News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Making IRC better by c7DJTLrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:30AM (#32000586)
I can understand not wanting to use a proprietary platform for communications about a FOSS project, but why does it have to be IRC? The world is moving on. I like being able to paste code into chat and have it syntax highlighted. I like being able to ping people so that they get a notification on their phone, and likewise, I like people to be able to ping me. Occasionally, I like to send a GIF.

I imagine IRC people will just call all of these distractions. They are in a shrinking minority of people.

Re:Making IRC better by tsujp on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:35AM (#32000660)

    > I like being able to paste code into chat and have it syntax highlighted.
Use a pastebin, there are plenty out there. See: https://paste.sr.ht/ or http://ix.io/ or https://paste.rs/ or https://bpa.st/ or https://gist.github.com/ or https://paste.ubuntu.com/ and many, many more.

Regardless of there being a better tool for syntax highlighting and holding small linkable snippets of code (so that logic doesn't need to be more to download when opening your chat) it also keeps it _out_ of the chat so it's not polluted. People not being able to instantly insert 20 lines of text is a _good_ thing. So, link to the resource don't embed it.

    > I like being able to ping people so that they get a notification on their phone, and likewise, I like people to be able to ping me
In the article you're responding to Drew directly mentions their suggestions for Push Notifications. I don't mean to sound facetious but, did you read this (article) in it's entirety?

    > Occasionally, I like to send a GIF
See above: link to the resource, don't embed it.
Re:Making IRC better by Macha on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:00AM (#32001026)
> People not being able to instantly insert 20 lines of text is a _good_ thing.

Element (Matrix) and Slack will render something like this as 3-5 lines with the expansion option to see all of it. I'm sure discord will eventually do the same too.

This is clearly preferable to using a different application entirely to view the snippet.

It's only IRC where some naive clients expand this out into 20 something messages where this is a problem. And since it's not part of the protocol, you're at the whims of the sender's client for how it's handled, so it's not like you can install a sufficiently smart client to render it how you like in all cases.

I'd also suggest your perspective of how much a problem even that 20 lines of text is is distorted by being in fast moving public chatrooms, like your typical Linux distro channel. In my small team or friends chat, it's perfectly fine

The same also applies to the gif. If this one bothers you, most clients even have the options to disable inline images, so the sender gets to choose. Also it means you just get the image file, and not whatever cruft the popular image host of this 5 year period is doing to monetise.

Image hosts and pastebins also seem more fragile than chat services. I've occasionally gone through old messages that link to pastie or similar and the context is gone.

Re:Making IRC better by zinekeller on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:19AM (#32001380)
> Image hosts and pastebins also seem more fragile than chat services.

Sadly true. While I don't use IRC much, looking at older posts from fora without on-forum file storage and I just see photos roughly like this Imgur example (https://imgur.com/NOnf.jpg). Heck, even older HN posts suffer from the same problem.

Re:Making IRC better by welterde on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @11:23AM (#32002333)
For me it's not really about fast moving rooms or not, but that I want to see a bit of context to what was said. In IRC it's easy to see more than 60 lines back without having to scroll, but all modern alternatives don't have that as a concern at all. Have a few people paste code, liberal use of quoting for messages that are less than 10 lines up (so you are seeing the same message 3 times repeated on the screen), people posting images and you'll be lucky to even have a tiny fraction visible compared to the IRC view.

I can of course see the appeal of all those features, but at least for me it translates into a much worse UX in the end.

Re:Making IRC better by Gigachad on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:56PM (#32009119)
The users still on IRC have their heads stuck in the sand and insist every feature irc is missing is actually a good thing and that the users are wrong.

The users then use other services which have these features and the irc users claim some grand conspiracy to kill open protocols.

Re:Making IRC better by Klonoar on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:05PM (#32008464)
>I'm sure discord will eventually do the same too.

Discord does this already.

Re:Making IRC better by encryptluks2 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:11AM (#32001225)
I think your expectations can easily be alleviated with the right IRC client. Most pastebins and image hosts use some form of markup so that if your IRC client was set to preview those links then it could, or even potentially cache those resources as well.
Re:Making IRC better by Macha on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:56PM (#32003669)
So what is this magical sufficiently smart client that can embed images from all major image hosts, code snippets from all major pastebins and also configures a bouncer for me and also lets me see messages on my phone without missing some as the phone OS killed it's network socket as it put the app to sleep?

