Ended up switching to these guys in Melbourne, never looked back: https://pinpayments.com
Porn is legal, and should not be discriminated against, but that's beside the point. The business in question was providing 100% legal services for adults, but nothing to do with either porn or prostitution.
Are you saying it is ok to discriminate against a business just because their services are oriented towards adults and not children? If that is the case, then Stripe should also discriminate against "straight" bars and pubs, which is not the case.
When I lodged the report (in person at the police station), I was able to find the courier job on Airtasker and provide the police with the phone number of an exec at Airtasker that I reached out to, and with the job ID and the IP address of the organiser who was using card fraud (from Stripe). They took the case straight away because there was a strong witness (the courier) and a strong lead on the organiser due to building IP trace from the telco (a young kid living in their parents basement).
It took them only about 2 weeks to get a permit to raid. The IP trace was essential because they had the courier deliver it to a fake address in a nearby suburb, where they impersonated the householder.
If you were selling high dollar electronic items or similar online, in my opinion it would be reckless to not implement that as a firm policy, which is fairly standard with high fraud risk vendors such as for photography equipment.
As a purchaser, I know that I've been on the customer side of this many times, ensuring that whatever small, high value electronic thing that I was purchasing from a certain vendor was being shipped to the address which is also set up for my bank and credit card bill.
Payment providers generally have heuristics to mark transactions as successful when there’s a high chance they’ve been finalized, but unfortunately this sometimes fails. In theory the final arbiter is the court system, but obviously that also has its limitations, as you encountered.
TLDR: It’s annoying, but I’m not sure any other provider would have actually done any better here.
So I gave away the goods thinking everything was good to go.
When it bounced, I rang up and complained and they did nothing, just shrugged it off.
Story ends like this though: caught the thief with the Stripe IP audit log, police raided his house, found hundreds of other items but I never managed to recoup the loss, because mine was gone. I still think that it was Stripes fault because the UX on the email (even the green banner) made it seem like everything was good to go.
(I routinely tell everyone to avoid Stripe now and go with PayPal, someone from Stripe feel free to reach out and change my mind ..)