News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by cyanydeez on Saturday June 04, 2022 @01:59PM (#31623337)
Coinbase is based on a scam market economy.

Eventually the snake has no more tail to eat.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by alx__ on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:03PM (#31623976)
Unregulated assets != scam

Predatory con artist are taking advantage of the wild west

Regulation is coming, I'd assume Coinbase is sensing the headwinds change

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by yossarian1408 on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:07PM (#31623408)
A flawed ideal maybe, but you can't say it's a scam.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by gitfan86 on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:22PM (#31623578)
The only reason you cannot say Coinbase is isn't a scam is because it is impossible to prove that the people involved were lying in regards to the viability of crypto not being effectively a Ponzi scheme.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by solveit on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:30PM (#31623655)
It is very difficult to believe Brian Armstrong was cynically cashing in on what he perceived as a Ponzi ten years ago when he founded Coinbase (he posted an ad for a co-founder here on HN).
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by kelnos on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:25PM (#31624167)
Unless you personally know him well and have spoken with him at length about this, I don't think that opinion is based on anything substantial. A post on HN looking for a cofounder tells you only what the person wants you to believe they're thinking and feeling about what they're doing.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by solveit on Saturday June 04, 2022 @08:37PM (#31626710)
My opinion is based on it being completely insane to stake multiple years of your life on starting a cryptocurrency exchange in 2012 unless you had a sincere belief in the promise of blockchain technology. Crypto circa 2012 didn't look anything like what it is now.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by kelnos on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:52PM (#31699762)
Agree with the sibling that people make insane gambles all the time.

But beyond that, I don't think your premise holds true. People do often start companies because they believe in (or even have a passion for) the thing their company will be doing. But people often just start companies because they believe those companies can make them money. That doesn't mean that the thing the company does is going to be good and sustainable over the longer term. Just that there's some money to be made, even if it's on the backs of speculators and gamblers that don't provide much value to the ecosystem.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by cyanydeez on Saturday June 04, 2022 @10:07PM (#31627237)
People make insane gambles all the time? Some of the most neurotic people find success.

Imagine you could peer into all the class A gamblers, there'll always be a subset who get lucky and convince themselves they "worked harder' or whatever.

Point is, without proper interrogation, it looks like a gamble and crypto looks like a scam. There's always tops of pyramid schemes.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:23PM (#31624680)
Guilty until proven innocent.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by kelnos on Friday June 10, 2022 @05:53PM (#31699769)
Not really. Just you don't know what you don't know. You're not going to get a reliable feel for someone's motivations unless you actually know them and spend a bit of time talking to them about what they're doing. A "cofounder wanted" post on HN doesn't remotely cut it.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by fosk on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:30PM (#31623660)
There is value in a global blockchain with the level of participation of crypto. And sure there are scams, there are scams in the real economy too.

Ponzi is not an acronym for “I don’t understand its value therefore it’s a Ponzi scheme”.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by smeeding on Saturday June 04, 2022 @02:49PM (#31623847)
I think the Ponzi claims stem from the fact that so many people are in the market for speculative profit (and not to revolutionize finance or whatever), and the fact that earlier investors can only capitalize on their investments by proselytizing, recruiting, and ultimately selling their bags to new investors. Framed that way, it’s quite Ponzi-ish.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by r3trohack3r on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:08PM (#31624024)
This is true of any value storage vehicle. You only make money - or get your money back out - by passing it on to the next person. Art, baseball cards, stamps, stocks, gold etc. all work this way.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by smeeding on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:50PM (#31624380)
> all work this way

Do they though?

Unlike cryptos, gold and stocks have real material value behind them, not just community buy-in.

You can make the art/baseball cards/stamps argument, but then you’d be conceding that the value of cryptos — something pitched as a revolutionary technology with limitless profit potential — is, in reality, determined by the same irrational valuation process as niche collectible markets.

There’s a reason we don’t pay for groceries and mortgages with baseball cards and stamps.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:34PM (#31624777)
I’d love to hear more about the distinction between “real material value” and “community buy-in” value. It’s not a distinction I’m familiar with from my more than 20-year career in finance.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by smeeding on Saturday June 04, 2022 @05:06PM (#31625071)
Cryptos have value because their investors all agree that they do. That’s where it ends. If those investors stopped believing that, their value would drop to zero because there’s no underlying material value supporting it’s market value. They’re shared delusions, and arguably self-perpetuating high-control groups.

What I’m calling “real material value” are things like physical assets and profit generation capacity. Companies own things, and they use those things to generate profit, which in turn filters down to investors. This dynamic doesn’t exist in crypto.

Gold has real material value as a useful product, not simply a store of value.

I’ve only worked in finance for 6 years, and only on the technical side, so forgive me if my vocabulary doesn’t meet your standards.