I'm no stranger to the IRC protocol (in fact one of my first submissions to this site 12 years ago in 2010 was an introduction to the protocol written as part of building an Android client that was my side project at the time), but I have no interest in putting in the time to make an IRC client with the experience I'd like in 2022, which is clearly a much lower bar on matrix when Element, nheko, Cinny, FluffyChat and Fractal have all managed it.

Re:Making IRC better by MaxLeiter on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @07:46PM (#32008318)
The Lounge will do all the above, minus uploading text to a pastebin (although there’s an open PR to add uploading large text as a file)
Re:Making IRC better by dpifke on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:03PM (#32003804)
https://www.irccloud.com/

(Not affiliated, just a happy user.)

Re:Making IRC better by encryptluks2 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @03:41PM (#32005816)
To be fair IRCCloud is not free nor open source. I believe there are other clients that offer similar functionality but it would be good to have something easy that does this readily available within open source
Re:Making IRC better by bchar on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:03PM (#32003805)
IRCCloud does much of this.
Re:Making IRC better by proto_lambda on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:42AM (#32000765)
> Use a pastebin

That's not a solution, that's a bad and inconvenient workaround. Having to use an external service just to share a couple lines of code is horrible for usability. Funnily enough, its also exactly the thing that IRC users complain about when the matrix bridge converts multi-line messages to links.

Re:Making IRC better by Arnavion on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:38PM (#32003424)
>Funnily enough, its also exactly the thing that IRC users complain about when the matrix bridge converts multi-line messages to links.

I assume you're trying to say this is hypocritical, but it isn't.

The problem with multi-line messages becoming links is that the message is the context of the question. You have to reach for a browser just to read what the other person wanted to say.

Things like images and pastebins are ancillary to the message. You read the text part, decide whether you want to engage with it further, and then if you do you reach for a browser to see the image or pastebin.

Compare:

    <h> hey guys im trying to install blub on ubuntu but it keeps complaining that my splines aren't reticulated. full error here: https://paste.rs/id123
with:

    <h[m]> hey guys... (full message at https://matrix.org/_matrix/media/r0/download/matrix.org/id123)
That last one is an actual example from an OFTC channel that's bridged to Matrix. It truncated at just two words because the original message had a newline after "guys".
Re:Making IRC better by proto_lambda on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @03:25PM (#32005597)
Oh yeah, that's indeed not great. For messages with up to ~5 lines, the bridge actually just sends several messages, but as soon as the message has more lines than that, it only shows the first line as a preview. I could've sworn it actually sends the first couple lines, then a "(full message at ...)" message, but apparently not (anymore) - would probably be worth opening an issue for :)
Re:Making IRC better by Arnavion on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:54PM (#32007304)
The full message was longer than five lines.

There's nothing to file a bug about. The bridge does not (and can not without some AI or heuristics which are both fallible) know where the relevant part of the message ends and the log spew begins, so a message with a one-line description and fifty lines of logs is treated the same as a message with fifty-one lines.

Re:Making IRC better by seanw444 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:48AM (#32000828)
Been using Sourcehut as my main repo host for like a year now, and didn't even know https://paste.sr.ht existed. Very handy. Thanks.
Re:Making IRC better by Tomte on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @11:08AM (#32002107)
"All sourcehut services" on the web site doesn't show all services, alas.

I wonder what else is missing besides paste and chat there.

Edit: but the manual does: https://man.sr.ht/

Re:Making IRC better by JohnHaugeland on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:41AM (#32001716)
is it not weird that you're responding to people who obviously know how to use irc and say "this is why i don't use it anymore" by trying to teach them how to do what everyone already knows how to do?

did you feel that you were offering solutions or something?

Re:Making IRC better by slightwinder on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:56AM (#32000953)
> but why does it have to be IRC?

Because IRC works. It's open, battle tested and has huge support by an endless amount of tools and documentation. There is not much reason to not use if all you wanna do is chat.

> I like being able to paste code into chat and have it syntax highlighted

> I like being able to ping people so that they get a notification on their phone

> Occasionally, I like to send a GIF.

That's the job of your client, not the communication-protocol.

