News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by cs702 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:42AM (#32013971)
The private equity industry -- excluding VC, which represents a small fraction of total capital raised -- relies extensively on debt (LBOs, debt-financed infrastructure deals, debt-financed real estate deals, etc.), i.e., borrowing to juice returns. It's not a coincidence that the industry was born in the 1980's, when interest rates in the US began declining, after the Fed had increased them to combat high inflation in the 1970's. Ever since, for four decades now, interest rates have only declined and declined, in fits and starts, making life easier and easier for borrowers of all kinds:

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=RveY

Many private equity deals that arguably were economically viable when the 10-year treasury's annual yield was ~0.6%, less than a year ago, may not be viable now that the 10-year treasury's annual yield is ~3%, and are likely to suffer financial distress if interest rates rise further -- say, 10-year treasury yields of ~5%, ~6%, or more. If that sounds high, keep in mind that the last time the Fed had to deal with high inflation, in the 1970's, the 10-year treasury yield rose to a peak of ~16%!

Over the same past four decades, valuation multiples have only risen and risen, in fits and starts, making life easier and easier for those who make money by buying businesses, holding them for a while, and selling them down the road. For example, here's the ratio of US stock market capitalization to the size of the US economy (GDP):

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/DDDM01USA156NWDB

The rise in valuation multiples over the past four decades makes sense, given that the net present value of any business is inversely proportional to the discount rate used to value its future profits, and discount rates are equal to prevailing long-term treasury rates plus a premium. If interest rates continue to rise, valuation multiples are bound to decline too.

--

EDITS: Changed language in response to comments below so it better reflects what I meant to write in the first place.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by balderdash on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:01AM (#32014209)
Most LBOs aren’t really that interest rate sensitive, let’s say you buy a company for $100m dollars 12x EBITDA, and 15x unlevered free cash flow ($7m), you would have put $50m of non amort. debt in the business @ 3%, so had a $1.5m interest payment. Lets say that doubles to $3m, earnings would have to be cut in half to not be able to service debt…
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by cs702 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:20AM (#32014455)
[EDIT: the data in this paragraph is WRONG! See comment below.] 12x EBITDA? Unlikely. According to the article, the average valuation multiple for US deals to take firms private is 19.3x EBITDA.

A 3% rate for a leveraged entity? Unlikely. Current high-yield spreads are in the neighborhood of 500-600bp, on top of treasury rates.

So, you'd need 60% more debt (19.3/12) to keep the same capital structure [EDIT: this last sentence is WRONG! The amount of debt needed would be the same, because the correct EV/EBITDA multiple is 12.3x. See comment below.], and the debt would be 2-3x more expensive, leaving much less margin for a downside scenario, say, in the event of a prolonged recession, rising rates, and/or declining valuation multiples. If all three of those things happen at the same time, things could get... ugly.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by mbesto on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:29AM (#32014563)
> According to the article, the average valuation multiple for US deals to take firms private is 19.3x EBITDA.

That's on a PIPE, which is a small subsection of all PE buyouts. Average multiples for ALL buyouts is 12.3x in NA:

Average buyout multiples in 2021 rose 9% to 12.3x in North America, and, despite a slight decline, still stood at a lofty 11.9x in Europe (see Figure 14).

https://www.bain.com/globalassets/noindex/2022/bain_report_g...