If you’re actually disagreeing with the point that I’m making, and not just being pedantic, please let me know who you work for so I can be sure to avoid their services in the future.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @05:42PM (#31625378)
What I’m actually trying - and apparently failing - to do is get you to reassess your misplaced confidence. You have a toy-like, airbrushed conception of value that is doing you an analytical disservice.

If you’re in finance and interested in value, find a great textbook and get to reading. It’s a fascinating topic.

I’ll leave you with Goethe: “Doubt grows with knowledge.”

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by aahortwwy on Saturday June 04, 2022 @08:40PM (#31626728)
This comment implies a great sense of knowledge, authority, and superiority on your part. But it doesn't demonstrate any of that. You couldn't even recommend specific reading. Just "a great textbook".

A pretty frustrating comment, honestly.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @09:05PM (#31626879)
I’m not gatekeeping. Parent’s misconception wouldn’t survive contact with any decent first-year undergraduate finance text book. There’s plenty of great curricula freely available on OCW, EdX, etc. Take your pick. Just read something.

Edit: You know what, forget the textbook: spend 5 minutes on [wikipedia](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_value_(economics)).

I usually just ignore this stuff. But people repeat this garbage over, and over, and over on HN to disdain others (have a look at examples in this thread) and it’s just plain wrong.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by shanusmagnus on Saturday June 04, 2022 @11:10PM (#31627642)
Anytime someone talks about how xx "isn't backed by anything, like gold" I know they haven't actually put in a modicum of intellectual work on the topic. Granted, figuring out that money of every stripe is nothing more than a belief coordination mechanism is kind of a mindfuck. Even so, you'd think smart people would at least begin down the road. But nope.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by gitfan86 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @08:30AM (#31630388)
Everyone is well aware that the USD is just a worthless piece of paper. No one is suggesting that owning gold is the path to riches. We are just pointing out that investing is crypto is no different than investing in Enron or Bernie Madoffs funds.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by shanusmagnus on Sunday June 05, 2022 @01:04PM (#31632783)
The point I'm making, and that parent is making, isn't about gold as a path to riches. It's about where value comes from. Gold is a convenient illustration.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by smeeding on Saturday June 04, 2022 @09:53PM (#31627163)
Whatever you’ve gotta tell yourself, buddy. I make reliable extra income every month relieving experts and believers like yourself of your crypto capital, so by all means, never change. The system needs suckers.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @10:04PM (#31627223)
Good on ya mate.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by unicornmama on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:29PM (#31624209)
None of the things you mentioned are "value storage vehicles". Currencies may be a stores of value.

Gold is a hedge against hyper inflation and global crisis. Art is an elaborate mechanism for money laundering. Baseball, stamps, and pokemon cards are collectibles and eb and flow with the tides of pop culture And I am too tired to explain stocks to you.

> You only make money - or get your money back out - by passing it on to the next person. It might actual shock you to learn that the US money supply historically grows faster than inflation.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by gitfan86 on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:56PM (#31624431)
People can and do speculate on collectables. The difference is that there is underlying value in the collectable. There are people who would like to own a Babe Ruth signed baseball just because it is a unique piece of sports history and have no plan to sell the baseball when the price goes up.

Speculation on that asset can make the price go up far above the underlying value. But that comes at a high risk of the price falling down to the underlying value. For crypto this underlying value is basically zero.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:31PM (#31624745)
If only I had a dime for every time someone on HN unironically threw around the term “underlying value” like it meant something they could build an argument off.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Saturday June 04, 2022 @05:48PM (#31625433)
You don’t believe in any concept of utility relating to value? You’d argue that a house has no underlying value due to location and comforts?
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @06:27PM (#31625707)
I think a house has “value” related to utility.

I also think the putative concept of “underlying value” - always defined in opposition to some other form of value the speaker is railing against - is a lazy rhetorical crutch that provides nothing of analytical value to a discussion.

Every time these crypto threads come along we have tens of people drawing this same distinction and hordes of software engineers nodding along in agreement like it’s actually a thing. It’s not a thing. At least, not the way it’s deployed here.

Usually I just ignore it but it’s beginning to pass into accepted wisdom through sheer repetition.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Saturday June 04, 2022 @06:34PM (#31625760)
So to me it sounds like you do acknowledge the concept of underlying value. A house has utility, it is scarce, there is competition for it, ergo its value is a function of demand for the asset (aka a proxy for the utility of owning the asset). This can be extrapolated to other assets besides houses. Unclear if it can be to crypto, it’s sort of you believe or you don’t on that one. I think that’s what people mean when they say it has no underlying value.

TLDR scarcity + utility is where value comes from. Crypto really only has scarcity arguing for it. Much like collectibles actually.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by darkteflon on Saturday June 04, 2022 @06:44PM (#31625845)
There’s just “value”. People use the term “underlying value” as a proxy for “real value”, in opposition to “not real value”. You can verify that by looking at any example of its use in this thread.

I’m saying it’s a rhetorical crutch that doesn’t lead to meaningful discussion or insight.