Re:Making IRC better by IshKebab on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @04:17PM (#32006243)
IRC works... if all you want to do is send basic text messages back and forth like it's still 1995.

That's not what I want. I want modern features like text formatting, links, images, file sharing (don't mention DCC), threads, linking to messages, persistent history, and even emoji reactions.

And when I say "modern" I mean "modern relative 1995 which is where IRC proponents are still stuck".

Re:Making IRC better by qu4z-2 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:07PM (#32009187)
Man, I use Mattermost at work and I don't like any of those things. I've managed to hide all the emoji with a CSS rule, inline images are at least collapsed by default, and thankfully no-one is using it for file sharing.

It allows you to disable threads in your UI but that's useless since then you can't reply to people by posting after them since for them it goes to main chat instead of the thread (instead of, y'know, just being the next message).

Also IRC definitely supports links, haha.

Re:Making IRC better by IshKebab on Thursday July 07, 2022 @06:31AM (#32012201)
> I don't like any of those things.

Why though?

> Also IRC definitely supports links, haha.

Oh how do you set the text of a link? Do IRC clients support markdown syntax these days?

Re:Making IRC better by Gigachad on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:59PM (#32009136)
Irc users like being stuck in 1995. What they don’t like is that no one else agrees with this.
Re:Making IRC better by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:59AM (#32001006)
> Because IRC works. It's open, battle tested and has huge support by an endless amount of tools and documentation. There is not much reason to not use if all you wanna do is chat.

How about encryption?

Re:Making IRC better by dijit on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:01AM (#32001043)
TLS is accepted, since you implicitly trust the server when using chatrooms in most cases.

for everything else there are plugins in your client for OMEMO (what signal is based on) and OTR (which is purely session based).

Handling this as a third-party implementation for E2EE is probably the only true way to gain trust anyway. If your provider provides the infrastructure and the client then how can you really trust it?

Re:Making IRC better by rdpintqogeogsaa on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:26AM (#32001491)
Yet there are also large networks like QuakeNet or UnderNet with no TLS anywhere.
Re:Making IRC better by dijit on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:31AM (#32001575)
And you can choose not to be there.

My network forces TLS: https://darkscience.net

Forcing people to "do what you want" is against the spirit of open standards.

Re:Making IRC better by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:03AM (#32001086)
I'm not a security expert, but my humble view is that if you need plugins for really basic functionality, that's a red flag.
Re:Making IRC better by dijit on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:06AM (#32001128)
"E2EE" is not really basic functionality.

I believe it is hard to get right, and only worthwhile on 1:1 communication, it doesn't work well at all on large chat rooms, which is what IRC is.

Regardless, if you don't want E2EE to be handled by a plugin- it is possible to make a client with it baked in.

There is no company that will stop you creating a third-party client unlike slack/discord which are extremely hostile to those endeavors by comparison.

EDIT: If you downvote without replying I'm just going to assume you're ideologically opposed to open standards, because I'm not sure what else I can take from it.

Re:Making IRC better by sdfhdhjdw3 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:50AM (#32001857)
I didn't downvote, and I'm very pro open standards. I just think we can do better than IRC, that's all.
Re:Making IRC better by dijit on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:56AM (#32001935)
Ah, I wasn't accusing you of downvoting, just the community.

You can't downvote direct replies.

---

Speaking about standards; have you looked at IRCv3? Is there anything specific that you feel is not being addressed?

Encryption (to my mind) is better handled outside of the spec itself, just like HTTP vs TLS wrapped HTTP (HTTPS) where the "TLS" has no bearing at all on how HTTP is implemented.

IRCv3 is attempting to address the persistence issues, though many people like the lack of persistence in general.

I don't want to guess at what your concerns are, but more generally; have you looked at the spec?

Re:Making IRC better by numpad0 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @11:50AM (#32002727)
It's not really a green flag when values offered by major commercial alternatives seems like then-experimental client features of existing thing(cf. Twitter, Slack, Discord)
Re:Making IRC better by ThatGeoGuy on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:16PM (#32008524)
There are OTR / OMEMO implementations out there for private queries. For rooms, I'm not convinced that we need full Olm / Megolm style encryption in most wider chats - encrypting messages across 200 individual parties with a magnitude more individual clients is perhaps just yak-shaving.

