News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by raesene9 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:23AM (#31630755)
One thing I didn't realise till recently, is you don't need spotify to generate white noise if you have an iPhone/iPad, as it's an in-built function under accessibility --> Audio/Visual and background sounds.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by mft_ on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:34AM (#31630841)
Thanks - really good to discover this!

Interesting to note the size of the samples that Apple is using:

* Balanced noise: 1.8MB

* Bright noise: 1.8MB

* Dark noise: 1.8MB

* Ocean: 62.4MB

* Rain: 63.7MB

* Stream: 72.1MB

That's a lot of effort to ensure your background water sounds are (presumably) high fidelity and non-repeating!

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by andrepd on Sunday June 05, 2022 @03:19PM (#31633997)
If you're interested in high quality background noise, I'll plug this absolutely amazing site: mynoise.net
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by laybak on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:31PM (#31635812)
wow didn't realize background noise can get so sophisticated haha
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by amelius on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:45AM (#31630934)
Doesn't the finite size imply that they are in fact repeating?
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by natly on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:08AM (#31631120)
In this case they're probably recordings, but you could imagine that they'd be procedurally generated in which case not necessarily. A call to `Math.random()` is a finite length 'file' but won't repeat.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by aftbit on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:36PM (#31634593)
A call to Math.random() will in fact repeat eventually. The backing PRNG has a finite period.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by shhsshs on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:41PM (#31634624)
Yeah, after it loops in several hundred years and I hear a pattern I've already heard, I'll be really annoyed!
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by MichaelBurge on Sunday June 05, 2022 @05:26PM (#31634998)
The human brain is also finite, so even a true infinite random sequence would give the listener finitely many states.

So it doesn't matter whether a sequence is finite or not.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by sudosysgen on Sunday June 05, 2022 @06:08PM (#31635269)
It may be partly affected by fully random effects such thermal noise, meaning there will be no period.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by JJMcJ on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:37AM (#31631940)
Good ones are loopable so there is no discontinuity when they repeat.

And the size of those files implies they are probably minutes in length, at the very least, so you probably don't notice the repetition.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by throwoutway on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:47AM (#31630955)
Yes. I can detect repetition of ocean “white noise” if the length is too short. But a long enough track is just fine
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by PartiallyTyped on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:50PM (#31632662)
Not necessarily.

In theory one can construct a chaotic (this is a precise definition) function with very little data that could replicate that class of noise with finite data.

Infinite lists are also another beautiful construct in lazily evaluated languages.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by Retric on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:59PM (#31632741)
Not at a fixed rate with finite computing power or finite memory. Essentially a fixed algorithm needs ever increasing or infinite levels of precision in it’s calculations to avoid loops.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by jacobolus on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:57PM (#31633316)
> Not at a fixed rate with finite computing power or finite memory. Essentially a fixed algorithm needs ever increasing or infinite levels of precision in its calculations to avoid loops.

If you start talking about true “infinity” then sure. You need to store enough state (or if you like, receive some input) for your computed output to be unique. And counting to infinity takes infinite amounts of memory. Infinity is not accessible to humans, and is best thought of as a thought experiment rather than a part of empirical reality.

But if you do 44kHz samples, a counter stored in a 32-bit integer that ticks up once per sample is enough state to give you all unique [i.e. non-looping] samples for about a day. A 64-bit integer will give you all unique samples for 13 million years. With a 75-bit integer you can get all unique samples for longer than the history of the universe so far.

So in practice, the “increasing” amount of memory required doesn’t (necessarily) grow fast enough to worry about.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by mejutoco on Sunday June 05, 2022 @06:14PM (#31635314)
Can prime numbers be used as lengths/periods so that there is no perceptible repetitions.

I saw this trick and used it to animate different parts of an animation (each part every p frames, where p is a prime) and it works very well.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by karmakaze on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:51PM (#31633268)
So like emitting 1, 0, 1, 1, 0, 1, 1, 1, 0, ...?

