There really is something about it being online that makes this terrible. I've never seen in real life debate that things deteriorated to what one reads regularly online.
With online text, I feel like each party only try to defend their own point and will not meeting concussion. On online forum, it's just a waste of time.
HN appears, to me, as one shining light in the darkness. Conversations here remain civil. I have just deleted my Twitter account for that very reason. If they had an army of Dangs they might be able to moderate to the degree that HN does. However I don't think Dangs scale.
One of my favorite online communities back in its heyday was somethingawful. You had to make a one-time token payment of a few bucks to be able to post, and they'd triumphantly ban you at the first or (usually) second hint of obnoxiousness.
This is specifically prevalent in the financial information space. Last week the news broke that the Twitter deal won't close.
Naturally, everyone who thinks of themselves as relevant needed to comment on it (myself included) Some people with valuable information others with less valuable information.
On Twitter / Stocktwits / Discord / Telegram commentary and rebuttal merge which makes it really hard to follow the threads.
On WSJ, Seeking Alpha, etc, the UGC articles are very long and don't encourage a proper discourse. The reason WSB on Reddit was so successful (14M users) was the simple fact that they encourage an online discussion that is weighted by quality.
Worse than that: it's very close to universal on some sites, like Twitter.
> They assume that everyone is talking in bad faith, probably to justify their own bad faith.
Yep, it's a positive feedback loop.
Bad faith is the driver. It's probably a majority of people now who respond in bad faith. They assume that everyone is talking in bad faith, probably to justify their own bad faith. Maybe it represents a broader shift in attitudes. That's also why humor and sarcasm are not tolerated, because people assume bad faith behind it. This was markedly different in the 90s and 00s where any joke was allowed and the intent was always assumed to be humor.