I even learned today that irssi has an OTR module by default! On Debian systems you have to install irssi-plugin-otr but once you have that and irssi you can just `/load otr` and `/otr init` in a query and that's it, you have E2EE.

This is handled client side though, so I suppose if your clients cannot agree on a protocol you'll be left with nothing. I'm not sure that's really the responsibility of the server though, since we're talking E2E after all.

Re:Making IRC better by astrobe_ on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:47PM (#32003525)
When a platform does not guarantees secrecy you just avoid holding private conversations on it. In my opinion, that's the spirit of IRC, a public place to discuss, because often channels are logged and the logs are accessible for anyone from the web. If not, just about anyone on a channel can do it without your consent. That's also true I think with other "secure" chat platforms because that's the nature of any-to-any chat protocols.

Then you use private messages as a way to talk to someone without disturbing, or away from the noise, of the channel - still not for really private conversations ; for this you don't need encryption, you need end-to-end encryption, but at this point you'd rather use a messaging platform rather than a chat platform.

Re:Making IRC better by ddevault on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:04AM (#32001112)
If IRC were designed today, it would probably be with E2EE. But it's not the end of the world that it wasn't, it just limits what use-cases it's appropriate for. Asking about kernel config options in #linux does not really demand particularly high privacy, and TLS between you and the server is generally sufficient. E2EE is also pretty difficult to get right and dramatically increases the complexity of the system -- Matrix's third-party client ecosystem is hamstrung by this requirement and very poor compared to IRC as a result. E2EE is nice to have and essential for some use-cases, but I don't think that IRC is invalid because it lacks it.
Re:Making IRC better by sdfhdhjdw3 on Thursday July 07, 2022 @02:33PM (#32017647)
So I tried Matrix yesterday for the first time in my life, despite having heard about it in passing for years on end.

It's fucking slow.

Re:Making IRC better by Idesmi on Friday July 08, 2022 @06:49AM (#32025404)
The matrix.org server is slow.
Re:Making IRC better by 300bps on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:19AM (#32001375)
I haven't heard of a widely-used IRC client that doesn't have built-in SSL connectivity for quite some time. For example:

https://www.mirc.com/ssl.html

Re:Making IRC better by usrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:22PM (#32004031)
Encryption makes more sense for small or one on one chats with people you know, the sorts of things people use XMPP for (which has OMEMO: signal style encryption.) In large public chat rooms being able to use a pseudonym is much more important than encryption.
Re:Making IRC better by ddevault on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:39AM (#32000725)
You might like pinging people so they get a notification on their phone, but they might not like being on the other end of your ping :)

IRC has been around a lot longer than most of the projects which have sprung up in the same space, and IRC views their features with skepticism rather than being the eternal trend-follower. If IRC had followed every trendy chat feature for the past 34 years then it would be a hulking monstrosity by now.

There is wisdom in moderation. A communication method can be effective without facilitating every style of communication -- often moreso. I'll note that you're unable to embed a GIF or highlight code or send an emoji reaction on your Hacker News comments, but we seem to be having this conversation in relative ease despite that.

Different people value different things. Matrix is there if you want a more "modern" option.

Re:Making IRC better by throw10920 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @04:35PM (#32006474)
> You might like pinging people so they get a notification on their phone, but they might not like being on the other end of your ping :)

This is a false dichotomy between "you have to receive annoying pings" and "there's no notification system in your chat system".

What actually happens in real life is that chat systems, even proprietary ones, give you control over what notifications you receive (and when you receive them). Discord, in particular, gives you significantly more fine-grained control than any FLOSS tool that I've ever seen.

Re:Making IRC better by corobo on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @11:24AM (#32002345)
If IRC had followed every trendy chat feature it might not be 10x smaller than it was when I last used it too, in fairness

Not even using comical exaggeration either, I'd say the user counts are pretty dead on 10x less now, give or take a few thou. Back then EFNet, Undernet, DALNet had like 100k users each. Barely getting over the 10k hump these days.

> You might like pinging people so they get a notification on their phone, but they might not like being on the other end of your ping :)

Notification settings aren't stuck in 1988 too, if you don't want to be pinged in 2022 that's on you :P

Re:Making IRC better by carapace on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:19PM (#32003152)
It's not humanly possible to talk to 100k or 10k people anyway, so what does it matter? It's not Twitter. If the hundred or ten people you want to talk to are there, that's enough, eh?
Re:Making IRC better by corobo on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:40PM (#32003441)
I'm not saying they were all in one channel lmao

What does it matter? If you go on IRC now every channel is idle, no chat, just joins quits and parts, boring, dead.