Doesn't need much to generate. It would need a wide counter but a MB is a lot of bits.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by kibwen on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:40AM (#31630901)
Or if you have any device with a web browser, since there are a zillion free sites for generating white noise. Here's an arbitrary top search result which appears to be a highly configurable noise generator: https://mynoise.net/NoiseMachines/whiteNoiseGenerator.php
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by jbmny on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:21AM (#31631776)
MyNoise is a really high quality, well maintained website run by a single person. He even goes out and does his own field recordings. I highly recommend it.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by akx on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:05PM (#31632185)
... With microphones he builds himself, too. https://mynoise.net/microphones.php
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by car on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:52PM (#31634729)
And really cheap, just $650!
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by b3morales on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:22PM (#31633529)
+1 There are associated mobile apps as well, that are not the prettiest, but provide access to the whole library. Really a gem.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by chias on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:35PM (#31633641)
I love mynoise.net! Am a very happy monthly donor. My two main use cases:

1. mixing "white rain" with "88 keys" to focus at work

2. downloaded an hour-long "white rain" to use as background noise for my newborn

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by app4soft on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:16AM (#31631172)
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by paskozdilar on Monday June 06, 2022 @09:47AM (#31640385)
MyNoise is awesome.

The fact that the site author literally travels around the world and records noises makes it so much more interesting to me that your average digitally-generated-white-noise app.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by moneywoes on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:24AM (#31631802)
Convenience is likely huge
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by gyan on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:46AM (#31630950)
FFmpeg has a colored noise generator. http://www.ffmpeg.org/ffmpeg-filters.html#anoisesrc
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by jedberg on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:07AM (#31631631)
This is awesome! Is it bad that my mind immediately went to how to use it to prank someone? Turn on white noise and then turn on "only when unlocked" and set it to a really low volume.

Drive someone nuts trying to figure out why it seems like they hear a noise every time they unlock their phone.

I won't do this though because I'm pretty sure it would be a violation of the Geneva conventions.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by HidyBush on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:00PM (#31633350)
Another day, another unknown Apple feature buried down in menus that has just made me uninstall a dedicated app
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by yborg on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:49PM (#31633762)
There are a lot of useful features lumped under 'Accessibility' because I guess Apple couldn't figure out what to do with them.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by azemetre on Sunday June 05, 2022 @03:04PM (#31633892)
White sounds are useful for people with cognitive disabilities. Seems like the right location to me FWIW.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by fomine3 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:31PM (#31636810)
Some features that helps not only disabilities but also other people tend to put under Accessibility menu.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by chucknelson on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:28AM (#31630799)
Woah, that is news to me!

What’s strange is that iOS gives you no indication of where that sound is coming from…I guess I expected to be able to pause it somehow. Interesting, though!

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by CamelRocketFish on Sunday June 05, 2022 @05:19PM (#31634953)
Turning it off is pausing it as it’s noise and not a song.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by michaelbuck on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:58PM (#31633838)
I never expected to find a feature like that in the settings menu of an operating system. Is there any history to this? How’d a white noise generator end up in the official Apple accessibility settings?

The idea of having a setting that makes my phone emit continuous noise until I turn it off is absolutely wild to me.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by askafriend on Sunday June 05, 2022 @03:16PM (#31633969)
I think you can ask Siri to play it for you which is probably how most people discover it.

My guess is the accessibility setting is for people that can't use Siri for whatever reason?

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by aaaaaaaaata on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:27PM (#31635784)
> for whatever reason

Weird reasons like...not trying to create a voice profile of yourself for corporations?

