News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by davidjohnstone on Thursday November 03, 2011 @11:36PM (#3194842)
As desirable as the specs are, this comment on Canon Rumors balances things up:

"To those fawning after the Red...sure, it looks nice, but the poor color rendering, impossible proprietary workflow, and constantly-in-need-of-updates software make the camera a nightmare, imo, to use. Canon's footage has nicer skin tones than I've ever seen out of a Red. There's a reason so much tv is shot with the Alexa, rather than the red, and why dSLRs are used on ads--1080p with nice and standardized colors out of camera is much better for post. Red is cool, but what you get in terms of extra tech you pay for in having to figure out how to use it efficiently. Canon's cine camera does seem overpriced for what you get, though--in that no man's land the AF100 and F3 already inhabit except even more expensive..."

From http://www.canonrumors.com/forum/index.php/topic,2059.msg410...

In other news, all these $10k-$20k cameras, zooms from $45k and primes for $7k make still photography look really cheap.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by stephen_g on Friday November 04, 2011 @03:58AM (#3195299)
From someone who has processed and edited a lot of RED footage, this is pretty much complete hogwash.

RED cameras use a RAW codec called REDCODE, which records the raw sensor data with lossless compression. Almost every other camera records RGB data that has been through gamma correction, a colour curve, sharpening (ugh..), and a whole lot of other image processing. These other cameras therefore give you very little flexibility in post production for grading and so on.

This gives the illusion that RED cameras have worse colour rendering - because it is not doing much image processing in camera, the un-processed image looks very flat - and it requires some skill to actually expose the image when you're shooting it, and properly process it in post production (this is a professional camera, remember). The amount of crap you see because of errors on set and in processing... But footage from somebody who knows how to shoot it properly is easily on par with the Alexa (which produces lovely skin tones but is very low resolution) and miles better than DSLR cameras with their aliasing and moire that comes from the line skipping and pixel binning that they need to do to get a decent frame rate out of a still camera sensor - not to mention the 8 bit low bitrate RGB codecs they use which are hopelessly lacking as an acquisition format.

And the workflow is sooo hard - I mean, it's such a battle to get RED footage into Premiere for example (File -> Import -> OK). And only pretty much every single grading package, every single non-linear editor and compositing package supports RED footage...

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by jermy on Friday November 04, 2011 @05:59AM (#3195506)
As only a minor nitpick (my excuse is that this is my day job), you've got it the wrong way round - REDCODE is actually storing data as RGB, whereas 'every other camera' is almost certainly using a MPEG-based codec and storing it as YUV with chroma subsampling - somewhere between 4:1:1/4:2:0 to 4:2:2 depending on the camera in use.

As with any lossless compression, it's a compromise between having almost all of the data shot to work with versus pretty much having to always do a full grade on any content you get and the additional online storage space needed in post-production.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by stephen_g on Friday November 04, 2011 @07:29AM (#3195646)
Are all the MPEG codecs YUV? I know MPEG2 is but I thought MPEG4/H.264 wasn't. Now that I think about it, you're probably right about that part (as for other codecs, I know the ProRes codec that the Alexa typically shoots (unless you use the ArriRAW recorder but hardly anyone does yet) definitely is YUV, but the HDCAM tapes that some of the more expensive Sony cameras shoot isn't).

But the point still stands that RGB and YUV codecs aren't RAW like REDCODE is.

REDCODE itself isn't exactly RGB. It actually is pretty interesting - it does store the red, green and blue pixels separably, but it's not usually classified as RGB since it stores two green channels for every red and blue channel (because of the way the bayer filter on the sensor is arranged - there's twice as many green pixels as red and blue), and because those channels haven't been demosaiced/debayered[1].

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demosaicing

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by zokier on Friday November 04, 2011 @06:38AM (#3195557)
The Wikipedia page of REDCODE claims that it contains the Bayer-patterned subpixel data, so it's more comparable to RAW images than rendered RGB images. But according to that page, it's also lossy format, which makes it quite interesting technically.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by davidjohnstone on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:04AM (#3195308)
I'm pleased to be corrected by somebody who knows what they're talking about :-)
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by Aqua_Geek on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:17AM (#3194912)
> impossible proprietary workflow

Speaking from experience, the workflow isn't hard at all. Do you have to know what you're doing? Sure. But the same could be said for just about anything.