> If the hundred or ten people you want to talk to are there,

They're not, and haven't been in 10 years. I'd love to get back into IRC but there's no IRC to go back to.

Re:Making IRC better by rascul on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:06PM (#32006828)
> If you go on IRC now every channel is idle, no chat, just joins quits and parts, boring, dead.

Not my experience at all. The channels I'm in have had a fairly stable number of users for at least the last decade. These are channels with hundreds or even thousands of users. There is lots of discussion in these channels every day. Sometimes so much I can't keep up with it if I'm there participating. I'm in mostly tech related channels, though.

Re:Making IRC better by welterde on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:26PM (#32007028)
Libera is still quite active, just hop on and onto your favorite programming language channels there (or science or news or ..) and chances are you'll see plenty of chat activity instead of only joins and quits.
Re:Making IRC better by stonogo on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:47PM (#32003518)
The world has been "moving on" from IRC for approximately thirty years, just like it's been "moving on" from email and phone calls and so on. Somehow, all these tools remain.
Re:Making IRC better by seoaeu on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @07:47PM (#32008328)
Roughly 5 billion people use phones. Roughly 4 billion use email. However only about 0.0004 billion people use IRC…
Re:Making IRC better by PostOnce on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:27PM (#32008953)
It may be that irc is used by 0.0001% of the general public, but approximately 90% of open source developers use it, me included.
Re:Making IRC better by Gigachad on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:04PM (#32009170)
It’s becoming increasingly rare for projects to use irc. These days both discord and matrix each seem more common.
Re:Making IRC better by Stampo00 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @11:24AM (#32002353)
I think we need to separate IRC the client from IRC the protocol. Everything you just described is possible with a sufficiently advanced client without any changes to the protocol. In fact, some clients already do what you describe.
Re:Making IRC better by eropple on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:54PM (#32003640)
"A client could do that" is true. It's also unhelpful. They don't all, or even most, do that. Consistency is valuable, and trying to coach people to switch IRC clients (assuming one exists that ticks the right boxes on their platform) is, to me, a pretty poor use of my limited time on this planet.

I don't love Discord or Slack and there are a lot of things I miss about IRC, but the amount of sandpaper around getting people who are less than extremely forgiving of Computer Stuff to use it adroitly is one. Two chat platforms is already one too many for me, and IRC doesn't really make the cut for a third anymore because I too am becoming less forgiving of Computer Stuff as I get older, too.

Re:Making IRC better by jjav on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:59PM (#32004544)
> "A client could do that" is true. It's also unhelpful.

That's a fundamental disagreement. I know some people like tightly walled gardens where there can only be one client and you're stuck with its limitations. Personally, I despise those systems and will do everything to avoid them.

> Consistency is valuable

Consistency is not valuable in this context, it is a straightjacket. I want a client which works exactly the way I want, which is likely different from what you want. So we need probably different clients, or at least an extremely configurable one.

This is why email is so wonderful and I use it above all else. I can have my client which I love and others can have their clients which they love and I find unusable but we can all be happy.

Re:Making IRC better by eropple on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @02:37PM (#32005008)
I completely agree--it absolutely is a fundamental disagreement! It's also why "but why won't people use IRC?" is misguided. I won't use IRC because I don't value what it does anymore. I valued it a lot more when almost everyone I talked to was as much of a computer nerd as I am--that's no longer the case and the computer-nerdy parts of my life are complementary pieces rather than core ones now, so I want different things.

The idea that IRC might be better was why I clicked on this thread in the first place, before I really parsed the srht part of it, 'cause my values absolutely do not overlap with theirs. (Which is fine. Like what you like!)

Re:Making IRC better by welterde on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:16PM (#32003946)
Part of the problem is though that there people (like myself) that simply don't want any of those features. If everyone agreed that these features are worth having then there would be no problem, since then every client would get them eventually.

People have different needs and expectations, so why shouldn't different clients for different people exist?