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by askafriend on Monday June 06, 2022 @01:23PM (#31643190)
I didn't mean for that phrase to be flippant. I literally just meant whatever reasons there are. There's plenty of good ones. Some people are mute, some people have speech issues, etc.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by drorco on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:29AM (#31630811)
Nice. Anyway to create a quick shortcut to this functionality? It's pretty deep inside the settings menu.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by kejaed on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:54AM (#31631022)
Yes, you can add it to Control Center

https://support.apple.com/en-ca/HT212775

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by quartesixte on Sunday June 05, 2022 @03:14PM (#31633952)
As someone who suffers from a rather high sensitivity to noise (particularly noise I do not have a control over) this is game changing and will 100x my quality of life
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by alexcnwy on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:48PM (#31632647)
Yes, you can set it to turn on when you triple tap the right button.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by frou_dh on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:54AM (#31631020)
Tap the ear icon ("Hearing") in Control Centre. I can't remember whether that icon is included by default though.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by al_borland on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:30AM (#31631874)
I have a ‘LectroFan, it’s just a little box with a bunch of fan/white noises in it. From what I remember it generates them vs just playing an audio clip on a loop. I prefer it to running something on my phone for 8 hours at a time.

I also have a mini one for when I travel, which has a battery and can double as a BT speaker. I do sometimes forget this when I travel, especially for short trips, so the iPhone feature is a good reminder. I think I heard about it before, but without using it, it’s easy to forget.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by dontbenebby on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:27AM (#31630793)
Thank you for this, great way to "keep things offline", a skill that the youth are rapidly losing.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by thatguy0900 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @09:35AM (#31630860)
Odd thing to blame the youth for. Losing, or having stolen from them? The people on this site who make these things are the ones making those decisions, if you expect a 14 year old to take hard ethical stances on theoretical privacy rights you are crazy.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by dylan604 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:16AM (#31631175)
Losing could be read as not from something they did themselves, but I lose the ability to do something if it has been taken away from me.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by languageserver on Sunday June 05, 2022 @12:08PM (#31632222)
to be fair I have seen more people loose precious photographs from film than from iCloud
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by brianzelip on Sunday June 05, 2022 @03:51PM (#31634262)
Hmmm, what iOS version? V14 doesn’t seem to have background sounds u det the Audio/Visual menu.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by CamelRocketFish on Sunday June 05, 2022 @05:18PM (#31634946)
iOS15
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by xwdv on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:13PM (#31632876)
This comment could cause lost revenue for these people. Take it down.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by winternett on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:35PM (#31633103)
I've worked my A$$ of literally for over 5 years now to put music on Spotify, through out those 5 years, I have about 30 songs up there, All in all I've probably only gotten about 1,400 streams generating about $20... I'm lucky I taught myself web development and project management, because with all the promise the Internet had when I was going through college, it seems that the only actual opportunity is in creating web sites and apps.

Fairness is simply not possible on these platforms, you can have the most polished product and sit totally ignored because of all the scams and schemes, I can't imagine how many people who don't have alternative opportunities like I did that are literally dying just trying to get a chance to be heard on a fiasco operation like this that literally and happily pays others to do absolutely nothing, while they charge creators for subscriptions and ads.

It's a really frickin bleak indicator as to the value of human labor going into the future... If the people who aren't providing value constantly win over the people that strive to, everything falls apart, and we'll end up in a total scheme economy.

As valid creators, we all need to back off and stop posting anything at all on social media and big platforms to highlight the total crap that is popular on the platform. A much better way is to create and maintain our own small independent sites and to link to each other more.

You can literally run a fan or leave a radio on a dead frequency to get white noise... You don't need a streaming service for that. This is ridiculous, and the article only serves to promote this brand of fraud. It's not capitalism, it's simply fraud from many facets.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by Cpoll on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:49PM (#31633239)
> If the people who aren't providing value constantly win over the people that strive to

Not that I don't sympathize with your struggles, but aren't the people who are creating background noise tracks doing exactly that, providing value? The article talks about tracks with natural noise or ambient noises, so it's not exactly the same as turning a fan on. I can't see how this is a scam.

Also from the article, there's a team of five making some of these, so it's not even accurate to label them as low effort (though I'll admit they're probably admin and marketing roles...).

