News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by ageitgey on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:55AM (#31835433)
In my experience, the time to make money selling mobile apps was 2008-2012 or so. The market is totally different now.

In my opinion, has never been harder to make money charging money for apps:

- Competition is huge (including underhanded competition that will clone any successful app instantly)

- Customer appetite to pay for "apps" is near zero. Customers don't even want to download more apps, let alone pay money for them.

- Programs like Apple Arcade and Google Play Pass have further eroded the idea of paying for apps

- Ad-driven trash apps and poor app store ranking/discoverability have further driven consumers away from trying new apps in app stores

Of course lots of successful businesses use apps as part of their business model. But very few are making money from selling the app itself unless they have a really good niche figured out.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:15AM (#31835628)
I agree with this, personally I stopped installing new apps a while ago and use the browser more. I see apps as just security and privacy nightmares and forget about getting me to pay for them. Not to say I won't pay for good things, I have a number of subscriptions to various web services. There are a few exceptions where I have to install and use an app, and I resent each of those situations.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by woojoo666 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:00AM (#31836887)
I use F-Droid for pretty much everything now. They've had zero malware, and are very good about privacy. While the app selection is much smaller, I've been pretty happy with what I find there, at least for apps that were released within the past few years. Examples: Florisboard, Aegis Authenticator, Material Files, Finamp, Newpipe, Shelter, Connectbot, and anything by Simple Mobile Tools
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by cobertos on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:07PM (#31839645)
Commenting to remind myself to check these out later.

I've also found SunTimes, SMS Backup+ (for SMS, MMS, Call log -> SMTP email), Markor, LawnChair, OpenCamera (specifically for manual camera control like exposure and focus), NewPipe, Aegis Authenticator, and FluffyChat to be really useful.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by 2Gkashmiri on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:46AM (#31837582)
Simple mobile tools recently fucked their gallery by removing password protected hidden folders for some bullshit reason.

The only fuckup they've done so far.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by bcraven on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:20PM (#31838031)
> Hi, apps like this can no longer show hidden files on Android 11+. It is a system limitation, not something we chose to do ourselves.

https://www.reddit.com/r/SimpleMobileTools/comments/u5fopt/s...

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by 2Gkashmiri on Thursday June 23, 2022 @05:09AM (#31846647)
how are older app versions working?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by xchip on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @06:02PM (#31842437)
Thanks for your list of apps, there were a few I didn't know and that are what I had been searching for :)
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by klausjensen on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:29AM (#31836442)
I hate installing new apps as well and prefer mobile websites for most things.

So on a new project, we just created an amazing, reponsive web-app.

The most frequent feedback we got from users we showed it to was: "That's awesome! When is the (IOS/Android) app ready?"

Sigh...

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by tpoacher on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:48AM (#31836701)
just ship a launcher that opens the webpage with the address bar disabled :p
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by runjake on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:04PM (#31840410)
No need to ship a launcher. You can already do this on iOS/iPadOS:

https://www.macrumors.com/how-to/add-a-web-link-to-home-scre...

When you tap on the icon on the home screen, it'll open up in Safari without any browser chrome visible.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by tpoacher on Thursday June 23, 2022 @04:27AM (#31846429)
Yes but then users know it's a weblink, and you're back to square one: "when is the Android/iOS app coming out?"
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by klausjensen on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:40PM (#31840043)
Apple will not accept that, unfortunately. :(
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by bradgessler on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @03:01PM (#31840364)
They will accept apps if it does something lame like implement login natively and have a bottom menu bar launcher.

I hate to say it, but I’d probably pay apple a cut if they’d let me distribute PWAs through their App Store without going through the trouble of building a lame native wrapper.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by quartzic on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:04AM (#31836955)
Or a PWA!
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by aaaaaaaaata on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:08PM (#31837878)
These two are not mutually exclusive, and well supported by most app stores now.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by klausjensen on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:41PM (#31840053)
Apple rejects apps that are just wrappers around a website. :(
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by nmstoker on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:45AM (#31835902)
Similar views here.

It has recently become even worse as the Google Store no longer shows permissions.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by jxramos on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:30AM (#31836454)
Same exact sentiment and behavior on my end. I’ve become what I call “app-averse”
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by moneywoes on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:46AM (#31835909)
Would you be more likely to pay for a chrome extension?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by bobkazamakis on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:14AM (#31836221)
I will never pay for a chrome extension because of the threat vector it allows for malicious actors. Yes, maybe you've got a great extension, but you require DOM access for every page I hit. Maybe I even trust you completely! But

I can't trust that next week a bad actor buys you out and drops in a browser exploit.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by afpx on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:40AM (#31836607)
Reminds me of people at work who blindly download and run github repos.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by xeromal on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:59PM (#31838653)
Yeah, I always get the heeby jeebies when I'm about to use a new github repo at work. I tend to add creedence to projects that have loads of stars simply because someone would've complained in the issues section if some nefarious things were afoot. Obviously this isn't foolproof.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by toyg on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:49AM (#31835944)
Most people don't even know what those are.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:48AM (#31835937)
Potentially, provided I found it both useful and trustworthy.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by octobus2021 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:47PM (#31839334)
I started a company making and selling Android games (phone and tablets) around 2010. Made 5 games with 0 revenue, however couple years later Google Ads found widespread fraud and they re-distributed some earnings and I ended up with a few hundred $$ (I spent several thousand on those games working with remote designers/developers, marketing, etc).