Re:Making IRC better by eropple on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:20PM (#32004000)
TBH? Because the expectation for a communications platform is that you want people to communicate with you, and imposing the need to keep a set of caps in my head for your client is grating and annoying. "I only accept text-based email" would be the closest equivalent I can think of, and I don't think I'd go out of my way to write a text-based email to you because you choose not to parse `<ul>`.

I'm not saying somebody who only accepts text-based email is wrong, mind--do as thou wilt and all. I am saying that the more barriers you present to being communicated with, the less reasonable it is to expect people to communicate with you. IRC makes it too difficult to communicate in modes I've come to expect as normal, so I'm just not gonna do that these days.

Re:Making IRC better by welterde on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:55PM (#32004481)
What do you mean with keeping caps in your head for my client? Capabilities? Why would you need to keep those in mind?

One doesn't need to keep anything in mind if one just has two different clients for the two user groups. And there are IRC clients, such as thelounge or irccloud (ok.. more than just a client), that offer things like inline images/audio, link preview, etc. (and wouldn't be hard to add missing things there). On the protocol level they just send urls in the irc messages, which falls back nicely for the other user group. I send images, pastes, etc. all the time on IRC it's just I don't want my client to render any of them inline - I want to decide if I look at something or not, while you want a client that does render everything inline for the most part.

PS: My spam filter judges html emails rather harshly :P

Re:Making IRC better by eropple on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @02:16PM (#32004732)
> What do you mean with keeping caps in your head for my client? Capabilities? Why would you need to keep those in mind?

Because the point of a conversation is to communicate. Your client is changing the meaning of what I am sending to you, and I have to know that to effectively communicate with you. I value clarity, and IRC doesn't offer me this without knowing what the other client is doing. I do not trust a normal, representative user to click on every relevant link and internalize it from there, because my experience is that people don't. On the other hand, being able to post a snippet makes it part of the conversation and not a reference, and in my experience means people are more likely to actually read the thing. The assumption that I should just throw URLs at you and you will parse them, either through a computer or mentally, and do the right thing with them increases the lossiness of communication, and adds to my mental stack. My mental stack is tall enough already for me.

In my experience from platform to platform it's a difference of kind, and frankly? It's also not one I really want to be dealing with myself on the sending end more generally. I don't like the bouncer paradigm and I'm not paying irccloud to host one for me when I can do so myself but doing so myself is annoying and work that other platforms do not demand of me. And I'm not going to a pastebin website when I can literally drag a code file in and click "post as snippet". It's slower and it's unpleasant. A sufficiently smart client could solve these things, sure--but Slack and Discord already do them, and the 99% case are there and not on IRC.

I am not, to be totally clear, saying you're wrong to like what you like. I've run IRC servers many times and I used them steadily for about fifteen years. But I have learned, personally and for me, that the things users seem to value on IRC makes those folks harder for me to communicate with as we've normed (for lack of a better term) rich experiences in group conversations. And if you're cool with that, that's totally fine. It's a tradeoff, not a moral thing. It does also means that (not that you're doing it, but some IRC defenders in this thread have definitely logged on) incredulity that Nobody Wants To Use IRC just isn't reasonable. It's not a friendly platform unless your values are its values. Mine aren't anymore, so I don't use it.

Re:Making IRC better by welterde on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @03:04PM (#32005341)
I don't think the argument that the mere existence of clients that work differently ruin the modern features somehow is really that fair (see below). The bouncer argument is kinda fair, but if you also don't like to live in a walled gardens (slack or discord), it limits the options a lot (although there are IRC servers that have integrated bouncers! Matrix is kinda like running your own bouncer again, unless you are ok with a third-party running it for you). I can also accept that there are many more non-modern IRC clients than modern ones that work the way you would expect, so the overall expectation would be biased. And that probably it was too little too late.

But I think you are overthinking it by a lot. If you were to use IRC, you should just use a modern "magical" IRC clients and not worry about what happens in the background (and btw it's not just "could" but "does".. there are clients that do all that already - where you can just drag and drop stuff in and it will magically do the right thing). And I am willing to bet that in other instances you already do operate that way. Unless your mail client is very broken it will send a plain text version of your email along with the html email. Do you worry there too that I am actually just looking at the plain text version of your email and not with the intended html formatting? Or do you worry that the person you are talking to on slack might just be connected via matterircd via IRC (or directly via IRC back before slack did the bait 'n switch) and not see any of your snippets, images, etc.? Which btw. I am totally doing despite how much it butchers everything - I just cannot stand that UI (and neither can my rather old laptop).

