News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by protomyth on Thursday November 03, 2011 @11:48PM (#3194863)
I think Canon Rumors is a little disingenuous (much like MacRumors). The workflow isn't that bad, and the skin tones look good with HDRx. Canon has some fun with formats, not giving a true RAW for video. Neither camera has the true killer feature for a lot of productions: on camera ProRes recording like the Alexa.

If Canon had come out with a camera with a good RAW format and on camera ProRes, then I would say Canon is the clear winner. As is, I think Red is a better value.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by mashmac2 on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:47AM (#3194971)
Of course, when we're talking cost, you'll most likely have the Scarlet on a support system, so it's an easy matter to add a Ki Pro Mini on the back, attach with HD-SDI, and record ProRes 422 (at 1080p) onto CF cards at a wide variety of bitrates.

Extra cost ($3k). Compared to $50k+ for Alexa, it's still a great price/deal.

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by davidjohnstone on Thursday November 03, 2011 @11:55PM (#3194878)
I should clarify that the comment was by a forum member, not Canon Rumors themselves.

How much does a $10k price difference matter when you live in a world where lenses can cost >$40k?

Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by protomyth on Friday November 04, 2011 @12:23AM (#3194924)
Not much, but both cameras can use the cheaper Canon lenses, and these cameras aren't the ones you are putting $40k lenses on unless you are renting. If you are buying the $40k lense you are buying an Epic, Alexa, or high end Sony. $15k for a complete Red rig is pretty good and can be used to do some serious work.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by rorrr on Friday November 04, 2011 @01:29AM (#3195049)
Most canon lenses can only be used in manual focus mode, the motors make way too much noise. That's why good cinematic lenses are so expensive.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by tincholio on Friday November 04, 2011 @04:57AM (#3195398)
Well, that's the way they would be used with this rig, as it doesn't support AF.
Re:Red Digital Cinema announces Scarlet X -- 4K resolution, ... by protomyth on Friday November 04, 2011 @10:58AM (#3196272)
According to the announcement, Scarlet does support autofocus on the Canon mount:

"Price for Scarlet-X, including Brain, Side SSD and Canon aluminum mount (auto-focus support) is $9,750" http://www.reduser.net/forum/showthread.php?65760-SCARLET-AN...