones changed the world. My life was and is full of other activities, yet I now use the phone hours per day. And it is an enhancement in most every way: language translation (bilingual household), security (MFA and a deterant when out late alone), news, fact checking, broader social network (albeit some "only" virtual), communication with distant friends and family, learning home improvement, a safe escape when feeling overwhelmed by extroverts, etc.

Past generations were probably pearl clutching over people with their faces in a book or newspaper "constantly". "Get back to working in the factory!" 12h per day until you die. "Look up at this beautiful scenery on our hike!" Same as the past 3 hours of scenery. Of course the solution is to stigmatize these worthless book worms! /s

Cut the kids some slack, they are exploring both a physical and virtual world. The former of which they often have little control or freedom. (Depending on parents, peers, and local culture.)

My hope is smart glasses or contacts will become more capable and accepted. Then we can enjoy the benefits and the "real" world together more seamlessly. Isn't that what all tools are for, to enhance our lives?

Re:The high price we pay for social media by abhaynayar on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:49AM (#32126726)
I didn't feel it was judgemental or condescending at all. Can you quote exactly what about it felt that way to you?

As for the generational differences, I agree to some extent. But we can't stop thinking about it at that point... Just because older generations complain about newer generations, doesn't mean we stop thinking about non generational factors.

These technologies have taken over the world in the last few decades. Our brains have been the same for at least 100,000 years. We need to be more vigilant about the negative effects of disruptive and exponentially growing technologies.

It's good to wield the positive side of technology (translation, security, facts, communication). But that's not the problem. The problem is companies who are creating algorithms that can easily overpower our human brain. Their incentives are not aligned with the mental health and well-being of society.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by skeeter2020 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:59AM (#32126811)
Here's the difference though: you take exception and list a diverse set of uses where your phone helps. That doesn't reflect the relatity of how people use their phones though; it's a collection of apps around social media and an evolving selection of ad-supported, click-to-win games with short lifetimes. Your inclusion of "fact checking" is actually kind of funny, as the limited sources used by almost everyone could be termed more "opinion entrenching".

>> Cut the kids some slack, they are exploring both a physical and virtual world

If this was true I wouldn't have a lot of valid objections but coming out of 2 years of Covid distancing it's just not reality.

>> Isn't that what all tools are for, to enhance our lives?

That's what you want from them, but is that what social networks are delivering?

Re:The high price we pay for social media by cloutchaser on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:02AM (#32126387)
> First, if anyone was doing anything for 12 hours a day, it's probably an issue. If my kids played football for 12 hours a day, or made Lego, or cooked, I'd be concerned.

But in a way using your phone is not the same activity for 12 hours. You could be doing multiple different things from gaming to social media to educational videos. So I don’t think this is a fair comparison.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by acdha on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:10AM (#32126450)
This is somewhat true but at least from an ergonomic standpoint it’s the same - which matters a lot for things like RSI or vision – and it’s often also the same from the perspective of chasing that “new stuff” stimulus. It’s not really healthy if you’re switching from the average phone game to IG/TikTok and back.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by winternett on Sunday July 17, 2022 @12:24PM (#32128190)
It's mobile phone manufacturers and OS developers that make devices that collect our data and grant access to that information to apps. The biggest point where data collection needs to be properly addressed is at this level. If there is no Lidar feature accessible in a phone, then TikTok can't get information on how many people are sitting in your living room with you.

The problem is that people are not educating themselves, paying attention to proper technology issues, and taking the right actions because they're so busy trying to make personal profit... The "giant social media monopoly" ship is sinking fast, everyone is trying to loot the gold stored in the ship's hull, not realizing that that's exactly the extra weight that will also sink their escape boat.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by jasonladuke0311 on Sunday July 17, 2022 @06:16PM (#32131984)
> Secondly, it strikes me as "out there in the world" that this is the biggest issue. To me, as a 50 year old man, it's bloody weird anyone spending this much time online, but to be outdoors, or at a bar, or a restaurant with your partner, or looking after your kids, or looking at a sunset, or on the beach - and be constantly in your phone - this is insane.

This is one of the few things I’m confident I’m doing well as a dad and husband. We don’t use our phones when out to dinner or doing family activities. I don’t set “rules” about it; we just have a shared understanding as a family that these times should be spent together, not off in the clouds.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by mellavora on Sunday July 17, 2022 @11:27AM (#32127635)
I try to observe a computer/smartphone sabbath from friday evening to saturday evening. It is hard, because I keep thinking of things I could do on my computer. It has eaten that much of my life.

The forced abstinence is an eye-opener.

Re:The high price we pay for social media by liberia on Sunday July 17, 2022 @09:05AM (#32126409)
Rather than cut out social media entirely it’s worth taking a break from it and then rejoining the fray once you’re calm and have enjoyed the more simple things in life (Sunsets, swimming in lakes, playing with your dog etc). Just like any drug, social media has a law of diminishing returns. There’s even people doing ‘dopamine starving’ to address their addictions. Worth trying.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by bumby on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:32AM (#32126225)
I would be curious if those downvoting this could elaborate on their disagreement to help foster conversation
Re:The high price we pay for social media by dmje on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:36AM (#32126241)
Me too. Hilariously I got the first downvote about 10 seconds after posting it, not enough time for anyone to actually read my thoughts.. :-)
Re:The high price we pay for social media by darkerside on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:46AM (#32126303)
The people who are on their phones 24/7 will read this as a dig. They're not the largest group, but statistically, they are most likely to get the first votes in on your comment.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by indymike on Sunday July 17, 2022 @08:50AM (#32126321)
It's a very good comment. Those early downvotes, when they happen to me seem to be out of whack - they are too fast to have read the comment, and often the comment isn't controversial, inaccurate, or negative in any way.
Re:The high price we pay for social media by ren_engineer on Sunday July 17, 2022 @10:18AM (#32126995)
social media is a supernormal stimulus, our brains didn't adapted to deal with it or the companies that are constantly iterating to make it more addictive

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Supernormal_stimulus

it isn't much different from some of the crazy increases in potency of actual drugs and the negative impacts on society are similar

>He's now at an age where I have no agency over him - he's an adult in 6 months and he's got to figure out his own way

I'm close to your kids age and I think this is a bad mindset, young adults still need guidance. You have an obligation to give advice even if it makes him mad. Unless he is completely financially independent you are owed some respect