It was already really REALLY BAD. People would "re-skin" games, so they would make a game (or more often just steal one and re-package as their own) and replace graphics/audio to make it look different even though it was the same game. If I recall correctly some managed to have almost a hundred re-skins of the same game. Of course the more games you have as a publisher the higher you are in the search results/easier it is for you to get new installs. Click fraud was rampant even then, with cloned and fake SIMs, real and virtual devices, botnets... It was nearly impossible to make anything in that market back then so I folded around 2012.

Of course it's loser's perspective, maybe somebody else has more optimistic take :-)

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by the_only_law on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @01:50PM (#31839396)
> It was already really REALLY BAD. People would "re-skin" games, so they would make a game (or more often just steal one and re-package as their own) and replace graphics/audio to make it look different even though it was the same game. If I recall correctly some managed to have almost a hundred re-skins of the same game

Mobile games are a pit.

Modern phones can run pretty impressive stuff now, hell iOS has Civ 6 and Total War Medieval 2 ports.

But instead the stores seem to be filled with endless reskins of the same tired concepts as a decade ago.

And then the ads are all lies. They'll legit just rip some footage from a well established and well liked PC game, say Age of Empires II, and use that in their ads when the actual game is just a shitty Clash of Clans ripoff.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by freemint on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:15PM (#31839761)
If you wanna get an idea how really bad the situation was/is i recommend this GDC talk. https://youtu.be/E8Lhqri8tZk
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by afpx on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:48AM (#31836696)
Poor discoverability makes for such an awful user experience. Google and Apple have no incentive to improve their search. It's easier and more profitable for them to shill out their promoted apps.

It's like if we were given the Internet in 1990 but forced to use AOL to search, forever. Someone please disrupt app search.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by jamil7 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:32AM (#31837379)
> In my experience, the time to make money selling mobile apps was 2008-2012 or so. The market is totally different now.

The market is very different I agree but I'd disagree on the money part. Subscription B2C business models are normalised and there's a lot of companies making a lot of money in both app stores right now. In fact I think you can probably make more money now than you could in 2008-2012. Granted it's all a lot more sophisticated and requires more up-front capital, larger marketing budgets and larger teams than it used to but the money is there.

As far as I see, people are installing less apps but the few they have they're spending more time and money in.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by orangecat on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:53AM (#31837679)
Granted it's all a lot more sophisticated and requires more up-front capital, larger marketing budgets and larger teams

Yeah, that's pretty much the point. In 2010 I released a paid app developed in my spare time, did zero marketing, and made around $10k after app store fees and taxes. That would never happen today.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by jamil7 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:17PM (#31837989)
Yeah paid upfront and zero marketing won't get you far anymore but that's true everywhere in software now.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by rasulkireev on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:00AM (#31836077)
> Customers don't even want to download more apps, let alone pay money for them.

Interestingly, I found myself thinking about this and thought about it a little different. I indeed want to have as little apps on my phone as possible, but that made me want to increase the quality of those apps. And thus I wasn't against paying for those if they are indeed better quality.

It's like with cooking. If your dish uses less ingredients, you can focus on better quality ingredients then.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by bombcar on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:36AM (#31837417)
The problem is almost all apps are just a wrapped webpage anyway - I want apps that keep working (to the best of their ability) offline, which very VERY few do. Kindle and HERE maps are some of the ones I can think of.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by gigaflop on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:07AM (#31836150)
Apps should fill some kind of utility for the user. Once I have my utilities covered, why would I want to get something else that does the same thing?

So, once I have my needs covered, I have very little desire to go hunting for something new.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by hgazx on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:45AM (#31836660)
The situation of games is dire. I wish there was a good rpg that I could pay for upfront, without micro transactions. I don’t even look for one because it’s unlikely to exist.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by coopierez on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:51AM (#31836755)
If you haven't played them yet, Dragon Quest and Final Fantasy I-VI are all available on mobile app stores. DQ IV-VI in particular are very charming and hold up well (imho!).