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by cs702 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:32AM (#32014616)
You're absolutely right. In haste, I misread the data. I updated my comment to indicate I was wrong about this. Thank you!
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by mbesto on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:41AM (#32014716)
All good! It's a total nuance to this space so I can understand if someone got it wrong anyway.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by balderdash on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:23PM (#32017523)
With regards to your comment on the rates, most LBOs are done with floating rate loans/ bank loans/levers loans, as such they trade at a spread over libor/sofr, which chops ~3% off your interest rate…
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by abirch on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:10AM (#32014323)
Correct. Many of the large private equity companies were started in the 1980's when the rates were significantly higher than they are today.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by engineeringwoke on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:40AM (#32014708)
It trashes your IRR though. Now what does the sponsor make?
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by formercoder on Thursday July 07, 2022 @11:14AM (#32015141)
IRRs have been waning the last few years anyway, to the point folks will look at 12.5%. There is a lot of money chasing PE allocations. Of course top quartile funds will just pull further away from the pack.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by balderdash on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:59PM (#32016460)
Not really, that rule of thumb is that if you can grow EBITDA at higher percentage than the EBITDA multiple you bought at, thing will just work out fine (e.g. buy at 20x need 20% cagr on earning over the next 5 years)
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by engineeringwoke on Thursday July 07, 2022 @01:29PM (#32016843)
There was a recent Economist article that said that 6% of the performance in PE is driven by earnings growth. It’s a Ponzi scheme built on debt because PE has so much money that they just trade around companies at higher multiples. Lol imagine believing in synergies, or that the trash you guys make is somewhat legitimate at all. Cutting shit to the bone and sending it to the next guy isn’t good business.

Enjoy the money and the carried interest loophole while it lasts. Community Health Systems? Dex Media? I’m not one of the fools that will buy it. Maybe it helps you sleep at night or whatever but if rates continue to spike, all the trash adjusted EBITDA nonsense will all die and you guys will lose your shirts.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by blabberwocky on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:08AM (#32014300)
LBOs haven’t been the defining structure of PE for a while now, though leverage is still a key ingredient. The massive growth of the “PE industry” over the last decade has really been on the credit side (which does include equity plays, e.g., in real assets and distressed debt that leads to equity positions) despite the low interest rate environment.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by paganel on Thursday July 07, 2022 @11:19AM (#32015201)
Do you happen to know if “private credit” (I don’t know if that is the actual correct term) is a big part of PE’s investments? I stumbled upon mentions of it more and more during the last 2 years (I’d say) and it kind of gave me some “this can’t be structurally right”-vibes. Or maybe that is just a very small market, comparatively speaking, and I’m talking bs, hence my question.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by mbesto on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:26PM (#32016030)
It's absolutely part of the investment structure. It's no different from buying a house that you would rent out for yield. If your yield outpaces the costs (maintenance, taxes, utilities, AND the mortgage rate) then you are basically have an arbitrage. This is no different from what PE does and is why they typically leverage ~50% of the acquisition price.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by clairity on Thursday July 07, 2022 @03:48PM (#32018474)
to nitpick, neither yield outpacing costs nor PE is arbitrage. arbitrage is structurally zero-risk, while those other cases have relatively small but non-zero risk, since yield, costs, interest rates, regulations, etc. can change over the lifetime of the deal. arbitrage generally happens due to a mispricing and an opportunity to buy and sell at (approximately) the same time.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by mbesto on Monday July 11, 2022 @05:32PM (#32062177)
Fair point.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by blabberwocky on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:21PM (#32015960)
Yes, it’s now a major business for the big PE firms (which today are really diversified investment managers) with AUMs that can significantly exceed that of (traditional) corporate PE. But its their credit vehicles that invest in credit. So their corporate PE funds might do buyouts or growth equity or whatever, but won’t generally be direct-lending or buying securitized debt.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by cs702 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:11AM (#32014331)
Thanks! Yes. I updated my comment.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by snake_doc on Thursday July 07, 2022 @09:56AM (#32014154)
> The private equity industry -- excluding VC, which represents a tiny share of total capital raised -- relies extensively on leveraged buyouts (LBOs), i.e., borrowing to juice returns.

In 2021, buyout was ~30% PE funds raised, VC was ~10%, growth was ~10%. “Tiny” is not true anymore. https://www.bain.com/insights/private-equity-market-in-2021-...

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by cs702 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:00AM (#32014199)
Thanks. Yes. I changed "tiny share" to "small fraction," and noted that the industry is much more than LBOs. Note that many other kinds of PE deals -- e.g., infrastructure, real estate, distressed secondary investments -- are done with lots of leverage too.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by pirate787 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @04:08PM (#32018692)
Regulatory and tax changes in the 1980s created private equity. Declining interest rates juiced it, as has computerization, but the fundamental change was Reagan's policy of financial deregulation and reducing capital gains and marginal rates so that entrepreneurs had more money to invest.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by missedthecue on Thursday July 07, 2022 @04:34PM (#32018978)
What specific regulatory changes occurred in the 1980s that created PE? KKR, a pioneer of the industry, was started in the '70s and they did a landmark $380 million deal in 1979, which is billions in today's money.