If people acknowledged in these threads that “value” is way more complex and nebulous than these facile comparisons make it out to be, we’d have more interesting discussion.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Saturday June 04, 2022 @06:49PM (#31625890)
I think it’s clear people are distinguishing value based purely on speculation in a scarce asset and value based on demand (and still maybe speculation) for some underlying good which has utility. Be that a house, a car, or stock of a SaaS business, a retail operation, whatever.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by gitfan86 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:16AM (#31631182)
This is the point that crypto people are trying to avoid. "Don't talk about underlying value. It is very complex".

It reminds me of the mortgage backed securities fraud. "You cannot criticize these complex financial derivatives, they were created by MIT PhDs."

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Sunday June 05, 2022 @11:20AM (#31631761)
Yeah I see what darkteflon is saying but he is clearly wrong. And condescending about it to boot. There is a meaningful and discussion worthy difference between “value” (price, really), driven by speculation and hope versus price driven by demand for scarce goods which have utility.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by r3trohack3r on Sunday June 05, 2022 @08:41PM (#31636232)
> (price, really)

Wealth isn’t denominated in currency - price is an exchange rate to another system of faith.

Value is the length people will go to acquire an asset. Utility is only one dimension. And true utility is arguably far less important than perceived utility. Being convinced something like gold has intrinsic utility that justifies its current exchange rate is sufficient to carry the current price regardless of whether that belief is based in reality.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Monday June 06, 2022 @01:34AM (#31637495)
I’m just saying with crypto all we have is its price to go on, plus fuzzy allusions from people like you about how value is beyond the understanding of the unwashed masses.

For an otherwise useless digital token which can only be held or exchanged, its price would seem to be pretty relevant when discussing its value as it literally only has exchange value and no utility.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by gitfan86 on Sunday June 05, 2022 @10:23PM (#31636775)
A huge percentage of economic activity has a strong correlation with real world utility. Food, clothing, housing, transportation, entertainment, childcare, medical care, banking services are all dependent on real utility being delivered in a short timeframe. If a top rated restaurant hired a new chef that was terrible and then failed it's health inspection and gave all of its customers food poisoning they would quickly lose perceived value.

I would agree that perceived value is more important than real value, but it is risky to place bets on there being a big difference between the two for a long time.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by dragontamer on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:22PM (#31624153)
You make money from stocks by holding onto them and collecting the dividend.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:52PM (#31624407)
You will lose all your money thinking like this.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by r3trohack3r on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:18PM (#31624637)
You will lose all of your wealth not thinking like this.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Saturday June 04, 2022 @05:43PM (#31625386)
Oh I’m sure all great fortunes were built by people who believe stocks and baseball cards are equivalent investment vehicles.
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by r3trohack3r on Sunday June 05, 2022 @08:51PM (#31636289)
> equivalent investment vehicles

This is borderline arguing in bad faith. You’ll need to demonstrate a good faith argument to continue this conversation.

All value is psychological. Money is a behavioral coordination system. Believing gold has an intrinsic value that justifies trading at $1.8k an oz is sufficient for gold to trade at that value - regardless of gold’s real utility to any holder of gold. It’s the belief that drives the value.

Every single thing you hold that you believe has value either: 1) has direct value to you or 2) can be traded for something that has direct value to you

History is full of people who mistakenly believed their wealth was far more “real” than it was.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by gitfan86 on Monday June 06, 2022 @08:43AM (#31639739)
You are right that psychological value is all that matters, you just need to take your logic one step further.

When the Dole company buys a banana plantation, it is because they believe that consumers will want to buy bananas in the future. That future may or may not become "real". This is where your logic ends. You have proven that perceived value is all that matters and have stopped.

You need to understand that a year later millions of bananas will be ready to harvest. And grocery stores will be placing or not placing orders to have those bananas delivered. So that perceived value is now hitting reality. The crypto people have done a pretty good job kicking the can down the road and avoiding reality hitting their perceived value, but it is hard to keep that up forever.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by chowchowchow on Monday June 06, 2022 @03:54PM (#31645291)
What, seriously, what are you talking about with the bad faith? We’re responding to your comment which said baseball cards and stocks worked the same way.

It’s bad faith to point out how wrong what you said was? Sorry about that, guess we can’t talk anymore.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by dixie_land on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:37PM (#31624268)
It is an acronym for "I do understand it has no value but as long as I'm not the idiot holding the hot potato in the end..."
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by jwilk on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:46PM (#31624887)
Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by lupire on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:51PM (#31624390)
Coinbase doesn't do the Blockchain part, except as much as needed to enable a blockchain -adjacent thing for people who don't want the blockchain part.

The non-blockchain part is the scam part.

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by puranjay on Saturday June 04, 2022 @04:31PM (#31624750)
HN has decided crypto is a scam and any attempt to change its mind is met with wild resistance

Don’t even try man

Re:Coinbase is rescinding already-accepted job offers by Marazan on Saturday June 04, 2022 @03:11PM (#31624052)
It's a scam.