> I have about 30 songs up there, All in all I've probably only gotten about 1,400 streams

That's only 46 listens per song. That suggests to me that you're not self-promoting, or doing something wrong. Even if there weren't white noise tracks on Spotify with 100k listens, there are millions of songs with <100 listens; even if the Spotify exposure algorithms were "fair" you wouldn't get any more listens than you already have.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by analog31 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:24PM (#31635767)
Oddly enough, I'm a performing musician, and an audience of 46 people would be fairly typical.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by winternett on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:01PM (#31634335)
You didn't have to take it in a personal insult direction friend. It's such a common response to an issue you really do not understand.

I'll refrain from salty comments concerning the quality of my work because you're already sold on the ideal that the platform is totally ethical, despite many well selling artists saying the same things I have numerous times.

The platforms exist to promote artists, they do not do that at all.

It's really not for me to defend the merits of my work in response to expressing my experience on the platform... It's really not for you to insult someone you know nothing about, who says they've worked hard. You should really think about that... I have solid success in many other places than Spotify, and that's why I dedicate my time there and not to Spotify.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by hetspookjee on Sunday June 05, 2022 @06:08PM (#31635274)
I find it odd that you seem rather adamant on the skill that goes into your own music, yet seem to disregard the noise genre as a whole and call it unfair that it gets that much attention. Indeed the world is not fair, but to discredit other peoples work that a lot of others seem to appreciate seems as a moot point.

I listen to a lot of music, mostly noise / ambient / drone and do so mostly during work, so the hours stack up quite rapidly. Per the Spotify model this is quite beneficial for the artist. But I am rather picky in the noise I appreciate so in the end it’s not that many songs I keep. Most I visit once and turn off halfway. So I definitely wouldn’t want to call it easy to create good ambient / noise.

Anyway the other day I saw a YouTube video with 116M views of 9 minutes long that showed hands going into slime. Now compared with a video from say Carfection or PBS EON, that’s quite odd than.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by winternett on Monday June 06, 2022 @12:51AM (#31637348)
I never commented on the overall quality of the ambient drone genre... I don't know where you got that unimportant idea?

There are people literally recording ceiling fans and then putting it on Spotify, and using low-effort production techniques like play bots to steal royalties from hard working artists. That's what I'm referring to. The only way that Spotify can really fix that is to rely less on algorithms, ban payola, and bring back real curators... But for the sake of their profit, that's not likely to ever happen.

This article is about a platform of hundreds of thousands of artists (or more) and you're using 2-3 artists you loosely observed to say that everything is fair. Thats not a real conversation at all rooted in fact. Far off the topic of making it about me.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by nyolfen on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:42PM (#31633166)
fraud? it sounds like your music just isnt very good
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by dinkleberg on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:46PM (#31633206)
Even if their music is good it’s hard to get discovered in a world of millions (billions?) of tracks. Unless you’re lucky, you’ll need to do some marketing of some sort to pull in listeners.
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by winternett on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:10PM (#31634418)
Agreed...

Marketing is indeed a necessity, but Social Media was developed under the premise of providing free "social" marketing for artists that aren't profiting from their work yet... These platforms have undermined that now into requiring absolutely all artists to pay for ads in order to be viewed, which is completely contradicting their original EULAs... Spotify in a way is a social platform, but more-so it is also a marketing platform that despite allowing people to promote, also creates a dynamic where success is tiered and artificially hard-limited by their algorithms.

Content displayed on the front pages of sites like Spotify, YouTube, Reddit (etc.), get the most views and plays. These sites intentionally only have front pages, with pre-designated featured content. That means that only the artists that land there get the lion share of the revenue from those sites... They provide little to no relative potential for success or visibility to the majority of artists that contribute content that they benefit from, and that makes the entire industry a pyramid scheme.