Re:Making IRC better by notriddle on Thursday July 07, 2022 @04:18PM (#32018799)
> I don't think the argument that the mere existence of clients that work differently ruin the modern features somehow is really that fair (see below).

It totally does, though. If I write an emoji thumbsup, and the recipient only sees a tofu box, they won't know if I'm agreeing, disagreeing, or saying something else.

If I'm participating in a heterogeneous environment, I need to refrain from including any mission-critical information in a form that can't be read by all of the participants. And since writing the same information twice is usually too much work, the extended functionality winds up completely unused, or at least only gets used for low-value spam.

> Or do you worry that the person you are talking to on slack might just be connected via matterircd via IRC

Yes, I do worry about that. If I find out that one of my coworkers is using a Slack client that doesn't implement all the functionality in the reference client, and can't just talk them out of it, then I'll have to make sure not to use anything that they can't see.

I might even start doing an IRC bridge myself, in fact, since at that point there's really no actual purpose in running a chat client with a bunch of functionality that I cannot use.

A major part of Slack's value is that this is very rare. Almost everyone just uses the reference implementation.

Re:Making IRC better by Gigachad on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:00PM (#32009146)
This is even worse because you have no idea what other clients support. The best part of modern IM is that you know what you see is pretty much what they see. Tiny differences in presentation make a huge difference on the message.
Re:Making IRC better by carapace on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:03PM (#32002919)
> They are in a shrinking minority of people.

Another way to say that is IRC helps filter out the worst of Eternal Eternal September. (Meaning nothing against you personally! No disrespect intended.)

(FWIW, it's a slowly growing minority.)

Re:Making IRC better by ZeWaka on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:15PM (#32003085)
Never thought I'd see an Eternal September post these days.
Re:Making IRC better by c7DJTLrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @02:58PM (#32005267)
"Growing". I doubt it. New developers are not jumping on IRC channels and mailing lists, they're going to Discord servers and Reddit, sorry to break it to you. Nobody below the age of thirty is using these old tools unless they're specifically working in spaces where they're used such as kernel dev or they want to be a hipster. I imagine the count of developers on Discord already outnumbers IRC 100:1.

Say what you want about these services being privacy infringing and proprietary (trust me, I don't like them either) but let's not be deluded. Their predecessors will die.

Re:Making IRC better by Shared404 on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @04:52PM (#32006668)
> "Growing". I doubt it. New developers are not jumping on IRC channels and mailing lists,

I am :) . I've found that the discussions I've had on IRC or read on mailing lists are typically higher quality, and more interesting than anywhere else.

Re:Making IRC better by usrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:44AM (#32000790)
If only I had a fraction of a Bitcoin for every time someone said "Why IRC and not Google talk? The world is moving on."

The world is not moving on, IRC is very much here to stay. It works way too well for this sort of thing and people like being able to have their client set up exactly right. It's just heavy iPhone users that left and once Apple allows web push iPhone users will be back on IRC again.

Re:Making IRC better by dijit on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:23AM (#32001445)
I think a large issue might be the fact that nobody runs their own bouncers, and the idea of paying a subscription for such a thing is not something people are comfortable with.

I run ZNC+Palaver and get push notifications on my iPhone; but I also run ZNC on my own machine somewhere, which is a cost and a setup most people don't usually have to bother with.

One solution for casuals is probably IRCCloud; since IRCCloud will give you the same experience as mine for free, but will disconnect you if you're inactive (unless you're paying).

Irccloud also precludes all of the nice features you might get if you're running your own clients... so, YMMV.

Re:Making IRC better by TingPing on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @10:39AM (#32001679)
IRCCloud now acts as a regular bouncer for any client.
Re:Making IRC better by ChadNauseam on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @06:20PM (#32007574)
> The world is not moving on, IRC is very much here to stay

I don't doubt that IRC is here to stay, but I've noticed more and more people moving from IRC to Matrix. Nix, the wgpu-rs guys, I believe the blender devs, and I believe the GHC devs are all on Matrix now.