If you're more of a western RPG guy I believe Icewind Dale and Baldur's gate are on there too.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by antifa on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:51PM (#31840197)
I'd be hesitant to pay for a Square Enix game on mobile. There are horror stories about the devs forcing users to be online and then also accidentally deleting the forced-online game saves.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by coopierez on Thursday June 23, 2022 @03:03AM (#31845983)
I agree that there are... issues with Squenix games from time to time on mobile (e.g. font issues on the new remasters of FF I-VI), but none of the games I mentioned enforce cloud saves.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by marlowe221 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:58AM (#31836854)
This person knows what he/she/they is talking about!
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by jtbayly on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @12:39PM (#31838304)
How do you know he/she/it doesn’t identify as a microchip?

“Person” is so speciesist.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by hadlock on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:09PM (#31839666)
Yeah I own a nintendo switch for games. One store for all my home and mobile gaming (for what little travel we do these days, where I'm not driving the car). I have no desire to get on the microtransaction treadmill as I am not part of the 3% or whatever of users that provide the majority of their revenue. Nintendo Switch has more than enough jrpgs to last a lifetime. Even charges off the same connector as my phone.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by egeozcan on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:02AM (#31836925)
"Divinity: Original Sin 2" is available on the iOS app store. It's the best game overall (not just among the tactical RPGs) I've ever played in my life.

https://apps.apple.com/de/app/divinity-original-sin-2/id1458...

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by vicek22 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:49AM (#31836723)
I find that the ports of older PC RPGs are the best for paying only once and getting the full uninterrupted game.

Knights of the Old Republic I and II are the best IMO.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by gesman on Thursday June 23, 2022 @12:22AM (#31845123)
Already successful business will strengthen their presence with app but not through app.

App-based business models are recipe for disasters. Many horror stories of app banned because scammy competitor complained. Apple or Google won't care.

High app rating for new app is a sure sign of cloned app or scam.

I won't download 95% of apps if i see "includes in-app purchases". Special purpose apps like "All Trails" or specialized aggregators/organizers that require lots of work to deliver - typically justify the cost.

Cute calculators that require recurring payments to disable annoying ads is complete nonsense

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by monkeybutton on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:53AM (#31835990)
>Customers don't even want to download more apps, let alone pay money for them.

I'm at the point where each OS update means another app gets purged from my phone.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by jxramos on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @10:33AM (#31836503)
Can you elaborate further. What’s the relation or workflow to the OS update that connects to native apps exactly?
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by withinboredom on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:10AM (#31837037)
The update takes up disk space. Ergo, if you have "too many" apps, you have to delete some to make up room for the update.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by monkeybutton on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @02:24PM (#31839866)
This is it. Even with keeping photos and music on a micro SD card, the internal storage for the OS and apps is often woefully undersized.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by lakomen on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @04:22PM (#31841395)
Good summary. Every time I install some random new app I feel like I exposed my phone to predators. As a result I don't even install new apps anymore, and when I do they get uninstalled quickly because they're really hostile. Let's take Twitter, you install it, it wants to know you date of birth and your phone number. Absolutely not. Facebook, if you have it and Instagram installed and allow "media access" it scans your phone's ssd to detect instagram then proceeds to annoy you to asking if you that's your instagram account and if you want to connect those. No I do not, I'd rather unistall both so you can't further spy on me. And many many more such examples. I just pick the 2 most prominent.

Also I don't see the phone as a proper OS where I would spend money on. It's a gadget, a plaything and my head hurts if I use it too long and I need some time to recover.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by altdataseller on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @08:44PM (#31843792)
There's usually tight period where you can make money when these new ecosystems pop up.

With Android/iPhone, it was clearly 2008-2012, as you mentioned.

With Google/SEO, it was 2004-2010 (right before Google Panda/Penguin algorithm).

With Facebook ads/Shopify/DTC, it was 2010-2016.

With SaaS, it was 2010-2016, IMO.

Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by neves on Thursday June 30, 2022 @01:50PM (#31936004)
And some apps, like Tweeter and YouTube, have better experience in a browser with an uBlock Origin or using the Brave browser.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by andyjohnson0 on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @09:48AM (#31835929)
Agree. I'd be very reluctant to pay for an app. Depending on need I might pay for a service that is delivered by app and browser, but I probably wouldn't bother with the app unless I was frequently interacting with the service on a mobile device.
Re:Ask HN: Has anyone made any serious money selling Android... by criddell on Wednesday June 22, 2022 @11:05AM (#31836965)
Although I'm not a mobile app developer, I wish the app stores made it easier for developers to charge for upgrades. There are some excellent apps out there that feel like they are too inexpensive. The purchase model with crazy low prices doesn't feel sustainable.

For example, Procreate on an iPad with the Pencil is probably my favorite program for any platform from any time. I think I paid $10 years and years ago. Since then the creators have continued to develop the program and it's way better than it was when I bought it. I would have been more than happy to send them another $10 here and there for some of the significant updates.

However, I don't like the subscription model unless it's implemented like JetBrains does it where the subscription fee entitles you to updates and you have a perpetual license for the software once you have it.