People like to say this because of how negative the consequences would be, but that is not a reason why it won't happen.
FWIW, given that it would only affect the US Gov't's new issuances, it's not impossible for them to let it happen.
There were brand-name crossover (I won't call them HFs) folks claiming that we would never see positive inflation ever again (right before that fateful Apr-21 print)
But what do you mean by positive inflation though? Like CPI > 0% YoY? Cause that's the craziest thing I've ever heard.
Hell, depending on what you believe about globalization and the nature of capital formation, one can still make a compelling contrarian argument that the developed world will see significant disinflation until we start getting serious about global warming (or global warming gets more serious, which is likely what will come first).
[0]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9J [1]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9M [2]https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9S [3] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/graph/?g=Rw9W
On the "contrarian argument", I see the case for that having deflationary pressure. However, I believe the Fed will try it's damnedest to prevent deflation, at all costs, for the foreseeable future. I also think the US birth rate will find a floor sometime in the next 20 years, at which point (very hopefully) politicians will have gotten serious about immigration reform.
I disagree that valuations have been crushed. You qualified that with a "relatively". We're lower than at the peak of the bubble of course but Shiller PE is still 30, higher than any time other than the dot-com bubble and the current bubble.
Private equity firms will choose not to write down the value of their assets, but the actual transactable prices will probably drop further than public stocks.
Valuation multiples are (relatively) crushed, and I don't think we'll see much more of a multiple compression. What we will see, in both private and public markets, is when businesses adjust their earnings forecasts for the (very likely) impending recession. If you look at Wall Street numbers companies are still forecasting growth pretty every quarter through 2023. Now, that doesn't seem very likely to me.
The deal is, the public markets will overreact as always and sell off harder, but private equity will stay more fairly valued because of it's inherent lack of liquidity (two wrongs make a right).