Unknown and unsponsored artists cannot succeed in this model, and even if they do somehow find an opportunity, they are often subject to predatory contracts from record labels and the larger industry as well. It's really insane what goes on behind the curtains.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by al_borland on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:24PM (#31635764)
The ones I've seen get noticed and gain a big audiance have done so by making entertaining music videos that poeple share and post to Reddit and other places. Lil Dicky is a great example of that. He made a mixtape in his bedroom using GarageBand, then made a bunch of videos for YouTube. Many of them went viral... or at least viral enough to fund his Kickstarter for his first full album.

Tom MacDonald is another (without getting into any politics). He makes a ton of videos and his songs have content that makes people want to share them. He had several songs hit the Billboard Hot 100 last year according to Wikipedia. I don't think he was even on steaming until recently due to a collaboration, just YouTube and selling physical CDs himself. He won't sign any of those predatory contracts, so things may be more difficult, but actually owning your music has it's value.

Both of these examples had a mix of hard work, talent, and luck, but that doesn't seem differnet than pre-social media when people were trying to get a record deal. Eminem just happened to hand his CD to a guy who worked with Jimmy Iovine after the Rap Olympics, had he not done that... who knows if we'd know who he is (I think it was the interview with Mike Tyson where he talked about this). If you've watched Jeen-Yuhs on Netflix, it shows no one wanted to give Kanye a chance as a rapper. Even though he was in the business, everyone just saw him as a producer, not a rapper. He had to push hard and keep asking for people to give him shot and got lucky one day when somene let him to a verse (I think Jay-Z). Jay-Z is another... no one would give him a deal, so he started selling his own stuff and made his own label (from what I remember hearing).

Breaking into the music business as a top artist as never been easy. It seems like the differnce now is the barriers are down, so it's more about getting people to listen instead of getting an record executive to like your stuff. It's hard to now if the market is any more crowded or if it's just that the consumers have full access now, instead of having to go through the gatekeepers.

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by prawn on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:29PM (#31635800)
"Social Media was developed under the premise of providing free "social" marketing for artists that aren't profiting from their work yet..."

I don't remember this. It might've been a bullet point in some fantastical interpretation of potential, but you'd have to be naive to think this was how it would play out. Doesn't take much thinking to see that every free platform gets overrun with hopefuls and spam and the platforms need a way to either rank content or monetise it.

Spotify and co provide distribution, not marketing. If it was as trivial as "create social music platform, get coverage for my music", you and every artist could do it, right?

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by winternett on Sunday June 05, 2022 @04:02PM (#31634347)
What kind of music do you like?
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by prawn on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:09PM (#31635693)
White noise and ambient sounds?
Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by donthellbanme on Sunday June 05, 2022 @02:59PM (#31633841)
I worked at a record store in the 90's. It was right after cd's took over. I think we had 1 record in the store.

I was shocked over the amount of tranquility music we sold. Tranquility was nature sounds. I didn't know about white noise back then, but we probally had it. It was basically music produced cheaply that supposedly relazed people.

I got it. People are stressed. Did listening to calming nature sounds help me--no, but listening to AM radio on a boring station does calm me down, or keeps negative thoughts away.

My sleepy time music was Classic music. Pretty much everything.

Even then becoming a musician was as hard as becomming an artist. There was just no formula besides 1 in a million talent, like Elvis, or just sheer luck, and that meant exposure.

(I am thinking about leaving an old iphone strapped to a tree to record creek sounds tomorrow, and plop it on Spotify under "Songs to calm. Natural, and organic music."), or never leave my house and produce it digitally?)

Re:Spotify podcasters are making $18k a month with nothing b... by throwaway7865 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @07:05PM (#31635667)
> My sleepy time music was Classic music. Pretty much everything.

I never had luck with that to be honest.

I’ve tried all classical playlists including all “Classical for Sleep”. It’s just too emotional with a lot of peaks and crescendos. A lot of treble. Demands a lot of attention to itself.

“Sleepy” jazz on the other hand is often comforting, muted and warm.