(No affiliation, I just like the service)

Re:Making IRC better by Arnavion on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @06:49PM (#32007879)
Nix, Blender and GHC all have IRC channels on Libera, with a few hundred members each. I didn't join them but I assume they're bridged to Matrix via EMS.
Re:Making IRC better by EmilyHughes on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @11:30AM (#32002436)
I can guarantee you that the amount of people using an iPhone that are desperate to get on IRC are almost 0%
Re:Making IRC better by MaxLeiter on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @09:03PM (#32008824)
Re:Making IRC better by usrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:08PM (#32003861)
Yeah when I had an iPhone I was really annoyed I couldn't leave an IRC client in the background. I'm certain I wasn't alone.
Re:Making IRC better by seoaeu on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:15PM (#32008517)
What percentage of internet users not using IRC would we have to reach for you to say that the world has moved on? 99%? 99.9%? 99.99%? Since it seems all those thresholds have already been passed…
Re:Making IRC better by usrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:36PM (#32008657)
It doesn't matter. Some tiny minority of internet users are actively involved in OSS development and they're the ones that use IRC.
Re:Making IRC better by u801e on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:17PM (#32003954)
> I like being able to paste code into chat and have it syntax highlighted.

> Occasionally, I like to send a GIF.

Some people don't like large blocks of text or images pushing other messages completely off screen.

Re:Making IRC better by fouric on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @04:28PM (#32006397)
I can think of many situations where I'd rather have an image that explains something much more clearly than a wall of text on my screen, and other situations where it's perfectly possible to send large blocks of useless non-syntax-highlighted text over IRC.

Don't try to solve social problems by removing useful technical features from tools.

Re:Making IRC better by Handytinge on Sunday July 17, 2022 @02:04PM (#32129334)
> Don't try to solve social problems by removing useful technical features from tools.

Thankfully, nobody is. We're simply using existing tooling without said "features".

Re:Making IRC better by fouric on Sunday July 24, 2022 @05:09PM (#32217762)
u801e was advocating for the removal of said features, so this comment is incorrect and irrelevant.
Re:Making IRC better by welterde on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @04:45PM (#32006588)
IRC does support sending URLs just fine. The key point here is though, do I want those images to be displayed inline among the text or not. And there are IRC clients (such as thelounge) that will just display those images inline (which is what you would want) and some where you can just drag some image/file and will upload it to some file/image host and then just send the url in the chat.

So options for people that have different usage patterns do exist.

Re:Making IRC better by rascul on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:10PM (#32006869)
> and some where you can just drag some image/file and will upload it to some file/image host and then just send the url in the chat.

The Lounge can do that also.

https://thelounge.chat/docs/configuration#fileupload

Re:Making IRC better by fouric on Monday July 11, 2022 @09:10AM (#32055668)
That's my point - that that's a client side decision. u801e was either unaware of that, or advocating for the removal of images from the protocol.
Re:Making IRC better by mikewhy on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @08:25PM (#32008588)
Discord and Slack let you hide inline images, it's nice when users don't have to worry about changes to third-party image hosts
Re:Making IRC better by shp0ngle on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:04PM (#32002937)
Come on, it’s sourcehut. This is what they do.

They think PRs and pull requests are a distraction and all should happen in mailing list.

If you host on sourcehut, you want these things

Re:Making IRC better by nsv on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @12:37PM (#32003401)
What is the replacement for IRC that the world is moving on to? Matrix? XMPP?

Personally all the people I want to talk to still use IRC, so I'll use it to.

Re:Making IRC better by Macha on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @05:54PM (#32007308)
The people/projects that care about an open ecosystem but want more than IRC are moving to Matrix, and those that don't are moving to Discord. In particularly basically every gaming community that used to be on IRC seems to be a discord now.
Re:Making IRC better by c7DJTLrn on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @02:53PM (#32005207)
Element and Rocket Chat are decent.
Re:Making IRC better by kodah on Wednesday July 06, 2022 @01:00PM (#32003732)
An IRC bouncer does what you're wanting in terms of offline notification, they're just hard to configure. The problem with IRC is largely it's structure. Huge networks don't really merge anymore, channel owners stay in their seats for very long periods of time, and the network operators largely run on a very libertarian ideology of non-interference. Discord solves that, and many people moved because of that before Discord had all the novel features it has. The people that stick around on IRC usually have gripes about the networks they're on, but the gripes are tolerable enough.