Re:I tend to avoid reading social news comments
by jsemrau on Sunday July 10, 2022 @07:32AM
(#32043751)
There is a big difference between rebuttals by an expert for a post and general commentary.
This is specifically prevalent in the financial information space. Last week the news broke that the Twitter deal won't close.
Naturally, everyone who thinks of themselves as relevant needed to comment on it (myself included) Some people with valuable information others with less valuable information.
On Twitter / Stocktwits / Discord / Telegram commentary and rebuttal merge which makes it really hard to follow the threads.
On WSJ, Seeking Alpha, etc, the UGC articles are very long and don't encourage a proper discourse.
The reason WSB on Reddit was so successful (14M users) was the simple fact that they encourage an online discussion that is weighted by quality.
Re:I tend to avoid reading social news comments
by jsemrau on Sunday July 10, 2022 @09:13AM
(#32044412)
The basic functionality of Reddit includes upvotes and downvotes that provide a ranking which arguably can be seen to measure quality.
Second, quality lies in the eye of the beholder. ;-)
This is specifically prevalent in the financial information space. Last week the news broke that the Twitter deal won't close.
Naturally, everyone who thinks of themselves as relevant needed to comment on it (myself included) Some people with valuable information others with less valuable information.
On Twitter / Stocktwits / Discord / Telegram commentary and rebuttal merge which makes it really hard to follow the threads.
On WSJ, Seeking Alpha, etc, the UGC articles are very long and don't encourage a proper discourse. The reason WSB on Reddit was so successful (14M users) was the simple fact that they encourage an online discussion that is weighted by quality.