The first LBO was of Orkin Pest Control in 1964 and there were about a half dozen other LBOs in the 60's.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by spamizbad on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:06AM (#32014282)
I don't think LBOs are that sensitive to interest rates are they? There was a ton of them in the 1980s when rates were still in the double digits.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by swader999 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:10AM (#32014317)
Interest rate trends are more of a factor.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by jollybean on Thursday July 07, 2022 @10:26AM (#32014523)
So your summary point applies irrespective of whether companies are leveraged with debt or not. Cost of Capital is rising across the board.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by ezekiel11 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:01PM (#32015714)
what does this mean if your company is acquired and run by a private equity? will the rising fed rate mean that they are looking to cut out the highest salaries? am I better off not takin a higher salary because that might paint a red target on myself?
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by jollybean on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:20PM (#32017487)
It just means that when entity A wants to buy entity B, they have a general 'cost of capital they use to determine whether or not they want to buy something - and it doesn't matter if it's with cash or debt really.

If you're an employee worrying about stuff, well, I wouldn't unless you're the CEO and have the power to make huge investments ...

If you are a very profitable company, i.e. 'cash cow' without a lot of debt, then private equity may be interested in buying your company with heavy borrowing, using the profits to pay for the debt.

Another way to look at it is, the company is not taking enough risk given the price of cash available in the market.

One thing a company might want to do is take on debt and extend the business.

If it's a private company with strong board control, and the shareholders don't want to sell, well, then you don't have to worry.

As for companies that do get acquired, this notion that PE just wants to screw things up short term etc. is a bit bullshit. Burger King was acquired by that famous Brazilian outfit, and they turned the company around. In that case, probably some execs got fired to clear the path for the new vision, but it will vary case by case. The company might get split up into components. Maybe there is a garbage part of the company dragging on revenues. Maybe that supposedly crappy part of the company is actually more 'long term' and killing R&D would hurt the company, but that's surprisingly hard to establish. A lot of R&D is a waste.

With rising interest rates, debt becomes more expensive, and companies have less to worry about getting bought out like this - of course, companies that are carrying debt have a greater burden.

In summary, companies probably need to adjust a bit given interest rates. This is where a good CFO comes in.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by guiriduro on Thursday July 07, 2022 @03:14PM (#32018067)
> A lot of R&D is a waste.

If its speculative, then its either going to deliver a multiple of its investment, or just be a cost, but one that may be worth it to explore an opportunity. I doubt that R&D which proves no viable product is feasible, or no market exists, is more wasteful than allowing a business to wither on aging uncompetitive product lines for want of proper R&D.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by ezekiel11 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @05:02PM (#32019369)
thanks I feel good now, I almost turned down a 4-bagger offer until I read your comment, but I am a bit wary, the new CFO is a bit of an unknown. am I going to show up on his radar now? I feel like the business can't run without what I built and my maintenance, in-depth knowledge of the critical business processes.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by jollybean on Thursday July 07, 2022 @05:23PM (#32019627)
Oh Jesus, get an investment banker to help you with these things, don't worry to much about what random 'me' has to say about it. I mean - it's actually not that complicated at the end of the day once someone becomes 'financially literate' but the underlying conditions of any deal matter 100x more than general patter of VC, PE and interest rates. There are people (investment bankers) who do this day and and day out and it's like riding a bicycle to them. Find one who cares enough to know about the details and doesn't push you into a deal because they want the commission, which will be their big incentive. They may just require a fee. Try your peer network out for that.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by simtel20 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @11:27PM (#32022728)
All PE overlords are not the same. Learn what the company's style is and base your decision on how they've handled their other investments. Did they gut it and continue to run a husk? Did they buy companies to change leadership and then sell it to be an "add on" to other PE investments? Did they cut costs, load.on a reasonable amount of debt, take it public again and remain on the board and reap the rewards? All that and more could happen, and you will see your future in what has been done to other acquired companies.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by qwertyuiop_ on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:49PM (#32017781)
Very insightful. Do you work in finance ?
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by M3L0NM4N on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:27PM (#32016041)
Sorry but ain't no way 10 year is going to 5-6%... I'd wager it's very likely peaked at 3.5% and it won't break that again (for this cycle).

