Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ...
by stephen_g on Friday November 04, 2011 @07:29AM
(#3195646)
Are all the MPEG codecs YUV? I know MPEG2 is but I thought MPEG4/H.264 wasn't. Now that I think about it, you're probably right about that part (as for other codecs, I know the ProRes codec that the Alexa typically shoots (unless you use the ArriRAW recorder but hardly anyone does yet) definitely is YUV, but the HDCAM tapes that some of the more expensive Sony cameras shoot isn't).
But the point still stands that RGB and YUV codecs aren't RAW like REDCODE is.
REDCODE itself isn't exactly RGB. It actually is pretty interesting - it does store the red, green and blue pixels separably, but it's not usually classified as RGB since it stores two green channels for every red and blue channel (because of the way the bayer filter on the sensor is arranged - there's twice as many green pixels as red and blue), and because those channels haven't been demosaiced/debayered[1].
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ...
by zokier on Friday November 04, 2011 @06:38AM
(#3195557)
The Wikipedia page of REDCODE claims that it contains the Bayer-patterned subpixel data, so it's more comparable to RAW images than rendered RGB images. But according to that page, it's also lossy format, which makes it quite interesting technically.
As with any lossless compression, it's a compromise between having almost all of the data shot to work with versus pretty much having to always do a full grade on any content you get and the additional online storage space needed in post-production.