It reminds me of something a friend told me about a youtuber called mister beast(or something); how in an interview he said he was practically raised with youtube as his sole life, spend all waking hours thinking "what would buzz on YouTube?" and not just him, he would talk about this with his fellow content creator, like they were obsessed.
Afaik the guy is doing really well. Now replace "YouTube" with whatever programming language you mentioned and you can see a similar story.
And the other side of your coin "glued in front of PC" is people like me who spent 16h a day of my Highschool year playing online games that lead to absolutely nothing except maybe a little bit better English knowledge.
When you're looking at kids glued to the phone, you're looking at how the generation above me/us looked at me,and not you. And I think I'm in the majority of people that was glued in front of the PC; Nothing "productive" really came out of it
I understand what you're trying to say about this generational view of youngsters being into the latest fad tech not being viewed as productive by the older people in their lives. I think mr. beast is an awful example. You picked one of the most successful and well known youtubers. For every one of him, there are millions of unsuccessful individuals with youtube channels or other social media "jobs." Survivorship bias is real here. The income distribution is extremely top heavy and unfair.
> When you're looking at kids glued to the phone, you're looking at how the generation above me/us looked at me,and not you. And I think I'm in the majority of people that was glued in front of the PC; Nothing "productive" really came out of it.
You're right that for the most part nothing productive comes from consuming entertainment as such for the vast majority of consumers of social media, especially when young. I'm still unsure of where I stand on this issue, but I'm certainly more cognizant of the costs of social media and so forth than the benefits.
He has like 100M subscribers and 16.5 billion views and counting. So yep, doing "OK". It's very, VERY dangerous to look at the peak of a mountain and try to extrapolate ANYTHING from a single data point. Comparing the history & outcome of someone like this with your personal experience isn't likely to be very valuable, but nothing you've presented discredits that neither of these approaches are likely to lead to enjoyable, fulfilling lives.
>spending time on YouTube can lead to being an e-celebrity
Two differences are that of those is a casino, and it's probably not the healthiest or most sustainable path for most people.
>When you're looking at kids glued to the phone, you're looking at how the generation above me/us looked at me,and not you. And I think I'm in the majority of people that was glued in front of the PC; Nothing "productive" really came out of it
The argument here is that the PC offers an onramp for some percentage of people to something really good, while the phone intrinsically doesn't. Or, if it does, it's an onramp to being an influencer. Nuff said. :p
That isn't really the point... but it is easy to read that out of my comment. The point is the devices don't offer the possibilities that a PC did. The only thing you can really create efficiently on a phone are short messages, photos and videos.
> And the other side of your coin "glued in front of PC" is people like me who spent 16h a day of my Highschool year playing online games that lead to absolutely nothing except maybe a little bit better English knowledge.
I probably did that more than a little bit as well ;-) and I do not reget a minute of it.
Personally for me making YouTube videos is very hard, much harder than programming. I hate making them and I hate watching them just as much. But I'm an outlier and I realize that.
I agree strongly with the rest of your post, but then you highlight the two biggest offending aspects of our current society: (1) Everyone is so busy capturing and sharing "memories" they're not actually experiencing them in the first place, (2) When we're trying to get somewhere we don't even look up to ask where are we right now IN RELATION to where we'd like to go before pulling out our device. The second is particularly odd to me, as my father (now in his 70's) did all sorts of adventure travelling as I was growing up with nothing more than paper maps and I now watch him routinely ask for gps directions to places he's been dozens of times. It makes me sad.
Do we really enjoy the moment as well when grabbing everything. I doubt it.
Normal non pro photographs human beings have very little energy to organize/tag/process their pictures, they mostly lie forgotten until google photos remember them of those moments, more often than not showcasing the ugiest badly framed photos.
The former is a good way to relive any experience. It's literally training data for the photographer to reconstruct their own memories.
The latter group will never have reason to look at the pictures they took. There is a lack of connection.
When in the field I rarely looked at a map to see where I was going. I never carried a compass.
Today I can get satellite photos on the internet, (quality? meh. some of the overflight photos were stereo. I suppose I could pay) but "up and down are forever".
Didn't you get pushback from that from your parents or family?
In the 80s spending so much time on the computer was much more 'weird' than spending as much time on a phone is now.
Remember people calling us nerds and saying we'd get square eyes? I don't hear anyone complaining about this in regards to mobiles now.
No, my parents were ok with it as long as I took care of the lawn (my Dad had MS and couldn't chase the mower) and didn't flunk out of high school. I also got a job programming at age 16 (writing medical diagnostic aids), and so they saw me making very good money for a 16 year old.
> In the 80s spending so much time on the computer was much more 'weird' than spending as much time on a phone is now.
I really don't have a good reference on what normal was. I spent a lot of time with the computer, put a lot of miles on training for cycling, and played soccer and went to school in between. I just did my thing, and didn't really worry about it.
Well it was kinda normal for nerds. But nerds were not really 'normal' (though very common anyhow!). I think for people born later it's hard to understand since IT is now taken in much higher regard. I mean if I tell people I'm in IT/Cybersec at a meetup they're usually like "wow cool" which exactly the opposite of what would happen in the 80s :D You'd be viewed as a total dork wasting their time.
You don't sound like a typical nerd though. Most of my nerd friends (and certainly myself) would not do any kind of sports. Especially teamsports.
I think the definition of a nerd is to be atypical. I'm glad it's celebrated now, as it should be.
You have a great point here.
Thinking about this. When I was young I spend an unnatural, lot of time in front of screens. Here is what I did: I learned BASIC, REXX, C, x86 assembler, Pascal, and Prolog. I learned to make software for a home comuputer, then for a real PC. It was productive, made money for me, and helped me develop a skillset that has resulted in six companies created, a couple hundred people having jobs, and a decent life for my family. I have exactly zero regrets for spending time with the computer.
What if the device was a phone? You can't even create software for a mobile phone with the phone. I guess I would have consumed a lot of content, and posted a lot of videos. Maybe I'd be able to build an audience, and make some cash from my gofundme or patreon. Maybe.
> Living a life, a real life, with real relationships and real sunsets and real beaches - is an enormous privilege. Many of us are wasting it. Life is short. Leave your phone at home, and truly live it.
This is really great advice. Or at least delete all the distraction as a service apps. The best feature on a phone is the camera and maps app. One is for capturing and sharing memories, and the other is for finding your way to friends and adventure to make those memories.