> [...] and why dSLRs are used on ads--1080p [...] out of camera is much better for post

Agreed. If your final delivery format is 1080p, it's a lot easier not to have to mess with transcoding.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by bgentry on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:45AM (#3195084)
impossible proprietary workflow

I know this wasn't your comment, but what exactly is impossible and proprietary about their workflow? AFAIK Redcode RAW is supported by Final Cut Pro, Adobe Premiere, Avid, etc..

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by unwind on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:20AM (#3195329)
Reading up a bit on REDCODE (simply by hitting http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/REDCODE) the fact that the audio is uncompressed amused me. With the bandwidth spent on the video content, I guess 4 channels of 24-bit PCM at 48 kHz just doesn't matter. :)
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by jermy on Friday November 04, 2011 @06:17AM (#3195534)
The REDCODE format is proprietary - any of the above need to have the Red quicktime or AMA plugin to access the content.

For amusement, see 'Baselight Kompressor' for what a linux-based grading system has to do to handle red content.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by jamesfmilne on Friday November 04, 2011 @08:50AM (#3195831)
You don't need to use a Kompressor (Mac Pro) to decode RED on a Baselight. Baselight supports RED natively on Linux (including RED Rocket support).

Kompressor is only there for handling codecs for which there is no (official) Linux implementation (ie ProRes), or connecting to storage systems that don't have native Linux drivers (like Avid Unity).

Disclaimer: I'm one of the Baselight developers.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by jermy on Friday November 04, 2011 @09:06AM (#3195874)
Ah, apologies, I'll eat my hat (or buy you a beer sometime - you folks Covent Garden based?).

I had assumed Kompressor also handled REDCODE with its hardware requirements, as well the Avid Connection Manager and other Quicktime codecs.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by jamesfmilne on Friday November 04, 2011 @09:08AM (#3195885)
Hey Jermy, no worries ;-) We're in Soho, so within spitting distance. Beer sounds good!
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by protomyth on Thursday November 03, 2011 @11:48PM (#3194863)
I think Canon Rumors is a little disingenuous (much like MacRumors). The workflow isn't that bad, and the skin tones look good with HDRx. Canon has some fun with formats, not giving a true RAW for video. Neither camera has the true killer feature for a lot of productions: on camera ProRes recording like the Alexa.

If Canon had come out with a camera with a good RAW format and on camera ProRes, then I would say Canon is the clear winner. As is, I think Red is a better value.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by mashmac2 on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:47AM (#3194971)
Of course, when we're talking cost, you'll most likely have the Scarlet on a support system, so it's an easy matter to add a Ki Pro Mini on the back, attach with HD-SDI, and record ProRes 422 (at 1080p) onto CF cards at a wide variety of bitrates.

Extra cost ($3k). Compared to $50k+ for Alexa, it's still a great price/deal.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by davidjohnstone on Thursday November 03, 2011 @11:55PM (#3194878)
I should clarify that the comment was by a forum member, not Canon Rumors themselves.

How much does a $10k price difference matter when you live in a world where lenses can cost >$40k?

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by protomyth on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:23AM (#3194924)
Not much, but both cameras can use the cheaper Canon lenses, and these cameras aren't the ones you are putting $40k lenses on unless you are renting. If you are buying the $40k lense you are buying an Epic, Alexa, or high end Sony. $15k for a complete Red rig is pretty good and can be used to do some serious work.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by rorrr on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:29AM (#3195049)
Most canon lenses can only be used in manual focus mode, the motors make way too much noise. That's why good cinematic lenses are so expensive.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by tincholio on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:57AM (#3195398)
Well, that's the way they would be used with this rig, as it doesn't support AF.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by protomyth on Friday November 04, 2011 @10:58AM (#3196272)
According to the announcement, Scarlet does support autofocus on the Canon mount:

"Price for Scarlet-X, including Brain, Side SSD and Canon aluminum mount (auto-focus support) is $9,750" http://www.reduser.net/forum/showthread.php?65760-SCARLET-AN...