Valuation multiples are (relatively) crushed, and I don't think we'll see much more of a multiple compression. What we will see, in both private and public markets, is when businesses adjust their earnings forecasts for the (very likely) impending recession. If you look at Wall Street numbers companies are still forecasting growth pretty every quarter through 2023. Now, that doesn't seem very likely to me.

The deal is, the public markets will overreact as always and sell off harder, but private equity will stay more fairly valued because of it's inherent lack of liquidity (two wrongs make a right).

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by cs702 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:34PM (#32016139)
Oh, I very much hope you're proven right. I mean, almost no one wants higher interest rates -- except the Fed, whose priority is curtailing inflation. I'm not sure anyone can predict rates accurately. Consider that just over a year ago, almost everyone was talking about rates going negative, and look at what actually happened!
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by M3L0NM4N on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:34PM (#32017658)
I mean I speak out if my ass and don't want to pretend to be the sole arbitrator of truth... I'm far from it. But the odds of the benchmark rate going negative were very slim. The Fed didn't need to counter deflation with interest rates when they could just print print print.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by RC_ITR on Thursday July 07, 2022 @12:31PM (#32016094)
>Sorry but ain't no way 10 year is going to 5-6%

People like to say this because of how negative the consequences would be, but that is not a reason why it won't happen.

FWIW, given that it would only affect the US Gov't's new issuances, it's not impossible for them to let it happen.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by M3L0NM4N on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:29PM (#32017604)
I think this administration and the current Fed chair are very averse to the negative consequences, that's why I'm saying it.
Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by RC_ITR on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:34PM (#32017653)
I would love to have heard your thoughts as of 1Q21 on 3.5% using the same inputs.

There were brand-name crossover (I won't call them HFs) folks claiming that we would never see positive inflation ever again (right before that fateful Apr-21 print)

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by M3L0NM4N on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:47PM (#32017761)
You're right, in 1Q21 I probably wouldn't have even guessed 3.5%

But what do you mean by positive inflation though? Like CPI > 0% YoY? Cause that's the craziest thing I've ever heard.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by RC_ITR on Thursday July 07, 2022 @03:26PM (#32018226)
I mean I won't name names, but yeah. Best-fit line on CPI was pointing to below zero within the decade (and a common statement was 'humans see crossing 0 as a major milestone, but numbers do not') and we had already seen deflation more or less happening in Japan [0] Italy [1] Switzerland [2] Greece [3] and other small economies with slow-growing population.

Hell, depending on what you believe about globalization and the nature of capital formation, one can still make a compelling contrarian argument that the developed world will see significant disinflation until we start getting serious about global warming (or global warming gets more serious, which is likely what will come first).

[0]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9J [1]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9M [2]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9S [3] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9W

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by M3L0NM4N on Friday July 08, 2022 @05:52PM (#32027799)
To be fair, none of those 4 countries listed have quite the level of control over their currencies' supplies like the US Federal Reserve.

On the "contrarian argument", I see the case for that having deflationary pressure. However, I believe the Fed will try it's damnedest to prevent deflation, at all costs, for the foreseeable future. I also think the US birth rate will find a floor sometime in the next 20 years, at which point (very hopefully) politicians will have gotten serious about immigration reform.

Re:Private equity may be heading for a fall by ProjectArcturis on Thursday July 07, 2022 @04:10PM (#32018708)
I agree on the 10-year. We might get Fed Funds above 5%, but the market won't expect that to continue for 10 years. (Mathematically, the 10-year yield should equal the expected average Fed Funds rate over the next ten years).

I disagree that valuations have been crushed. You qualified that with a "relatively". We're lower than at the peak of the bubble of course but Shiller PE is still 30, higher than any time other than the dot-com bubble and the current bubble.

Private equity firms will choose not to write down the value of their assets, but the actual transactable prices will probably drop further than public stocks.